Global Warming. Fact or grossly exaggerated??

Whats your opinion on global warming?

  • Its too late! We're all gonne bake, frie and die in a few years

    Votes: 44 30.1%
  • Its not as bad as scientists say. We got at least 100 to 200 years before shit hits the fan

    Votes: 33 22.6%
  • Its not real at all. Its a carbon credit money making scam

    Votes: 45 30.8%
  • Its all a big conspiracy MAN!!!

    Votes: 9 6.2%
  • Its way too cold in Canada, I wish it were real. Start up the SUV's

    Votes: 15 10.3%

  • Total voters
    146
  • Poll closed .
In case AK and MF2 can't find a copy, i'll help.

http://www.ipcc.ch/publications_and_data/ar4/syr/en/spm.html

You're not really buying into Groggy's foolishness, are you?

I have had no trouble at all finding the primary source for the IPCC prediction that is the source of my wager. Here it is again, in case it was forgotten:

https://www.ipcc.ch/publications_and_data/ar4/wg1/en/spmsspm-projections-of.html

Groggy won't take my bet or AK-47's because he knows all too well the IPCC's prediction will likely be wrong. Accept no other excuse.

True. One of the worst polls ever.

Well, at least it doesn't involve the Communist Manifesto. :D
 
For the next two decades, a warming of about 0.2°C per decade is projected
Plain simple English, groggy. Take the bet you coward
 
I have had no trouble at all finding the primary source for the IPCC prediction that is the source of my wager. Here it is again, in case it was forgotten:

https://www.ipcc.ch/publications_and_data/ar4/wg1/en/spmsspm-projections-of.html


Yup, I've agreed to the bet according to the full paper (linked above) including the footnotes which both you and ak aren't smart enough to understand.
You've once again challenged me to the bet, supplied the full report as its source and then complained when I said you were making the bet on the full report.
And you still don't think you suffer from dunning kruger effect?
Shame.

How many times do I have to say I've accepted the bet?
You really aren't that smart, are you?
 
Yup, I've agreed to the bet according to the full paper (linked above) including the footnotes which both you and ak aren't smart enough to understand
Post the exact footnotes again, please.

Its a very simple copy/pasta, which I know you're good at :thumb:
 
Really? "Still within the IPCC projections"? That's not what the IPCC's fifth assessment report said in its summary for policy makers.

You obviously missed Post #118, so I'll repeat it.

Let's make a friendly wager on the IPCC's predictions. We'll bookmark this thread and see who was right.

By 2017, I will bet that the 0.2 degrees Celsius temperature increase that the IPCC predicted in 2007 will fail to be reached (i.e., that the Earth's surface temperature in 2017 will not be 0.2 degrees Celsius higher than what it was in 2007). You can bet that the IPCC prediction is accurate.

If you win, I have to hold my nose and buy the following book:

http://www.chapters.indigo.ca/books/...nn&ikwsec=Home

But if I win, you have to buy the following:

http://www.chapters.indigo.ca/books/...FUok5godImoAAA

Do we have a bet?

How many times do I have to say I've accepted the bet?

Good. We now have a clear bet on whether or not the Earth's temperature will be at least 0.2 degrees Celsius higher at the end of 2017 than what it was in 2007, as Groggy has wagered.

We shall see. Based on current trends, I don't like Groggy's chances.
 
Post the exact footnotes again, please.

Its a very simple copy/pasta, which I know you're good at :thumb:

Sure, in the interest of clarity, here is the full footnote.
Its footnote 10.3 thats the most relevant.


The context for the climate change results presented here is set in Chapter 8 (evaluation of simulation skill of the control runs and inherent natural variability of the global coupled climate models), and in Chapter 9 (evaluation of the simulations of 20th-century climate using the global coupled climate models). Table 8.1 describes the characteristics of the models, and Table 10.4 summarises the climate change experiments that have been performed with the AOGCMs and other models that are assessed in this chapter.

The TAR showed multi-model results for future changes in climate from simple 1% yr–1 CO2 increase experiments, and from several scenarios including the older IS92a, and, new to the TAR, two SRES scenarios (A2 and B2). For the latter, results from nine models were shown for globally averaged temperature change and regional changes. As noted in Section 10.1, since the TAR, an unprecedented internationally coordinated climate change experiment has been performed by 23 models from around the world, listed in Table 10.4 along with the results submitted. This larger number of models running the same experiments allows better quantification of the multi-model signal as well as uncertainty regarding spread across the models (in this section), and also points the way to probabilistic estimates of future climate change (Section 10.5). The emission scenarios considered here include one of the SRES scenarios from the TAR, scenario A2, along with two additional scenarios, A1B and B1 (see Section 10.2 for details regarding the scenarios). This is a subset of the SRES marker scenarios used in the TAR, and they represent ‘low’ (B1), ‘medium’ (A1B) and ‘high’ (A2) scenarios with respect to the prescribed concentrations and the resulting radiative forcing, relative to the SRES range. This choice was made solely due to the limited computational resources for multi-model simulations using comprehensive AOGCMs and does not imply any preference or qualification of these three scenarios over the others. Qualitative conclusions derived from those three scenarios are in most cases also valid for other SRES scenarios.

Additionally, three climate change commitment experiments were performed, one where concentrations of greenhouse gases were held fixed at year 2000 values (constant composition commitment) and the models were run to 2100 (termed 20th-century stabilisation here), and two where concentrations were held fixed at year 2100 values for A1B and B1, and the models were run for an additional 100 to 200 years (see Section 10.7). The span of the experiments is shown in Figure 10.4.

This section considers the basic changes in climate over the next hundred years simulated by current climate models under non-mitigation anthropogenic forcing scenarios. While we assess all studies in this field, the focus is on results derived by the authors from the new data set for the three SRES scenarios. Following the TAR, means across the multi-model ensemble are used to illustrate representative changes. Means are able to simulate the contemporary climate more accurately than individual models, due to biases tending to compensate each other (Phillips and Gleckler, 2006). It is anticipated that this holds for changes in climate also (Chapter 9). The mean temperature trends from the 20th-century simulations are included in Figure 10.4. While the range of model results is indicated here, the consideration of uncertainty resulting from this range is addressed more completely in Section 10.5. The use of means has the additional advantage of reducing the ‘noise’ associated with internal or unforced variability in the simulations. Models are equally weighted here, but other options are noted in Section 10.5. Lists of the models used in the results are provided in the Supplementary Material for this Chapter.

Standard metrics for response of global coupled models are the equilibrium climate sensitivity, defined as the equilibrium globally averaged surface air temperature change for a doubling of CO2 for the atmosphere coupled to a non-dynamic slab ocean, and the TCR, defined as the globally averaged surface air temperature change at the time of CO2 doubling in the 1% yr–1 transient CO2 increase experiment. The TAR showed results for these 1% simulations, and Section 10.5.2 discusses equilibrium climate sensitivity, TCR and other aspects of response. Chapter 8 includes processes and feedbacks involved with these metrics.
https://www.ipcc.ch/publications_and_data/ar4/wg1/en/ch10s10-3.html

I'm sure after you've read it you fully understand the ramifications on the bet.
If you're smart enough to understand it.

Hahahahahahahahahaha.
 
^^ I'll be perfectly honest, groggy. I dont quite understand what they're trying to say. I am a business man by trade, and the science of global warming is restricted to what I learned in high-school. If you think that makes me stupid, so be it. I prefer to think its just not my forte.

But since you're so much smarter then us, why dont you explain in layman terms what the footnote says


EDIT: it sounds perhaps like IPCC is trying to say a 0.2 increase in temperatures per decade is dependent on whether CO2 increases remain the same. Is that right??
 
But since you're so much smarter then us, why dont you explain in layman terms what the footnote says

Not a chance. He doesn't have a clue what any of it means.

Hopefully, though, he can understand this: The terms of the bet were set by me, not him. There will be no adjustments to the terms, regardless of whatever footnotes, etc., are provided.

If Groggy thought I was misinterpreting the IPCC's prediction, he had the right to decline. But, as the man who set the terms, I can assure everyone that the terms are exactly what I said they are. No exceptions.

Groggy insists he "accepted" the bet as I described it. It's on.

Sometime between now and Dec. 31, 2017, Groggy might want to clear some space on his bookcase for Mr. Delingpole's book.
 
Not a chance. He doesn't have a clue what any of it means
Thats what I think too. He quickly went through the IPCC site, picked some complicated footnote, then uses it as insurance in case he loses the bet, so he can say the footnote explains why temperatures didnt increase, but we're not smart enough to understand it.

Its an obfuscating technique. He's the dumb one if he thinks thats gonna work

Groggy insists he "accepted" the bet as I described it. It's on
Guaranteed groggy is gonna welch on the bet. GUARANTEED!!
 
Thats what I think too. He quickly went through the IPCC site, picked some complicated footnote, then uses it as insurance in case he loses the bet, so he can say the footnote explains why temperatures didnt increase, but we're not smart enough to understand it.

Its an obfuscating technique. He's the dumb one if he thinks thats gonna work

I think he lost the right to call other people "stupid" after he tried to argue that a "decade" is 20 years.
 
This thread is golden.

Keep at it boys.
Keep trying to figure out what that footnote says, it really shows how relevant your opinions on the science is.







dunning kruger effect showcase, that's what this thread is.
 
This thread is golden.

Keep at it boys.
Keep trying to figure out what that footnote says, it really shows how relevant your opinions on the science is
Then please highly intelligent one, explain to us in layman terms what the footnote says.

And you better believe I'm gonna email IPCC to verify what you're saying is true, so you better make it good :happy:
 
Then please highly intelligent one, explain to us in layman terms what the footnote says.

And you better believe I'm gonna email IPCC to verify what you're saying is true, so you better make it good :happy:

I will, when the bet is called in.
Why would I want to do it now?


Its right there, maybe you can get your father to read it for you.
Or maybe you can call on your high school science teacher.
 
Do these changes allow humanity to safely exist in our current numbers? That answer is pretty clear. If you are happy with the massive death and conflict that will be the result then keep on playing the conspiracy theorist.

As I have said several times, the problem isn't the change but the rapid rate of the change not allowing natural adaptations to either species or society.

Well thats an entirely different train of thought but
Quite frankly I would welcome a mass extinction
I do not think any scientist (or even moderately intelligent person) can possibly think having billions of humans alive is a good thing
We do alot more than put a little CO2 into the air
 
Well thats an entirely different train of thought but
Quite frankly I would welcome a mass extinction
I do not think any scientist (or even moderately intelligent person) can possibly think having billions of humans alive is a good thing
We do alot more than put a little CO2 into the air

I would love to hear what you think "good" means.

There are lots of lifeless planets out there. I bet you think Venus is "good" because it is a pristine world undisturbed by humans....
 
I will, when the bet is called in.
Why would I want to do it now?
Right, thats what I thought. You're full of shit
 
Why would I want to do it now?

Because no one believes you.

Besides, there's a bigger point that you are completely missing.

Let's assume there's something in your "footnotes" that supports your argument that the IPCC's predictions aren't necessarily as they appear. In other words, the IPCC's predictions are total rubbish.

You seem to think that will help you win the bet (it won't).

But the thing you seem to be missing is that if your assertion is right and the IPCC's predictions (and, as a result, the reports in general) are utter nonsense, that really proves my overall point.
 
Because no one believes you.

Besides, there's a bigger point that you are completely missing.

Let's assume there's something in your "footnotes" that supports your argument that the IPCC's predictions aren't necessarily as they appear. In other words, the IPCC's predictions are total rubbish.

You seem to think that will help you win the bet (it won't).

But the thing you seem to be missing is that if your assertion is right and the IPCC's predictions (and, as a result, the reports in general) are utter nonsense, that really proves my overall point.


Everyone else can read and understand the footnotes for themselves.
Its right there for everyone to see, I'm not hiding anything.

Its just you and AK who can't understand what the thing says.
Which just proves my main point:

Moviefan2 and AK47, deniers that they are, think they are smarter then the thousands of scientists and 97% of climatologists who approved of the IPCC's reports, but they aren't smart enough to understand even one footnote.
 
Groggy is full of shit, he's obfuscating!!

If you're so smart, groggy why dont you explain to us right now in layman terms what that footnote means