Danes Kill Gentle Giraffe

You forgot to mention that they are anti-semitic

Which northern European nation or in fact any European nation is not anti-semitic? How would this relate to butchering a giraffe and then feeding giraffe sashimi to the lions recorded in front of a live audience?
 
Translated by Google:


"We hate cute animals just as much as we hate the poor ," declared a spokesman for Goldman Sachs, who acknowledges that the bank was behind the murder of defenseless giraffe Marius .
You forgot to mention that obviously former president Bush, former vice-president Cheney and Haliburton were all also involved.
 
You forgot to mention that obviously former president Bush, former vice-president Cheney and Haliburton were all also involved.

Obama gave the executive order. Drones were unfortunately not an option, as the Copenhagen Zoo had a "bring your children" day.
 
In fairness, Canadians would be more comfortable with this if it was clubbed to death.
 
It scares me when people think animal lives are more sacred than fellow humans.....it indicates a warped value system, with a touch of psychotic thrown in.....

Yeah, that could be used to describe me.

I tend not to like people very much. Oh, I can get along just fine, and I have friends and such, but for the most part, people annoy the shit out of me. I can't count how many times I've been threatened, assaulted, harassed, and generally fucked over by humans.

Not so much with animals.

Can't say I've ever met an animal I didn't like. I've met lots of people I don't like.

I feel sad about this giraffe being sacrificed at the whim of his human keepers without a thought about his life.

I for one don't think that a human life is any more valuable than a giraffe's life simply because one animal is a human and the other is not.
 
More illogical and overly emotional argument.

Here's an interesting ethics question: you take your five year old son to an exhibit to see the last surviving female member of an almost extinct lion species. She is pregnant with a litter of kittens that conservation authorities hope will reestablish this lion species.

Unfortunately, your son slips into her enclosure when you aren't looking, and she attacks. You have a hunting rifle and a clear shot. If you pull the trigger her entire species goes extinct. If you do nothing, your son dies.

I submit that you are a psychopath if you don't shoot her and save your son's life.

Of course I would save my son.

But I'd let her eat your son.
 
In this case, it is.

The giraffe was part of a zoo. The zoo is supposed to look after the animals it has, not butcher them for food. The giraffe itself was apparently quite tame and even friendly. Besides, the zoo is saying that they simply didn't want his genes. That he (Marius) was simply a weed to culled from the herd. They aren't saying, "we can't afford to feed the lions any more (and if that is the case, they need to close this zoo)". They are saying, his genes were surplus so we killed him. People don't like to hear about killing living things because other people want to play God and decide who lives and who dies due to their genes. Add to this, Marius was not raised for food, he was a giraffe and there aren't that many giraffes around as far as I'm aware.

The only good thing to come out of this horror show was that he was fed to the lions.

But the thing is, he should not have been killed in first place. There was no need to do that.


Good points. It seems that not all avenues were exhausted.
 
More illogical and overly emotional argument.

Here's an interesting ethics question: you take your five year old son to an exhibit to see the last surviving female member of an almost extinct lion species. She is pregnant with a litter of kittens that conservation authorities hope will reestablish this lion species.

Unfortunately, your son slips into her enclosure when you aren't looking, and she attacks. You have a hunting rifle and a clear shot. If you pull the trigger her entire species goes extinct. If you do nothing, your son dies.

I submit that you are a psychopath if you don't shoot her and save your son's life.


He IS logical Fuji. You're not his son. :p
 
Still bad publicity Fuji, if not worse, even though we all know that animals tear each other limb from limb in the wild.

I actually think it would be great publicity, and that the Zoo could advertise it an event. Make it an event reserved for people who buy annual Zoo memberships only. No doubt, annual memberships would sell like hot cakes.
 
Of course I would save my son.

But I'd let her eat your son.

What gives you the right to decide that your son is more important than an entire species? Pull at that thread, and the whole fabric of the animal rights ideology will come unglued.

The answer is that you decide what has value, you make it up, all by yourself, and you are able to do that because you are human, you're able to form opinions on what has value and what doesn't. A giraffe doesn't have values, but you do. In a broader sense, all values are human-generated, animals have no intrinsic rights, they have whatever value we decide they have, nothing more. They are in no way equal to humans in that respect, they're not even on the same scale. We made up the scale.
 

Preventing a lion from hunting and killing is cruelty to animals. Dogs don't naturally fight to the death. Pet cats also hunt and kill birds which I assure you terrifies the birds. Preventing an animal from engaging in its natural behavior is what is objectionable.
 
Here's an interesting ethics question: you take your five year old son to an exhibit to see the last surviving female member of an almost extinct lion species. She is pregnant with a litter of kittens that conservation authorities hope will reestablish this lion species.

Unfortunately, your son slips into her enclosure when you aren't looking, and she attacks. You have a hunting rifle and a clear shot. If you pull the trigger her entire species goes extinct. If you do nothing, your son dies.
This sounds more than a bit like the African Painted/Wild Dog incident at the Pittsburgh Zoo - negligence on the parents part, not an excuse to kill the animal.