Danes Kill Gentle Giraffe

The Danes are just being logical. Which this board isn't being: this board is being ridiculously emotional.

Giraffes are an LC species. Categorically, they're the same as a white tail deer. Fly one to England in a C-17? Really? The resources to fly a non-endangered animal in a C-17 hundreds of miles, eating up massive amounts of fuel, for WHAT? So the cute cuddly widdle giwaffe won't be killed?

Holy crap, what a bunch of emotionally manipulable little girls!

This was a surplus animal to the needs of the EU giraffe breeding program (which has to be very low priority, but at least provides a backup genetic repository to the wild population). The resources to transport this animal or even to keep it alive in a non-breeding capacity within the Danish zoo could be spent much more profitably on endangered species all around the world. SOMEWHERE IN THE WORLD RIGHT NOW, there's an endangered animal in the hands of conservationists that will die because transport can't be arranged. But you're spending your tears and efforts on a non-endangered zoo animal because IT GOT PRESS THAT PUSHED YOUR WIDDLE EMOTIONAL BUTTONS.

The important stuff you don't see, you don't give a damn about. The unimportant stuff you DO see, you cry buckets of tears over. Pathetic.

+1 I don't always agree with you, but this time - spot on
 
Giraffes are an LC species.
That entirely depends upon the subspecies you are discussing

Rothschild's giraffe, The Rhodesian or Thornicroft giraffe, and the West African giraffe are endangered

The Masai Giraffe is Conservation Dependent

The problem here is several fold:

The Copenhagen Zoo refused to do anything to limit breeding, they then refused to sell Marius the giraffe despite several offers to purchase him - because they were afraid that his descendants might be sold to a circus or a private collector - (so being in a circus or in a wildlife park in say Texas is worse than being killed and cut up to feed to lions?). The point was then raised that the only way to have shipped him was by ship, it was pointed out that at his size there were aircraft available which could have transported him - it does depend upon operational requirements, but pilots have to fly a certain number of hours to maintain proficiency and whether that flight time is merely spent chugging around the continent or transporting a giraffe really makes no difference.


You make a valid point about wildlife conservation but everyone involved knows that it is far easier to get people involved with the plight of "cute" animals than something which is not.
 
The Copenhagen Zoo refused to do anything to limit breeding,

This charge will not get much sympathy here on Terb.


so being in a circus or in a wildlife park in say Texas is worse than being killed and cut up to feed to lions?

I would argue that. Texas is well known for "game parks" where basically chained animals are "hunted" for sport. Besides there are laws in Denmark, and I believe the EU against using non-domesticated animals in Circus.

At least the poor animal was killed without pain or distress. (less distress than cows and pigs are exposed to every day in abatoirs).
 
Cough, cough, cough!

As I understand it they had offers from both England and Scotland and were both were non-breeding locations.


At the size of that particular giraffe the RAF might have been willing to fly it.


Even neuter it if you have to. What they did was EXTREME. Crazy.
 
The Danes are just being logical. Which this board isn't being: this board is being ridiculously emotional.

Giraffes are an LC species. Categorically, they're the same as a white tail deer. Fly one to England in a C-17? Really? The resources to fly a non-endangered animal in a C-17 hundreds of miles, eating up massive amounts of fuel, for WHAT? So the cute cuddly widdle giwaffe won't be killed?

Holy crap, what a bunch of emotionally manipulable little girls!

This was a surplus animal to the needs of the EU giraffe breeding program (which has to be very low priority, but at least provides a backup genetic repository to the wild population). The resources to transport this animal or even to keep it alive in a non-breeding capacity within the Danish zoo could be spent much more profitably on endangered species all around the world. SOMEWHERE IN THE WORLD RIGHT NOW, there's an endangered animal in the hands of conservationists that will die because transport can't be arranged. But you're spending your tears and efforts on a non-endangered zoo animal because IT GOT PRESS THAT PUSHED YOUR WIDDLE EMOTIONAL BUTTONS.

The important stuff you don't see, you don't give a damn about. The unimportant stuff you DO see, you cry buckets of tears over. Pathetic.

What they did was more expedient than logical.

If someone else would pay for the transport, why do you care? We can't chop trees in this city, and they can't save an animal that is unique to Europe?

Are the Danes going to send money to save some endangered animal elsewhere in the world?

Couldn't they have neutered this beast? If it's like a white tail deer, why can't they send it to some local farm. Who's fault is it to let in-breeding to occur in a zoo? Man, the superior species, easily erases his mistakes because he has dominion over all other animals. No problem.
 
Would it have been that easy, to just bring this animal into the UK? First an application has to be made for this and then hopefully being granted an import license, I'm not sure if a giraffe is considered an exotic animal or if there is a special application for zoo animals. After this is granted, then the difficulties in acquiring transport and actually transporting this size of animal comes into play. There are issues with penning this size of animal for transport and tranquilizing it enough for safe transport as well. Not to mention the cost of such. Then the animal has to be put into quarantine for 6 months. Again, another associated cost to be picked up.

I think they made the cheaper choice, zoos not being real money makers. I still think they should have also had a big bbq, serving some of Africa's finest to the zoo's patrons.
 
Would it have been that easy, to just bring this animal into the UK? First an application has to be made for this and then hopefully being granted an import license, I'm not sure if a giraffe is considered an exotic animal or if there is a special application for zoo animals. After this is granted, then the difficulties in acquiring transport and actually transporting this size of animal comes into play. There are issues with penning this size of animal for transport and tranquilizing it enough for safe transport as well. Not to mention the cost of such. Then the animal has to be put into quarantine for 6 months. Again, another associated cost to be picked up.

I think they made the cheaper choice, zoos not being real money makers. I still think they should have also had a big bbq, serving some of Africa's finest to the zoo's patrons.


If it's on the zoo's ticket, and they can't give it to a local petting farm, then so be it, but they don't have a clue what bad publicity means.
 
Giraffes are notoriously difficult to transport, they can easily become stressed and when they reach that state they kick. I kick from a giraffe can kill a lion where it stands. They do not have the even temperament of elephants. It was possible for the Toronto Zoo to ship it's elephants to California,giraffes never. The Copehagen Zoo must have money to burn, a giraffe is more valuable alive not as expensive lion fodder.

In the wild a giraffe is not a docile beast, they are deceptively fast and fight to the death. If a hunted giraffe gets reinforcements they can decimate a lion pride. A pride of lionesses cannot bring down a giraffe with help from the males.

 
Why did Copenhagen Zoo kill its giraffe?
A young giraffe at Copenhagen Zoo has been euthanised - in the words of officials - to prevent inbreeding. The BBC examines the reasons for the action, which caused an outcry.

The zoo says this was done because the genes of the giraffe, named Marius, were too similar to those of other giraffes in a breeding programme run by the European Association of Zoos and Aquaria (EAZA).

Breeding closely related animals increases the chances that rare, harmful genes are expressed in offspring.

Two copies of a gene are inherited - one version from each parent. One of these copies might be harmful (deleterious), but if the other parent carries a non-harmful version of the gene, pairing them up might not result in any adverse consequences for offspring.

When parents are closely related, it increases the chances that two harmful copies of a gene will pair up.

A spokesman for EAZA stressed that, as an individual, Marius was not particularly inbred, nor was the giraffe suffering from any identifiable health problem. But the spokesman explained that Marius' parents had produced other offspring, so there were already giraffes with similar genes in the organisation's breeding programme.

"That means that the giraffe Marius, unfortunately, cannot add anything further to the breeding programme that does not already exist," an EAZA spokesman told BBC News.

The programme aims to make the most of the genetic diversity that exists, avoiding matings between the most closely related animals available.

He said all alternatives were looked at, but none were found to be viable, describing euthanising animals as a "last resort". When the future survival of a species was at stake, he said, unpalatable decisions sometimes had to be made.

"We need to prioritise - wherever possible - individuals who can help safeguard that future over the long term," said the spokesman.

According to the European stud book for giraffes, which dates back to 1828, only five giraffes have been euthanised for conservation reasons.

Marius was dissected as part of an educational event
According to EAZA, giraffes born in zoos generally need to be moved away from their family group once they reach sexual maturity.

Giraffe breeding groups in zoos are made up of a single bull together with a group of females. So female offspring must be removed to prevent inbreeding, and bulls must be removed around the age of 18-24 months to prevent fighting.

Joerg Jebram, who oversees the European endangered species programme for giraffes, told the AP news agency: "Zoos could design new giraffe facilities, but many don't have that option.

"A young bull could theoretically be sent to an all-female group as stud, but experts prefer a larger, more mature male for that, and Marius didn't fit that bill.

"A final option is sending the giraffe to a zoo that doesn't participate in the EAZA-led breeding programme, but that could leave the giraffe or its offspring being sold into worse circumstances, such as those of a circus or private collection."

Copenhagen Zoo had turned down offers from at least two other zoos to take Marius and an offer from a private individual who wanted to buy the giraffe for 500,000 euros ($680,000).

Why not move Marius?

Bengt Holst, Copenhagen Zoo's scientific director, said it had turned down an offer from Yorkshire Wildlife Park in the UK, which is a member of EAZA, because Marius' older brother lives there and the park's space could be better used by a "genetically more valuable giraffe".

The EAZA spokesman said it stood fully behind the decision by Copenhagen Zoo to euthanise Marius.

In one respect, Marius may have been a victim of giraffe-breeding success by European zoos.

"Historically, many of the 347 zoos that belong to [EAZA] were eager to have giraffes of any kind," said Mr Jebram.

"But in the past several years zoo breeding programmes have produced enough of some sub-species."

So why not prevent closely related animals from breeding in the first place?

Contraception and castration have been raised as possibilities, but both would require sedation. This is a relatively high-risk procedure in the case of giraffes, as they are liable to break their necks when they fall while sedated.

Mr Jebram told AP that in the past few years a contraceptive has been developed that can be injected into females from a distance.

But the EAZA spokesman said: "Contraception is in its infancy for giraffes and there are significant side-effects with certain drugs, such as irreversibility. This means we would lose vital animals in terms of breeding.

"We have to weigh up all the considerations, but we have a limited amount of space in which to conduct this endangered species breeding programme."

Ethical question

In a statement, the Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (RSPCA) said it was "extremely saddened to hear the story of this poor giraffe".

"What a shame another home could not be found for him, especially as it sounds as if there were suitable offers."

A post-mortem examination of Marius was broadcast live on the internet.

A crowd of visitors, including children, watched as the carcass was skinned, cut up and fed to the zoo's lions.

Peter Sandoe, Professor of Bioethics at the University of Copenhagen, who is well acquainted with the zoo, said he sympathised with the decision to put down the giraffe.

"When small children can go and see this giraffe and see it being turned into lion food, it's a very good picture of what nature is like," he said.

On the savannah, Prod Sandoe explained, "many will die young, killed by lions, killed by diseases, killed by accidents, by lack of food".

On the question of contraception as an alternative, he said: "You're already taking away a lot of the natural behaviour by putting them behind a fence.

"If you take away their ability to procreate, you are taking away even more of their natural life."
 
A regime change may be coming in Denmark. The US ambassador is getting involved in the Marius case. From Rufus Giffords facebook page:


Hundreds of you have reached out to me about the death on Sunday of Marius the 18-month old giraffe at the Copenhagen Zoo. I was unaware of it before it happened. As an animal lover, a WWF supporter, and the partner of a man who has dedicated his life to animals (Stephen is a veterinarian and spent his whole life working with animals large and small) I find the situation to be disturbing and the video hard to watch. I have also read numerous articles about the reasoning and justification for his killing and talked to Stephen about it at length. Despite being personally troubled by the action, I also understand the zoo is trying to teach the public about the species, the complexity of life for zoo animals and the life of giraffes in the wild.

Stephen and I will visit the Zoo soon to try and understand why they do what they do. I will keep an open mind until I hear all the different perspectives which is my responsibility.
 
Any excuse for killing an animal, other than it is sick and injured and you are putting it out of it's misery is pure BS. They have had more than enough times to deal with this situation, either by transferring the animal when it was young (another zoo or reserve) or to simply neuter him.

Further if one giraffe is enough to bring fears of inbreeding, then they should have been exchanging giraffe's with other zoo's years ago imo.
 
You all realize that many animals are killed on an ongoing basis to feed these lions. This giraffe was put down humanely and then butchered. So what.


where do you think the meat the lions normally eat comes from?
 
You all realize that many animals are killed on an ongoing basis to feed these lions. This giraffe was put down humanely and then butchered. So what.


where do you think the meat the lions normally eat comes from?

The ones in Copenhagen get horse meat.
 
Is killing a giraffe worse than killing a horse?

In this case, it is.

The giraffe was part of a zoo. The zoo is supposed to look after the animals it has, not butcher them for food. The giraffe itself was apparently quite tame and even friendly. Besides, the zoo is saying that they simply didn't want his genes. That he (Marius) was simply a weed to culled from the herd. They aren't saying, "we can't afford to feed the lions any more (and if that is the case, they need to close this zoo)". They are saying, his genes were surplus so we killed him. People don't like to hear about killing living things because other people want to play God and decide who lives and who dies due to their genes. Add to this, Marius was not raised for food, he was a giraffe and there aren't that many giraffes around as far as I'm aware.

The only good thing to come out of this horror show was that he was fed to the lions.

But the thing is, he should not have been killed in first place. There was no need to do that.
 
Having followed this story closely, my conclusions are as follows:

1. There are no more any need for ZOO's with exotic animals. Like the Circus animals, their time has gone.

2. The indignation should be directed towards the humane treatment of domesticated animals. Pigs, cattle and poultry are systematically mistreated for the purpose of making food a little cheaper. Marius was not mistreated in any way.
 
In this case, it is.

The giraffe was part of a zoo. The zoo is supposed to look after the animals it has, not butcher them for food. The giraffe itself was apparently quite tame and even friendly. Besides, the zoo is saying that they simply didn't want his genes. That he (Marius) was simply a weed to culled from the herd. They aren't saying, "we can't afford to feed the lions any more (and if that is the case, they need to close this zoo)". They are saying, his genes were surplus so we killed him. People don't like to hear about killing living things because other people want to play God and decide who lives and who dies due to their genes. Add to this, Marius was not raised for food, he was a giraffe and there aren't that many giraffes around as far as I'm aware.

The only good thing to come out of this horror show was that he was fed to the lions.

But the thing is, he should not have been killed in first place. There was no need to do that.

I just don't get this at all. Knee jerk, illogical, emotional positions don't suit you very well. Lion food was the best use of this animal.

Giraffes aren't endangered.