The Egyptian coup plotters go full thug

First, that's hyperbole. They don't have a right to "make up laws".

Second, he campaigned on it.

First, that's what the news reports seem to say.
Critics say the new constitution, which was hurriedly drafted by Morsi's Muslim Brotherhood and its Salafist allies, is undemocratic and too Islamist, and that it could allow clerics to intervene in the lawmaking process and leave minority groups without proper legal protection.
http://www.theguardian.com/world/2012/dec/26/mohamed-morsi-egypt-constitution-law


And second, as skyrider points out, you can't have a democratic vote to repeal democratic rights.
 
First, that's what the news reports seem to say.
Critics say the new constitution, which was hurriedly drafted by Morsi's Muslim Brotherhood and its Salafist allies, is undemocratic and too Islamist, and that it could allow clerics to intervene in the lawmaking process and leave minority groups without proper legal protection.
http://www.theguardian.com/world/2012/dec/26/mohamed-morsi-egypt-constitution-law

And second, as skyrider points out, you can't have a democratic vote to repeal democratic rights.

There are English translations online, which you can go read for yourself. Core democratic rights were preserved or improved and most importantly free elections were enshrined with universal suffrage.

I say most importantly because once you have free elections you can resolve ANY other problem. Constitutions can be amended. If the population matures and realizes they want more of a separation of mosque and state, they can do so. I would point out that within certain domains Imams and Rabbis "make up laws" in Israel. So what? It had no bearing on the elections so the people remain ultimately in control.

The criticisms mostly conflate human rights with democracy. There is a western ideological conceit that they are the same thing, but they clearly aren't. Women and blacks used to lack human rights in Canada and the US, but we were still democracies, while implementing much more oppressive human rights violations than Egypt.

There is no question that in Egypt there are culturally rooted prejudices that have led to human rights abuses against women and minorities. These were present before Morsi, and they are still present under the coup.

I ridicule the argument that human rights problems made it OK to chuck out democracy. Democracy is the SOLUTION to those problems, but they were not created over night and they will not be solved overnight. It took the US two hundred years to seriously tackle its human rights problems, I think Egyptians deserved at least two decades to work it out.

Democracy is the only means by which those problems will be resolved. Democracy is about a nation having a conversation with itself about what it is, and what it wants to be. Sometimes it isn't pretty, but it's the only way I know of for a country to face down its demons openly and ultimately move past them.
 
... Constitutions can be amended....

So I guess the constitution that was democratically approved my many more people than Morsi's should be good in your books.

Yes, much higher support and much higher turn out despite calls by the Muslim Brotherhood and their clerics to boycott.
 
So I guess the constitution that was democratically approved my many more people than Morsi's should be good in your books.

Yes, much higher support and much higher turn out despite calls by the Muslim Brotherhood and their clerics to boycott.

It was not democratically approved. That is an absurd statement, you are walking far out on the tree branch making that claim. I hear it cracking.

Can you name another democracy where all opposition is jailed, people trying to vote are beaten, anti government media is shut at gunpoint, demonstrators are mass arrested and held for months without charge, journalists ate charged with "influencing the public" for airing interviews with dissidents, and then in this environment somebody thinks a pro regime vote I'd free and fair?
 
It was not democratically approved. That is an absurd statement, you are walking far out on the tree branch making that claim. I hear it cracking.

Can you name another democracy where all opposition is jailed, people trying to vote are beaten, anti government media is shut at gunpoint, demonstrators are mass arrested and held for months without charge, journalists ate charged with "influencing the public" for airing interviews with dissidents, and then in this environment somebody thinks a pro regime vote I'd free and fair?

Israel?
 
It was not democratically approved. That is an absurd statement, you are walking far out on the tree branch making that claim. I hear it cracking....

Bull-fucking-shit.

Bigger turnout than Morsi's Islamic constitution and many more people voting for it. The Brotherhood chose to promote a boycott, their right in a democracy.
 

Again, bull-fucking-shit.

People are arrested in Israel for acts of violence (as many MB members should be as well), not for stating their opinions. In Israel, prominent opponents of Israel's government get well paid jobs as journalists and commentators.

Under the PA and Hamas (or the MB) on the other hand, people get thrown in jail for joking about Abbas playing for Real Madrid (or in Egypt about Morsi wearing a big hat).
 
Fuji. You clearly seem only to see Egypt as a struggle between the good guys and the bad guys. Fact is, in Egypt and in Syria, it is bad guys vs. a different group of bad guys.
 
Bull-fucking-shit.

Bigger turnout than Morsi's Islamic constitution and many more people voting for it. The Brotherhood chose to promote a boycott, their right in a democracy.

The Brotherhood didn't "choose to promote a boycott", they were under arrest in prison, their media shut down, their leaders arrested, their public gatherings attacked with gunfire. When their supporters showed up in polls in areas where they were strong, they were beaten up.

I can't fathom how you think an election is free and fair when one side jails the other and beats up its supporters at the polls.
 
Fuji. You clearly seem only to see Egypt as a struggle between the good guys and the bad guys. Fact is, in Egypt and in Syria, it is bad guys vs. a different group of bad guys.

No, I see it in a much more nuanced way than that, I am looking at the big picture, about ten miles higher up than you are seeing it.

Morsi is clearly an Islamist, and as such, the "other side" in a great Islamist/Western conflict that has engulfed the world in terrorism, violence, and war. But he was also something new, so new it was surprising, so surprising that many inherently refuse to believe it actually happened -- a democratically elected Islamist who was pursuing his goals through the ballot box, more or less through democratic processes, which right up until the day he was forced from office he had respected and followed. Turkey's Erdogan plays up being an Islamist, but he's really not one. Morsi was the real deal.

The conflict we're having isn't going to be resolved by one side killing off everybody on the other. At some level, some day, maybe far in the future, it will be resolved by the arrival of some sort of reconciliation. What form that reconciliation will take--who knows--but there's no other end game than that. We can win battles and wars, we can protect ourselves, and we can attack threats in the countries they originate from -- and we must do that -- but this is all at some really high level just containing, managing, and controlling. It's not solving.

The Egyptians started a very peculiar conversation by electing Morsi. For the first time that I have *ever* seen we had a guy we could talk to, who was committed to playing by something at least close to our rules, but who clearly and legitimately spoke for the other side of the conflict.

That really was a conversation worth having, and I don't know how many more decades we will have to wait now before we can have it again.
 
The Brotherhood didn't "choose to promote a boycott", they were under arrest in prison, their media shut down, their leaders arrested, their public gatherings attacked with gunfire. When their supporters showed up in polls in areas where they were strong, they were beaten up.

I can't fathom how you think an election is free and fair when one side jails the other and beats up its supporters at the polls.

Wow. Even though Brotherhood figures speak publicly demanding a boycott, fuji knows better.
 
And that makes it possible for you to overlook the undemocratic nature of the election?
You're as bad as groggy, get caught making shit up and just try to change the topic.


The vote on the constitution was democratic and the Brotherhood promoted the democratic choice not to vote.

And despite the boycott, more people voted in favour of this constitution than the last one.
 
You're as bad as groggy, get caught making shit up and just try to change the topic.

The vote on the constitution was democratic and the Brotherhood promoted the democratic choice not to vote.

And despite the boycott, more people voted in favour of this constitution than the last one.

So you don't believe the following happened:

-opposition news media shut at gunpoint
-opposition leaders arrested and jailed
-opposition rallies dispersed with gunfire
-opposition supporters beaten up at polls
-journalists prosecuted for airing opposition views

And so on.

Or you think that these things are compatible with democracy?
 
As I said, caught lying and tried to change the topic.

By which I meant a boycott was forced on them when they were prevented from campaigning. Yes they called for a boycott after being targeted with extreme repression.

Now you're going to play Gryfin, obfuscating by debating petty and trivial points while ignoring the substantive fact that the referendum wasn't even remotely democratic.