Are Canadian police paid too much?

blackrock13

Banned
Jun 6, 2009
40,084
1
0
The thing I don't understand about retention pay, is who cares, lots of people want these jobs. I don't mind paying cops fairly well, but I think it has little to do with corruption. If you paid them 65K top scale it would be fine, plus perhaps a premium for cost of living in Toronto.

Lots may want them, because they are supposedly 'sweet', but how many succeed in becoming officers. A whole lot less than the number of who apply.
 

Frosty

Active member
Sep 1, 2001
2,009
0
36
Toronto
Some American police forces have huge problems with officers on the take because they don't earn enough.
I don't think it really has anything to do with not making enough.
Look at the TTC ticket booth guy who stole from the sales of tickets. I'm pretty sure he was making over 100K.
If you're a bad person and you know you have an opportunity to get away with it. The money is always good to them. It's the same for police especially when there's a code of silence.
 

red

you must be fk'n kid'g me
Nov 13, 2001
17,572
8
38
I don't think it really has anything to do with not making enough.
Look at the TTC ticket booth guy who stole from the sales of tickets. I'm pretty sure he was making over 100K.
If you're a bad person and you know you have an opportunity to get away with it. The money is always good to them. It's the same for police especially when there's a code of silence.
That's right- the amount of money available to bribe a cop far outweighs anything we could pay them

A corrupt person will take the bribe no matter what they are paid
 

red

you must be fk'n kid'g me
Nov 13, 2001
17,572
8
38
Lets not forget crime rates......murders, robberies and such.

These are so much lower in Canada than the USA.

Maybe hiring and paying good talent a top dollar results in these much better crime rates than our neighbors to the south.
Was the crime higher or lower in the fifties and sixties when cops were paid less and we're high school educated at best?
 

nottyboi

Well-known member
May 14, 2008
22,535
1,387
113
Lots may want them, because they are supposedly 'sweet', but how many succeed in becoming officers. A whole lot less than the number of who apply.
I don't think we want people who are attracted by money, that is not attracting the right kind of person. A bit more turnover would be good. Too many lifers on the payroll.
 

nottyboi

Well-known member
May 14, 2008
22,535
1,387
113
Interestingly enough, on the Government Corruption Index, the US ranks 20th best Canada is 9th and Finland is 1st out of 175 countries. Uzbekistan was last.

http://www.nationmaster.com/red/graph/gov_cor-government-corruption&ob=ws

Further to the US; http://www.policemisconduct.net/2010-npmsrp-police-misconduct-statistical-report/

this was a surprise;http://www.targetmap.com/viewer.aspx?reportId=6486&embed
Why is it a surprise? Almost no officers get held to account for misconduct so the rate appears low.
 

jetfuel

Active member
Jan 31, 2005
564
41
28
Way overpaid and $80k is crazy for a three year vet, especially in London. I know many University students from top schools who can't even find a job, let alone one that pays half that amount.
We are way over policed in Toronto, of course the propaganda will tell you crime is on the rise.
Then again bus drivers make almost the same amount.
 

blackrock13

Banned
Jun 6, 2009
40,084
1
0
Why is it a surprise? Almost no officers get held to account for misconduct so the rate appears low.
So you don't believe the facts/findings I see, nothing new for you. From the same report.

According to our 2010 data:

  • Approximately 11% of the reports tracked this year involved US drug policies.
  • 698 Law enforcement officers were involved in reported misconduct that involved drugs in some way.
  • 343 of those law enforcement officers were criminally charged, convicted, or sentenced for those incidents.
  • At least 7 lives were lost due to misconduct involving drug laws.
  • At least $11,220,000 was spent in civil litigation due to drug law related police misconduct.
I suspect 343 officers would beg to differ. Of the 698 investigated on drug charges, ~1/2 were found guilty and sentenced.

Likewise ~1000 others were convicted and sentenced on other charges .

That doesn't come anywhere close to 'almost no officers'.


 

blackrock13

Banned
Jun 6, 2009
40,084
1
0
Way overpaid and $80k is crazy for a three year vet, especially in London. I know many University students from top schools who can't even find a job, let alone one that pays half that amount.
We are way over policed in Toronto, of course the propaganda will tell you crime is on the rise.
Then again bus drivers make almost the same amount.
Perhaps these unemployed grads should have applied to be a cop. I mean it's such a sweet deal. Compared to other N. American forces in comparable cites, Toronto doesn't have too many. How many officers do you think would be enough?
 

George The Curious

Active member
Nov 28, 2011
2,006
8
38
So you don't believe the facts/findings I see, nothing new for you. From the same report.

According to our 2010 data:

  • Approximately 11% of the reports tracked this year involved US drug policies.
  • 698 Law enforcement officers were involved in reported misconduct that involved drugs in some way.
  • 343 of those law enforcement officers were criminally charged, convicted, or sentenced for those incidents.
  • At least 7 lives were lost due to misconduct involving drug laws.
  • At least $11,220,000 was spent in civil litigation due to drug law related police misconduct.
I suspect 343 officers would beg to differ. Of the 698 investigated on drug charges, ~1/2 were found guilty and sentenced.

Likewise ~1000 others were convicted and sentenced on other charges .

That doesn't come anywhere close to 'almost no officers'.


I think nottiboy mean Canadian cops are just as crooked as th US , just ours are not exposed, or prosecuted more. Thus we rank lower in corruption index but in fact we are so corrupt crooked cops often walk away with just slap on the wrist.
 

afterhours

New member
Jul 14, 2009
6,321
3
0
That's right- the amount of money available to bribe a cop far outweighs anything we could pay them

A corrupt person will take the bribe no matter what they are paid
I guess you need to spend some time dealing with officials in a poor corrupted country to understand the absurdity of that proposition.
 

blackrock13

Banned
Jun 6, 2009
40,084
1
0
I think nottiboy mean Canadian cops are just as crooked as th US , just ours are not exposed, or prosecuted more. Thus we rank lower in corruption index but in fact we are so corrupt crooked cops often walk away with just slap on the wrist.
So it the old 'just my opinion, but I have no facts or findings to back it up' argument. Maybe Canadian cops are smarter and therefore don't get caught as often, really?:confused:

Considering he use think all drug cops were bent, he's certainly come down from that. That cops get lesser penalties when convicted is not in dispute now or ever, but juries do that all over the two countries. Blame the juries, people whom the police protect, not the laws or the courts.
 

afterhours

New member
Jul 14, 2009
6,321
3
0
So it the old 'just my opinion, but I have no facts or findings to back it up' argument. Maybe Canadian cops are smarter and therefore don't get caught as often, really?:confused:

Considering he use think all drug cops were bent, he's certainly come down from that. That cops get lesser penalties when convicted is not in dispute now or ever, but juries do that all over the two countries. Blame the juries, people whom the police protect, not the laws or the courts.
Actually juries have no say on punishment, their role is only to make a finding of guilt.
 

Pickpa

New member
Nov 5, 2013
118
0
0
I am kind of torn on this one.
On one hand the compensation that the public sector employees are receiving in Ontario is absurd and unsustainable
On the other hand cops save lives, enforce private property rights and maintain law and order.

They are probably overpaid, however on a relative scale I do not begrudge their excessive comp any where near as much as the weasels @ OPG, the thousands of blood sucking bureaucrats on the provincial payroll, or teachers who are the poster boy for excessive compensation.

I would place doctors and firemen in the same relative group of those who are probably overpaid, however are essential

City employees, garbage men and any other group of parasites who use the threat of a strike as route to excessive comp from the taxpayer are in the same low-life category as teachers.

There will be a tipping point where the debt burden of this province will trigger massive layoffs in the public sector.
Their unions willfully ignore this and just move us closer and closer to that point with their ridiculous demands and inflexibility
I fully agree on this. I think most unions need to be cancelled dropped from most if the jobs. Doctors, firemen are the essential in my book. We have more than enough police men trying out to get into the force, there are more nurses looking for work than we need, that's why most work part-time and usually don't full benefits which I am against for due to their physical and mental well being for their work environment. But although we can debate that these people risk their lives, but they understand the basic requirements of these jobs, they can always find another job if they don't enjoy such a setting. The union makes them stay and use excuses of "mentality and physically distress" of these jobs that make the employers go to the union and strike. Teachers, and garbage men? Go dig a hole and shut up. The government should look into limited and restraining more public services such as Ontario works and maybe focus more on pension plans.
 

blackrock13

Banned
Jun 6, 2009
40,084
1
0
Actually juries have no say on punishment, their role is only to make a finding of guilt.
I understand that, so they might lean towards finding the police not guilty, or if given the option, guilty on a lesser charge with a lesser sanction.
 

Curious36

Member
Nov 11, 2007
500
11
18
Most cops are great, honest, hardworking folks BUT there are some who arent. A buddy is a cop....he told me that those in drug enforcement are the highest paid. i.e. $200K in cash found, $100K is reported. The difference is distributed with a strict code of silence. Are the perps going to say "we had more drug money than reported"?....
Not saying this happens EVERY time....but dont kid yourselves....it happens.
To stay on topic, people are arguing that TO cops should be the highest paid due to cost of living. It would be interesting to see how many DONT live in TO. I know 3 city cops personally and they all live in Durham. Now before someone says "why arent cops allowed to commute when others obviously do?"....I'm just saying people will naturally gravitate to affordable housing and CHOOSE to work where they do/can....
 
Toronto Escorts