Gawker Claims Video Exists of Rob Ford Smoking Crack

You made all sorts of ridiculous assertions that the Star simply had an agenda, and could not be believed. Would you like some choice quotes from your posting history?

I never heard any complaints that the Star had an agenda when they broke the eHealth, gas plant, school board spending, or ORNGE stories, nor any doubt cast on their motives for reporting that Chow and Layton lived in subsidized housing back in the day. Not a peep about bias when they ended Giambrone's mayoral campaign by outing sordid details from his personal life.

Ok, I will play along. List my "ridiculous assertions that the star had an agenda", but please provide:
1) sound logic/reasoning why my assertions were ridiculous
2) proof/logic/reasoning that the star did not have a bias against rob ford.

Next, please remove the tunnel vision glasses you have on. I never claimed that we should not be delving into rob fords personal life.
I never claimed him being drunk on the danforth was not really stupid.
Ehealth, Ornge, gas plant etc, Giambrone's stupidity were all easily verifiable. Just like
the police report cemented fords issues. They are completely different situations.
Duffy, Wallin, and Brazeau scandals are the same as Ehealth, oRnge etc.. they were verifiable.



The fact is that all these stories come from the Star for a good reason, they have the largest investigative team in the business. They get the scoops and they publish what they find.

The Star was the only paper checking out Ford's claims about his backyard park land purchase because they are the only ones with the investigative staff to routinely do that sort of fact checking.

Ford hates the Star for one reason: they don't just lap up what he says in press releases. They check. They go down to Florida and get his arrest report. They interview the people he screams at in public. They send investigators to find out if he was intoxicated on the job. In short, Ford prefers media outlets like the Sun that never investigate anything, that just print things released in statements to the press, alongside opinion pieces.

Agree that the star has done a great job over the years, and I don't know if they have the "largest investigative team in the business", but as one of the largest (if not the largest) paper in Canada, it is believable.
So why did they not use their people to investigate. Instead they relied on gossip. "this neighbor said blah blah blah", "the guy down the street said blah blah blah" and stories about ford's associates or
speculation about whether he only wears red ties because he is a member of the "Bloods Gang".

If Ford hated the star, then the star hated ford.. not sure which came first, the chicken or the egg, don't really care.

Please see my reply to groggy about the video.

Fuji, that was really a terrible attempt at a point, much like the stars stories about ford you need to step up your game....

JUST HAD AN EPIPHANY... the point about bringing up my "ridiculous assertions" is exactly how the star handled their "investigation" of rob ford.
Instead of dealing with the things that mattered (such as the day to day business of running the city), they went out and tried to find "the ridiculous".
Instead of focusing on the important stuff, they resorted to the lowest form.

As much fun as I am having with this, let me give a hint of what might help.
You might start with admitting that the star might have had a bias against rob ford, and that some of their reporting was
sensationalized..... I am not going to give you the rest of the answer, lets see if you can figure it out yourself.

At the end of the day, I believe that the star severely compromised their integrity, did everything they could to smear rob ford partly because
of their bias, and partly because publicity and/or sales.
 
If Smitherman had become mayor and they got wind of a story I have absolutely no doubt that the Star would put just as many reporters on the trail
And what about during the mayoral elections. Did the Star come after Smitherman to see if he was still using drugs??

No, they didnt.

Kind of important dont you think. I'd like to know before I vote for someone to see if they're still using hard drugs
 
Ah the grand conspiracy theory. Every time the papers report on Ford's problems it's all just a big conspiracy. Why do you think these people have a hidden agenda? Your ONLY reason is because they spoke out about Ford's behavior.

Do you realize how pathetic you sound now that the truth has come out?

Quote Originally Posted by PornAddict View Post

That why you so full of it.. I watched on CTV news.. the football player said to ctv news reporter that rob ford never assualted him and that if Rob Ford had laid a finger on him he would had beaten the living crap out of him! LOL. I strongly suspect you work for the Toronto Star .. I hope they go bankrupt with the trash they print! I will never every buy a Toronto Star ("Red Star")!
Multiple witnesses confirmed the assault. The kid was lying about not being assaulted, I assume Ford, or one of his thugs, got to the kid and intimidated him into being silent.

Fuji, are you on crack, or do you suffer from short term memory loss or don't you read the shite you post.

In one post you write that ford and his cronies intimidated a kid, in the next you ridicule pornaddict about his grand conspiracy theory.

Obviously, I need to point out that you are trying to debunk his conspiracy theory with your own conspiracy theory, but somehow you think your conspiracy theory valid
and his is just "kooky"...
 
We never said we said they were lying- we said they put a biased spin on it using very insinuating language, and then slipping in those key words like "possible", "alleged" appeared, etc. and added disclaimers to protect themselves legally.

In this case, it appears they were right, and myself and a few others gave them props for that, upon hearing a TRULY non-partisan source of REAL credible information source, in this case the police chief. (The video itself would have also sufficed...) Which most of us said we would do in such a case.

To argue that the Toronto Star is not biased in its reporting is just plain kooky. The entire free world knows that newspaper bias is common place. To deny that, it just ludicrous. Name a newspaper, and any common citizen will tell you its political bias. :hand:

As for your "partisan rubbish" comment, speaking for myself- I hate all political factions equally. Take today's situation as a perfect example as to why:

Federally- the conservatives are in all sorts of hot water due to its senator scandal. Seriously? I thought the Cons campaigned on cleaning up the senate- and here they are making a complete and total debacle out of it! :frusty:
Provincially: The liberals are in all sorts of hot water over the gas plant scandal. :hand:
Municipally: Ford's fiasco is just plain ludicrous! :mad:

How many times have you guys heard me say they ARE ALL a bunch of lying, cheating thieves?!

We need to stop all the fucking bullshit, and take back our country, our province, and our cities! We are letting these assholes run our lives. Actually- that last statement is wrong, we aren't "letting" them... we are ASKING them.

The fact that voter turnout is at an all time low, is because there are no good candidates to vote for!

Ridge, my issues was not that they used those disclaimers like "alleged' etc. It was that the story was written to diminish the impact of those words, and the headlines were misleading.

As you said, the star nation, like ford nation refuse the accept the fact that the star has some warts. Sadly, the cannot see that their
refusal to accept the inherent bias of the star weakens all their other points.
 
Except it's the Basso house in the background that they are posing in front of.

Except that Ford has admitted that him and Basso are friends from high school (I believe), and that he visits his friend.

i will start deducting points for stupidity, and only give you 1/2 points for effort

keep trying....
 
Plus Ford has made repeated visits to that house described by police as a 'crackhouse' that were witnessed by neighbors and whose occupants are drug dealers.

And on the day that photo was taken Ford is alleged to spend hours upon hours inside of there.

Certainly wasn't 'dealing' with constituency issues.

Not claiming that they are the same exact situations but since I love hypothetical:
If you went to your friends house, spent a few hours, had a few beers and left. After you left
your friend beat up his wife, and police arrested him. Should you be arrested for helping him
to plan to beat up his wife??

More to the point, did the STAR NATION find someone who was willing to go on record to say they supplied or saw rob ford smoke crack.
With the amazing investigative powers available to STAR NATION they could not find one crack addict who would admit to sharing a pipe
with rob???

-1 for STAR NATION, keep trying.

To clarify, the scoring system is:
STAR NATION vs fair and balanced nation (will try to come up with a better term).

Love this game, its more fun than Madden 25 or Skyrim...
 
Except that Ford has admitted that him and Basso are friends from high school (I believe), and that he visits his friend.

i will start deducting points for stupidity, and only give you 1/2 points for effort

keep trying....

So he is posing in front of a crack house owned by a friend, with some crack dealers, and the photo was provided to the Star by the crack dealers who had a video of Ford smoking crack. Circumstantial, yes, but strongly, strongly corroborated the first hand primary report of the video.
 
Fair enough question groggy..

I don't think I ever commented on the photo. You are treating Shack, Phil, and I as if we represent the same opinion. The 3 of us have slightly different opinions, and probably different
motivations for them.

The Photo: I understand your point, but you don't see the basic fault in your logic. You have to prove that the photo means something.

The photo did mean something, it was very clear evidence that the video was most likely real. It placed Ford at the crackhouse and with the crackheads.
It came out from the same person, Siad, who was selling the video as teaser evidence.
This 'Ford is in lots of pictures' defense was a crock of shit in context.



The star (notice I refuse to capitalize their name) making the claims when they already have a huge bias against ford falls in the same type of category. Not the same category, maybe not in the same
area but the same time zone perhaps. The thing that I now realize about my distaste for the star reporting was that they kept going to sources... "someone says they saw him and Lisi meeting 4times/week"
" a neighbor of the drug house said they have seen ford there many times" etc...etc... I might be wrong on this, but why did they not have their own people investigate these claims and verify them?

Now we are getting to the real issue.
Your personal bias clouded your judgement to the point where you were believing a crackhead over the reports in all papers.
First, the Star put out the original story, but every media outlet investigated it to their abilities and found only evidence that backed up the Star.
Yet, you and a few others, continued to allow your personal bias to cloud your judgement. Your characterization of the story as a 'Star' story when it became all media was one element, as was your ignoring of the photo evidence and corroborating stories.

That kind of thinking is typical of hardcore partisans, where their arguments are based off of talking points they've heard from those they follow, instead of being able to think through the issues for themselves. Typical behaviour like calling those who didn't support Ford as 'libtards' or some other insult, which is used to denigrade the opposition to the point where they feel that they are above responding to legit arguments.

For the good of our political system it does no good to blindly follow any party. We need to be watching those who are leading us, those who are policing us and those who are reporting on us. Partisan free tickets for offenses, like excusing Ford's history of lying about substance abuse, will just continue to weaken our system instead of strengthening party support.

So I'll call out McGuinty for the gas plant cancellations, call out the two previous liberal federal leaders for being idiots, call out Trudeau for not having a single cogent policy and call out Harper for the crap he's pushed into the senate and the millions he's wasted in this country.

What would be great, but entirely unlikely reading your responses, is that you personally learn a lesson from this. That you can't just take the word of the party, you need to make sure they aren't paying off senators or hanging out in crackhouses with gang members. You need to start listening to arguments from the other side and responding with honesty and integrity.
Otherwise we'll end up with more crackheads and liars taking care of where our taxes go.


About the video: The star was sitting on the biggest story of the year, perhaps the decade, or maybe even the biggest story of the last 40 years.
They had it in their hands. We talk about Rob Ford having bad judgement, but as a business, how much worse was the judgement to let the
video get shopped around. So how the heck are we supposed to put faith what they have to say, when would not even back up their talk.

I tried to answer the question as fairly as I possibly could.

The Star acted responsibly. They didn't give a crackhead $200k to buy a story, then they reported as clearly and honestly on what they saw, as they should.
They did their job just as they were supposed to, and I sure hope that it helped sell some papers so that they can continue this work on all leaders.

And by the way, I do appreciate this dialog.
 
You are treating Shack, Phil, and I as if we represent the same opinion. The 3 of us have slightly different opinions, and probably different
motivations for them.
.
Here's how I approached it.

Call it bias or not, were they out to get him or not, it doesn't matter. The Star, unequivocally, did not like Ford right from the time he announced his candidacy.

When a story like this which condemns a certain individual is promoted and driven by a source who clearly does not like that certain individual (again whether they are correct or not to dislike him) I'd expect any rational person to at least have some measure of skepticism. Some more so and some less. That's to be expected. Not all people accept information at the same level.

For those of us that had more skepticism, we stated that clearly. We did not, as some blisteringly characterized us in spite of our attempts to explain ourselves, were not defending Ford. We did not say he was innocent. We did not say the Star was lying. We were saying we were skeptical and we wanted something that was more verifiable and from a source that did not possibly have a bias (or less chance of a bias). The fact that after 6 months, nothing had materialized, it should be understandable that it was possible for that skepticism to linger if not even increase.

Our position was not entrenched (again as some incorrectly characterized us, and still do) and as such, once the police waded in with verifiable evidence (as it appears at this point) we immediately accepted it.

I think almost any rational person would give more credence to evidence provided by the police than by any media, let alone one that has stated their dislike (whether they are right or wrong and I'm not saying bias) for the subject and published numerous negative articles and editorial cartoons even before the crucial incident came to light. Probably the only time I'd accept the medias' reports before the police's is if it were a matter dealing with the police department itself. That shows consistency in that if it was about the conduct of the police, I would have more skepticism about what they're telling me than the media. There is more chance of bias by the police, in this case. Fuji, we all know that you constantly question the source of the clown boys' reports. I'm not directly comparing the integrity of their sources with that of the Star, just that we should, and I know you do, at least have a critical eye as to who the source is and what possibly might be their motivation. Your posts on this whole affair makes it sound like that if something is printed in the Star, it must be true. You continued to use the Star's credibility, and investigative team etc. etc, as proof that Ford was guilty of what they reported. I think it may be difficult for you to disagree with anything printed in the Star from here on in. Saying that proof of Ford's guilt is because the Star printed it, and if in the future disagreeing with their reporting (not editorial opinion, of course) would be hypocritical at worst and inconsistent at best.

So accuse us of being somewhat more skeptical than you and others, but we w kept an open mind as to the possibility the Star was correct, and once we got a source less open to skepticism, we immediately accepted it.

Personally, I have no crow eggs on my face to eat (or something like that).

I sincerely hope you understand and accept this explanation at face value and do not continue to paint us a being kooky and ramming it down our collective throats. Not everybody sees things the same way. We admittedly had more skepticism, that was proven to be misplaced, but our skepticism was not irrationally arrived at and was not a position carved in stone.
 
So he is posing in front of a crack house owned by a friend, with some crack dealers, and the photo was provided to the Star by the crack dealers who had a video of Ford smoking crack. Circumstantial, yes, but strongly, strongly corroborated the first hand primary report of the video.

+1 for admitting circumstantial
- 1 for assuming that ford knew the guys in the pic were crack dealers
-1 for assuming ford knew it was a crack house
-1 for bringing up the video, that STAR NATION had in its hands, but decided to let it go.

STARNATION is now at -3
 
Quote Originally Posted by PornAddict View Post

That why you so full of it.. I watched on CTV news.. the football player said to ctv news reporter that rob ford never assualted him and that if Rob Ford had laid a finger on him he would had beaten the living crap out of him! LOL. I strongly suspect you work for the Toronto Star .. I hope they go bankrupt with the trash they print! I will never every buy a Toronto Star ("Red Star")!
Multiple witnesses confirmed the assault. The kid was lying about not being assaulted, I assume Ford, or one of his thugs, got to the kid and intimidated him into being silent.

Fuji, are you on crack, or do you suffer from short term memory loss or don't you read the shite you post.

In one post you write that ford and his cronies intimidated a kid, in the next you ridicule pornaddict about his grand conspiracy theory.

Obviously, I need to point out that you are trying to debunk his conspiracy theory with your own conspiracy theory, but somehow you think your conspiracy theory valid
and his is just "kooky"...

Sorry but his big conspiracy theory that the multiple witnesses who confirmed the assault were all lying because of hidden agendas is just completely pathetic and ludicrous. Talk about unsubstantiated accusations!
 
+1 for admitting circumstantial
- 1 for assuming that ford knew the guys in the pic were crack dealers
-1 for assuming ford knew it was a crack house
-1 for bringing up the video, that STAR NATION had in its hands, but decided to let it go.

STARNATION is now at -3

Nonsense you are being stupid. The Star ran the photo explicitly to corroborate the video. You can't discuss it without discussing the video it is there to corroborate. It came from the same source.

And it is very relevant that Ford is posing in front of a crack house with crack dealers. Still more relevant in light of how frequently Ford visited the crack house.

That absolutely corroborates the primary first hand account of witnessing a video of Ford smoking crack.

(We now know the video was shot in that house, though at the time of the story we didn't)
 
The photo did mean something, it was very clear evidence that the video was most likely real. It placed Ford at the crackhouse and with the crackheads.
It came out from the same person, Siad, who was selling the video as teaser evidence.
This 'Ford is in lots of pictures' defense was a crock of shit in context.
Agree to disagree, the photo does mean something now, but not when first presented.
Second reasoning problem... why take the picture of them outside the house? why not take the picture of ford
smoking crack?? Reasonable explanation: Ford visits his friend, meets the drug dealers outside the house.

Sorry, just because you say its a crock of shit does not make it so. The Mayor of Toronto is important. If I saw him, I would ask him to take a picture.
In fact, I can take it one better, if I had seen Miller, I would not ask him for a picture because he seemed like a snob. Ford, no problem.


Now we are getting to the real issue.
Your personal bias clouded your judgement to the point where you were believing a crackhead over the reports in all papers.
-5 for flawed logic on this one for saying that I was believing the crackhead over the reporters. My issue was that the reporters were
believing the crack dealers/crackheads. By crackhead, I am assuming you mean rob ford. We don't even know if ford is a crackhead, methhead
coke fiend, boozer, toker or a combination of all. But yes, I did give him the benefit of the doubt because of the bias of STAR NATION, the unreliability
of the sources, and lack of decent proof.

First, the Star put out the original story, but every media outlet investigated it to their abilities and found only evidence that backed up the Star.
Yet, you and a few others, continued to allow your personal bias to cloud your judgement. Your characterization of the story as a 'Star' story when it became all media was one element, as was your ignoring of the photo evidence and corroborating stories.

That kind of thinking is typical of hardcore partisans, where their arguments are based off of talking points they've heard from those they follow, instead of being able to think through the issues for themselves. Typical behaviour like calling those who didn't support Ford as 'libtards' or some other insult, which is used to denigrade the opposition to the point where they feel that they are above responding to legit arguments.

For the good of our political system it does no good to blindly follow any party. We need to be watching those who are leading us, those who are policing us and those who are reporting on us. Partisan free tickets for offenses, like excusing Ford's history of lying about substance abuse, will just continue to weaken our system instead of strengthening party support.

So I'll call out McGuinty for the gas plant cancellations, call out the two previous liberal federal leaders for being idiots, call out Trudeau for not having a single cogent policy and call out Harper for the crap he's pushed into the senate and the millions he's wasted in this country.

I agree with you that we need to think things through. I agree with the old adage "if it looks like a duck, walks like a duck, and quacks like a duck, it probably is a duck".
That is good enough for you, me, and the general public, but it is not good enough for a "newspaper". You talk about partisanship, but the star is partisan, there is no debate about that, yet
in this thread we are asked to pretend that the star is not partisan because they are "right". i don't think I initiated the name calling but I admit I indulged in it.
-5 for fair and balanced nation

What would be great, but entirely unlikely reading your responses, is that you personally learn a lesson from this. That you can't just take the word of the party, you need to make sure they aren't paying off senators or hanging out in crackhouses with gang members. You need to start listening to arguments from the other side and responding with honesty and integrity.
Otherwise we'll end up with more crackheads and liars taking care of where our taxes go.
I have learned a great many things from this. However, I have never played into the partisan politics. My points
were never about right or left, it was always that bias the star had was tainting their reporting, and that what they
reported was not good enough. That they threw as much shit on the wall and tried to make it stick. That it clouded the
issue worse than if they had stuck to issues, and then added the rest as a throw in. Ex. "Ford's position about
stopping the gravy is full of shit because of .... and on another topic......" Instead they lead with the
biases stuff, thus tainting anything else they had to say.


The Star acted responsibly. They didn't give a crackhead $200k to buy a story, then they reported as clearly and honestly on what they saw, as they should.
They did their job just as they were supposed to, and I sure hope that it helped sell some papers so that they can continue this work on all leaders.

And by the way, I do appreciate this dialog.

I strongly disagree that the star acted responsibly, but it is my opinion.
$200k was asking price, lets be real, $50k - 100k with a bit of negotiation would
have closed the deal. Why would the star not want to buy the video? They might say its about their ethics or something like that.
Lets put it another way, if the video is real, proof of the mayor of toronto doing something so stupid needs to be revealed. I would counter that
something like this does not contradict their ethics, in fact they might even be ethically required to prove it.

I also appreciate the dialogue. I am getting that feeling that a bromance is on the horizon..
 
The Star did not buy the video because the Star does not pay for news tips. If they started out by paying 200k for this video then everyone calling in a tip would demand a payoff.
 
Reality Nation vs. The 'Alternate Universe' Nation

What's it like residing over there?

Attempted rationalizations, lame excuses, blame-game, deflection, denial.....
 
My points were never about right or left, it was always that bias the star had was tainting their reporting, and that what they reported was not good enough. That they threw as much shit on the wall and tried to make it stick

Bullshit. All of the Star's reporting on Ford was fair and accurate. All of it. They have not had to, and will not have to, retract anything they have published. All of it was good journalism. None of their stories were tainted, none were poor journalism.

Take the rose coloured glasses off. The reason they had so many stories to print about Ford's outrageous behavior is because Ford behaves outrageously. I am guessing from the hints we are getting that there is a lot more to come, too.

Now that Ford has been thoroughly outed the wall of silence that had protected him is starting to crumble, plus the police seem to have a good deal more on him than has yet come to light.
 
Here's how I approached it.

Call it bias or not, were they out to get him or not, it doesn't matter. The Star, unequivocally, did not like Ford right from the time he announced his candidacy.

When a story like this which condemns a certain individual is promoted and driven by a source who clearly does not like that certain individual (again whether they are correct or not to dislike him) I'd expect any rational person to at least have some measure of skepticism. Some more so and some less. That's to be expected. Not all people accept information at the same level.

For those of us that had more skepticism, we stated that clearly. We did not, as some blisteringly characterized us in spite of our attempts to explain ourselves, were not defending Ford. We did not say he was innocent. We did not say the Star was lying. We were saying we were skeptical and we wanted something that was more verifiable and from a source that did not possibly have a bias (or less chance of a bias). The fact that after 6 months, nothing had materialized, it should be understandable that it was possible for that skepticism to linger if not even increase.

Our position was not entrenched (again as some incorrectly characterized us, and still do) and as such, once the police waded in with verifiable evidence (as it appears at this point) we immediately accepted it.

I think almost any rational person would give more credence to evidence provided by the police than by any media, let alone one that has stated their dislike (whether they are right or wrong and I'm not saying bias) for the subject and published numerous negative articles and editorial cartoons even before the crucial incident came to light. Probably the only time I'd accept the medias' reports before the police's is if it were a matter dealing with the police department itself. That shows consistency in that if it was about the conduct of the police, I would have more skepticism about what they're telling me than the media. There is more chance of bias by the police, in this case. Fuji, we all know that you constantly question the source of the clown boys' reports. I'm not directly comparing the integrity of their sources with that of the Star, just that we should, and I know you do, at least have a critical eye as to who the source is and what possibly might be their motivation. Your posts on this whole affair makes it sound like that if something is printed in the Star, it must be true. You continued to use the Star's credibility, and investigative team etc. etc, as proof that Ford was guilty of what they reported. I think it may be difficult for you to disagree with anything printed in the Star from here on in. Saying that proof of Ford's guilt is because the Star printed it, and if in the future disagreeing with their reporting (not editorial opinion, of course) would be hypocritical at worst and inconsistent at best.

So accuse us of being somewhat more skeptical than you and others, but we w kept an open mind as to the possibility the Star was correct, and once we got a source less open to skepticism, we immediately accepted it.

Personally, I have no crow eggs on my face to eat (or something like that).

I sincerely hope you understand and accept this explanation at face value and do not continue to paint us a being kooky and ramming it down our collective throats. Not everybody sees things the same way. We admittedly had more skepticism, that was proven to be misplaced, but our skepticism was not irrationally arrived at and was not a position carved in stone.

Nicely written Shack.
After 6 months, and no real proof, I took it one step further and I believe that the star needed to be taken to task.
My position was show us some proof of real "wrongdoings" in his personal life or stick to the issue of running the city.