"If I said…"? Dear me, here I've been assuming you knew at least that, even if you were perhaps uncertain between the Star's actual statements and their implications.
If "a different set of guidelines" are indeed used for the media by courts, you should have little trouble finding some evidence of what you say. There's a long Wikipedia article on Defamation in Canadian Law, in which I find no such mention.
Again, please stop. You are either lying or not as worldly as I believe you are. Wikipedia is amazing, but it is not an all inclusive compendium of law, and the absence or presence of information on Wikipedia is certainly not proof.
Oh Dear, I did forget that Wikipedia might fall into the realm of Journalism, so if the info is not there, then you must be right (sorry could not resist).
In reality, to prove my claim, I would have to hire a really good lawyer or spend many weeks of research. Neither of which I am inclined to do. So I guess you win the debate... See how nicely that works.... note that it does not mean that your position is correct, it just means that I don't have the resources to battle with you.. I would try to prove it to you by using an analogy, but you would just dig up some more information to shape the debate in another direction.
I love the last line of your post "we have a free press to protect us ordinary folk......." In a previous post you had nothing but disdain for those ordinary folk who cannot take the time to read past the misleading headlines in a newspaper, or to take the time to wade through pages if not volumes of information before they can determine if the story they are reading is balanced.
The fact that you cannot even admit that Headlines are misleading, or that newspapers are aware of this and use it to their advantage is disappointing, but it shows how entrenched you really are.
The last line is also an interesting and telling line, putting the journalist up on a pedestal against "those who've sold themselves to politics or other unsavory trades" Wow, you have really romanticized this profession as the last great bastion of all that is good and pure in the world.
It is unfortunate that you cannot see that, like everything else in the world, many journalists have sold out.
Two significant points from that article are that any defendant—no special mention of media—has a reverse onus of proving the statement innocent, and that as libel laws go, ours is the most plaintiff-friendly. Both of which increase the fear-factor for media, and anyone else, getting it wrong. In fact it makes a tactic like your contradictory complaint that the Star slandered Rob but used weasel words so as not to slander Rob extremely risky. So evidence please, for this special 'by' the media gets.
Or is this another, "everyone knows …," perhaps like your slur about what the Star intends? Certainly like so much of the wishful blather about what the news should be, instead of what it actually and precisely has been.
What we all agree on I trust, is that the news should not be of a Mayor who seems to be consorting with convicted criminals, murderers, (and their victims) and drug-dealers, let alone consuming dangerous drugs, whose illegal status might persuade him to secrecy and tempt him to the dangers we know he's succumbed to before of driving himself while impaired.
That has been the news; we can disagree as we choose about what parts of it we attribute how much credibility to. But I hope neither of us thinks the citizens would be better off with this all this stuff puritanically or fearfully ignored, suppressed and kept from us by the media, while the gossip filled the cocktail parties, political watering holes, balls and drug dens of various 'insiders'.
We have a free press to protect us ordinary folk with our busy lives from just that sort of insider dealing by those who've sold themselves to politics or other unsavoury trades we can't do without.
As I mentioned before, my issue is not with any one story in The Star. The Star stories themselves have been carefully proofed, and reviewed by their legal teams to ensure that they fall certain parameters. The issue is with the sensationalism, and the attempt to connect the stories to smear Rob Ford.
OJ, I wish you well in that ivory tower, like our buddy Mike Duffy, please try not to do too much damage when that tower
starts to crumble around you.