Arrest warrant issued for Constable Forcillo

I believe that's what the police will be counting on. Colour me a cynic, but I simply don't believe a cop in Toronto will be put in jail for this charge.

i tend to agree with you.......being charged is one thing being found guilty is quite another. i remember a few being charged but i do not recall any being convicted. time will tell i guess!
 
I'm sure the SIU has video from the streetcar cameras but we'll probably never see that footage.

After it becomes an exhibit for trial, it's public information.
 
You guys are very jaded, indeed.

I have refrained from commenting on this case because I thought there must be some evidence of special circumstances we know/knew very little about that might offer an explanation for what, IMHO, is a very clear and strong case of second degree murder.

Now that the SIU has instigated charges, it is fairly obvious -- though not certain -- that there is no such evidence or explanation.

And you are mistaken if you think the Crown Attorney's office or the judiciary takes these type of cases casually... not in Toronto! If there is persuasive, cogent evidence, the Crown will put a huge effort into this prosecution...

On the facts that we know so far about this case, I think a jury will likely lean very strongly for conviction, and a judge even more so.

If there is no evidence of attenuating circumstances and there is an acquittal at trial, there will be huge demonstrations in Toronto and people like me will be part of them.

But let us wait until ALL the evidence is in before jumping to any conclusions.

Perry


I hope you are right and I am wrong.
 
I doubt it. Cops don't testify against other cops. Without the video, there is no charge. Even with the video, there is probably no conviction. I hope I am wrong about that, but how often do you see cops going to jail?
That cop who assaulted that black kid during Caribana a few years ago got jailtime. IIRC he was allowed to serve weekends.

It is indeed pretty rare though
 
That cop who assaulted that black kid during Caribana a few years ago got jailtime. IIRC he was allowed to serve weekends.

It is indeed pretty rare though

Most first time offenders don't see jail time. Judges are very cautious about destroying people's lives. 1st. time offenders are usually given a break unless the crime warrants severe punishment.
 
After it becomes an exhibit for trial, it's public information.

Not all videos are released to the public after they become an exhibit for trial. Depends on the content. The judge can order a publication ban.
 
I agree, The first three could have been argued as bad judgement regarding the actual threat and response but when he was on his back - the cop made a conscience decision to kill the kid.

What I am very curious is that this one individual obviously was rogue even among his fellow officers. Would they have ever reported this incident themselves ? At what point would a cop report a rogue cop ?


Weren't the police filmed or accused of tampering with evidence at the scene of this crime already?
 
I don't think the number of shots is the determining factor. If the first shot killed him then the other eight are a non issue. Besides, we don't even know how many bullets hit him. The way I see it, this will be about why he opened fire in the first place when it doesn't appear the officers life was in immediate danger, not the total number of shots fired.


I doubt he was dead after the first shot. My take on it is that YS may have been waving his knife after he was down in his state of shock and desperation. JF, who was also taunted, lost his cool, and pumped six more bullets into YS to finish him off instead of waiting for the taser or for JF to pass out or be over-powered by others or other means.
 
You guys are very jaded, indeed.

I have refrained from commenting on this case because I thought there must be some evidence of special circumstances we know/knew very little about that might offer an explanation for what, IMHO, is a very clear and strong case of second degree murder.

Now that the SIU has instigated charges, it is fairly obvious -- though not certain -- that there is no such evidence or explanation.

And you are mistaken if you think the Crown Attorney's office or the judiciary takes these type of cases casually... not in Toronto! If there is persuasive, cogent evidence, the Crown will put a huge effort into this prosecution...

On the facts that we know so far about this case, I think a jury will likely lean very strongly for conviction, and a judge even more so.

If there is no evidence of attenuating circumstances and there is an acquittal at trial, there will be huge demonstrations in Toronto and people like me will be part of them.

But let us wait until ALL the evidence is in before jumping to any conclusions.

Perry


We are not a judge or jury so it's okay for us to opine.
 
I am very happy for the young man family with regard to the news. However, past results showed "...of the six previous Toronto cases involving charges of manslaughter or murder, all officers were acquitted."
Even if the officer convicted at the end,it would cost tax payers lots of money just to keep the guy 'in shape' from the inside!
 
The best the prosecution can hope for I think is a hung jury.

If you're going to stand there with a knife in your hand making threatening gestures to the public and police officers one possible outcome is that a police officer in front of you will become afraid and once that happens all bets are off. There's a reasonable chance you're going to get shot even if you are a really nice guy from a nice family who is just slightly mentally ill or disturbed.

Every day cops have to deal with the worst of the worst of the worst that society puts out there and some jury member will cut him some slack because of this.
 
The best the prosecution can hope for I think is a hung jury.

If you're going to stand there with a knife in your hand making threatening gestures to the public and police officers one possible outcome is that a police officer in front of you will become afraid and once that happens all bets are off. There's a reasonable chance you're going to get shot even if you are a really nice guy from a nice family who is just slightly mentally ill or disturbed.

Every day cops have to deal with the worst of the worst of the worst that society puts out there and some jury member will cut him some slack because of this.
Back to #9. Your perfectly lawful shooting, may turn into an unlawful shooting if you continue to shoot after the threat is no longer actively present.
 
Back to #9. Your perfectly lawful shooting, may turn into an unlawful shooting if you continue to shoot after the threat is no longer actively present.

Especially if you stop shooting, yell at the victim, observe him fall, and then lower your aim and shoot at him on the ground.
 
Can't leave him in a close street car. We would not want him in control of a street car to run over whatever is in his way.


Even *I* know how to pull down on the tension cable on the back and unhook the power. Seen it come off and put back on lots.