Is this an appropriate wedding gift?

IMO, the gift is fine given the relationship (or rather non-relationship) of the guests to the bride(s), and it's fairly creative with a thoughtful and appropriate message in the card. The article mentions the brides and these guests are "casual acquaintances".

Which begs the question, why were these particular guests invited to the wedding in the first place? Seems like the goal of "Bride Laura" was to extract as much money as possible from as many people as possible.
 
Apparently the guests who gave the gift said there was more in the basket but the recipients sent a pic that had items missing (pasta, salsas, balsamic vinegar and olive oil, pesto and Godiva biscuits).
 
No matter how appropriate the gift was, the response from the bride was even less appropriate.
She showed no class at all.
A gift is a gift. If you don't like it, just say thank you and move on.
 
This why I hate weddings nowadays. This expectation that you will cover the plate with a financial gift is becoming more and more common. I've been invited to 3 weddings in the past 2 years by people I don't even know all that well. I didn't go to any of them, just made some crappy excuse that they probably didn't believe lol. My friend went to one of them and it ended up costing him about $400 with the gift and cost of hotel, plus he had to take the afternoon off work.

Agreed. If it's going to be a business transaction, the "happy couple" should just sell tickets.
 
Apparently the guests who gave the gift said there was more in the basket but the recipients sent a pic that had items missing (pasta, salsas, balsamic vinegar and olive oil, pesto and Godiva biscuits).
Maybe a contribution to a party feast but not exactly a gift that helps the new couple on their wedded way. If the bride invited people without ensuring they knew and accepted 'the deal' she's the one at fault. The more so because she then was so crass, rude and inhospitable to her own guest as to demean the gift. However odd or inappropriate a gift may be in your eyes, they gave it, and thanks is all you need to say, if you can't say more nice things. It's your fault for inviting such stingy, unknowing gusts and the more you say, the deeper you dig your hole.

What ever happened to inviting people you wanted to share your day with?
 
This why I hate weddings nowadays. This expectation that you will cover the plate with a financial gift is becoming more and more common. I've been invited to 3 weddings in the past 2 years by people I don't even know all that well. I didn't go to any of them, just made some crappy excuse that they probably didn't believe lol. My friend went to one of them and it ended up costing him about $400 with the gift and cost of hotel, plus he had to take the afternoon off work.

You do realize that even if you don't go to the wedding you are obligated to give a gift.
 
why is that?

It's called Etiquette.

If you are invited to a wedding you are supposed to give a gift whether you choose to go or not.

In the past, I have always attended friends and relatives weddings when invited and given the appropriate gift of cash (only). On the couple of occasions when I could not make it, I gave a gift of the same amount as if I had attended the wedding. I can't say I've ever been invited to a wedding where I didn't really know the person.
 
It's called Etiquette.

If you are invited to a wedding you are supposed to give a gift whether you choose to go or not.

i disagree. especially if the person is not close and is only known through work
 
i disagree. especially if the person is not close and is only known through work

It doesn't matter whether you disagree or not, the correct etiquette is that if you are invited to a wedding, you give a gift whether you go or not. Not everyone knows this, but this is the rule. (I will bet that the work friends who invited you to their wedding knew the rule and they think you're a cheapskate because you didn't follow proper etiquette.)
 
It doesn't matter whether you disagree or not, the correct etiquette is that if you are invited to a wedding, you give a gift whether you go or not. Not everyone knows this, but this is the rule. (I will bet that the work friends who invited you to their wedding knew the rule and they think you're a cheapskate because you didn't follow proper etiquette.)

i get lots of invites- including from people I don't like. I am under no obligation to send them gifts if i dont attend their wedding. i disagree with you thats its proper etiquette.

http://etiquette.about.com/od/Receptions/a/Guide-To-Proper-Wedding-Gift-Etiquette.htm
 
from Ms. Manners

Miss Manners: Gentle readers, Miss Manners is here to help.

_______________________

Holiday, Fla.: We've been invited to a wedding celebration for a longtime friend of my husband's family. We aren't planning to attend, and I need to know whether we're obligated to send a present. I don't even like the bride.

Miss Manners: You will be relieved to hear that you do not have to send a present, but less so to hear that in addition to your formal letter declining the invitation, you should send a letter wishing the couple happiness. In neither should you mention that you don't even like the bride.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/discussion/2010/03/11/DI2010031103184.html
 
You are obligated to give a gift.

1. If you’re invited to the ceremony, it’s customary to send a gift.
“This holds true whether or not you’re able to attend,” Post says. However, this guideline applies only if you’re invited to the actual marriage ceremony. If you’re invited to a belated reception, such as one that takes place after a destination wedding or an elopement, gifts are not obligatory. “You’re not on the line for a gift,” Post says, “but many people give one anyway.” Likewise, a wedding announcement does not require the recipient to send a gift, but many friends and family members still do
.


http://www.divinecaroline.com/life-...ous-giving-seven-rules-wedding-gift-etiquette

And another:


If I can't make it to the wedding, do I still give a gift?

Yes. Ideally, says Woodham, guests give gifts to help the couple commemorate the occasion and start their new life together and that should be the case whether a guest partakes in the wedding festivities or not. "If you care about the couple, you send a gift not just because you were invited to the wedding," she says
.


http://www.smartmoney.com/spend/family-money/the-wedding-gift-etiquette-guide-23264/


This is the way it has always been. I've known this rule since I was 18 years old.

I suppose you could make the argument that if you haven't even seen your cousin that is getting married in 20 years and he invited you to his wedding (along with 400 others) then damn it, you don't need to send a gift. (I'd probably buy that.)

But if you know the person, even a work colleague, and they invite you to their wedding, it is proper decorum to send a gift whether you attend the wedding or not.
 
well Ms Manners and I disagree.


since this is terb, I will be exagerate in a wild fashion

so if hitler and eva sent you an invitation and you couldn't attend because you were at dachau- you would send a gift?
 
No I don't realize that because it's a load of nonsense. Sure sending a gift regardless may be a nice thing to do, and I probably would do that if the people getting married were close relatives or even reasonably close friends, but I still would'nt be "obligated", and in these situations where I literally hardly knew the people involved, that doesn't "obligate" me to do feck all. Going by your logic if I was getting married I could invite the entire population of Mississauga and they would all be obligated to give me a gift just because I invited them. Hmmmm hang on....

exactly right.
 
I don't make the rules.

But don't ever kid yourself, people know the rules.

If you're invited to a wedding (of someone you know), you are supposed to give a gift whether you go or not. The idea of a wedding gift is just that - a gift. It's not supposed to be about an exchange of a gift in return for a meal and booze, etc. They are getting married, they invited you to their wedding (presuming you know them), you're supposed to give a gift.
 
exactly right.

No, exactly wrong.

I know you can't get your head around what I've just told you. (I can tell that up until this moment in your life, you had no idea. (So you learned something today!!)) You think that because you have chosen NOT to attend the wedding that you are off the hook for buying a wedding gift, but this is simply not the case.

Sorry, as I said, this is common courtesy.

And the example of inviting the entire city of Mississauga is absurd.

Do you know them?

Yes.

Did they invite you to their wedding?

Yes.

Then you get them a gift whether you attend their wedding or not.

No-one is forcing you to do anything. If you choose not to buy them a gift, that is your choice, but proper decorum is that you buy them a gift.

If it was me getting married and you were my "friend" and I invited you to my wedding and you chose not to attend and did not send a gift, I wouldn't say anything to you, but I sure as hell would take note of your cheapskate behaviour and it would forever be in my memory that you are cheap.
 
I don't make the rules.

But don't ever kid yourself, people know the rules.

If you're invited to a wedding (of someone you know), you are supposed to give a gift whether you go or not. The idea of a wedding gift is just that - a gift. It's not supposed to be about an exchange for a meal and booze. They are getting married, they invited you to their wedding (presuming you know them), you're supposed to give a gift.

yes but not all etiquette people agree with you. so the rules are not so clear cut as you think.

you also are making an assumption about the relationship. I get lots of invites from business acquaintances and staff- we are not close and they just sent me the invitation because i have lots of money. a gift is just that - a gift- it can never be an obligation or a duty.