Toronto Mayor Rob Ford has won his conflict of interest case. For good
The Supreme Court of Canada announced Thursday morning that it has rejected a request to hear a final appeal of Ford’s January victory. As usual, the court did not offer an explanation.
The decision, made by a three-judge panel, ends a 15-month saga that nearly cost Ford his job last year. The case weakened him at council, took attention away from his agenda, and cost him tens of thousands of dollars.
The court was always unlikely to grant the appeal. It accepts only about 12 per cent of the applications it receives in a given year, and it rejects cases it does not think involve legal questions of significant public importance.
The lawyer who pursued the conflict of interest suit, Clayton Ruby, had told the court in a written filing that the case involves “legal questions that are fundamentally important to all municipalities and all Canadians.” Ford’s lawyer had disagreed.
The case could have added significant uncertainty in the 2014 mayoral election. Under the court’s normal timetables, a decision would probably have come during the campaign, possibly very shortly before voting day.
Ford has triumphed in three separate legal cases during his troubled mayoralty, though one, a defamation suit, is still under appeal. He remains embroiled in a scandal over a video that appears to show him smoking crack cocaine; he denies that he uses crack and that a video exists.
Under provincial law, it is up to citizens to pursue politicians in court over alleged conflicts of interest. Ruby worked on behalf of resident Paul Magder — and Adam Chaleff-Freudenthaler, a left-leaning activist, Ford opponent and former library board vice-chair who recruited Magder