Should we keep the Queen?

Should we keep the Queen?

  • Yes

    Votes: 38 40.4%
  • No

    Votes: 50 53.2%
  • Yes but in a different form

    Votes: 4 4.3%
  • Undecided

    Votes: 2 2.1%

  • Total voters
    94

Yoga Face

New member
Jun 30, 2009
6,307
19
0
To some she represents both the good and bad history of English civilization while today representing the English at their majestic best.

Nobility was a necessary stepping stone to allow civilization to develop to its present democratic height.


th


To some she represents oppression - the oppression of nobility over the working class and the oppression of the development of a truly democratic society.


th
 
Last edited:
My oddball opinion is royalty should be voted in.

It should be an honorary position and its job should be to represent its people at its finest with charity work and an immaculate public display of what it means to represent the people of the Empire.


I do not understand the concept of bloodlines being important.
 
When I first saw this thread, I thought that maybe rumours of a video of the Queen smoking a crack pipe may have surfaced.


In my youth I couldn't see the value of the British monarchy, but after visits to London and some of the royal castles - I realize that the monarchy provides tradition and stability particularly through turbulent times. The bloodlines are important to the tradition - otherwise the pomp and ceremony makes no sense.

If you do have an elected monarchy, the stability & tradition are out the window and it becomes possible (how ever remote) that a Rob Ford clone could be your next King.
 
And to some she represents a useless figure, that outlived its purpose a very long time ago, while still costing a hefty sum of money to taxpayers.
 
And to some she represents a useless figure, that outlived its purpose a very long time ago, while still costing a hefty sum of money to taxpayers.

QEII only costs Canadian Taxpayers when she visits Canada as tradition dictates that we pick up the tab for her travelling costs.

Other than that, the Canadian Taxpayers don't contribute towards the cost of the Monarchy.

Canada is the greatest country in the world. While I will not dispute that it is a multicultural society, the fact is that Canada as we know it was conceived and built by the British system of government, laws, and society. This is a fact of history. The Royal Family is part of that history, part of what makes Canada the greatest country in the world and ending it would be denying our heritage.

The Queen has dedicated her entire life to the service of the Empire, the world even. She has served with dignity and grace and that is a scarce thing in this day and age. I for one would not want her life. She lives in a guilded cage as far as I'm concerned.
 
When I think about the british monarchy I see colonialism and oppression. The British used to be what the Americans are now, I vote to put as much distance between those two countries as possible.
 
We have a 1000 years of political development behind us through our relationship to the British Isles. I don't see the big republics of France and USA working any better. We live in one of the best countries in the world.

Have some (or all of them) monarchs screwed the population? Yes. Has most every other leader done the same? Yes.

Personally, I need some big convincing to change horses after 1000 years.
 
The problem with getting rid of the Queen is that the Canadian Constitution would have to be opened up to do so. Its not just an amendment like in the States; we don't do it quite so easily. It is the entire Constitution being opened up for review, updating, change etc. I would be happy to be rid of the Queen of Canada, but to do so would mean EVERY special interest group, ethnic group, gender group, language group, etc ad nauseum, would be lobbying hard to have their particular needs incorporated into the Constitution. What a fucking quagmire that would be. Keeping the Queen is far and away the least evil, when compared to the nightmare of opening up the Canadian Constitution for review. Ugh.
 
When I think about the british monarchy I see colonialism and oppression. The British used to be what the Americans are now, I vote to put as much distance between those two countries as possible.

That's more a comment on you. What does the monarchy do that oppresses you? Are you that much of a wimp. You're right, 'use to do'. The British empire is no more. If you want to feel oppressed think about the history of the Chinese, with or without their monarchy.

I'm surprise this poll didn't come earlier this month when the Queen celebrated her 60th anniversary.
 
My oddball opinion is royalty should be voted in.

It should be an honorary position and its job should be to represent its people at its finest with charity work and an immaculate public display of what it means to represent the people of the Empire.


I do not understand the concept of bloodlines being important.

You must have a dysfunctional or complicated family, if you don't know the importance of bloodlines. So who would you vote for?
 
When I first saw this thread, I thought that maybe rumours of a video of the Queen smoking a crack pipe may have surfaced.


In my youth I couldn't see the value of the British monarchy, but after visits to London and some of the royal castles - I realize that the monarchy provides tradition and stability particularly through turbulent times. The bloodlines are important to the tradition - otherwise the pomp and ceremony makes no sense.

If you do have an elected monarchy, the stability & tradition are out the window and it becomes possible (how ever remote) that a Rob Ford clone could be your next King.

disagree that bloodlines are so important

by voting in nobility we would be changing its concept of what it is to the better

some of the monarchs of history make Ford look like a genius


the history of the monarchy is one of self serving war for the riches of the nobility


progress in civilization was often halted or even sent reeling backwards as nobility protected its turf often with the church's blessings


I find it difficult to believe it was a necessary step in social development

the whole concept and proven social value of democracy was established as far back as Athens and Socrates but British nobility and the lackey church pursued self interest above humankinds development making a mockery of the term `nobility`


the English finishing schools that put self interested bloodlines into power today make me want to revolt


Lord Dufferin (Dufferin Street) was a rare exception to this as he cared for the starving Irish while the rest of the nobility built mansions


they have not changed to this day and I find the royal families caring attitude for the working class a scam not representative of the British Nobility as a whole


my experience with them at the U of T is that they are bred to be snobs


Socrates-Quotes-5.jpg
 
When I think about the british monarchy I see colonialism and oppression. The British used to be what the Americans are now, I vote to put as much distance between those two countries as possible.

Really?

I see the foundation of the free world. The so called "western democracies". It's not perfect, but it's a damn sight better than any other alternative out there. And you can thank the British for that.

But I guess you'd rather have a system that was put in place by Islamo Fascists or maybe the Chinese, or Russians, or Africans, or (take your pick).
 
Really?

I see the foundation of the free world. The so called "western democracies". It's not perfect, but it's a damn sight better than any other alternative out there. And you can thank the British for that.

But I guess you'd rather have a system that was put in place by Islamo Fascists or maybe the Chinese, or Russians, or Africans, or (take your pick).

I would disagree that nobility is the foundation of the free world


that it has evolved into freedom was not its raison d'être


its raison d'être was to keep the rich and powerful rich and powerful


it was by circumstance, not design, that it evolved into a democracy so it should not be trumpeted

and that is (now sound the trumpets) what I think
 
disagree that bloodlines are so important

by voting in nobility we would be changing its concept of what it is to the better

some of the monarchs of history make Ford look like a genius


the history of the monarchy is one of self serving war for the riches of the nobility


progress in civilization was often halted or even sent reeling backwards as nobility protected its turf often with the church's blessings


I find it difficult to believe it was a necessary step in social development

the whole concept and proven social value of democracy was established as far back as Athens and Socrates but British nobility and the lackey church pursued self interest above humankinds development making a mockery of the term `nobility`


the English finishing schools that put self interested bloodlines into power today make me want to revolt


Lord Dufferin (Dufferin Street) was a rare exception to this as he cared for the starving Irish while the rest of the nobility built mansions


they have not changed to this day and I find the royal families caring attitude for the working class as a scam not representative of the British Nobility as a whole


my experience with them at the U of T is that they are bred to be snobs

...... and some monarchs were most highly educated and some of the most advanced thinkers of their times. Peter the Great comes to mind. Elizabeth I in the areas of languages (she spoke 6, how about you?), religion, grammar, logic, philosophy, literature, geography, history, mathematics and astronomy.

If you don't like the english finishing schools you must UCC, Ashbury, and Appleby, St Andrews, LCC, and Bishops as well.
 


...... and some monarchs were most highly educated and some of the most advanced thinkers of their times. Peter the Great comes to mind. Elizabeth I in the areas of languages (she spoke 6, how about you?), religion, grammar, logic, philosophy, literature, geography, history, mathematics and astronomy.

If you don't like the english finishing schools you must UCC, Ashbury, and Appleby, St Andrews, LCC, and Bishops as well.

yes some were and they had a very tough job dealing with the ruling class, other monarchs, peasant revolt, invasion, the church ....

even if they wanted a democracy they were not going to be allowed to create one

not criticizing individuals but a system of nobility that includes finishing schools (where everyone passes) that polish you up for your future prestigious appointment as a Lord or Duke or even President (think of Bush and his skull and bones ivy league school )
 
You must have a dysfunctional or complicated family, if you don't know the importance of bloodlines. So who would you vote for?

you must have had a misguided childhood, perhaps spent too much time as a Boy Scout or boy scout leader....to believe that bloodlines are of any value, importance or significance in todays day and age
 
Last edited:
r bscoutoyu

you must have had a misguided childhood, perhaps spent too much time as a Boy Scout or boy scout leader....to believe that bloodlines are of any value, importance or significance in todays day and age


Mutley! Where have you been? Broke free from you cave?

I guess you've never heard the phrase blood is thicker than water. Most people put family/blood ahead of all else. It brings out loyalty more often than not. Yet as any good breeders knows some outside lines once and a while is good practice. I guess we can put you in the no column then. That's also why money often marry money, not always for love. How are those crocs, any new colours out?
 
You must have a dysfunctional or complicated family, if you don't know the importance of bloodlines. So who would you vote for?

you can see the importance of nobility bloodlines in the Habsburgs

Charles_V.jpg


it is an embarrassment to the humanities that these drooling idiots were kept in power by a self serving elite



I would vote for this guy

th
 
you can see the importance of nobility bloodlines in the Habsburgs

Charles_V.jpg


it is an embarrassment to the humanities that these drooling idiots were kept in power by a self serving elite



I would vote for this guy

th

I'm quite familiar with Hapsburg legacy, yet it wasn't unique to the Royals, or Upper Class society through history. There are a couple of members who could school you quite well on the ins and out of their lineage better than I.

As for your vote there are a number of members, not I, who would strongly argue against him, labeling him a hypocrite, charlatan, phony. Good luck with it.