Should brothels be legal? Supreme Court of Canada ponders issue

Butler1000

Well-known member
Oct 31, 2011
30,181
4,363
113
If legal, would Terbites visit the Bunny Ranch franchise in TO?
It would depend on their pricing structure. The one they use now would fail. We tend to prefer "all inclusive" here.
The other factor would be its visability. I could see people outside videotaping people going in for various reasons. It would have to be in an out of the way industrial area or get protested.

Somehow I don't see something like the Keg Mansion doing a conversion any time soon. With Dolly Parton at the ribbon cutting ceremony.
 

explorerzip

Well-known member
Jul 27, 2006
8,129
1,310
113
It would depend on their pricing structure. The one they use now would fail. We tend to prefer "all inclusive" here.
The other factor would be its visability. I could see people outside videotaping people going in for various reasons. It would have to be in an out of the way industrial area or get protested.

Somehow I don't see something like the Keg Mansion doing a conversion any time soon. With Dolly Parton at the ribbon cutting ceremony.
Casa Loma would be an interesting site; it's not used much anyways. Has that Eyes Wide Shut kind of aura around it.
 

Trojan Horse

Banned
Jun 9, 2013
21
0
0
I heard in Ontario its already legal. I remember reading someone tried to open one, but it was near a playground and a bunch of people protested it to shut down.

If you know guys are paying for sex and going in and out of a building, all of a sudden they are creepy criminals who shouldn't be around kids. However, if you talk to those same guys, they usually have kids, and are your coworkers and relatives.

I guess perception is everything.

So, in conclusion brothels are already legal, and if you go there you are a sick pervert and your sexual desires are a blight on society.

SHAME ON YOU

SICKO !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 

Plan B

Race Relations Expert
Jun 7, 2008
1,055
4
38
Hopefully, at some point the safety of the John will also be a consideration. The violence, threats, and robbery committed on Johns is probably one of the greatest under reported crime categories in the history of mankind.
 

Butler1000

Well-known member
Oct 31, 2011
30,181
4,363
113
Hopefully, at some point the safety of the John will also be a consideration. The violence, threats, and robbery committed on Johns is probably one of the greatest under reported crime categories in the history of mankind.
Oh no......I'm sure all we would get is "well then...don't solicit hookers" with a snicker and a dismissive wave.
 

bluecolt

Well-known member
Jun 18, 2011
1,456
324
83
Today's the day at the Supreme Court of Canada. Go Terri Jean Bedford. Rah, rah Alan Young.
 
Last edited:

explorerzip

Well-known member
Jul 27, 2006
8,129
1,310
113
I'm not the poster saying they favor a Nordic legal scheme.
I was just trying to say that guys that push boundaries beyond what the lady is comfortable with should be dealt with harshly, which should include jail time if warranted. The vast majority of us never push a lady beyond her boundaries, but there are some out there. I'm not saying that you are one of those guys Aardvark just so you know.
 

avxl1003

New member
Aug 31, 2009
1,346
0
0
I think brothels should be legal, and I would definitely visit one.

I do think, however, that even if things are "legalized" it will be some time before a good legitimate brothel opens up.
 

explorerzip

Well-known member
Jul 27, 2006
8,129
1,310
113
I heard in Ontario its already legal. I remember reading someone tried to open one, but it was near a playground and a bunch of people protested it to shut down.

If you know guys are paying for sex and going in and out of a building, all of a sudden they are creepy criminals who shouldn't be around kids. However, if you talk to those same guys, they usually have kids, and are your coworkers and relatives.

I guess perception is everything.

So, in conclusion brothels are already legal, and if you go there you are a sick pervert and your sexual desires are a blight on society.

SHAME ON YOU

SICKO !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Not sure about this. I think brothers are not illegal, which is a big difference from being legal. I believe Toronto licenses massage parlours, but that doesn't make them legal for sexual services. I also think that Barrie licences escort agencies, but that doesn't give them free reign to open brothels just that they can send out ladies to private homes, hotels, etc.

The legal grey zone that sex workers are in doesn't help the situation at all. The big problem here is that sex workers from both sides have valid points. If you worked as a sex worker and faced abuse (from pimps, clients) or were introduced to drugs, etc. then it's understandable that you'd want a complete ban on brothels and the whole industry. The ladies that did not have to face that abuse and are in control over how they conduct themselves are likely going to favour legalization or decriminalization. Then you have all sorts of ladies somewhere in the middle. The end result is that no matter what the courts decide, one of the sides is going to be upset and the industry will either be out in the open with licensed brothels or underground and unseen.

I think it's the same with any industry and any company. Some have a negative experience and what the industry or company shut down and others have the opposite experience.

Plan B has a great point too in that client safety and rights would have to be considered if the courts to decide to legalize. Clients should have the right to be reasonably secure at a brothel just like any other business establishment.
 

GPIDEAL

Prolific User
Jun 27, 2010
23,359
11
38
I heard in Ontario its already legal. I remember reading someone tried to open one, but it was near a playground and a bunch of people protested it to shut down.

If you know guys are paying for sex and going in and out of a building, all of a sudden they are creepy criminals who shouldn't be around kids. However, if you talk to those same guys, they usually have kids, and are your coworkers and relatives.

I guess perception is everything.

So, in conclusion brothels are already legal, and if you go there you are a sick pervert and your sexual desires are a blight on society.

SHAME ON YOU

SICKO !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
The laws on bawdy houses has not been repealed, even though there was the Ontario court victory prior to this appeal. Perhaps the police weren't enforcing things until the outcome of this SCC appeal.
 
Toronto Escorts