Doug Ford says critics ‘can’t go after our fiscal record’ – challenge accepted
Over the weekend, as the downward spiral continued, Coun. Doug Ford claimed in a CP24 interview that all the scandals facing the Ford family are just the inevitable result of the great work they’re doing down at City Hall.
The media comes up with these negative stories, he said, because “they can’t go after our fiscal record.”
Challenge accepted. My name is Matt and today I’ll be going after the Fords on their fiscal record.
As the scandals have been heating up, Doug’s been giving essentially the same stump speech all over town. Let’s look at a few of his more common talking points.
Doug says: “We’ve saved the taxpayers over a billion dollars.”
False.
Absolutely, definitively false. I’ve turned this number over in my head again and again and I can’t find any fair accounting of the city’s finances that supports the Fords as saving anywhere near a billion dollars. When Mayor Rob Ford took office, the gross operating budget was $9.214 billion. This year, it’s $9.405 billion. That represents an increase of about $200 million, not a decrease of a billion dollars.
The net operating budget — the part of the budget you pay with your property taxes — increased from $3.534 billion to $3.713 billion. Also not a reduction of a billion dollars.
So how does Doug Ford get to a billion dollars in savings? I have two theories.
The first is that he is doing some kind of calculation that takes into account multi-year savings on various budget lines. For example, council’s decision to partially contract out garbage collection is projected to save about $78 million over the life of the seven-year contract. He could be adding up a bunch of multi-year figures like that on both the capital and operating side of the budget. But that’s cherry-picking and ignores all the moves the Fords have made that cost the city. Things like stalling Transit City for a year, removing the Jarvis bike lanes and firing senior bureaucrats.
The other theory? He’s using an analysis put forward by the Toronto Taxpayers’ Coalition which compares the growth of the city’s operating budget over the first three years of Ford’s term with the growth of the same budget over the first three years of Mayor David Miller’s first term.
It’s a ridiculous analysis....