Gawker Claims Video Exists of Rob Ford Smoking Crack

What is the objection to having Ford take a drug test? If he is clean that will firmly put the issue to rest.
.

Try doing that with any employee in Ontario and you will ensure a lawsuit.

The evidence seems to be getting weaker as time goes by and not stronger. As an example - another bit of shoddy reporting with all the stories about the cops visiting City Hall. There were stories in both the Star and the Globe. Now according to City Hall employees the cops were there on a routine basis to obtain info on various complaints about suspected drugs sites that are regularly phoned into City Hall. Had nothing to do with any video.

So at the end of two weeks what do we have? A missing video made by drug dealers that almost no one has seen except two Toronto Star employees. Given that it's missing (or non-existent) no one can verify if its real or been tampered with. Isn't this analogous to saying Mel Lastman hung with biker gangs because he had his picture taken with them?

At this stage the accusations seem pretty weak. The conclusions that people reach that he is guilty because of an unverified newspaper story and becausehe hasn't sued are laughable. If these were valid criteria think of how many guilty politicians there must be are out there.

The way I see it - the Jennifers, the Matt's and the Fuji's of this world rub their hands together in glee and seize on ridiculous logic as if it were sold fact because they want to trash Ford to prove they have been right all along. Fine. Ford's an idiot, you would have to be brain dead not to see that. But for goodness sake wake me up when there is some actual evidence and not all this BS.

Oh and if you want to hang people on better evidence direct your attention to the Provincial Liberal Party.
 
Err, you appear to be unfamiliar with the notion of journalistic privilege. No reputable reporter is going to reveal the identity of a confidential source. Period. Journalists have gone to jail over this.

Fair enough. While your here can you also explain to those who are asking the lack of about libel suits how the 2009 Grant vs Torstar case makes it that much more difficult to sue. Many here seem to think its easy and the lack of litigation is a sign of guilt.
 
Err, you appear to be unfamiliar with the notion of journalistic privilege. No reputable reporter is going to reveal the identity of a confidential source. Period. Journalists have gone to jail over this.

And rightly so. There is no reason reporters should be above the law :D
 
Ridiculous, Ford-ish question. If they made up their story, they would never work again in their field and both they and the Star would be hit with a massive libel suit. Smarten up.

You are correct. They didn't make it up. But they may have been conned. So hypethetically if this true and they are now sitting on this information, where does it leave them legally? Will a simple retration cut it?
The second asticle and its embellishments really have me wondering now. That and almost 2 weeks now with no sign of a video.
 
Jesus H Christ....

Do you really think that the Star reporting about the 2 reporters seeing the video would not have been cleared by the Star at the highest level and the Star's lawyers?

At this point if it turns out the reporters were conned they may have deniability in the courts. Awaiting the lawyers to grace us with their wisdom on this one.
 
You are correct. They didn't make it up. But they may have been conned. So hypethetically if this true and they are now sitting on this information, where does it leave them legally? Will a simple retration cut it?
The second asticle and its embellishments really have me wondering now. That and almost 2 weeks now with no sign of a video.

It is just as likely that they were duped by a faked tape as it is that the tape is real. The real guilt of the Star is their eagerness to trash Ford without corroboratingevidence. That's like Journalism 101, but in the case of Ford they are willing to waive best practices.
 
Something else has been bothering me as well.
When the two reporters (and I suppose the gawker guy) got into the car did they think to take down the license number? Wouldn't that make sense for a reporter to do do that. And if the police are in fact investigating this in relation to a murder shouldn't the police be informed of this information?
More and more I wonder about this......
Says a lot about the reporters if they didn't even do that....
Or if they did and haven't used the information at this point to find them.....
If they were led to the car on an angle where the light allowed them to see the license and they could memorize it—they had no notebooks, remember—indeed they might have used it later to discover the plates had been switched, or the car borrowed, and the original registration was a dead end. Even fake drug-dealers doing this sort of thing for the first and only time are quite likely to have thought about obscuring the plates. Heck lotsa 'honest' people protect their plates with dark plastic shields, or drive with them dirty. And fake or real, they're not likely to give reporters who show an interest in stuff that could lead back to them any view of the video at all.

Then again, this is an argument that unprincipled reporters making up false attacks weren't very good at details and that proves they made it up. As if honest folk never missed a trick or a detail, and every parent didn't learn early on that too much detail in a story was a a giveaway.

While it's useful to point out, as you did, missing facts, impossible gaps in logic or unconsidered possibilities, which might explain the video, it's utterly stupid and harmful to the basic concept of democracy to simply repeat prejudices and insults about the people at the centre of this shitstorm. Slagging changes no one's mind, and the few bits of real information or insight that have been added to the mix are not at all conclusive. Again, and still, the only sensible position is that people did see something like what they described in their accounts, and until there's more concrete evidence the rest of us, like them, will have to work with whatever thought processes we usually use and the opinions we form as we normally do.
 
You are correct. They didn't make it up. But they may have been conned. So hypethetically if this true and they are now sitting on this information, where does it leave them legally? Will a simple retration cut it?
The second asticle and its embellishments really have me wondering now. That and almost 2 weeks now with no sign of a video.

According to the timeline posted in #1156, the Star reporters saw the video on April 2 but didn't publish the story until the middle of May.
They sat on the story for 6 weeks, most likely while they went through all the legal ramifications and research they could pull of to justify the major risk to their paper for publishing this story.
And so far nothing has come out to substantially weaken the initial story.
 
I like your quote about parents and too much detail OJ. What do you make of the second article by the reporters that added several embellishments to the story?

And I don't see how they couldn't have gotten it even when the car drove away. There are lights on it. Especially new cars as the reporters describe it.
 
You guys are like people who are told that shit smells but require a sample of shit to confirm that it smells.
Even if it never appears we have independent testimony... not only do we have that, we have precipitated massive effect.

Yet your only defense is 'gahduhhhhh Torana Sturr h8s Rub Foooooord' hate doesn't constitute a motive, nor does it constitute proof.
That analogy fails miserably.

The reason we shouldn't need to smell the shit is because we've smelled it many times before. We already have proof. We've seen/smelt the evidence.

In this case there are only two people who claim to have seen what may or may not be shit and they we don't even know them personally. The rest of us need to see the evidence/smell the shit ourselves. And so far we have not had that opportunity, including you.
 
According to the timeline posted in #1156, the Star reporters saw the video on April 2 but didn't publish the story until the middle of May.
They sat on the story for 6 weeks, most likely while they went through all the legal ramifications and research they could pull of to justify the major risk to their paper for publishing this story.
And so far nothing has come out to substantially weaken the initial story.

Except for the fact no video has been released.....after almost 2 weeks.

I want the video. I want them to say this is the video. Then test it.

If its real....roast the Mayor

If its fake....roast the Star

If it doesn't come out. I consider it a wash. He said/he said. Not enough.
 
We have just as much proof now as we would if the video is released. No more. No less. All the objection being raised by the Ford loons would be raised if the video were released. We hear from the usual suspects that it's a look a like, altered, etc.

Only a drug test will provide the answers everyone is looking for.
 
Try doing that with any employee in Ontario and you will ensure a lawsuit.

He is not "any employee", he is the mayor. More to the point, he wants to run for re election. Voters routinely demand things from politicians no employer event could, like tax returns, etc.

The burden rests with Ford to prove he is worth voting for

The evidence seems to be getting weaker as time goes by and not stronger. As an example - another bit of shoddy reporting with all the stories about the cops visiting City Hall. There were stories in both the Star and the Globe.

On the contrary, the Globe story reinforces the relationship between the Ford family and drugs. He is under a dark clouds now despite the lunatic claims of the most extreme Ford supporters.

No way he wins the middle of the road votes he needs to remain mayor without clearing this up.
 
We have just as much proof now as we would if the video is released. No more. No less. All the objection being raised by the Ford loons would be raised if the video were released. We hear from the usual suspects that it's a look a like, altered, etc.

Only a drug test will provide the answers everyone is looking for.

I guess you would consider me a "Ford Loon" because it appears that I am defending him. Which is not the case. I think he is a buffoon... and HARDLY credible, and certainly not Mayor material... but that doesn't preclude the fact that HE IS THE MAYOR, and he was fairly elected to the job under our current electoral process.

Regardless, and mutually exclusive of that simple fact... he is also a citizen of this city and country and according to the laws of the land, he deserves the right to be fairly judged, which he is not.

I have no problem with him taking a drug test, but there is a little thing called the Charter of Rights and Freedom, (which was championed by one of "your" guys BTW), which GIVES him that right to refuse to take such a test.

Funny how that worked out isn't it. :confused:
 
He is not "any employee", he is the mayor. More to the point, he wants to run for re election. Voters routinely demand things from politicians no employer event could, like tax returns, etc.

The burden rests with Ford to prove he is worth voting for

He is under no obligation to take a test , even if he runs for re-election. Voters can decide at that time whether they want him for another term. You would be the last person that I would rely on for telling me how the average voter thinks. You originally said that Ford would lose the election in 2010 and your track record has gone downhill from there :D



On the contrary, the Globe story reinforces the relationship between the Ford family and drugs. He is under a dark clouds now despite the lunatic claims of the most extreme Ford supporters.
.

If you would get the correct Globe story you might have a point, unfortunately you have the wrong one.
 
A line in a story today at the globe (darn pinko papers!) might give us a little insight into the video location.
Hours later, in a meeting with colleagues, the same man dropped a bombshell on Mr. Ford’s chief of staff, according to sources. He [David Price] said, according to one source, that he received a tip that the cellphone video was connected to a violent crime – and that the drug dealers trying to sell the video for six figures may have shot someone to get it.
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/toronto/meet-the-man-at-the-middle-of-torontos-city-hall-storm/article12218380/

Ford's staff thinks someone was shot in order to get the video in the first place.
If Ford's staff is correct, then who knows what shenanigans are going on with the people who have the video now.
They could also now be dead or in hiding.
 
We have just as much proof now as we would if the video is released. No more. No less. All the objection being raised by the Ford loons would be raised if the video were released. We hear from the usual suspects that it's a look a like, altered, etc.

Only a drug test will provide the answers everyone is looking for.

actually if the video was released we would have some proof. as of right now there is zero proof.
 
I like your quote about parents and too much detail OJ. What do you make of the second article by the reporters that added several embellishments to the story?

And I don't see how they couldn't have gotten it even when the car drove away. There are lights on it. Especially new cars as the reporters describe it.
Have you ever tried to get a plate number as someone drove away? Not easy. How do we know there were working license lights on the car? On occasion mine have been out for who knows how long before I noticed, and I have no motive to mud up my plates or tape over, remove or smash the license light. The video guys had every reason to.

Selling eyeballs means getting them back the next day for more developments, which means you never tell the whole story off the top. It's part of how journalism, and all the media less concerned with truth—like reality shows—make their money. Think striptease or cliffhangers.

While I've read my Star everyday, no one can have no idea what 'second article' you might be referring to in this era of internet media with hourly updates. If you're inviting specific comment on details, please give a specific reference; you already have my general opinion.

My own sense is that all the historical, circumstantial background stuff—the dangerous driving, the Garrison Ball, the arrests—and the specific details recounted make this a plausible story, one that's been made worse by being handled in the Fords' usual incompetent and blustering way. But there's all sorts of room for small details like the plates to show up as truly significant when we finally have enough facts about the video tale to make a sound judgement on it one way or another.