Top 10 Leafs Playoff Heartbreaks

lovelatinas

Well Known Member
Sep 30, 2008
6,678
2
38
I have been a Leafs fans since the early 1980's and I have gone through my share of playoff heartbreaks. So here are my top 10 Leaf playoff heartbreaks.

1. 1993 Game 6 loss to LA Kings in OT. The Leafs just came back down 4-2 to tie it (Wendel Clark's best game ever with a hat trick) in the third to force OT and the Leafs had all the momentum in OT but a missed high sticking call on Doug Gilmour by Gretzky went undetected by ref Kerry Fraser and Gretzky scores the OT winner.

2. 1993 Game 7 Loss to LA Kings. Would have been a Leafs vs Habs Stanley cup final.

3. 2013 Game 7 Loss in OT to Bruins after a 4-1 lead. Young inexperienced team just stopped skating in the third period thinking they had in the bag.

4. 2013 Game 4 Loss to Bruins in OT. Phenuef's untimely pinch to keep the play alive in Boston's zone cost the Leafs the game.

5. 2003 game 4 OT loss to the Flyers in triple overtime 3-2. The Flyers win the series in 7.

6. 2002 game 6 loss to Carolina in OT 2-1. Carolina wins the series 4-2.

7. 1987 Leafs losing game 7 to the Redwings after leading the Series 3-1.

8. 2001 game 7 loss to New Jersey Devils after having a 3-2 series lead.

9. 1986 Leafs losing game 7 to St. Louis 2-1.

10. 1994 Game 5 loss to Vancouver in double overtime (4-3) to lose the series in 5 games.

What are your most heartbreak moments?
 
Any from the 70's, 60's and 50's? Anyone go that far back? The Leafs were good in the 60's, 50's, 40's and 30's. Can't imagine there were many heartbreaks.
 
thet were up 2-0 in 78 against flyers, won first 2 games in philly, then lost 4 straight. sittler scored 5 goals in one of the games... they still lost.
 
Just want to chime in here because of the word heartbreak...

TSN radio yesterday had a call in show, most noted to me is this idea: heartbreak we can always deal with and will always be dealt to, but the sense of hopelessness in the last 9 years is over. "Tomorrow" we will numb the pain and realize that Our Buds is not hopeless anymore, there is a bright light at the end of the tunnel at last.

Wishing the Leafs a relaxing summer, golf your heart out, you've earned it. Come back next year, and keep this pain in your heart always, it makes you as a team grow bigger and better. There is no hope for the indifference, live and play HARD.

Thank you Buds for a wild run in '13.
 
Other then Playoffs I remember when the Leafs were up 5-0 and LOST 6-5 against St. Louis!
I can't remember the year but I think it was in 2002
 
I find it hard to be heartbroken about 1986 & 1987. Those teams didn't trully belong in the playoffs in the first place - it was quirk of the leagues alignment at the time - the 5th place teams in the Patrick & Adams were easily better than at least 4 of the 8 playoff teams in the Campbel Conference - it was a total bonus to even be in the playoffs those years.

*************************

I have to say this yeqr was just as bad as anything I can remeber. Just because blowing a 4-1 third period lead is so catastrophic and the loss erases all the moral victories which the Leafs could have taken from this series into next season.

Blowing a 4-1 third period lead is defensible only when totally screwed out by the officials or if facing some dynasty type club aremd with at least two, if not three possible Art Ross winners - the Bruins are not such team.

It would have been better to lose the series in 5 games. It would have been better to lose in 6 games.

It would have been better to lose game 7 because the Bruins came out on fire, got the leafs in pentaly trouble and went up 2 or 3 goals and by the time the Leafs straightened out the damage was done.

All of those other scenarios would be entirely acceptable for an inexperienced team that wasn`t even supposed to be there, playing against a highly ranked, recent Cup champion.

But to blow it after getting so close, and after proving the Bruins were a team they CAN beat (there were about as many periods of the Leafs outplaying the Bruins as there were the other way around...) I find this massively deflating.
 
3. 2013 Game 7 Loss in OT to Bruins after a 4-1 lead. Young inexperienced team just stopped skating in the third period thinking they had in the bag.

I dont think it is just a question of experience. They just dont have the winner attitude it takes to win important games. Worrying...
 
Agree with 1 and 2. Would move the recent game four OT loss down significantly because it was not the backbreaker. Also as horrible and (to some) unfair as game seven with the Bruins was, a victory would have prolonged our season by a series or two. A Stanley Cup final was never a serious possibility.

Was it 1999 we lost to the Sabres? Hachek was out and the backup (was it Rutherford? Rollins?) stole game one and we never really recovered. That series along with the 2002 loss to Carolina stick in my mind, because I think we were out coached both years. We should have gone on to the cup finals.