Negotiating a Severance Package

I am assuming you're"HR" guy does not work in Canada. Seniority is only one of many factors considered in determining the appropriate notice period, as has been stated many times on this thread. I have not seen a case where anyone got as low as one week per year of service and, unless negotiated beforehand, no one is getting more than 2 years awarded to them by a Court in Canada.

no hun i just happened to have a conversation with an expert on this topic from the country you are talking about when right when this thread came up hun. so i know everything once again and if you try to say i am wrong again i will trash every aspect of your life cuz i am an insecure person, hun.


sorry i was projecting for a minute.
 
After a layoff, what's the best technique for negotiating a severance package? If you were there 10 years, how much should you be asking for?

Apart from engaging a lawyer's services, here's one technique which has yielded good results:

1. Ask HR for copies of all documentation related to your employment and termination, including:
a. Your original offer of employment or employment contract.
b. All your performance reviews from the past 10 years.
c. If you've received any commendations for going "above and beyond", a summary of those.
d. A written explanation of specifically why you are being let go.

Even if you already have these, just request them anyway so HR knows you are not satisfied with their initial offer and are building your case for a better deal. This helps get them in a negotiating mood.

2. When the deadline for responding to the offer approaches, ask HR for an extension because you need additional time to have the package reviewed.

Use this time to gather info about "midrange" and "good" deals for others in your situation (like you are doing now). You may want to actually consult with a lawyer (a few hundred bucks for an hour consult), who will basically check their database to find circumstances similar to yours and what others received.

3. Book an appointment with HR to discuss/negotiate your package. You can negotiate in several areas: the total cash severance package, extension of health/dental benefits, timing of the payments, etc. Don't just ask for "more", go in with specific requests based on your research. If you did actually see a lawyer and have some guidance, it will help your confidence when negotiating. As others have mentioned, 3-4 weeks severance per year of employment is not unreasonable, but it is situation dependent.

4. At all times, be polite but direct. Laying off staff is uncomfortable for the HR person too, but if you're polite and courteous the HR person will want to help you out within their power to do so, while at the same time avoiding a legal confrontation which is costly for all parties. However if you rage at HR and act like an asshole, any sympathy credit you have will quickly vanish.

Good luck!
 
thats about right depending on whether you had a contract, union agreement or something else which could increase it or mitigate it

All correct, unless you were with a small company...then your closer to one week per year of service. Have a short read through the Employment Standards Act - termination of employment section...and lawyer up. Good luck.
 
All correct, unless you were with a small company...then your closer to one week per year of service. Have a short read through the Employment Standards Act - termination of employment section...and lawyer up. Good luck.

The biggest mistake people - employees and employers alike - make in Employment law is thinking that the Employment Standards Act is the last word on an employers obligations to its employees upon termination of employment. The ESA is where the (wrong) notion that a terminated employee is only entitled to one week notice (or pay in lieu of notice) per year of service derives from. The ESA is the statutory minimum that an employee is owed - however a court will also take into account the "common law", which usually results in a much longer period of notice being awarded to the employee.

Size of company per se is not a factor I have ever seen considered in a wrongful termination decision. it becomes a secondary factor inasmuch as the duties and responsibilities of a 'vice-president" of a small, family owned business might not be in any way comparable to the duties and responsibiltiies of a v.p. of a multi-national and might, in fact, be more analagous to the duties and responsibilities of an intermediate manager of the multi-national. However I have never seen where a Court has said that just because a company is small it owe its employees a shorter notice period.
 
I am assuming you're"HR" guy does not work in Canada. Seniority is only one of many factors considered in determining the appropriate notice period, as has been stated many times on this thread. I have not seen a case where anyone got as low as one week per year of service and, unless negotiated beforehand, no one is getting more than 2 years awarded to them by a Court in Canada.


You are correct. He is a recently retired from a US company. So he could be way off in Canada. :)
 
no hun i just happened to have a conversation with an expert on this topic from the country you are talking about when right when this thread came up hun. so i know everything once again and if you try to say i am wrong again i will trash every aspect of your life cuz i am an insecure person, hun.


sorry i was projecting for a minute.


Well hun,

I bet you associate with gas station attendants and truck drivers socially :) We associate with retired people from corporations. Simple. The HR director / executives seem to be all over the place. I guess they gave themselves huge settlements :).


Qui se resemble, s’assemble.
 
I sort of decided to do a quick search to find useful information.....

Your papers are fool of articles on severance packages.

http://www.thestar.com/business/per...o_get_a_fair_settlement_if_you_are_fired.html

Might be interesting. If you are staff and being offered 1 month of pay for every year you worked it sounds like a reasonable deal :)


It seems that there is a lot of 'go see a lawyer' type advice. But it is easy to see what people on the average are getting for similar jobs with similar seniority by using the self help tool at

http://www.wrongfuldismissaldatabase.com/Home.aspx

Amazing what you can find if your school included classes on how to use a search engine. :) lol


"Employment law in Canada is governed at the provincial level with very minor differences in each piece of legislation. With IBM Corp.’s Toronto and Markham, Ont. area offices appearing to be the hardest hit in Big Blue’s latest round of cuts, we’ll use Ontario’s employment legislation as an example.

Under Ontario Ministry of Labour’s Employment Standards Act, workers are entitled to one week’s notice (or payment in lieu of notice) per year of service, up to eight years.

Workers employed more than five years will most likely be eligible for an additional severance package, consisting of one week’s pay per year of service, up to 26 weeks. This comes into play if the company has laid off 50 or more employees within a six-month period or if the employer has a total payroll of over $2.5 million.


This puts the employer’s total responsibility under the act at a maximum of 34 weeks." from http://www.itworldcanada.com/news/laid-off-make-sure-you-get-what-you-deserve/108758

I wonder how much more people would get if they hired a lawyer, and how much better off they are after the lawyer gets his share?


Not being snarly, just curious. :)
 
Well hun,

I bet you associate with gas station attendants and truck drivers socially :) We associate with retired people from corporations. Simple. The HR director / executives seem to be all over the place. I guess they gave themselves huge settlements :).


Qui se resemble, s’assemble.
You would lose that bet. I hang with everyone from truck drivers to tree guys to people that would make you look broke.
 
You would lose that bet. I hang with everyone from truck drivers to tree guys to people that would make you look broke.

Of course you do hun, and they all come to your house and run around bare foot :).

Someone asked a resonable question and people tried to respond. Except you. PLease be a nice person and leave me alone :)
 
Last edited:
no, they wear socks, like normal people.

Oh a giant leap up the evolutionary ladder. Well done.

Maybe you should contact a Norther Canadian Tire Store and have them add studs? LOL

Simon, why do you bother trying to have a conversation with me? You know I dislike you and find you uninformed and argumentative?
 
Oh a giant leap up the evolutionary ladder. Well done.

Maybe you should contact a Norther Canadian Tire Store and have them add studs? LOL

Simon, why do you bother trying to have a conversation with me? You know I dislike you and find you uninformed and argumentative?
except you are the only person trying to argue here and i wouldn't have to go that far back to find quotes from you saying you missed me and i am one of your favorite posters here. remember all this started from me saying you were wrong about something and you flying off the handle. just cuz someone says you are wrong doesn't mean that they are insulting your as a person. i am not the only person here you have done this with. anyone you are fighting with here is because you take it as a personal attack when someone says you are wrong about something. remember the time not to long ago when i was one of the last people here that actually defended you and we talked normally quite a bit.

don't bring up the tires again. you were wrong about what you said and i wasn't. canadian tire does not sell studded tires, they sell tires that can be studded. that never changed and is still true. several phone calls proved that and just because you don't believe it doesn't make it less true.
 
You are correct. He is a recently retired from a US company. So he could be way off in Canada. :)

Well then, once again, we know that you are full of crap when speaking about a legal issue. There is no single guiding principle that is universally applicable in American employment laws. The various individual states are a mix of at will employment, implied contract exceptions (by statute) and, most recently, "right to work" states. No one, even remotely familiar with American employment law, would say that there is anything as a general guiding principal beyond the borders of any one state.

Also, its interesting that you suggested that you hoped your advice to the OP would be of help to them. Just curious why you thought the ramblings of a, quite likely imaginary, American HR specialist would be of assistance in a Canadian employment context. Or did you just bail on a blatant lie, and take the ready made exit ramp I provided you by suggesting that your "expert" might not have been speaking about Canadian employment situations.
 
I wonder how much more people would get if they hired a lawyer, and how much better off they are after the lawyer gets his share?
Not being snarly, just curious. :)

There is an abundance of perfectly ethical employment lawyers in Ontario that are more than willing to tell you whether an employment law case, or a case of any other nature, is actually worth the investment in legal fees. Canada is also a "loser pays" jurisdiction - if you feel you have to hire a lawyer to represent you the lawyer will negotiate that the adversary pay the majority, but not all, of your legal fees.
 
Well then, once again, we know that you are full of crap when speaking about a legal issue. There is no single guiding principle that is universally applicable in American employment laws. The various individual states are a mix of at will employment, implied contract exceptions (by statute) and, most recently, "right to work" states. No one, even remotely familiar with American employment law, would say that there is anything as a general guiding principal beyond the borders of any one state.

Also, its interesting that you suggested that you hoped your advice to the OP would be of help to them. Just curious why you thought the ramblings of a, quite likely imaginary, American HR specialist would be of assistance in a Canadian employment context. Or did you just bail on a blatant lie, and take the ready made exit ramp I provided you by suggesting that your "expert" might not have been speaking about Canadian employment situations.


Well mostly because you have proven on several occasions that you love to try to lay imaginary traps to prove something or another you believe about me, and I really did not want to get involved in a long discussion with you. You seem to like playing the lawyer game that "I HAVE PROVEN SOMETHING OR ANOTHER"

I know our table partner worked for a major US based company and they had layoffs in Canada so I think I trust his off the cuff statement.

He also said that if any middle management person without a contract tried to get over a month per year all he was doing was letting another lawyer take money out of his pocket. (in Canada). So little colt, whatever you want. I just do not like or need to feed you with silly arguments.

I accept you love to arguing and in your mind you are making some telling points.

I know next to nothing about layoffs. I had someone at our table who had done it a lot and I asked him a simple question. He gave me a simple answer: if the company wants to buy the employees out... etc. Min 1 week per year paid. Max 1 month per year. Is he wrong? How would I know. I just have more faith in him than you :).
 
There is an abundance of perfectly ethical employment lawyers in Ontario that are more than willing to tell you whether an employment law case, or a case of any other nature, is actually worth the investment in legal fees. Canada is also a "loser pays" jurisdiction - if you feel you have to hire a lawyer to represent you the lawyer will negotiate that the adversary pay the majority, but not all, of your legal fees.

LOL ok lawyers are perfectly ethical.