Another shooting tragedy in the US.

Unfortunately this is not related to the thread I posted yesterday...

New Jersey police: 6-year-old dies a day after being shot -- by a 4-year-old
By Julia Talanova and Laura Batchelor, CNN
updated 9:54 PM EDT, Tue April 9, 2013

A 6-year-old New Jersey boy has died after being shot in the head by a 4-year-old playmate as their parents stood in the yard nearby, a local police chief said.
http://www.cnn.com/2013/04/09/us/new-jersey-child-shooting/index.html?hpt=hp_t2
 
The real culprit is alcohol over dose and nobody here has pointed that out.
 
Alchohol is an element in at least half of the crime in the U.S. Seems that first posters on the thread did allude to it being a factor in the story. In the tragedy of the 4 year old shooting the 6 year old simple negligence in storage was the key factor I would guess.
 
Fuji...in the situation where someone has broken in to you home in the middle of the night...how do you determine that they are only there to steal property and not to cause physical harm.


You make it sound as if protecting your home is the bad thing. If you don't want to see people get hurt in these situations, maybe you can come up with a solution where people don't break into other peoples homes. Consider that the intruder had to walk onto the property, break through locked doors or windows and then plans on taking something that doesn't belong to him/her. I think someone who's made those choices should accept the risk that harm may be done to them if the property owners catch them.
 
Fuji...in the situation where someone has broken in to you home in the middle of the night...how do you determine that they are only there to steal property and not to cause physical harm.

You can't go around killing people because of what they MIGHT do.

You make it sound as if protecting your home is the bad thing.

Certainly killing people to protect mere property is a bad thing. You can forcibly remove a trespasser, and you can place someone under citizens arrest if you witness a crime.

You cannot go about murdering people because they damaged your property.
 
anyone care about the 5 firemen being held captive by a gunman in georgia today ?
 
You can't go around killing people because of what they MIGHT do.



Certainly killing people to protect mere property is a bad thing. You can forcibly remove a trespasser, and you can place someone under citizens arrest if you witness a crime.

You cannot go about murdering people because they damaged your property.

So you don't think it's okay to bring harm to an intruder until they actual strike, stab, shoot or harm you or your loved ones?! WTF...if you consider being woken in the middle of the night by an intruder...how much time do you really have to determine their intentions? What they might do?...they've already broken laws by entering your home in the night...I'd rather assume they were going to hurt someone than wait to act until after they actually did hurt some one. The intruder can avoid danger by obeying the law and not breaking in in the first place!

How do you forcibly remove a trespasser who is armed with a knife, bat or gun? How do you detain them for citizens' arrest if they are armed, crazed or violent? Eventually you might need to use force and you might have to decide between your own safety, the safety of those you love or having to deal with this lawbreaking idiot who put him/herself in danger by breaking in.
 
So you don't think it's okay to bring harm to an intruder until they actual strike, stab, shoot or harm you or your loved ones?! WTF...if you consider being woken in the middle of the night by an intruder...how much time do you really have to determine their intentions? What they might do?...they've already broken laws by entering your home in the night...I'd rather assume they were going to hurt someone than wait to act until after they actually did hurt some one. The intruder can avoid danger by obeying the law and not breaking in in the first place!

How do you forcibly remove a trespasser who is armed with a knife, bat or gun? How do you detain them for citizens' arrest if they are armed, crazed or violent? Eventually you might need to use force and you might have to decide between your own safety, the safety of those you love or having to deal with this lawbreaking idiot who put him/herself in danger by breaking in.

Pointing a gun at someone is still considered a use of force and theoretically, it could be used to perform an arrest or forcefully remove a trespasser. Unfortunately, as a Canadian citizen, you're likely to get in more trouble for unlocking and loading your guns than some jackhole will for breaking into your house.

In the event of a break in, I would prefer to barricade myself in a specific room, with "Candice" loaded up with 00 Buck and Toronto Police Services on the line. The shitty thing is, the likely scenario would be that the intruder fucks off and I still get charged for "unsafe storage". One of my many reasons why I despise "safe storage" laws, they're designed to fuck over regular citizens.
 
So you don't think it's okay to bring harm to an intruder until they actual strike, stab, shoot or harm you or your loved ones?!

The law expects you to react the same as you would on the street or anywhere else. Would you wait for an aggressive person on the street actually strike, stab, shoot or harm you or your loved ones?!

No different in your home. Same law of Canada is in effect in both places.

WTF...if you consider being woken in the middle of the night by an intruder...how much time do you really have to determine their intentions?

How much time do your have to determine the intentions of a hostile person on the street?

What they might do?...they've already broken laws by entering your home in the night.

Again. You don't kill people for what your paranoid imagination invented.

I'd rather assume they were going to hurt someone than wait to act until after they actually did hurt some one.

You have to wait until there is a real, actual threat and the only way to ensure everyone remains safe is to use force.

Imagined threats don't cut it.

The intruder can avoid danger by obeying the law and not breaking in in the first place!

Considering you are proposing to commit acts of cold blooded murder you have no place to criticize thieves! You are planning a far more serious crime.

How do you forcibly remove a trespasser who is armed with a knife, bat or gun? How do you detain them for citizens' arrest if they are armed, crazed or violent?

If they are armed, crazed, and violent you are facing a real threat, force is justified, whether they are on the street or in your home.

Quite different than shooting someone before your know whether or not they are a threat.