Another shooting tragedy in the US.

Why?

What is it you are really saying that you don't feel that "A man's house is his castle" at all. That no one has a right to self defense in their own house unless the intruder shoots them first or what.

You don't believe that when the Burglar Alarm started wailing that a sensible teenager, drunk or not should have said why the Hell is a Burglar Alarm going off?


Shoot first and ask questions later it seems. B & E doesn't mean the homeowner's life was in imminent danger. The use of deadly force was a disproportionate response. Even if he said halt but the intruder flees doesn't give the homeowner the right to kill the assailant IMHO unless they had hurt some other occupant or threatened to shoot back.
 
The NRA will probably argue that this is a tradegy but arming American homeowners to the teeth probably "prevented" millions of breakins because burglars know that American (and South African) homeowners are armed to the teeth so they avoid breaking into homes.
 
You guys have a very unrealistic approach to situations like this. Its easy to look at a story after the fact and from the comfort of your own home break it down piece by piece.

Now try to be in the home owners shoes, middle of the night, alarm goes off. He gets up and has no idea whats going on. Grabs his gun in case someone is in his house and finds a guy in HIS HOUSE in the middle of the night. Tells him to leave and the guy instead keeps going. What would you have done in this situation?
Sat back and got knifed/shot/beaten? Had your wife raped?

You have a split second to make a decision that will forever impact your life and your family's well being.
Its unfortunate for the sake of the kid, but he did the right thing given the circumstances at THAT MOMENT.
It doesn't matter that the kid was 16, was a basketball payer yada yada, he was in someones home in the middle of the night, his intentions were unknown to the home owner.

I know its difficult for some of you to see this since you're so against guns that your mind was already made up before you even read the article.
 
You guys have a very unrealistic approach to situations like this. Its easy to look at a story after the fact and from the comfort of your own home break it down piece by piece.

Now try to be in the home owners shoes, middle of the night, alarm goes off. He gets up and has no idea whats going on. Grabs his gun in case someone is in his house and finds a guy in HIS HOUSE in the middle of the night. Tells him to leave and the guy instead keeps going. What would you have done in this situation?
Sat back and got knifed/shot/beaten? Had your wife raped?

You have a split second to make a decision that will forever impact your life and your family's well being.
Its unfortunate for the sake of the kid, but he did the right thing given the circumstances at THAT MOMENT.
It doesn't matter that the kid was 16, was a basketball payer yada yada, he was in someones home in the middle of the night, his intentions were unknown to the home owner.

I know its difficult for some of you to see this since you're so against guns that your mind was already made up before you even read the article.

The guy keeps going, yes. Maybe he was going to get the fuck outta there. You think you have the right to shoot someone dead for fleeing? Unless you know it's a mass murderer or some notorious terrorist, how can you shoot them dead?

Homeowners are not trained like law enforcement officers in the use of firearms. Shoot and ask questions later is okay with you. Why didn't he fire a warning shot at the moment? Did the homeowner know he was in imminent danger? This is why in Canada, we have different laws. This is not the wild west.
 
The NRA will probably argue that this is a tradegy but arming American homeowners to the teeth probably "prevented" millions of breakins because burglars know that American (and South African) homeowners are armed to the teeth so they avoid breaking into homes.

We should also do what Archie Bunker said: Give every passenger a gun, and you will prevent hijackings outright.
 
How about, "He raped a girl because he thought she was his girlfriend but was too drunk to know the difference."

Then try calling him a victim.
Then try calling him just a kid.

And yes, guns prevent about a million crimes a year.
 
a break and enter is a break and enter whether you're drunk or not... Imagine if people started using drunkedness as a scapegoat for break and enter

if the homeowner had called police the boy could have been charged
 
EDIT: I just read the story! The kid wasn't trying to rob or hurt anybody, just thought it was his house!!

Too bad, feel bad for the kid! Just a horrific set of circumstances!
 
It happened to me once when I was in university but I wasn't drunk. I lived off campus with a group of friends in an apartment. I was bringing up my laundry from the basement and miss counted the flight of stairs walking into a strange apartment. The first thing I noticed was a big map of Newfie land over the living room sofa and I laughed at it thinking it was a practical joke by my buddies. Quickly I saw that I was in the wrong place about the same time I noticed this couple hugging each other in another small sofa. I excused myself and left.

I guess if I lived in the US I could have been dead now.

That happened to me once back when I lived in an apartment. I miss counted the floors walking up from the basement and got off at the wrong floor. I walked into someone's apt and said "wft" as soon as I entered. I quickly did a 180 and left as quite as I could. I didn't see anyone.

It also happened where a women walked into my apt thinking that she was in hers 1 floor up from me... I had several bags of groceries in my hand when I entered my apt and when I walked in I took them straight to the kitchen. After a few mins I heard my door open and this women walks in then stops suddenly and says " shit, sorry I thought it was my place".. I smiled and said "no prob, as honest mistake"..

Even if I owned a gun I would never shoot first unless I was seriously threatened becuz I know that once I pull the trigger that's it, they're dead. I'm lucky though becuz I'm not the kind of person who panics easily so they're wouldn't be any unforced shooting from me.

Nice house by the way. Perfect size
 
A very sad, tragic story.

I don't blame the home owner. His house is hooked up with an alarm system that was set off when Caleb entered by the window. He fired a warning shot and told the intruder to leave. The intruder didn't leave. If that is the way it went down, then I don't blame the homeowner for firing. I would be scared shitless in that situation.

On the other hand, the guy feels threatened enough to install an alarm system and own a gun for home protection. Yet he leaves his windows unlocked. That is just careless.

Further to that, seeing as I am not a big booster of the mentality that encourages proliferation of guns in society, I can't help but think that if the homeowner did not own a gun, then a good kid who made a mistake would still be alive. So that is where I put the blame.

I highly doubt the homeowner blew a hole in his wall/ceiling to warn the kid, before blasting him. More like he shot the kid, realized he might be in for some trouble, and decided to mitigate it somewhat by saying he had fired a warning shot.

It's just an all-around bad situation. I feel for the guy who shot him. There's no way of knowing if the shadowy figure coming up the stairs represents an extreme danger to your person.

Good point. But we should take the facts in the article at face value. Its pure speculation that homeowner fired the warning shot after in order to cover his tracks. I expect the police are investigating that possiblility though. And I would think that neighbours could verify how much time passed between shots. Five seconds = believable story. One minute = enough time to realize what he has done and think of a way to cover it up.

If it did indeed happen as described, the homeowner must be devastated. Unless he is a complete asshole. I know if I was in his shoes, I would never pick up a gun again.
 
How about, "He raped a girl because he thought she was his girlfriend but was too drunk to know the difference."

Then try calling him a victim.
Then try calling him just a kid.

And yes, guns prevent about a million crimes a year.

oh wow. Not the same thing at all. Can you site an example where this actually happened? No one is suggesting that the boy did not break into the house. People are saying he is a victim of his own youthful stupidity and mistaken identity by the owner of the house.

I think a more comparable analogy would be if a guy rapes a woman, someone sees that he is raping a woman, pulls a gun, fires a warning shot, but he keeps on raping her because he thinks she is his girlfriend, and then gets shot. Sorry, its not a very realistic scenario.
 
In this case alcohol is more culpable than guns IMO. Seriously do
people think alchohol should be allowed for a 16 year old?
 
if the homeowner had called police the boy could have been charged
Yeah and when the homeowner said Stop or Halt or drop or whatever and he didn't the homeowner was supposed to see if the teen just wanted to give him a big drunk hug?

Yes Red the kid died, no this wasn't murder.

For the person that said what if he was attempting to back away - in most places shooting someone in the back gets you charged charged with murder (unless investigation shows the kid was walking backwards).
 
oh wow. Not the same thing at all. Can you site an example where this actually happened?
If I took long enough going through the cases, yes absolutely I could find you cases along the lines of "He raped a girl because he thought she was his girlfriend but was too drunk to know the difference."
 
I heard that "they" are working on developing a gun that won't shoot bullets, but shoot some kind of "krazy glue" that immobilizes the target. Better alternative to killing drunk or mentally ill people waving a knife. Of course, the taser was suppose to be an alternative to deadly force but seems to have fallen out of favour.
 
Without firing up the "guns kill people" versus "people kill people" debate, perhaps I'm naive, but I can't help wondering . . .

Isn't it possible for an armed homeowner to fend off an unarmed intruder with a bullet to the leg instead of the chest or head?

Hollywood produced movies aren't meant to be documentaries, shooting someone in the leg is difficult and actually pretty irresponsible.

The good news is it looks like Feinstein's ridiculous "Assault Weapons Ban" looks like it's going nowhere. Hooray for freedom.
 
The guy keeps going, yes. Maybe he was going to get the fuck outta there. You think you have the right to shoot someone dead for fleeing? Unless you know it's a mass murderer or some notorious terrorist, how can you shoot them dead?

Homeowners are not trained like law enforcement officers in the use of firearms. Shoot and ask questions later is okay with you. Why didn't he fire a warning shot at the moment? Did the homeowner know he was in imminent danger? This is why in Canada, we have different laws. This is not the wild west.

First off he did fire a warning shot.

Second if someone's in your house in the middle of the night, you come out with a gun and fire a warning shot and tell him to leave and instead he comes at you what would you think in this situation? "oh, this fine young gentlemen broke into my house for a coffee"

And finally in Canada we are able to defend ourselves as well, and in the same scenario you can shoot the person, kill them and walk free. Look it up, section 34 and 35 of the canadian criminal code.


EDIT: Here, i even looked it up for you and highlighted the important parts

34. (1) Every one who is unlawfully assaulted without having provoked the assault is justified in repelling force by force if the force he uses is not intended to cause death or grievous bodily harm and is no more than is necessary to enable him to defend himself.

Extent of justification


(2) Every one who is unlawfully assaulted and who causes death or grievous bodily harm in repelling the assault is justified if

(a) he causes it under reasonable apprehension of death or grievous bodily harm from the violence with which the assault was originally made or with which the assailant pursues his purposes; and

(b) he believes, on reasonable grounds, that he cannot otherwise preserve himself from death or grievous bodily harm.
 
you guys forgot to post about the shooting last week. 6 shot 4 dead in nyc.