Banning Items to Save lives

Banning which of the following would save the most lives in the US?

  • "Assault" Weapons

    Votes: 6 24.0%
  • Cigarets

    Votes: 12 48.0%
  • Alcohol

    Votes: 2 8.0%
  • Cats

    Votes: 5 20.0%

  • Total voters
    25
, but now you have come upon a surprising fact, which totally violates all your assumptions.

How is it that one can say with certainty that limiting access to what is currently the most popular firearm would have no impact. Sorry fuji.
I don't consider this to be a fact.

The reality is that firearms owners don't commit crimes,
Until they commit murder or let their sons get their hands on the gun to, once again, commit murder.

The point is that the more guns that are in circulation increases the chances for something bad to happen with those guns.


The people who buy "assault rifles" tend to be law abiding types who don't kill anybody.-despite the AR15 being a wildly popular firearm few people are killed with it.
Regardless of how they were acquired, this gun was involved in 4 very recent mass murders, so your defense that these guns are irrelevant to the issue at hand is out the window.
 
I see. You have chosen option B--ignore the surprising fact, try to deny it, put it out of your head, and persist with your wrong beliefs.

If you decide you would rather be an informed person, you can go to the FBI website and have a look at the percentage of gun crimes committed with a rifle. Anytime you like--the truth is there waiting for you. It totally contradicts your "the more guns in circculation" hypothesis, and as such represents a good learning opportunity for you.
 
I bought my "assault rifle" for the same reason why I bought skis, so I can participate in a sport.

Yes, but your next door neighbor bought his assault rifle to kill children..

He also bought skis to kill children but, like you, he's a bit of a moron that way.

When the day comes to start his killing spree, what do you think he'll choose to bring? His assault rifle? Or his skis? I did say he's a bit of an idiot, so who knows.. But I'm rooting for him, so I hope he brings the assault rifle.
 
Yes, but your next door neighbor bought his assault rifle to kill children..

I think that is pure fear mongering. Mass shootings with assault rifles are so incredibly rare that it is just entirely unlikely that I will even remotely come into contact with somebody like that. I am more likely to win a significant lottery prize. It is about as statistically valid as saying 99% of drivers on the road street race while drunk. That is how far off from reality you are.

Do you have any arguments to make that are not pure unadulterated fear mongering without any factual or statistical basis whatsoever?
 
I think that is pure fear mongering. Mass shootings with assault rifles are so incredibly rare that it is just entirely unlikely that I will even remotely come into contact with somebody like that. I am more likely to win a significant lottery prize. It is about as statistically valid as saying 99% of drivers on the road street race while drunk. That is how far off from reality you are.

Do you have any arguments to make that are not pure unadulterated fear mongering without any factual or statistical basis whatsoever?

You don't have an argument here. You haven't come up with any facts to back up your claim that shootings with assault rifles are so rare that banning them would have zero effect. Nobody's doubting that handguns are the bigger problem. You keep bringing that up like it points to assault rifles being NO problem. That's not the case.

Assault rifles are used in mass killings (almost exclusively these days it seems like). But they're also used in robberies, gang shootouts, calculated murders, etc.,. Yes, in all cases handguns are undoubtedly used far more often. But that doesn't mean that Assault Rifles are NEVER used.
 
Last edited:
You don't have an argument here. You haven't come up with any facts to back up your claim that shootings with assault rifles are so rare that banning them would have zero effect. Nobody's doubting that handguns are the bigger problem. You keep bringing that up like it points to assault rifles being NO problem. That's not the case.

Assault rifles are used in mass killings (almost exclusively these days it seems like). But they're also used in robberies, gang shootouts, calculated murders, etc.,. Yes, in all cases handguns are undoubtedly used far more often. But that doesn't mean that Assault Rifles are NEVER used.

Rifles of ALL types, incudling hunting rifles and assault rifles both, were only used in 323 of the 12664 homicides in the US last year, and that includes everything--mass shootings, robberies, arguments, and so on. Assault rifles would only be a small part of those 323 rifle homicides, but really it's unclear because nobody can agree on how to define "assault riflie". If you mean any semi-automatic rifle it's probably a fairly high share of the 323, but nobody is proposing banning those. If you mean the formal definition, a fully automatic military rifle, it's probably a fraction of a percent, if any at all.

Here's the data:

http://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/uc....-2011/tables/expanded-homicide-data-table-11

If you were to eliminate ALL crime with ALL rifles, not just assault rifles, somehow, and none of those murders switched to using a handgun or knife, you would reduce the homicide rate by 2.5% and plainly in reality many of those crimes would still have been committed with another type of firearm or a knife.

It's just not statistically viable to claim you are going to impact the homicide rate by banning assault rifles, or even rifles in general.

p.s. - this is why the long gun registry in Canada was scrapped too, criminals just don't use rifles very often.
 
I think that is pure fear mongering. Mass shootings with assault rifles are so incredibly rare that it is just entirely unlikely that I will even remotely come into contact with somebody like that. I am more likely to win a significant lottery prize. It is about as statistically valid as saying 99% of drivers on the road street race while drunk. That is how far off from reality you are.

Do you have any arguments to make that are not pure unadulterated fear mongering without any factual or statistical basis whatsoever?
You see avx, you're up against thinking that says as long as the death rate is low enough—like below lightning strike deaths—it's acceptable. What the new low marker will be when an American takes out more than 54, or the total mass murder toll gets that high, we'll have to wait on fuji to suggest.
 
You see avx, you're up against thinking that says as long as the death rate is low enough--like below lightning strike deaths--it's acceptable.

Absolutely. The number of activities that we would have to ban if you went after every theoretically preventable death with a higher mortality rate is huge. Swimming kills ten times more people, so let's just ban that. People going out on public transit when they have a cough--kills more people (and kills other people). We simply flat out accept this level of mortality for commonplace activities.

You are fear mongering, failing to apply the same risk tolerances to shooting sports as you apply to other sports, and to human activity in general.

Just to put this in clearer terms, it's a death rate of 0.1 deaths per 100000 people.
 
I think other gun or type not stated means that they haven't recovered the firearm and/or don't have enough investigative information to confidently say what it was. An AR15 is not a Title II rifle because it does not have a short barrel and it is not an automatic weapon. Its military cousins the M4 and M16 would be Title II because they are fullly automatic.

"Assault rifles", meaning military issue fully automatic rifles, are probably never used in crime--they are just too rare.

"Assault type rifle", meaning a semi-automatic dressed up to look like an assault rifle, don't currently have any special status under US law and so they would be lumped in under rifle.
 
I think other gun or type not stated means that they haven't recovered the firearm and/or don't have enough investigative information to confidently say what it was. An AR15 is not a Title II rifle because it does not have a short barrel and it is not an automatic weapon. Its military cousins the M4 and M16s would be Title II because they are fullly automatic.

"Assault rifles", meaning military issue fully automatic rifles, are probably never used in crime--they are just too rare.

"Assault type rifle", meaning a semi-automatic dressed up to look like an assault rifle, don't currently have any special status under US law and so they would be lumped in under rifle.

.. Maybe. Still seems like a lot of assumption on your part. But I'll concede you might be right.

Either way, I don't care about infringing on the rights of legal gun owners because I'm not one of them and I could care less about them... They have a "fetish" or desire or whatever to collect lethal weapons for fun, show, or actual lethal use. To me that means they likely have a few screws loose and are poisoning the Human Gene pool..

In short, I wish all gun owners slow painful deaths brought on by the very weapons they covet..
 
Either way, I don't care about infringing on the rights of legal gun owners because I'm not one of them and I could care less about them...

So, shall we ban every sport where the death rate is higher than the number of people killed every year by rifles? Or only the sports you personally are not involved in?

By the way--thanks for agreeing that there is no objective basis for your belief, that it's just some sort of emotional grudge.
 
So, shall we ban every sport where the death rate is higher than the number of people killed every year by rifles? Or only the sports you personally are not involved in?

By the way--thanks for agreeing that there is no objective basis for your belief, that it's just some sort of emotional grudge.

You're still arguing?

You really live for this shit, don't you?
 
You're still arguing?

You really live for this shit, don't you?

Its all part of the right wing/gun nut connection.
Dig a little deeper and Fuji will go on about racist stereotypes and how all gun crimes are from gangs and from certain darker complexioned groups.

The US, in particular, is a mess that way. The highest incarceration rates in the world, racist records of incarceration which then justify racist policies which take money out of the lowest classes and feed the cycle anew.

The US incarceration rate began increasing in the mid-1970s, but exploded dramatically after passage of the 1986 Anti-Drug Abuse Act. Between 1970 and 2005 the prison population rose 700 per cent. The US comprises only 5per cent of the world’s population, but contains 25per cent of the world’s incarcerated people. Over seven million Americans are entangled with the criminal justice system through parole, probation or other forms of correctional supervision, while 2.3 million are behind bars. At 730 per 100,000 the US prison rate is 4-7 times higher than other western nations and up to 32 times higher than countries with the lowest rates like Nepal, Nigeria and India.

Racial disparities among the incarcerated are glaring: one in every 36 Latino man and one in every 15 black man is a prisoner compared with one in every 106 white man. Four percent of Native American adults are under correctional control. Data comparing apartheid era black incarceration rates in South African with current black male incarceration rates in the US provides a jarring perspective. According to the Prison Policy Institute, in 1993, during the apartheid era in South Africa, black men were incarcerated at a rate of 853 per 100,000 total black male population. In 2010, under the Obama administration, US black men were incarcerated at a rate of 3,074 per 100,000. As the law of the land, McCleskey v. Kemp became an alibi for the racialised logic of mass incarceration, obstructing recognition and elimination of blatant racism in the criminal justice system.

Featured in the December issue of the Smithsonian Magazine, Stevenson was described as “the most important advocate for death row inmates in the US,” having successfully argued cases before the Supreme Court that banned mandatory life sentences without parole for minors. Stevenson is an eloquent, soulful man who sees the world through the eyes of imprisoned children and equates the incarceration of African Americans in the post-Civil Rights era with the enslavement of Africans in the US.

Mass incarceration, he argues, has radically changed society. He speaks of urban communities, like Philadelphia, Los Angeles and Washington, where 50 percent of young black men are in prison, on parole or probation and where the disenfranchisement of convicted felons “has horrific implications for the political aspirations of people of colour.” In Alabama, Stevenson said, 34 per cent of black men have permanently lost the right to vote and within the next 10 years the level of disenfranchisement will be higher than it has been since passage of the Voting Rights Act in 1965.

Stevenson points to the consequences of the 1996 Welfare Reform Law which denied drug offenders eligibility for public housing, food stamps and other benefits, and that has had a disastrous impact on black women and children. Black women comprise half of the female prison population, although they are only 12 percent of the total population. Between 1986 and 1991the number of black women incarcerated for drug offences soared by 828 percent.

It’s not just racism in Stevenson’s analysis that drives the shame of mass incarceration. A class system defined by gross wealth and income inequality and entrenched poverty also subverts the achievement of justice. “We have a system of justice in this country,” he said, “that treats you much better if you’re rich and guilty than if you’re poor and innocent.” A racially biased war on drugs, poverty and political disenfranchisement combine, Stevenson argues, to create “a new class of untouchables, 1 million strong,” who cannot be reached by the public health or welfare systems and are “marginalised in ways from which there is no recovery.”
http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/2013/01/201311782939161836.html