Banning Items to Save lives

Banning which of the following would save the most lives in the US?

  • "Assault" Weapons

    Votes: 6 24.0%
  • Cigarets

    Votes: 12 48.0%
  • Alcohol

    Votes: 2 8.0%
  • Cats

    Votes: 5 20.0%

  • Total voters
    25
And then alcohol and then I think it's probably close between the number of people who are killed by cat allergies vs shot with an "assault" rifle.....

The point is that the odds of cigs killing 20 school kids in 10 minutes is a bit lower don't you think? And its still a lame piece of logic. Very lame.
 
Banning which of these would save more lives in the US?

So is the test of when products should be banned or controlled is the number of lives which would be saved? I guess then there is no reason to ban the uncontrolled public ownership of explosives. Your poll is really quite silly. No one is suggesting banning guns generally. The sad fact is that in the last several mass killings the Bushmaster was the common denominator.
 
Last edited:
Maybe that one shouldn't be. There are already restrictions on alcohol and cigarette sales to minimize the risk to minors. Why such an uproar that the government wants restrictions on guns?
Even cats have to be registered and licensed in some places, like Toronto.

But of course no one with brains has forgotten the unintended consequences of the Eighteenth Amendment that banned alcohol. The idea of banning guns is the usual sort of straw man the gun guys set up just so they can knock it down. What Prohibition should have taught people is that control and regulation is far more useful and achievable than any sort of banning, and that it just needs a bit of campaigning to repeal a constitutional amendment, like the Second.

But as an example of stupid and ineffective bans I'm surprised OTB left out non-medical drugs, which have been illegal and banned longer than any of us have been alive, and to little or no positive effect.
 
The point is that the odds of cigs killing 20 school kids in 10 minutes is a bit lower don't you think? And its still a lame piece of logic. Very lame.

So killing hundreds of kids a year slowly is preferable? I'm not sure I follow your logic here.

OTB
 
So is the test of when products should be banned or controlled the number of lives which would be saved? I guess then there is no reason to ban the uncontrolled public ownership of explosives. Your poll is really quite silly. No one is suggesting banning guns generally. The sad fact is that in the last several mass killings the Bushmaster was the common denominator.

Guns generally are not one of the poll options, "assault" weapons are - and have recently been banned in NY and the POTUS just proposed a ban, so I don't think it's a silly question at all.

OTB
 
It is a dumb poll because it does not seek opinions, it seeks to argue alleged facts.

But even the philosophical underpinning of the argument is flawed because it does not distinguish between self-harm and harming others.
 
No need for a TERB poll. The stats are out there:

"The leading causes of death in 2000 were tobacco (435 000 deaths; 18.1% of total US deaths), poor diet and physical inactivity (365 000 deaths; 15.2%) [corrected], and alcohol consumption (85 000 deaths; 3.5%). Other actual causes of death were microbial agents (75 000), toxic agents (55 000), motor vehicle crashes (43 000), incidents involving firearms (29 000), sexual behaviors (20 000), and illicit use of drugs (17 000)."

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15010446

Don't like those stats? Guess which uber-popular website to go to to find thousands of other pages of data?
 
Guns generally are not one of the poll options, "assault" weapons are - and have recently been banned in NY and the POTUS just proposed a ban, so I don't think it's a silly question at all.

OTB

Cigarettes and booze may be used to kill yourself. So called assault weapons are used to kill others. The point of the law is not to reduce all gun violence but to reduce the ability of an individual to kill many people. It is amazing to me that there is any objection to that. Colin Powell supports it, general McCrystal supports it etc. hardly commies.
 
Cigarettes and booze may be used to kill yourself. So called assault weapons are used to kill others. The point of the law is not to reduce all gun violence but to reduce the ability of an individual to kill many people. It is amazing to me that there is any objection to that. Colin Powell supports it, general McCrystal supports it etc. hardly commies.

Did you miss that stats on second hand smoke? Even with the smoking regulations that Blackrock13 noted there are tens of thousands of deaths every year. It's a far bigger issue.

There were More than 10,000 deaths due to just drunk driving http://www.madd.org/blog/2012/december/2011-State-data.html Not all of those were those driving drunk.

The number of deaths associated with "assault" weapons is very small and a ban will have no effect.

OTB
 
It is a dumb poll because it does not seek opinions, it seeks to argue alleged facts.

As interesting as opinions are facts are often more insightful. Anyone can source the facts, no need to "allege" them.

But even the philosophical underpinning of the argument is flawed because it does not distinguish between self-harm and harming others.

You can certainly focus on second hand smoke and drunk driver deaths (two examples) of these items being used to kill others can you not?

OTB
 
The number of deaths associated with "assault" weapons is very small and a ban will have no effect.

Literally more people are killed by lightning every year.

Even those who are killed by mass shooters, it isn't clear that a hunting rifle would be less effective and in many cases a handgun would kill more people. (Handguns are more effective at close quarters.)
 
Did you miss that stats on second hand smoke? Even with the smoking regulations that Blackrock13 noted there are tens of thousands of deaths every year. It's a far bigger issue.

There were More than 10,000 deaths due to just drunk driving http://www.madd.org/blog/2012/december/2011-State-data.html Not all of those were those driving drunk.

The number of deaths associated with "assault" weapons is very small and a ban will have no effect.

OTB

You are quite right. But smoker and drinkers do not set out to kill people. You can continue to split hairs and attempt to confuse the issue but assault style weapons have no place on our streets. Don't ask me. Ask General McCytsal who has at least some passing familiarity with that type of weapon.
 
So killing hundreds of kids a year slowly is preferable? I'm not sure I follow your logic here.

OTB

When you kill them slowly they are old fuckers by the time they are dead.. and no one gives a shit about old fuckers...
 
You are quite right. But smoker and drinkers do not set out to kill people. You can continue to split hairs and attempt to confuse the issue but assault style weapons have no place on our streets. Don't ask me. Ask General McCytsal who has at least some passing familiarity with that type of weapon.

I'm not splitting hairs, I'm simply laying out facts. I won't ask you.

OTB
 
Maybe the poll should be:

What would be more likely to cause you to shit your pants:

A cat pointed at you
A bottle of Rum pointed at you
A carton of smokes pointed at you
An AK-47 pointed at you
 
When you kill them slowly they are old fuckers by the time they are dead.. and no one gives a shit about old fuckers...

Don't tell woody that, there are many more years of good service left in that 15yr old Gateway in his basement....
 
I'm not splitting hairs, I'm simply laying out facts. I won't ask you.

OTB

No you are conflating different issues. there is a legitimate question to be asked about banning cigarettes and alcohol and other items as well. But the number of deaths attributable to one or another has nothing g at all to do with whether you ban any one of them. each should be decided on its own merits whatever they may be and it is not an either or proposition. Did your poll permit a responder to check off more than one?
 
No you are conflating different issues. there is a legitimate question to be asked about banning cigarettes and alcohol and other items as well. But the number of deaths attributable to one or another has nothing g at all to do with whether you ban any one of them. each should be decided on its own merits whatever they may be and it is not an either or proposition. Did your poll permit a responder to check off more than one?

I was forcing a choice... Given how rare deaths are from rifles (much less non-selective fire "assault" rifles I'm wondering what the "merits" would be. Does anyone really think this will stop a madman from killing, the last time there was a ban there was no drop in crime... so, other than the silly argument (no one needs.....) what would the "merits" be?

OTB
 
Maybe the poll should be:

What would be more likely to cause you to shit your pants:

A cat pointed at you
A bottle of Rum pointed at you
A carton of smokes pointed at you
An AK-47 pointed at you

Personally, I think we should just ban smokers who insist on hard liquor while they walk around with their cat guns.
 
Did you miss that stats on second hand smoke? Even with the smoking regulations that Blackrock13 noted there are tens of thousands of deaths every year. It's a far bigger issue.
So your answer is do nothing about a confirmed problem (gun deaths) until another problem is corrected first.