Marketplace: no difference between Premium and regular.

Twister

Well-known member
Aug 24, 2002
4,985
695
113
GTA
Unless you're car requires premium like some Porsche, but even cars that require premium like a corvette ran well on a regular.
All kinds of test were performed , they don't run cleaner, no better mileage nada.

http://www.cbc.ca/marketplace/
 
Bullshit i always get better mileage.
 
If you drive a Corvette like it's designed, you need the premium fuel to prevent knock and get maximum performance. The computer can compensate for the reduced octane, but it's reactive. When it senses knock, it retards the timing, but knock has to occur first. Continued hard driving with lower octane will eventually cause the cylinders to oval out, causing lower compression and increased oil consumption.

Higher octane fuels can result in lower mileage because of the increased additives to prevent knock.

If you drive your Corvette like a normal car and never go within 1000 rpm of the redline, you can run regular no problem, but where's the fun in that?

A more useful test by these idiots would be which oil company gives you better fuel economy per litre. Cheap Cdn Tire fuel never got me the mileage Sunoco got me.
 
CBC -waste of tax dollars

Unless you're car requires premium like some Porsche, but even cars that require premium like a corvette ran well on a regular.
All kinds of test were performed , they don't run cleaner, no better mileage nada.

http://www.cbc.ca/marketplace/

A car requiring premium, will always get better mileage with premium, because the controller will advance the ignition timing, which will produce better mileage.

Don't believe anything you see on the looney left's TV station.

FAST
 
Engines are designed for a certain type of fuel. The amount/percentage of combustible (octane) is directly related to the size of the combustion chamber in the engine. In each explosion, a specific amount of force is needed for optimum engine rotation and using more or less will give less than optimum performance. As a poor analogy, consider the lack of performance in high efficiency dishwashers that were designed to use phosphate based detergent now that phosphates are gone.

My only question is if the less than 2% difference in octane enough to noticeably affect performance in an engine (I would think that the amount of impurities and additives would have a greater impact than 87 vs 89 octane).

p.s. I will admit that I haven't studied anything about IC engines since university - more than a few years ago.
 
They reference on the show that the US Federal Trade Commission found the same results:

http://www.ftc.gov/bcp/edu/pubs/consumer/autos/aut12.shtm

Are you tempted to buy a high octane gasoline for your car because you want to improve its performance? If so, take note: the recommended gasoline for most cars is regular octane. In fact, in most cases, using a higher octane gasoline than your owner's manual recommends offers absolutely no benefit. It won't make your car perform better, go faster, get better mileage or run cleaner. Your best bet: listen to your owner's manual.

The only time you might need to switch to a higher octane level is if your car engine knocks when you use the recommended fuel. This happens to a small percentage of cars.

Unless your engine is knocking, buying higher octane gasoline is a waste of money, too. Premium gas costs 15 to 20 cents per gallon more than regular. That can add up to $100 or more a year in extra costs. Studies indicate that altogether, drivers may be spending hundreds of millions of dollars each year for higher octane gas than they need.
 
Its designed that way

GUYS,...its all about the design (compression ratio etc) of the engine.

If its designed to use premium, it WILL benfit by using premium = better mileage etc.

Obviusly,...if it does not require premium, it will NOT benefit from using a higher octane fuel.

And a small point, if there IS an explosion in the combustion chamber, there is something wrong, and if it knocks, there is also something wrong.

FAST
 
Not something that comes up except in recreational vehicle forums. Premium is all gas and relatively stable. Regular gas has 10% or more ethanol . Ethanol is relatively unstable with a shelf life of a month. When manufacturing ethanol , there is always some water in it as a byproduct. For intermittently used vehicles- fewer problems if premium gas is used.
 
Having a car manufacturer spec for regular fuel seems like a significant selling point to me.
I don`t see why they would want to specify premium fuel if it just benefits the oil companies and not their cars and customers.

Even if there isn`t an instant tangible negative effect, that doesn`t mean there is no detrimental effect in the short or long term.
 
When I was a teen I tried a couple of times of zeroing the trip odometer and comparing a full tank of each type of gas. I thought there was a difference but it was informal.
 
Bullshit i always get better mileage.

If you drive a Corvette like it's designed, you need the premium fuel to prevent knock and get maximum performance. The computer can compensate for the reduced octane, but it's reactive. When it senses knock, it retards the timing, but knock has to occur first. Continued hard driving with lower octane will eventually cause the cylinders to oval out, causing lower compression and increased oil consumption.

Higher octane fuels can result in lower mileage because of the increased additives to prevent knock.

If you drive your Corvette like a normal car and never go within 1000 rpm of the redline, you can run regular no problem, but where's the fun in that?

A more useful test by these idiots would be which oil company gives you better fuel economy per litre. Cheap Cdn Tire fuel never got me the mileage Sunoco got me.

One of the experts has a corvette, among others vehicles, and it is his fun car. He's driven it with regular for a long time and sees no difference. Of course the fuel companies refused to be interviewed. That should tell you something.
 
Do as your car manual tells you to do. The info on Marketplace is distorted BS to fill in a hole to make a story. While it may be true that using premium fuel for 90%+ of drivers is a waste of money. Some cars are designed for premium fuel and require it.
 
Do as your car manual tells you to do. The info on Marketplace is distorted BS to fill in a hole to make a story. While it may be true that using premium fuel for 90%+ of drivers is a waste of money. Some cars are designed for premium fuel and require it.


In the whole story there is no claim that all cars can be driven with regular gas,. There are definitely some who require premium. The report said that many manuals 'suggest' a fuel grade. That's the rub. I gather you didn't watch the show, but still feel the need to comment about the report and the show. The Marketplace show doesn't ever need to fill shows with BS.
 
They fill it with distorted reality, while this information is accurate for some people it is not true for all. I call it sensationalism.
 
If your car does not NEED a higher octane fuel, then it is correct, you will not bennefit by purchasing a higher octane fuel in the least.

But if you have a higher compression engine and you want better peformance (gained by advancing the timing - which on an older car with a distributor, you can easily alter yourself as opposed to a newer computer controlled ignition system (which requires the correct software and tools)) you need higher octane fuels.

By the way,

Octane does not deliver power.

Octane simply prevents premature ignition of the air fuel mixture during the compression stroke of the piston.

And 87 89 91 etc. are not percentages, they are octane ratings.
 
There were many things that were done in the pass that does not apply today, like pumping you gas pedal a few times before you start your car. or pumping the brakes when your car skids. Many today have accelerator pedals that are no longer mechanically connected to the fuel system, and cars with ABS do the pumping of the brakes for you in a skid.

Many years ago, if a car pistons were covered in crud, a tank or two of premium would might have cleaned out some crud to make the engine run better because premium gas back then had cleaners in them.

All of this do not apply today, but many people are going by the methods of years ago.