If you drive a Corvette like it's designed, you need the premium fuel to prevent knock and get maximum performance. The computer can compensate for the reduced octane, but it's reactive. When it senses knock, it retards the timing, but knock has to occur first. Continued hard driving with lower octane will eventually cause the cylinders to oval out, causing lower compression and increased oil consumption.
Higher octane fuels can result in lower mileage because of the increased additives to prevent knock.
If you drive your Corvette like a normal car and never go within 1000 rpm of the redline, you can run regular no problem, but where's the fun in that?
A more useful test by these idiots would be which oil company gives you better fuel economy per litre. Cheap Cdn Tire fuel never got me the mileage Sunoco got me.