Is it rape?

Woman falls asleep after sex, guy has sex with her again in her sleep--is it rape?

  • Yes

    Votes: 91 59.1%
  • No

    Votes: 44 28.6%
  • Maybe

    Votes: 19 12.3%

  • Total voters
    154
Huh? You clearly were trying to say that Assange should be persecuted by the US because he wasn't critical enough of Ecuador. It was a ridiculous thing that you were saying. Whether or not he's been critical of enough of Ecuador is irrelevant.

Huh? Maybe instead of a guide dog, you could use a reading dog. It doesn't take more than grade 8 reading skills to understand what I'm saying.

If you need it put simpler - Assange is full of crap about 'abuses' since he ignores that horrible state of things in other countries and only focuses on the actions of the US, one of the lesser rights issues in the world (sort of like the UN Human Rights Commission - and you've made your views on them pretty clear).



p.s. The issue is not just sleeping but refusal to use a condom.
 
If you need it put simpler - Assange is full of crap about 'abuses' since he ignores that horrible state of things in other countries and only focuses on the actions of the US, one of the lesser rights issues in the world (sort of like the UN Human Rights Commission - and you've made your views on them pretty clear).

So that sounds like what I said: You think it's OK for him to be persecuted by the US, because he hasn't complained adequately about Ecuador. That's just stupid.
 
A guy and a girl go back to his place and have happy consensual sex, then fall asleep together in the same bed. A little while later that same night the guy wakes up and has sex with the woman a second time while she is still asleep beside him in the bed.

Is it rape?

Of course.
 
legally, of course it in (in canada at least). however, if i was with a woman in that way at night, i would expect that almost anything we do is ok between us. whether it's sleepy time stuff or whatever. at least until we say goodbye.
 
To cloud the issue further...is it rape if the male in question is doing it in his sleep? I have been guilty of that more than once...but I don't think I have ever stuck it in when I was actually awake and knowing my partner was asleep. But I have done it during my sleep.
 
1. I don't see how you can fuck a woman who is asleep and she doesn't wake up. (What, is your dick a half inch inch in diameter and a foot long that you can snake it between her ass cheeks and into her pussy without her feeling it?)

2. Starting to play with a woman while she is asleep naked in bed beside you- I.e. rubbing her, carressing her, etc. is not rape - it's foreplay. Presumably at some point she wakes up and either spreads or gets disgusted with you and springs out of bed.

3. Assange was set up.
 
I've been the unresponsive MALE..........many a nights only to be woken up with a mouth around my cock or her riding me while i'm asleep. Do i consider that rape.........ahhhhhhh nope. To some women........they love being woken up with a cock in them or mouth on their pussy as they are sleeping..........its fun times for some of us.

the law , the law, the law.........cmon..........we all break them without even knowing it at times, like going faster than the posted speed limit.

Every situation is different.

I actually agree with this.

Though I'm still not sure how a man penetrates a woman without her knowing it.
 
Though I'm still not sure how a man penetrates a woman without her knowing it.

Sadly, some are not as gifted as others.

There certainly seems to be a different perspective from some girls who make money from penetration than those who are in a loving relationship. I have spooned my SO with a hard johnson rubbing her pussy when she was sleeping. She responds slowly getting moist (I figure she's conscious but enjoying the moment). Our love making usually ends up with full participation by both of us. I am not always the initiating party to these events.

Recently I took the time to talk to my SO with the excuse that the topic had come up with guys at work. She told me that she enjoys it and further more - she wouldn't be in bed with someone if she felt that she was being raped if he started to have sex with her in the morning. If she is not feeling well - I'm not pushing it but I am blessed by not having a cold bitch that presses rape charges for a morning loving encounter.
 
Legitimate rape - legitimate response.

Case closed.

So the your kangaroo court has never entertained the notion of two sides to every story ? Nor have the witnessed the pure evil that generate from a woman's scorn ?

So normally women would wait until they know they are pregnant before reacting to a rape ? There isn't a case of an affair that goes wrong when the boyfriend refuses to believe he is the father or refuses to do the honorable thing and marry the girl leaving her alone & embarrassed ?

It's pretty convenient when you can heap allegations on someone who cannot answer them. I have no sympathy for a rapist but I like to see proof before making a judgment.
 
2. Starting to play with a woman while she is asleep naked in bed beside you- I.e. rubbing her, carressing her, etc. is not rape - it's foreplay. Presumably at some point she wakes up and either spreads or gets disgusted with you and springs out of bed.

Maybe in some stunted justice system...but not in Canada baby.
 
Maybe in some stunted justice system...but not in Canada baby.

In your dreams and any normal loving couple's nightmare. Show me a precedent to the successful persecution of a married male that made a pass at of his wife before he realizes she has had a mood swing. What kind of emotionally stunted sleeping arrangement do you have if any caress could result with an assault charge ? What next - when you come up behind your current spouse for a hug - she could charge you with rape ?

Get a dose of reality here boys!
 
In your dreams and any normal loving couple's nightmare. Show me a precedent to the successful persecution of a married male that made a pass at of his wife before he realizes she has had a mood swing. What kind of emotionally stunted sleeping arrangement do you have if any caress could result with an assault charge ? What next - when you come up behind your current spouse for a hug - she could charge you with rape ?

Get a dose of reality here boys!

Funny how you feel the need to add some facts in.

But let's look at them. Do you think the fact the woman is your spouse is relevant? I hope not because they can be raped as well.

The law is very clear that a person must give consent before you engage in sexual acts. The law is also clear that someone who is asleep or unconscious cannot consent.

If you look at the post I was actually commenting on, one of the possible outcomes to "foreplay" included disgust and jumping out of bed. If she is disgusted enough and she chooses to call the police, on those facts a conviction is pretty much guaranteed.

If you concur with James T., it is you who need the dose of reality. Here is some discussion from the Supremes on the issue: http://ifls.osgoode.yorku.ca/2011/05/sccreleasesja/

And I say to you the same thing that Justice MacLaughlin suggested in the ruling, if you don't like it, contact parliament, because that is the law.
 
2. Starting to play with a woman while she is asleep naked in bed beside you- I.e. rubbing her, carressing her, etc. is not rape - it's foreplay.

No, it's sexual assault. What part of "must give consent" don't you understand? You know, the rules that are in those anti-rape guides where it says that a women who is drunk or sleep cannot give consent? Are the rules a bit harsh? I think so. It is a little BS that a woman can say she wants to screw you but if she is drunk, people can say she did not give consent and nail you with rape. Those are the laws. If those are the laws in the US and Canada, I would image the laws are 100x stronger in a haven of feminists and women's rights like Sweden.

Was Assange set up? Maybe. But did he commit a crime in Sweden? Yup.
 
For all the dumb asses that say 'she must give consent'

you are dumb.

It has nothing to do with 'she must give consent' in the real world.

The real world is you have sex - maybe for the first time or for the 30th time and either she decides to charge you with rape or she does not.

Nobody signs consent, nobody records a video to say I consent to sex.

You piss her off and she could cry rape even if it was consensual and it all comes down to your word against her.

So you fuck her while she is sleeping and either she likes it or she charges you with rape. Not really different from the first time you sleep with her except that maybe the first time she is into it and the sleep time she is pissed off.
 
what if she moaned "yes" in her sleep? I figure if she willingly had sex with you an hour ago the consent is implied if she is still lying naked beside you ( as long as you don't take other liberties like removing the condom or anal that she did not consent to). But that is my version of common sense, not an accurate reflection of our laws after 40 years of feminist activism.

My girlfriend once told me "when I say no, I mean yes!".....so anyway you look at it gents, you are fucked, either literally or figuratively.
 
i just read this thread. a lot of fucked up people up in here. jesus lol.