Is it rape?

Woman falls asleep after sex, guy has sex with her again in her sleep--is it rape?

  • Yes

    Votes: 91 59.1%
  • No

    Votes: 44 28.6%
  • Maybe

    Votes: 19 12.3%

  • Total voters
    154

fuji

Banned
Jan 31, 2005
79,936
9
0
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
is.gd
A guy and a girl go back to his place and have happy consensual sex, then fall asleep together in the same bed. A little while later that same night the guy wakes up and has sex with the woman a second time while she is still asleep beside him in the bed.

Is it rape?
 
Is this an ongoing relationship? Or has this occurred in past (i.e. he fucking her while she's asleep)? Or did she tell him that he can fuck her while she's asleep?
If no, then a case could be made for rape. Would it be successful? Probably not.
So, bottom line, I think it's rape but the guy would probably get away with it (very gray area).
 
A guy and a girl go back to his place and have happy consensual sex, then fall asleep together in the same bed. A little while later that same night the guy wakes up and has sex with the woman a second time while she is still asleep beside him in the bed.

Is it rape?
Fuji, it really doesn't matter what any of us here on TERB feel should be so. The way the law is written in both Canada, the U.S.A., and the U.K., consent is required for each act - period.

Agree with the law, or not - if she is asleep, you are rolling the dice.
 
I never understand how someone can rape a woman or fuck her while she is asleep. I can't even fuck a woman who is willing but I can tell is not really into it, just don't feel anything and have to stop.
 
my girl gave me the green light to get in there anytime i want. asleep or awake.
 
Some women fuck like they are dead so maybe the defence would be for the guy he couldn't tell the difference because she never moves or opens her eyes even when she is awake having sex.
As noted by another what the law states is all that matters.
 
I hardly think anyone in a real relationship would be crying rape here. Hell, if I woke up with a girl I just had sex with straddling me and going at it, I'd be quite amused. So long as she used a cover....
 
In Canada there is no doubt that answer is "yes".

Consent to one sex act does not give eternal consent to future sex acts.
 
actually now i think about it i was listening to the jay thomas show on friday and the girl co-host said that when she was 16 her and her boyfriend were sleeping the same bed and she woke up and he was fingering her and trying to stick the tip in. she broke up with him and considered that rape.
 
It's rape. I was reading a lot about rape and rape statistics a few weeks ago. If a woman is not able to agree to the sex it's rape. I read about one girl who didnt remember the first time she had sex because she got so drunk. She didnt pass out or anything, but she didnt remember it at all... She considered that rape... And in a way i agree with her. When i was younger and in between apartments a man (my boss) offered to let me stay until all the appliances the landlord ordered arrived for my new place. It was only a few days but the first night i had a few drinks and fell asleep in his bed. I ended up waking up to him inside me. I was devastated, i had never had sex before... And that's how it happened. I waited to be with the right person and some old perv took my virginity. I stopped going to work for weeks. He started showing up at my house offering me stuff for my apartment. We patch things up i guess and became friends... But bottome line, if the person can't consent to it, it's not right.
 
my girl gave me the green light to get in there anytime i want. asleep or awake.

And how do you think that will stand up in court in Ontario? Likely a conviction if she ever wakes up one morning and calls the cops. You need to consent before sex.

Klute
 
Hard to say if it is rape or not, but for the most part, if you want to fuck a girl in her sleep, you HAVE to ask her. No excuses.
 
She did not consent. Therefor it is rape. Whether it would be prosecuted is an entirely different issue.
 
It's rape........ If a woman is not able to agree to the sex it's rape.

B.S. You need written consent because a girl has second thoughts on an established consensual relationship over good nights sleep ? When I think of all the times my S.O. decides to wake me up with a BJ and I could have charged her with rape. I have fully consensual sex in every position possible into the wee morning hours and she thinks that is a green light to touch my privates in the morning ??? Book her Dano ! Sexually depraved slut ! I feel so utterly violated.

The charges against Assange are flimsy at best but the plan is to get him in a place that he can be extradited to the U.S. Ecuador has recognized this and it is the main reason that they gave him asylum. They requested to both the UK & Sweden a guaranty that Assange would not be sent to a third country - the answer was no. They asked the U.S. if they would try to extradite him from Sweden - the US refused to comment.

With respect to the UK honouring the warrant against Assange for charges that would be dismissed immediately in any Latin American court - they wonder why South American international extradition warrants for a Chilean dictator that murdered thousands was ignored by the UK but this case is treated seriously.

BTW: Having sex with a drunk unconscious woman who cannot give her permission is rape and light years away from Assange's supposed crime.
 
The charges against Assange are flimsy at best but the plan is to get him in a place that he can be extradited to the U.S.
You don't believe he could be extradited to the U.S. from the U.K.? I'd far rather attempt extradition from the U.K. than from Sweden.
 
A guy and a girl go back to his place and have happy consensual sex, then fall asleep together in the same bed. A little while later that same night the guy wakes up and has sex with the woman a second time while she is still asleep beside him in the bed.

Is it rape?

Perhaps you just thought she was asleep. :)

Are you so small she didn't wake up?

There are a number of smart-ass responses to this somewhat unrealistic question.