Un (insert superlative) Believable

hamermill

Senior Member
Oct 2, 2001
4,558
2,620
113
In a place far, far away
http://www.thestar.com/news/gta/cri...ces-assault-charge-for-stabbing-home-intruder

Moses Mahilal and his girlfriend, Sarah Walsh, sensed trouble as they entered her mother’s house just after 3 a.m. on July 31, 2011, and found the side door ajar.

They became even more alarmed when they saw a large pair of black, high-top Air Jordans at the bottom of the staircase leading to the second floor, where her mother, Kimberly Walsh, was asleep.

Mahilal, 26, made a beeline for the kitchen, grabbed a large knife and ran upstairs, where he confronted the intruder hiding behind the door of Kimberly Walsh’s bedroom.

Within minutes, the wounded intruder, Kino Johnson, 33, was gone, and hours later Mahilal, was under arrest and charged with aggravated assault. A preliminary hearing is set for Sept. 11.

The case highlights the much-debated subject of how much force is too much when a stranger attempts to steal your property or break into your house.
Johnson has already admitted he was unlawfully inside the upscale home near Keele St. and Eglinton Ave. W. On June 28, he pleaded guilty in Ontario Superior Court to break and enter and two counts of possessing stolen property, including jewelry taken after he broke into an unoccupied Finch Ave. W. highrise apartment.

Johnson “gained access by unknown means” to the Walsh residence, and once inside, “one of the victims armed himself for safety,” Crown attorney David Fisher said, reading from an agreed statement of facts.
A “struggle ensued,” and Johnson received a stab wound to his chest and lacerations to his hand and leg, Fisher said.

.......

:mad:
 
Hmm, based upon TERB I was under the impression that police in Toronto are omnipresent, hence no one would ever face needing to protect themselves from someone who had broken in.

Guess that isn't true.
 
Un-Fucking-Believable it right.

Buddy with a past criminal record of Break and Enters, a total career criminal gets a total of 15 months in jail with dead time, but this man could face up to 14 years in jail for protecting his family.

Guess all 3 should have just handed the criminal all their stuff, laid down on the floor and been good little victims. :rolleyes:

Next the criminal will get the smart idea to sue for the victims for his injuries.
 
TDL (aka Bucket List)...
Asian
What I find Un (insert superlative) Believable is that you've been on terb since 2001 and still have "Asian" on your TDL when that could have been remedied at any time in the past 10+ years in a half hour for as little as $80 in pretty much any area of the city.
 
This is so fucking stupid.

Cops and prosecutors at their best again. I want my tax dollars back!
 
Lets see how the people who are prosecuting this case deal with a criminal intruder in their own house at night.

What an absolutely bullshit legal system this is sometimes.
 
I would like to be on that Jury. NOTHING would convince me to convict.
 
Why the hell would he take his shoes off?! I thought it was okay to do something like that to an intruder...

Makes me want to consider moving to a place where you can shoot the low lives. I can't imagine coming home to find everything valuable, gone. I would be devestated. They should have a right to attack someone invadin their home... That's just not right!
 
Un (insert expletive) Believable…edit…
.......

:mad:
Superlative form of the hyperbolic adjective 'un-fucking-believable' would be 'most un-fucking-believable', unless 'fuckingest' was intended in the parentheses.

Fixed the title.

As you were; carry on.
 
this is exactly what the "stand your ground" law was for. maybe one day we'll get back to "home=castle".
 
this is exactly what the "stand your ground" law was for. maybe one day we'll get back to "home=castle".

Just to be clear, 'Castle Doctrine' is the American legal doctrine that allows for the use of (up to) lethal force when you are inside your own home with virtually no threat of legal prosecution.

The related 'Stand your Ground' law is the away-from-home version of 'Castle Doctrine', where if you are attacked in public somewhere, you have the right to stand your ground (i.e. you have no duty to retreat first) and kill your attacker without threat of prosecution.

That being said, with only the limited information available, I sure hope Moses gets off. Home invaders shouldn't feel that they have too many legal protections!
 
The reference to "American" is misleading as their law is based on English Common Law with references to "home is a castle" dating back to the 1700s. Note that our laws, other than in Quebec, are also based on the common law.
 
The reference to "American" is misleading as their law is based on English Common Law with references to "home is a castle" dating back to the 1700s. Note that our laws, other than in Quebec, are also based on the common law.

Do you really feel that it is misleading to say that Castle Doctrine is an American law?

As far as I'm aware (IANAL), England does not currently have Castle Doctrine like the US (nor do they have Stand Your Ground laws either).

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Castle_doctrine
 
From the thief's view, he was being peaceful and non-confrontational when trying to get out. If that's the case, the level of violence was unneeded.

If the thief was at all threatening then he got what he deserved.
 
hey there is another thread about this topic and it's better than yours.
 
From the thief's view, he was being peaceful and non-confrontational when trying to get out. If that's the case, the level of violence was unneeded.

If the thief was at all threatening then he got what he deserved.


The intruder was in the mother's room, had left his shoes at the bottom of the stairs for whatever reason, and was hiding behind the door. We hear from all the cop backers here how a guy with a knife can be a threat in open space at even a distance of 20 feet or so to an armed officer.

How much adrenalin do you think was running through Moses' body when he ran upstairs to protect his mother and found the guy behind the door? At close quarters, at 3am in a small room, what chance would you take with a possibly armed intruder in your mother's room?

Being peaceful and non - confrontational would have meant walking past the house, not breaking and entering and being caught in a lady's bedroom at 3am..
 
I think it's really scary to know that men dont have the right to defend their women... especially in their own homes :(
you do, with reasonable force. you don't have the right to repeatedly stab an unarmed person with a kitchen knife.


Guess all 3 should have just handed the criminal all their stuff, laid down on the floor and been good little victims. :rolleyes:

yes because there are ZERO options between giving an unarmed criminal all his belongings and trying to murder him.

gimme a fucking break
 
The intruder was in the mother's room, had left his shoes at the bottom of the stairs for whatever reason, and was hiding behind the door. We hear from all the cop backers here how a guy with a knife can be a threat in open space at even a distance of 20 feet or so to an armed officer.

How much adrenalin do you think was running through Moses' body when he ran upstairs to protect his mother and found the guy behind the door? At close quarters, at 3am in a small room, what chance would you take with a possibly armed intruder in your mother's room?

Being peaceful and non - confrontational would have meant walking past the house, not breaking and entering and being caught in a lady's bedroom at 3am..

I believe he has been charged because it is alleged that he pursued the thief down the stairs and stabbed him as he was trying to escape not because of what he did at the top of the stairs.

You have a right to defend yourself and your family, not a right to pursue and kill people who have crossed you. He is in legal trouble because he is alleged to have stabbed the guy after a chase.
 
You have a right to defend yourself and your family, not a right to pursue and kill people who have crossed you. He is in legal trouble because he is alleged to have stabbed the guy after a chase.

And how do I know he's ready to leave the house and not trying to get to the kitchen to grab another knife to come back and kill me and my family?