Michigan Cops shoot knife-wielding man 30 times

Oh come on! Perhaps in Toronto, but certainly not where I am, and I'm pretty certain not in Michigan either.

"Put down the chalupa or I'll send in the dog (lots of barking dog noises)" is not going to either get someone out of what they have been charged with or secure an indictment of the Trooper/Constable.


p.s. for any TERBites thinking of going over to the "Dark Side" in most jurisdictions attacking a police dog carries the same penalties as attacking a police officer/constable.

I didn't say anything about getting the guy off or indicting the cop. Just saying that if you are in a stand off with an agitated person threatening to release the hound is not helpful.
 
Troops and Frankcastle, either of you ever participate in a "shoot don't shoot" exercise involving someone with a knife?

You know the answer will be no.

So you're telling me that 6 cops with gun training can't stop shooting even though the guy is well outside of stabbing range and has fallen to the ground?
 
Problem is cops aren't trained to disarm or to disable, because it's too dangerous.

They are trained to shoot twice at the torso in rapid succession, and sometimes fire a third time to confirm that the target has been taken out

So with 6 cops acting at once that should be 12 to 18 shots not 30.

Reminds me of the guy with the scissors in TO who was shot by the police.
 
It all depends upon whether the person is a treat, merely standing there refusing to put down the weapon may indeed pose a threat then again it may not. These matters are extensively reviewed, typically by the State's Attorney General's Office.

Yeah that's the thing. The officers were not close enough to get stabbed. No civillians were around to get stabbed. They should have tried to talk him down first (not threaten to sic a dog on him if that is true), if that fails coordinate a less lethal response amongst the 6 officers. For example, did all 6 have to shoot?

Maybe there should be police protocol to designate two of the officers as the ones to take first shots.
 
So with 6 cops acting at once that should be 12 to 18 shots not 30
Yup. But like Aardie said it doesnt matter if you die by the 1st bullet or the 30th bullet. All it shows is a certain power trip by the cops, why else would they fire so many bullets??!
 
Yup. But like Aardie said it doesnt matter if you die by the 1st bullet or the 30th bullet. All it shows is a certain power trip by the cops, why else would they fire so many bullets??!

Yeah but my point is that they went overboard so 30 shots does matter.

I thought in the video you could see him fall and hear shots continue (also note that there is no way he was close enough to stab). No one was in danger except the guy with 6 guns pointed at him.

It didn't have to go down that way.

Thus excessive force.
 
The number of rounds has nothing to do with it, you are just as dead if the first shot hit you squarely in the front of the forehead.

The first half of your sentence contradicts the second half.

5 cops. X. 10 shots each.....about right.

6 cops, 5 shots each = 30 rounds

But without an investigation, it's impossible to know how many shots were fired by each officer. Maybe one or two trigger happy cops busting 12 rounds each.

wtf...........a stun gun would have put him down.

Not always.

Unfortunately he had mental problems. When somebody is holding a knife at a group of armed officers, they're likely beyond repair. It may be for the better that he was killed. In fact, it was probably his wish.
 
It all depends upon whether the person is a treat, merely standing there refusing to put down the weapon may indeed pose a threat then again it may not. These matters are extensively reviewed, typically by the State's Attorney General's Office.

you really are the poster boy for right wing "political correctness'...those cops executed the guy, that plain and simple..and lawyerese and polite gibberish from you wont change that..
 
The first half of your sentence contradicts the second half.



6 cops, 5 shots each = 30 rounds

But without an investigation, it's impossible to know how many shots were fired by each officer. Maybe one or two trigger happy cops busting 12 rounds each.



Not always.

Unfortunately he had mental problems. When somebody is holding a knife at a group of armed officers, they're likely beyond repair. It may be for the better that he was killed. In fact, it was probably his wish.

I think the field of psychology would disagree on your diagnosis. Maybe he was off his meds.

Plus he could have been high, drunk or something else. Nothing says that once he picks up the knife he is forever a knife waving maniac.
 
The first half of your sentence contradicts the second half.



6 cops, 5 shots each = 30 rounds

But without an investigation, it's impossible to know how many shots were fired by each officer. Maybe one or two trigger happy cops busting 12 rounds each.



Not always.

Unfortunately he had mental problems. When somebody is holding a knife at a group of armed officers, they're likely beyond repair. It may be for the better that he was killed. In fact, it was probably his wish.
so cops now have the power to decide, because aperson appears to have mental problems, that it would be better if said person was dead..or using your logic again, we expect cops to be able to , within seconds, discern whether someone wants to commit suicide..you really do need to rethink your post...is life really that cheap?
 
Check out this murder of four cops .....with a knife wielding lunatic.

Move forward to the 6 minute mark.

Cops have to shoot...and quickly.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kfz4jeudr9o&feature=youtube_gdata_player

Not saying a person with a knife is not dangerous. Two big difference is that the cops in your video moved within lunging range. Furthermore these cops did not have their guns trained on him.

As an aside what are you doing watching sick videos like that?
 
Yes that video was crazy..came up doing a YouTube search.

Goes to show how well trained the Michigan guys were.


2 bullets.....or 30?

Does it matter?
 
so cops now have the power to decide. . . ?
Simple answer yes. If the shooting is justified the shooting is justified. The Attorney General's Officer doesn't engage in elaborate speculation as to what if they had done this instead of that.
 
You know the answer will be no.

So you're telling me that 6 cops with gun training can't stop shooting even though the guy is well outside of stabbing range and has fallen to the ground?
The point being that that "stabbing range" is much greater than the two of you seem to belive it is up to 50 feet/15 meters away.

Yeah that's the thing. The officers were not close enough to get stabbed.
See the above.
 
you really are the poster boy for right wing "political correctness'...those cops executed the guy, that plain and simple..and lawyerese and polite gibberish from you wont change that..
What can I say other than, I explained the law to you and you disagree with the law, so be it.

As for me I believe I'm going to wait for the results of the investigation.
 
Last edited: