Michigan Cops shoot knife-wielding man 30 times

Phil C. McNasty

Go Jays Go
Dec 27, 2010
32,205
9,500
113
It entirely depends upon two things a) were they justified in using deadly force (he had a knife and refused to put it down - presumably he didn't move away from them) and b) whether they continued to fire at him after he was clearly no longer a threat to them.

The number of rounds has nothing to do with it, you are just as dead if the first shot hit you squarely in the front of the forehead.
 
30 seems a bit excessive but if the cop was a bad shot and the guy was hopped up on PCP then I suppose it would be justified.

I think number of rounds is relevant because being hit a few times might have incapacitated the guy instead of killing him.
 
After watching the vid I'd say it was excessive.... the shooting continues after he has fallen to the ground.

Also, if the witness was correct in saying one of the cops threatened to release the dog on him then they escalated the situation.

The length of time of the investigation is also intriguing.
 
wtf...........a stun gun would have put him down.
 
wtf...........a stun gun would have put him down.
Yeah but then you gotta face your 5 buddies as the guy who pulled a stun gun when they all brought their handguns to the party. Plus you know how much of a hassle it is to holter a weapon when 5 of your buddies can cover for you? Then you have to go to the trouble of pulling out the stun gun. :D
 
/
Also, if the witness was correct in saying one of the cops threatened to release the dog on him then they escalated the situation.
Oh come on! Perhaps in Toronto, but certainly not where I am, and I'm pretty certain not in Michigan either.

"Put down the chalupa or I'll send in the dog (lots of barking dog noises)" is not going to either get someone out of what they have been charged with or secure an indictment of the Trooper/Constable.


p.s. for any TERBites thinking of going over to the "Dark Side" in most jurisdictions attacking a police dog carries the same penalties as attacking a police officer/constable.
 
It entirely depends upon two things a) were they justified in using deadly force (he had a knife and refused to put it down - presumably he didn't move away from them) and b) whether they continued to fire at him after he was clearly no longer a threat to them.

The number of rounds has nothing to do with it, you are just as dead if the first shot hit you squarely in the front of the forehead
I'm not concerned about amount of shots, more about whether they were legally justified to shoot him. I know the video isnt very clear, but the suspect didnt appear to lunge at the cops, he just stood there holding his knife.

You're a lawyer, right?? Is that legal grounds to shoot a suspect??
 
Troops and Frankcastle, either of you ever participate in a "shoot don't shoot" exercise involving someone with a knife?
 
I'm not concerned about amount of shots, more about whether they were legally justified to shoot him. I know the video isnt very clear, but the suspect didnt appear to lunge at the cops, he just stood there holding his knife.

You're a lawyer, right?? Is that legal grounds to shoot a suspect??
It all depends upon whether the person is a treat, merely standing there refusing to put down the weapon may indeed pose a threat then again it may not. These matters are extensively reviewed, typically by the State's Attorney General's Office.
 
Troops and Frankcastle, either of you ever participate in a "shoot don't shoot" exercise involving someone with a knife?

No......but they could have given him a warning shot in the leg. to drop knife.
 
No......but they could have given him a warning shot in the leg. to drop knife
Problem is cops aren't trained to disarm or to disable, because it's too dangerous.

They are trained to shoot twice at the torso in rapid succession, and sometimes fire a third time to confirm that the target has been taken out
 
Yeah, right unless your Aunt was Annie Oakley.

It seemed like pretty close range to me from that vid. i know i could have taken his leg out at that range.
 
The place seems to be a small shopping mall. Are they just lucky, or had they investigated and made certain that there was nobody standing behind the guy, within range of stray bullets? They don't seem to be inhibited about spraying the landscape with bullets and ricochets. No reports of any bystanders being hit by strays?
 
excessive? yeah but perhaps the crook wanted to die. He could of dropped the knife any time
 
So, there are SIX cops there against a guy with a knife and they fire 30 rounds !!

I can understand if its a one on one situation where a single cop is confronting a guy with a knife but judging from the video and general logic, the use of force was very excessive in this case.
 
it's michigan, everyone is on crack and needs a few extra bullets to put them down.
 
Reality TV

I think those cops are watching too much TV and movies !!!

FAST