I am a huge Trekkie/Trekker/pocket protector guy. I am not sure that I would agree with this. Though it is a great episode, and quite fun and well-acted, I think connaseurs would find other episodes as good, if not better. Some include:
City on the Edge of Forever - Kirk and Spock go back in time to prevent a change in the timeline that would obliterate their existence. They realize that a woman in the past that Kirk has fallen for MUST die in order for the timeline to be restored. Harlan Ellision, a genius writer penned the episode, and it is well-known that Roddenberry screwed within even more brilliant draft from Ellison.
Mirror, Mirror - the parallel universe one is a great study in character.
Where No Man Has Gone Before - A study in friendship, compassion, leadership and eugenics... Can a superior human being be created over-night and be able to master and comprehend his powers in order to continue to live among regular men?
There are others I like including Space Seed, The Doomsday Machine, Tomorrow is Yesterday and A Piece of The Action.