Everything you say is true, and a road won't replace a 4/6 lane Series 400 highway and the Saint Lawrence Seaway traffic.
Ok, so the line up to Moosenee can be upgraded and there is nothing to say that you cannot build a major highway down into the US and through its Northeast states. As for cheaper foodstuffs, I am pretty sure that the Americans can produce it cheaper than we can. So far, nothing you have said makes it insurmountable for Canada to dump Quebec and come out ahead financially.

