Quebec

Shrivel up and die, hahaha, it would be stronger than ever. Part of the separation agreement would be the highway. Quebec adds nothing to the country.
Nothing...except passion, emotion, spirit of adventure, music, beauty, appreciation of the arts and collectivism.
Quebec athletes have won a third of the individual medals won by Canada at the Winter Olympics, even though Quebeckers make up only 23 per cent of the Canadian population
 
The Quebec chicks seem to like the Anglophone guys.... could never figure that one out, but that's all good.
 
Sure, and while we're at it, give the use of our currency, passport and the army. Then we have to discuss the rail lines and the Seaway. We'\ll all be dead before that gets settled.

Are you implying that Quebecers would be difficult to deal with :D

Seriously though look at Europe - not as if these are really significant problems if Quebec wanted out.
 
Quebec would continue selling their product, you think they'd screw their own farmers by saying they can't take money from Canada?
They would continue buying oil from us at the same price but they'll have to jack up their taxes to pay for it. No more $7/day daycare and students would have a real reason to riot.
 
Are you implying that Quebecers would be difficult to deal with :D

Seriously though look at Europe - not as if these are really significant problems if Quebec wanted out.

These request were made the last time around, not new. On the international stage the economy of Quebec would be equal to that of Cameroon, or is it Gabon. They know they have it good and it's just talk.
 
Quebec would continue selling their product, you think they'd screw their own farmers by saying they can't take money from Canada?
They would continue buying oil from us at the same price but they'll have to jack up their taxes to pay for it. No more $7/day daycare and students would have a real reason to riot.

I didn't say they would stop doing business just that it would be a sellers market. You might be surprised how much oil Quebec buys from foreign sources and not Canada.
 
Anybody know how much Quebec pays in Federal taxes? I hear they put in a lot more into the pot than the equalization payment they get back. Just like Ontario.
 
Anybody know how much Quebec pays in Federal taxes? I hear they put in a lot more into the pot than the equalization payment they get back. Just like Ontario.

Uh, no.

Quite the opposite.

Same with Ontario. We are now a "have not" province for the first time in 144 years. Quebec receives equalization payments and so does Ontario. It's basically federal government welfare to the provinces.
 
JFK puts a lot of credence in the fact that the majority of Quebecer's were born French Catholic and of course that means they live the life of a French Catholic 'til they die. Something tells me that not the case. Oh, ya my in-laws. Many would be surprised if I was to tell you that less than half would be considering practicing RC?

No, it means there is a commonality in their ethnicity.
 
These request were made the last time around, not new. On the international stage the economy of Quebec would be equal to that of Cameroon, or is it Gabon. They know they have it good and it's just talk.

In Billions GDP via PPP
Cameroon 47.12
Gabon 24.28


Quebec
$303.7 billion (2009)

Actually using the same 2011 PPP numbers it would be almost the level of a Greece by coincidence.

Not that
Luxembourg 43.55
or
Liechtenstein 5.028

seem to be bothered at being at or below the level of Cameroon and Gabon.
 
Nothing...except passion, emotion, spirit of adventure, music, beauty, appreciation of the arts and collectivism.
Yeah that isn't racist at all.
 
In Billions GDP via PPP
Cameroon 47.12
Gabon 24.28


Quebec
$303.7 billion (2009)

Actually using the same 2011 PPP numbers it would be almost the level of a Greece by coincidence.

Not that
Luxembourg 43.55
or
Liechtenstein 5.028

seem to be bothered at being at or below the level of Cameroon and Gabon.

I guess you missed the symbolism in my statement and couldn't miss a chance open your cake hole to drop a load.

$305 Billion GDP would rank Quebec in with Nigeria and Malaysia for 2012, right in in the middle of the pack and not in the top 10 with Canada.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_o...(nominal)#IMF_estimates_between_2010_and_2017
 
Canada sends several billions of dollars ($8 billion?) a year in equalization payments alone to Quebec. I'm sure that a few hundred million of that can pay for any reasonable tariffs through the seaway. Alternatively, with the billions saved we can expand rail and road networks to Hudson Bay and to points west and south.

Not one of your foodstuffs is unique to Quebec. In fact, I don't think you'd find any Quebec-sourced foodstuffs in your typical Toronto supermarket aside from cheese perhaps. Most of the stuff in my local supermarkets comes from Ontario or American producers and I have no problems with eating it. I'd be even happier if the money saved from equalization payments goes to Ontario farmers and producers.


Hudson Bay? Have you ever seen rail and road built on tundra and permafrost. The worst road and rail beds in the country and you want it to replace the busiest highway and rail corridor in Canada.

You might want to check your chickens. Quebec is second only to Manitoba for pork production, second to Ontario for chicken and second only to ontario for egg production. You also might want to check up on the interrelationship between Ontario Hydro and Hydro Quebec.

Where does Eastern Ontario gets it's oil from? A bottleneck like you suggest would get the Irvine family in a huff.

All of that is irrelevant. There is nothing to say that Ontario and points west cannot replace all of Quebec's foodstuffs with either homegrown or American products. We would most likely get it even cheaper.

As for oil, so what? Again, we have tons of the stuff out west that cannot find a market to the US and we are now looking to try to export the stuff to Asia. And the Irvine family does not control Canadian politics.

P.S. As for tundra and permafrost, I don't think the permafrost line goes down that far south because the TransCanada Highway and main rail line goes pretty close to Hudson's Bay.
 
We can talk about separation till the cows come home, but what we have all forgotten about our neighbour to the south. At no time has the U.S. EVER expresed an opionon on the matter in order not to appear as meddlesome EXCEPT once by accident when ( either Carter or Clinton can't recall who) in response to a question on separation, responded that the US would not tolerate any insatbility on it borders. The handlers and publicists quickly backtracked, but the cat was out of the bag.

We can do the academic debate all we want, but if the separation game appears to forecast a 3rd world country (like another Mexico, Cuba?) springing up on a long and sparsely guarded border, that could allow extremsits and terrorsist to set up a base or drug cartels to find a new route into the country, do you really think the US wll stand back and allow a bunch of xenophobic, racist, socialists set up "une republique banana" and allow them to mess with US homeland security ?

In the final analysis, we need to worry less on this and party more. I think we need to establish 13 September as a NEW DAY OF NATIONAL CELEBRATION. That's when the French lost at the Plains of Abrahm. The Spanish have the Cinqo di Mayo, when they tossed the French off ( they don't seem to have much luck on this continent do they?) Th francos can't really complain, because they ain't FRENCH(from FRANCE) no more. They are Canadians with a distinct HANGLISH accents, that speak white-trash french and survice as recipents of millions of dollasr of federal money acquiescing and coddling a dying culture.

It's funny to notice how many Americans learn to speak Spanish, beacuse THAT culture remains strong without any governemnt support and they have only ONE officil language.
 
All of that is irrelevant. There is nothing to say that Ontario and points west cannot replace all of Quebec's foodstuffs with either homegrown or American products. We would most likely get it even cheaper.

As for oil, so what? Again, we have tons of the stuff out west that cannot find a market to the US and we are now looking to try to export the stuff to Asia. And the Irvine family does not control Canadian politics.

P.S. As for tundra and permafrost, I don't think the permafrost line goes down that far south because the TransCanada Highway and main rail line goes pretty close to Hudson's Bay.

I'm guessing you've not spent much time in northern ontario let alone Manitoba and the Territories. There is a reason there are no roads running to James Bay and Hudsons Bay and that's the terrain. There is one limited use rail line to both, but they aren't able to handle anywhere near the load that would be expected. I don't know about the Moosenee run but the up keep on the Churchill line is horrendous. It not just permafrost but also tundra, read bog. Look at a map and try and spot the gravel gravel roads north of Cochrane and Red Lake. You can build a road, but it can't handle heavy traffic loads. The Dempster Highway in the Yukon is a perfect example of what will happen. It's a 500 mile gravel road constantly in repair with very light traffic. You can be driving on it, able to 10 km in front and back and not see a single vehicle, yet this traffic causes the toad to need repairs from wear and tear because of the climate. The roads you're thinking of would be the same.

As for replacing the product and cheaper, you're guessing pure and simple.