Well wouldn't you agree that they just took on more entitlements without really trying to figure how to really reduce healthcare costs. When was there enough revenue to satisfy a liberal.
More people buying car insurance in Ontario never really led to decreased premiums for everyone else right?
How so? It looks like he was right on.
How so? It looks like he was right on.
I wrote in post # 11The individual mandate was found to be constitutional, contrary to his claim.
I will be absolutely shocked if the individual mandate is not held an overbroad use of the Commerce Clause.
No, I posted that the individual mandate was a clear over-reach of the Commerce Clause. That you want to stretch what I stated is fine, given that you are not a Judge with jurisdiction.You clearly expected the individual mandate to be struck down, as did OTB, Astrix, and kdouglas.
Go up to #64 click on the link and read the first three pages, pretend that you have twenty seconds to get whether the law has been upheld or held unconstitutional and I believe you will see why on live television they initially got it wrong.Meanwhile, in a replay of "Dewey Defeats Truman," CNN and Fox News first reported the mandate had been struck down and Obamacare invalidated.
No, I posted that the individual mandate was a clear over-reach of the Commerce Clause.
You know I've disagreed with of lot of TERBites who just come unglued on you. But in this instance I honestly have to say in what the Hell State are you admitted to the Bar? Of what the Hell Law School are you a graduate?The individual mandate was not an over-reach of the Commerce Clause.
So that The President, Speaker Pelosi etc. . . all insisted the it was not a tax until the Solicitor General as his second alternate argument to the Court said that if it was not Constitutional under the Commerce or the Necessary and Proper Clause then it must be a tax. . . is all irrelevant?The individual mandate was a tax.
No, I posted that the individual mandate was a clear over-reach of the Commerce Clause. That you want to stretch what I stated is fine, given that you are not a Judge with jurisdiction.
What frankly is just as interesting as The Chief Justice siding with the liberal four, was that Justice Kennedy did not just side in part with the conservative four, he wanted to hold the entire law unconstitutional.
See post #40Many people have suggested that what Roberts did was to protect the court from charges of judicial activism.
No disagreement from me!cye; said:the fundamental flaw of the American system remains the inability to control costs.
The American people are being lied to. Pure and simple.
For profit over the health of their own neighbours. Their own countrymen.
Shame on them.
+1!!!
And the right has the best paid LIARS Big Money, that owns them, can buy!...![]()
Well, roll me in egg and flour and bake me for 30 minutes. I never expected Chief Justice Roberts to cross over and join the liberal wing of the bench on this. In fact, I think you would be hard pressed to find anytime this has happened previously. Scalia must be totally pissed off. Good. He deserves it.
He looked long and hard at what his legacy would be if he dismantled Obamacare.
Asterix, I believe you will find you put far more ulterior motive not to mention conspiracy into Supreme Court deliberations whether in Canada or the U.S.A than is there.
Aardvark154 said:You know better than the entire U.S. Supreme Court or did it just happen to escape your attention that both the majority as well as the dissenters agreed that that it was an overreach of the Commerce Cause!?