Elliot Lake mall collapse

Someone was alive in the rubble. Because of the delay in getting to them, that person is now dead.

If that person could have been saved, had bureaucratic bumbling (to whatever extent it existed) not gotten in the way.. I wonder how those people will be able to sleep at night, knowing that they could have saved a life.. but didn't.

yeah, its astonishing that the media isnt talking about that. there was someone who was alive and they died waiting. without a doubt had the rescue effort started much sooner which is now proven to be 100% possible since they have completed a late rescue, that person would have been pulled out alive. whether or not this person would have survived in hospital who knows point is if I was their family id be so disturbed and angry they died there for nothing
 
yeah, its astonishing that the media isnt talking about that. there was someone who was alive and they died waiting. without a doubt had the rescue effort started much sooner which is now proven to be 100% possible since they have completed a late rescue, that person would have been pulled out alive. whether or not this person would have survived in hospital who knows point is if I was their family id be so disturbed and angry they died there for nothing

Well that's going too far. We don't know whether that person could have been pulled out alive, but certainly, that person deserved our best effort to get them out, and didn't receive it.
 
"After the Premier’s intervention, it required only a five-minute conversation between Staff Insp. Neadles and Mr. Hefkey to authorize the use of heavier equipment. And the gigantic excavator ultimately proved an effective way of getting through the rubble. The bodies of Doloris Perizzolo and Lucie Aylwin, the two women who had been trapped inside, were recovered Wednesday."

It is absolutely clear that they fucked up. That it required the Premier to intervene in order to get it moving after FOUR DAYS implies at least two fuckups:

1. The people managing it weren't doing their jobs, and

2. The Premier did not intervene soon enough

Five minutes after he asked for options, he got options. They should have either been GIVING him options, up front, or else just doing it without asking permission. He should have been all over it on day one making sure that everything that could be done was being done. "What else can you do? What's plan B?" should have been his question on the first day, and the answer should have been "bring in heavy equipment", "yes, do it". Didn't happen that way, though.

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news...ollowing-elliot-lake-disaster/article4375877/
 
Wow, it is amazing the tangents and accusation people in their comfy chairs make.

These rescue people, who are mostly volunnteers do care and don't you for a moment think they don't feel. T%hey're not just weekend warriors as they are sent all over the country and theworld to do what they do. They are the best. I've seen first hand some them breakdown and cry when they didn't get there 'in time'.

The equipment that was finally brought wasn't theirs to take, nor was it part of the normal equipment use successfuly 100's of time. It belonged to a private firm, Pressley(?) and had to be asked for or offered once the true situation was realized that the normal equipment wouldn't do the job. Just like someone earlier wrongly thought miners rescuers could do just as well.

The 2 bodies were found so close to where the rescuers were approaching, but they could not reach them 'safely' as the building could collapse taking more people with it. They decided to try plan B and approach from behind, and that was more time consuming, requiring the new equipment. One body was found with a few thousand pounds of concrete on top of it with barely feet and hands exposed. it quite possible that the person who was taping was similarly trapped and died moments after the last sounds. You can be conscious able to talk and communicate, but suffering from a crushing injury that you can't successfully extricated from.

As for the numbers of unaccounted, that may be explained later, but no big thing in my thinking. It may be that from videos it was shown that X number of people were near the collapse site 'moments' before, may not have been locals so were not identified and accounted for.
 
Could they not at least have sent in a "snake camera" on day 1 or 2 to where they heard "tapping" sound? Don't send in a human being but a $100 camera. No one cares if a camera gets killed.
 
Could they not at least have sent in a "snake camera" on day 1 or 2 to where they heard "tapping" sound? Don't send in a human being but a $100 camera. No one cares if a camera gets killed.

They did send in a remote camera, but I don't remeber when.
 
All true, but the same happens in earthquakes and this is but one mall, how much easier to send in the specialists for one building (and in the summer at that) than for an earthquake.

I wonder, and this is an honest I don't know what has been asked, whether the Province or Federal Govenment have asked for the assistance of those types of specialists.

We lack the specialist that the US and other countries have in areas such this. We would have real issues here if something major happened, like an earthquake or bombing, I shudder to think of these things.
 
If this happened in a 3rd world country, Canada would have rushed the heavy equipment over there 4 days ago.

No, we would have sent water filtration stuff and medical supplies, we lack heavy equipment.

Unacceptable that in this country,it should take 4 days to get proper heavy equipment in with trained personal for the rescue.
Pathetic and heads should roll. Hope they actually find people alive.

The equipment required probably had to come in fron the Soo or Sudbury.

I agree with what most of you say, except that in a collapsed mine situation it is NOT just earth and rock. Gone are the days of digging by hand with shovels by candle light lol. Mines these days are huge, hundreds of feet under neath, thousands of pounds of twisted steel supports, hundreds of huuuge 2 tonne mining trucks/drillers/excavators etc... Not to mention some stocks of explosives and there's always the threat of digging upon a gas pocket. Mines are a lot more complicated than just 'earth and rocks'.

A mine is different in the fact that the equipment required to dig out is on site and the location of survivors is usually known, so they can dig without fear of killing anyone and they have a disaster response unit and disaster response plans on site and available to all.

The slow political response was particularly astonishing when you consider that McGuinty and his Liberals were in Sudbury when this happened.

Don't local authorities need to ask for help before the next level of government steps in to help. Like the tornado in Vaughn last year, they declared a state of emergency and asked the provincial gov for help.
 
Here is the proof. Once they started using the heavy machinery, they recovered 2 bodies in less than 1 day. However, it took 4 fucking days before they brought in the heavy machinery. WHY THE DELAY?

Elliot Lake is in the middle of nowhere.
 
We lack the specialist that the US and other countries have in areas such this. We would have real issues here if something major happened, like an earthquake or bombing, I shudder to think of these things.

We do not lack the expertise, as members of these team are sent around the the world, but do lack the numbers, only 4/5 such team, for such a large country.

As said earlier the heavy equipment eventually used for the plan B, which was put into motion after plan A was found too dangerous, is not normally available and was privately owned. As for why the delay, you might want to get the answer from the owners of the multi million dollar piece of equipment Priestly. The engineers members of TERB might be able to put a price tag better than I. Even if the province was to have one how many times would it be used, making a very expensive possession, not use very often.
 
It's fun watching Blackrock fumble around in his foggy way making excuses for the rescuers.

Equipment not theirs to take? Plan B not started until after plan A failed?

Clearly they could have requisitioned any equipment required, and it was sheer management incompetence not to start plan B in parallel with plan A.

In my job if we face a serious enough risk I order implementation of the backup plan in parallel, and all we have at risk is money. While in the end there were only two trapped, on day one they believed there were as many as nine. It was a big deal.
 
That is the real tragedy here.


Agreed. There should be no excuse for what happened.

Unfortunately DJ's crystal ball can't say how soon after the tapping was heard did the person die and as mentioned before if it was the person under the crushing weight of a few thousand pounds of concrete with only hands and feet exposed, the word rescue is used incorrectly. We can have the medical professionals on TERB explain the fine points.

There are very few on TERB who responsibilities involve sending workers into dangerous life threatening situations, and no you don't send them into situations of danger beyond limits. The limits are not set in concrete but are fluid. The risks taken at time are calculated risk and people who know more about what was happening in EL said no. Even after that the next approached was being planned by multiple levels of command and control. Most members just sit in their comfy chair and make judgement on their skill, training commitment and courage. Fuck you people and the boats you came in on.
Many of you are the same who think firemen are adrenelin junkies, headline seeking who are over paid and spend most of their time eating and sleeping.

A drum tech died at Downsview in minutes from a crushing injury while a few people watched from a few feet away because they couldn't reach out to him or crawl to him. A rigger at the top of the stage had a hairy ride down to ground and is rethinking his career choices. Why, will be discovered and reported on in the near future.
 
It's fun watching Blackrock fumble around in his foggy way making excuses for the rescuers.

Equipment not theirs to take? Plan B not started until after plan A failed?

Clearly they could have requisitioned any equipment required, and it was sheer management incompetence not to start plan B in parallel with plan A.

In my job if we face a serious enough risk I order implementation of the backup plan in parallel, and all we have at risk is money. While in the end there were only two trapped, on day one they believed there were as many as nine. It was a big deal.

Privately owned equipment is not anyones to take and requisitioning is out of the question, unless they have the ability to do so without going up some sort of chain-of-command. This is probably where the issue lies for the delay.
 
Privately owned equipment is not anyones to take and requisitioning is out of the question, unless they have the ability to do so without going up some sort of chain-of-command. This is probably where the issue lies for the delay.

Somebody gets it. I take FUJI comments you quoted just like his comments on Law, High Seas, UCMJ, or Constitutional. He just doesn't know much at al,l but thinks he's better at it than the Justices of the US Supreme Court, The Hague, and International Tribunal on Law of the Seas. The lawyers on TERB just smile most of the time; sometimes not. FUJI has little understanding of most aspects of SAR, but that doesn't stop him from pontificating in his smoking jacket and velvet slippers. Others on TERB get regular re-certification and training that according to the rules of FUJI doesn't count to much as they don't know squat.
 
We do not lack the expertise, as members of these team are sent around the the world, but do lack the numbers, only 4/5 such team, for such a large country.

As said earlier the heavy equipment eventually used for the plan B, which was put into motion after plan A was found too dangerous, is not normally available and was privately owned. As for why the delay, you might want to get the answer from the owners of the multi million dollar piece of equipment Priestly. The engineers members of TERB might be able to put a price tag better than I. Even if the province was to have one how many times would it be used, making a very expensive possession, not use very often.

I believe the only team available in this area is from Toronto and they are of, as yet, untested.

While I'm sure Priestly may have wanted to do their civic duty, there is a question of liability, Priestly does not want to get sued for anything that may happen in a situation such as this. This isn't a regular demolition.

Why would one need answers from the owners of Priestly? Are they to assume their equipment is needed for the purpose of recue. Until contacted, they probably had no idea their services were required.

The equipment used is a high hoe. Buckets are removed and grabbers and cutters are attached, they would be too expensive, not very practical for use in rescue as they need level ground and space to operate and if used near areas where there might be survivors, they could cause more harm than good.
 
I believe the only team available in this area is from Toronto and they are of, as yet, untested.

While I'm sure Priestly may have wanted to do their civic duty, there is a question of liability, Priestly does not want to get sued for anything that may happen in a situation such as this. This isn't a regular demolition.

Why would one need answers from the owners of Priestly? Are they to assume their equipment is needed for the purpose of recue. Until contacted, they probably had no idea their services were required.

The equipment used is a high hoe. Buckets are removed and grabbers and cutters are attached, they would be too expensive, not very practical for use in rescue as they need level ground and space to operate and if used near areas where there might be survivors, they could cause more harm than good.

I don't know anyone personally on the Toronto HUSAR, but I believe they were involved in the collapse of some building a few years back at Bloor and Yonge and have been to Haiti. I'd have to check, but I believe HUSARs are also located in Winnipeg, Vancouver, and Halifax.
 
Privately owned equipment is not anyones to take and requisitioning is out of the question, unless they have the ability to do so without going up some sort of chain-of-command. This is probably where the issue lies for the delay.

McGuinty was two hours away in Sudbury when this happened. He should have been a true leader and made things happen. This sort of thing should come instinctively. It unfortunately reminds me of the shameful non-reaction of GWB during the Katrina disaster. This is a low point in Ontario's history.