Elliot Lake mall collapse

The backlash was strong and very understandable, but based on emotions not experience, training, commonsense, and reality. The team that made the initial decision is one of the worlds best. Don't you even think, from your comfy couch, you can match their analysis.

yeah of course im not there, but this world has seen its share of disasters that are far greater than this one. you cant deny there are some major fuck ups that went on. what if an earthquake leveled a few city blocks? if this happened before the election mcguinty would be there now without question
 
yeah of course im not there, but this world has seen its share of disasters that are far greater than this one. you cant deny there are some major fuck ups that went on. what if an earthquake leveled a few city blocks? if this happened before the election mcguinty would be there now without question

The fuck ups are there, but not with the first responders on site in EL. Nice of you bring in earthquakes as many of this same crew were in Haiti because they are some of the best.
 
Yes MSOG.... And if Darlington had exploded, killing 8 million in the GTA, you can bet your ass Harper would have been There (cause McGuinty would have fried)

But we are NOT.

We are talking about a section of roof collapsing in a small mall.
 
blackrock13 said:
The backlash was strong and very understandable, but based on emotions not experience, training, commonsense, and reality. The team that made the initial decision is one of the worlds best. Don't you even think, from your comfy couch, you can match their analysis.

Bull shit.
 
Yes MSOG.... And if Darlington had exploded, killing 8 million in the GTA, you can bet your ass Harper would have been There (cause McGuinty would have fried)

But we are NOT.

We are talking about a section of roof collapsing in a small mall.

Harper would be in his bunker, where ever that is now.

Unfortunately, doing what they are now to retrieve the bodies, is destroying much of the evidence, if there is a design or material flaw originating from the builders or designers.
 
Yes MSOG.... And if Darlington had exploded, killing 8 million in the GTA, you can bet your ass Harper would have been There (cause McGuinty would have fried)

But we are NOT.

We are talking about a section of roof collapsing in a small mall.



what you are saying is true, which highlights how simple and easy this should have been for trained professionals to deal with. harper also shares some blame, after 24 hours or sooner he should have called in the army to help once it was well established the first responders werent qualified or competant.
 
In this case I agree with you. The Province should have been all over this from the moment it happened. It's obvious that small towns don't have the capacity to deal with disasters like this, they needed outside help, and the Ontario Government should not have waited to be asked. They should have been in there on day one, with a big list of all the help they could provide, #1 on the list being management teams to help with co-ordinating the rescue.

While the Ontario government is more directly relevant, due to its role in supervising municipalities, the Federal government also was quite tardy in stepping up to the plate.

The small town can be forgiven for inexperience, the other two levels of government have no such excuse. They should have been on the ball, they weren't, and now perhaps a dozen or more people have died who might have been savable.

You might want to read today's Globe to understand what the responsibilities and protocols are before voicing your opinion. I mean I realize you are a recue expert, in addition to your expertise in contitutional law and infectious deseases, but perhaps for once you might want to understand the facts before shooting from the lip. This need to second guess, politicize and critisize before all the facts are known is in some ways uniquely terb.

Just a thought and I think the Globe outlined what is known so far fairly well today.
 
Harper would be in his bunker, where ever that is now.

Unfortunately, doing what they are now to retrieve the bodies, is destroying much of the evidence, if there is a design or material flaw originating from the builders or designers.

You should also read the Globe page 8 and 9 - they clearly state that the emergency chain of command is for the province under Emergency Management Ontario to call the shots.
 
You should also read the Globe page 8 and 9 - they clearly state that the emergency chain of command is for the province under Emergency Management Ontario to call the shots.

There was talk of calling the army and that would involve the Feds. I'm not going to say it would or should be done, but it was considered. I'm not saying it was the Feds responsibility, but they have assets that can be used. You are right the province is in control. The bunker comment was in response to the fictitious Darlington scenario.
 
why didn't they just tell the locals to go home and get their tractors and loaders. i lived up there, they all have them. the locals could have it sorted out real fucking quick.
 
Here is the proof. Once they started using the heavy machinery, they recovered 2 bodies in less than 1 day. However, it took 4 fucking days before they brought in the heavy machinery. WHY THE DELAY?
 
if I were mcguinty id get in a chopper and fly my ass over there just like bush in the days after 9/11. id join in the rescue efforts after all I get paid to do fuck all. instead mcguinty is doing nothing cause he has no balls or morals

The slow political response was particularly astonishing when you consider that McGuinty and his Liberals were in Sudbury when this happened.
 
Here is the proof. Once they started using the heavy machinery, they recovered 2 bodies in less than 1 day. However, it took 4 fucking days before they brought in the heavy machinery. WHY THE DELAY?

Incompetent provincial program and a lack of training. Strange thing is when I think back to the Walkerton water deaths, one of the factors was related to cutbacks...Now, we have thrown money at programs and end up with the same result - Unqualified personnel.
 
Someone was alive in the rubble. Because of the delay in getting to them, that person is now dead.

If that person could have been saved, had bureaucratic bumbling (to whatever extent it existed) not gotten in the way.. I wonder how those people will be able to sleep at night, knowing that they could have saved a life.. but didn't.
 
Someone was alive in the rubble. Because of the delay in getting to them, that person is now dead.

If that person could have been saved, had bureaucratic bumbling (to whatever extent it existed) not gotten in the way.. I wonder how those people will be able to sleep at night, knowing that they could have saved a life.. but didn't.

I am sure they will sleep just fine because they don't care. If it was one of their family members you wouls see all roads opened up wide for the equipment to get there an hour after the collapse. Sad but unfortunately I believe this to be true.
 
What I don't grasp is that within the last 24 hours I read or heard broadcast repeatedly that 12 people were unaccounted for. Today they found 2 bodies, and the media makes it sounds as if this mission is over. Did I miss something? Aren't there still 10 peole missing and presumed inside? The reporting seems to be as poor as the response has been.
 
You should also read the Globe page 8 and 9 - they clearly state that the emergency chain of command is for the province under Emergency Management Ontario to call the shots.

Well if that's the case, then there really is NO excuse for the fucked up way this was handled.

#1 - Technical fuckup, they should have had the heavy equipment inbound even if they weren't sure they were going to need it, in a situation like this, you advance plan B even while you are still working on plan A, because you just don't have time if plan A doesn't work.

#2 - Political fuckup, telling people who are agonizing over the fate of their loved ones that the search is "called off"

Even if you are going to slow activities while you wait for equipment, you do not "call off" the search. You continue to do whatever you safely can, looking for signs of life, whatever can be done safely. They fucked up the communications horrendously, and unless there's some really big piece of information we don't have--they fucked up the rescue in a technical sense as well. Badly.
 
Here is the proof. Once they started using the heavy machinery, they recovered 2 bodies in less than 1 day. However, it took 4 fucking days before they brought in the heavy machinery. WHY THE DELAY?

There's no excuse. It's possible that we would have survivors had they called it in on day 1. Maybe not--maybe they died instantly, but that is not something anyone would have known on day 1 when they should have been calling that equipment in.