Elliot Lake mall collapse

Why didn't the military respond sooner?
Aren't they trained to go into 'dangerous' situations?
How would you feel if your mom, sister or son was one of the trapped?

Largely because the military responds to domestic emergencies only when they are asked to by a provincial government. Also because when it comes to first response, the civilian agencies are better at it than the military, because its the job of civilian agencies to be better at it than anyone.

And, if you are insinuating that the civilian responders aren't brave enough to go into the rubble, you are waaaayyyy off base.
 
Why didn't the military respond sooner?
Aren't they trained to go into 'dangerous' situations?
How would you feel if your mom, sister or son was one of the trapped?

Good questions. The disaster happened on a weekend so weekend staff were involved in assessing the situation.

spell it out!
m i c k e y¸
m o u s e
 
Why didn't the military respond sooner?

Because the crisis was originally managed by local authorities, who struggle managing the pothole detail. They've never dealt with anything like this before and they had no idea what to do, so they did not ask the right people for help.
 
Because the crisis was originally managed by local authorities, who struggle managing the pothole detail. They've never dealt with anything like this before and they had no idea what to do, so they did not ask the right people for help.

outsorce.
 
Unacceptable that in this country,it should take 4 days to get proper heavy equipment in with trained personal for the rescue.
Pathetic and heads should roll. Hope they actually find people alive.
 
Unacceptable that in this country,it should take 4 days to get proper heavy equipment in with trained personal for the rescue.
Not sure if politics play a role (Rock, politics plays a role in everything in our lives) but I think the MP for Elliot Lake is NDP.
 
just another example of useless govt bureaucrats except this time its wasting lives as well as tax dollars. can;t believe these useless OPP officers sitting on their asses doing nothing as well as govt bureaucrats are turning away qualified professionals from the private sector who want to help
 
if I were mcguinty id get in a chopper and fly my ass over there just like bush in the days after 9/11. id join in the rescue efforts after all I get paid to do fuck all. instead mcguinty is doing nothing cause he has no balls or morals
 
if I were mcguinty id get in a chopper and fly my ass over there just like bush in the days after 9/11. id join in the rescue efforts after all I get paid to do fuck all. instead mcguinty is doing nothing cause he has no balls or morals

In this case I agree with you. The Province should have been all over this from the moment it happened. It's obvious that small towns don't have the capacity to deal with disasters like this, they needed outside help, and the Ontario Government should not have waited to be asked. They should have been in there on day one, with a big list of all the help they could provide, #1 on the list being management teams to help with co-ordinating the rescue.

While the Ontario government is more directly relevant, due to its role in supervising municipalities, the Federal government also was quite tardy in stepping up to the plate.

The small town can be forgiven for inexperience, the other two levels of government have no such excuse. They should have been on the ball, they weren't, and now perhaps a dozen or more people have died who might have been savable.
 
Where is Carol Huges, NDP MP for Elliot Lake?

This isn't a legislative issue. It's an executive issue. It's the Government of Ontario, and the Federal Government, through their Ministries, that should have responded. The legislative role here is after-the-fact review, and what MPP's and MP's should and I assume will do next is ask some hard questions as to why the government wasn't better prepared for this.
 
It is disgusting a big country like Canada can't show any urgency during such emergency, especially given the fact that there might have been people still alive and trapped under the rubble. Rather than calling off the search for the night, the rescue operation should've gone on all night.

This is a minor incident compared to major disasters around the world. Can you imagine a disaster to the magnitude of the Japanese tsunami occuring here? You can be certain many lives, that could've otherwise been saved, will be lost.

Politicians and authorities are good for nothing but making pure wind sound credible.

Can you imagine being one of the unlucky ones stuck underneath the rubble? Every minute feels like an eternity... and these fucking good-for-nothings want to go home for the night and spend all day coming up with a rescue plan ><
 
Elliot Lake is an old mining town (uranium, I think) so they do have a history of digging stuff and people out of the ground.

The dynamic of a collapsed mine and a collapsed building are very different. I'll let the engineer on TERB give you the more in-depth reasons. The SAR rescue teams do not take those decision at all easily. The order to go back was purely political form Toronto and not much more. I hate to say it, but hey are doing what they are now to satiate the locals hearts and minds. The response was slow but that's because the response is multi leveled and decentralized. Even at the federal level, which Harper is trying to claim doesn't exist, justifying future cuts, there being 5 Heavy Urban Rescue Teams across Canada, That's not a provincial program. The one in EL is from Calgary. as joint project of City of Calgary under the banner of Emergency Management ,Government of Canada under the division of Public Safety Canada, Province of Alberta with Alberta Emergency Management as the leader, Calgary Fire Department and Alberta Health Services. Harper want to cut the Federal suport and put it on the shoulders of the other governments.
 
also, rescuers are supposed to take risks, you have to be brave. how many rescuers died on 9/11?, liquidators in chernobyl? in every disaster rescuers have to take risks its a dangerous profession. if you are a pussy or want to avoid dangerous work get a different profession
 
Can you imagine if a food court in downtown Toronto collapsed and a dozen people were trapped inside?

We called the army in over a snow storm, it would be treated as a national emergency.

Not only would the premier personally tour the site on the first day, with media in tow, he would have a federal minister with him, and they would pull out all the stops to get people out.
 
also, rescuers are supposed to take risks, you have to be brave. how many rescuers died on 9/11?, liquidators in chernobyl? in every disaster rescuers have to take risks its a dangerous profession. if you are a pussy or want to avoid dangerous work get a different profession!

They are supposed to take 'calculated' risks, a big difference. No one working on that site is a pussy.
 
They are supposed to take 'calculated' risks. No one working on that site is a pussy.

if the backlash wasnt so strong forcing the politicians to act there would be no rescue attempt going on, or it would have started much later than it has costing lives. it would be written off as too dangerous with no hope of finding survivors
 
There is a lot of emotion here..that may be skewing reality.

First off...you are relying on newspaper reports. WRONG.

secondly..none of us is there. Hard to comment from this far away.

And NOOOOOOO.... You do not die trying to save someone else? WRONG WRONG WRONG.

RISK IS ALWAYS CALCULATED.

who are we to say here they are not taking all the risk possible.
 
if the backlash wasnt so strong forcing the politicians to act there would be no rescue attempt going on, or it would have started much later than it has costing lives. it would be written off as too dangerous with no hope of finding survivors

The backlash was strong and very understandable, but based on emotions not experience, training, commonsense, and reality. The team that made the initial decision is one of the worlds best. Don't you even think, from your comfy couch, you can match their analysis.