Pond Death

why is the homeowner so seriously regulated when the city' roads and access to the rivers and lakes is not fenced and never subject to this kind of liability after drownings and accidents? BULLSHIT!

I originally thought charging the home owner was bullshit.

However, It does make some sense that if a home owner is going to dig a pit in his back yard, fill it with water, and line it with a slippery material, that maybe it should be fenced off. Calling it a pond sounds nice, but it could also be called a toddler trap.
 
However, It does make some sense that if a home owner is going to dig a pit in his back yard, fill it with water, and line it with a slippery material, that maybe it should be fenced off.
Yes, we all agree he is guilty of bad fencing. But CRIMINAL NEGLIGENCE CAUSING DEATH is a bit over the top. Based on the negligence charge, one would have thought the homeowner was baby sitting the 2 year old and through gross neglect allowed the 2 year old to drown because he was too busy watching a porno movie.
 
"But to repeat known and easily measured facts: As far as ponds and water features go, if it's more than 600mm, it needs a fence. Which is why the pond's owner was charged."

Right... to repeat some not so common sense..... IF YOU HAVE A 2 YO KID YOU FUCKING WATCH THEM & however deep the pool or bitey the dog or dense the traffic on the road it won't be a problem.


WATCH YOUR OWN FUCKING KIDS OR DON'T HAVE THEM.
 
You really think this?

Yes. ANY non moron with a sense of people being held accountable for their OWN ACTIONS would...


After a toddler dies when a fence WOULD have protected him from the hazard the law was enacted to protect children from?

Maybe, maybe not... But Non fuckwith parents who WATCH THEIR FUCKING KIDS would be the best protection.


So the two year old should pay with his life because of the neglect of the neighbour?


The kid paid for his life because the parents didn't WATCH THEIR FUCKING KID.


YES, I agree that the parent/grandparent/responsible person also neglected the care of the child. Often the police do not charge the parents in these cases because they feel they have "already paid" a big price etc. I don't agree with that either.

Ok, so the parents have paid enough. They're the only ones who SHOULD pay because it's THEIR JOB TO WATCH THEIR FUCKING KID


But, if you have a pool or pond etc on YOUR property, it is smart and the law to protect others from it.

That's a good point you made, it's YOUR property. NOT your kid. If a kid wanders off their property, whatever happens to them is the PARENTS FULT BC THEY DIDNT WATCH THEIR FUCKING KID.

Parroting on & on & on & ON about "it's the Law" means NOTHING. There are shittons of stupid fucking laws out there that have NO basis in reality, or common sense.

The Law of NATURE says the world is dangerous & if you care not to see your kid get itself killed guess what?? WATCH YOUR FUCKING KID


Just like these gun people always harp on about safe storage. If you have a gun, it is YOUR duty to protect ME from someone ELSE stealing it to shoot me!

NO! It's the person SHOOTING you who has a duty not to shoot you. MY duty is to protect MY property.

If you have a car, it is YOUR responsibility to lock it, take the keys and NOT leave it running outside the 7-11 so some thief doesn't steal it and run over a cop.

NO! It is the theif's duty NOT TO RUN OVER COPS!!!

Are you RETARDED?????


If you have a pool or pond it is YOUR responsibility to society and children to take reasonable steps to protect them from YOUR hazard. Fixing a gate is hardly an onerous task, nor expensive. And if there was a gate here, would you not agree that the kid would not have drowned there? (Spare the blame of the parents for purposes of THIS point)

NO. It would not ba a hazard if PARENTS WATCHED THEIR FUCKING KIDS.

& NO I do NOT agree that if there was a gate here the kid would not have drowned there because it should have been made an irrelevant issue by the PARENTS WATCHING THEIR FUCKING KIDS.

(Spare the blame of the parents for purposes of THIS point)

Absolutely NOT. NONE of your points would even be a factor if people were responsible for their OWN actions.... like FAILING TO WQATCH THEIR FUCKING KIDS

Your bias is so thick it is impossible to break through it.

& yours ISN'T?????? Jesus fuck dude your entire point would be rendered moot if only you had the common sens to see that the INSTIGATING & ultimately CAUSAL factor of this mess was the parents NOT WATCHING THEIR FUCKING KID! If they had done their job NONE of this would be a problem. NONE OF IT.


If you think that the laws regarding fencing pools, railing heights and leaving open pits where people can fill in them were created solely to blame people, then there is no sense in talking. You should run for office and see if you can get elected to repeal such laws

Right like anyones going to be elected on a platform of self responsibility & common sense in a land populated by fuckwits like you who can't even grasp that nannying & policing the whole wide world is in ANY way a better solution to WATHING YOUR FUCKING KID..

You find a kid dead in your pool it may be safer to protect yourself from unjust retarded laws made by the likes of ^this jerkoff & turn it into a missing persons case.
 
I think the charge is absurd really. It shows what a fucked up stupid legal system we have. This case will cost the guy probably a minimum 100-120K to defend. he will be acquitted because it is a BS charge. But he will be fucked out of 120K by the legal system and parasitic lawyers that exist though it. The tax payers will be fucked out of another 150-200K...and at the end of the day the child will still be 100% dead.
 
Lots of tragic things can happen to an unsupervised 2 year old. He could just as easily climb up a few stairs on his neighbour's house and then fallen off the porch and break his neck. Should we also put a gate in front of our front stairs?

They sell quite well to new parents. And the law already requires the stairs have railings adequate to prevent a toddler from falling.

Now you know. Both are reasonable precautions, as is obeying the law. As is fencing any body of water deep enough to drown someone. But only a fool argues that means fencing your soupbowl.

So, there is no bylaw fence requirement for ponds of less than 23 inches?
Oh Rocky! 23.6220472 inches to be precise, although the unit 'inches' is archaic and not legally acceptable. You cannot really be that foolish.

Don't go there.

The owner had a clear legal obligation to have a fence that would prevent an infant from getting to his pond. A person died who wouldn't have, had he not neglected that obligation. That's clearly negligence resulting in a death. Death is serious, so in law we call it 'criminal negligence causing death' and leave it to the calmness of a courtroom and the dispassionate consideration of real evidence before we determine guilt and assign penalty. In some imaginable instance the negligence might be as heinous as an outright murder, so the maximum penalty of life imprisonment is available. Fortunately Our Harper Government's push for mandatory minimum sentences hasn't affected this charge—I'm trusting TERB lawyers will correct me—so the judge can vary the sentence appropriately to the circumstances.

Just what part of all that is the problem? You don't really want a charge like, 'minor carelessness with unpredictably deadly consequences' do you? The Councillors who debated and passed that law (and there are lots of laws like it in lots of places) would take exception to the word 'unpredictably'.

Too bad neither the parents nor the pond-owner were as thoughtful as the lawmakers, but that's why we have laws.
 
Last edited:
"But to repeat known and easily measured facts: As far as ponds and water features go, if it's more than 600mm, it needs a fence. Which is why the pond's owner was charged."

Right... to repeat some not so common sense..... IF YOU HAVE A 2 YO KID YOU FUCKING WATCH THEM & however deep the pool or bitey the dog or dense the traffic on the road it won't be a problem.


WATCH YOUR OWN FUCKING KIDS OR DON'T HAVE THEM.
Like that saves a single unwatched kid from anything. Brilliant thinking.

Do we shoot the kids that shouldn't have been born, or their parents after the kid drowns?
…Right like anyones going to be elected on a platform of self responsibility & common sense
Certainly the sort of shouter who starts interminable, repetitive posts with "you moron" and finishes with "fuckwits like you" wouldn't appreciate a platform of responsibility and common sense.
 
wigglee said:
…edit…The bluffs kills adults and children every year and I don't see the city preventing access or being sued for it. The lowly homeowner gets the shaft every time.
The obvious solution to your issue is for you to follow the news more carefully. Going out to the Bluffs and looking at the fences (new and repaired sections every year) would also help.
 
Like that saves a single unwatched kid from anything. Brilliant thinking.

NO. It takes no "Brilliant thinking" to recognize that UNWATCHED KIDS should be saved by parents....oh I don't know WATCHING THEIR OWN FUCKING KIDS!
I know it may seem a bit complicated for you because the very fact that you can't grasp this Simple Point means you're too used to be sheltered & spoonfed....but the ENTIRE ISSUE here is "UNWATCHED KID" You even said the words...^right there^ & still this simple concept eludes you.

Watch
YOUR
FUCKING
KIDS

& they won't need saving.

Do we shoot the kids that shouldn't have been born, or their parents after the kid drowns?

Where does this ^ BS even come from? Sorry, using an absurd extreme in arguments doesn't illustrate your point....it just points out that you don't have a valid one.

Certainly the sort of shouter who starts interminable, repetitive posts with "you moron" and finishes with "fuckwits like you" wouldn't appreciate a platform of responsibility and common sense.

Calling a fuckwit out for being a fuckwit IS challenging their common sense (or lack thereof) & holding them accountable for their fucktardery... There is Nothing inconsistent here. You're issue seems to be the language used. Go fuck yourself.
 
themexi said:
NO. It takes no "Brilliant thinking" to recognize that UNWATCHED KIDS should be saved by parents
But it does take brilliant thinking to figure that nonsense statement out. Save them with their eyes shut?
themexi said:
Where does this ^ BS even come from?.
Answer:
oldjones said:
themexi said:
WATCH YOUR OWN FUCKING KIDS OR DON'T HAVE THEM
Do we shoot the kids that shouldn't have been born, or their parents after the kid drowns?
Back to you:
themexi said:
Sorry, using an absurd extreme in arguments doesn't illustrate your point....it just points out that you don't have a valid one.
Couldn't have said it better myself. But I guess I failed to get across the absurdity of your instruction to parents who don't watch their kids. Retroactive birth control? Brilliantly practical!

If you calmed down and shouted less, you might clearly state a thoughtful point. As for, PARENTS SHOULD WATCH THEIR KIDS, we all get that. First alluded to in Posts 2 and 3.

But it didn't save this kid, and it won't save the next. How would you do that?
 
I don't have an answer about how to save the next kid & I don't have to. Not my kid, not my problem. It was their kid. the kid's death is their failure. The responsibility for that kid starts & ends with them.

Their kid, their problem. Not Mine... not anyone else's.

Unless someone actively attacks their kid or trespasses on their property & does something to make it dangerous.... No One else should be blamed but those who took on the responsibility of having that kid by bringing it into existence.

When I said don't have kids if you won't/can't watch them I meant it as said. Not kill unwanted kids. It seems that if one doesn't care enough about their kids to watch them then the whole having a kid thing sorts itself out anyway & the only person to blame is the negligent parents.

There is NO getting around the fact that it really shouldnt' matter what is outside their property so long as they watch their kids. Therefore anything that happens to the kid if the parent fails to do their job is their fault.
 
I don't have an answer about how to save the next kid & I don't have to.…edit…
If you don't, I can't see why you bother posting on this topic. In fact, over and over you said you did have the answer and it was the obvious: WATCH YOUR KIDS. This event—and there's one like it every year that makes the news in TO—proves that's a bad answer answer for keeping kids safe. No one's arguing that helpful tip to parents, but everyone has to deal with what happens when they don't pay attention. And every parent, even the best, loses track now and then.

It's not practical to make the world perfectly safe, for every idiot and no one tries. But neither is it practical to leave everyone—infant or adult—to fend for themselves facing dangers known or unknown. We strike a balance as best we can. So we require that electrical wires be insulated, and hydro tower ladders not come to the ground, and cars be driven according to rules, and guns not be shot off in the city, and houses have smoke detectors, dangerous dogs be leashed and muzzled, cars not be left running in the street, manholes be covered, excavations be promptly backfilled and ponds be surrounded by fences.

The basic principle is: What would a reasonable person do? The answer is: She'd say, "A kid could drown in this, they wouldn't be able to stand up. Good thing I have no kids, and I can manage the ones I invite. Wait! What stops a kid from chasing his ball into the yard? Or my daughter's kid with the ADD from running to Gran when I'm in the house, and his Mom's getting the things outta the car. Or the little kid next door whose idiot parents can't keep track of him". Reasonable people don't ignore danger, trusting that some other person—like a bad parent, unreasonable by definition—will look out for it.

It's why they invented fences in the first place, to keep unwanted intruders out. It's why the advice on all the pond websites and brochures, written by reasonable people for reasonable people is: Have a fence. It's why the law says: Have a fence.

If "Parents watch your kids" worked, we wouldn't need fences at all. In fact you wouldn't have needed to do all that typing, and we'd all have halos. But some parents are unreasonable, just like some pond owners. And for both, we have laws.

PS:
themexi said:
When I said don't have kids if you won't/can't watch them I meant it as said
fair enough, but that is not what you said, even if it is what you meant. I quoted what you shouted all in caps more than once. It is unreasonable to imagine that others will magically figure out what you really meant, if you can't put it into words yourself. Thanks for doing so, but that still leaves the issue of the innocent kids of bad parents. And the momentary lapses of good ones and …. And the stupid negligence of the guy next door with bad parents of a two year old next door leaving his unattended pond already fenced, but with a busted gate.
 
Last edited:
If you don't, I can't see why you bother posting on this topic. In fact, over and over you said you did have the answer and it was the obvious: WATCH YOUR KIDS. This event—and there's one like it every year that makes the news in TO—proves that's a bad answer answer for keeping kids safe. No one's arguing that helpful tip to parents, but everyone has to deal with what happens when they don't pay attention. And every parent, even the best, loses track now and then.

Respectfully I disagree. It's Not a bad answer for keeping kids safe... it's simply not perfect. Nothing is perfect. That's just life, & in the case of a Very few unlucky kids, death.

It's insane to give up on reinforcing the best though imperfect solution to the problem holding parents responsible for watching their kids. It is downright stupid to compound the abandonment of that solution by offering the even less fair & feasible solution of the whole world watching out for every possible hazard to be encountered by negligent parents stray kids.


It's not practical to make the world perfectly safe, for every idiot and no one tries. But neither is it practical to leave everyone—infant or adult—to fend for themselves facing dangers known or unknown.

If parents watched their kids they wouldn't be facing such dangers alone. The fact that a many parents fail & a tiny subset of kids die as a result does not negate the reality that parents who watch their kids have a much lower probability of tragedy happening......& that when it does their failure is solely to blame. Accidents happen. All I suggest is that we confine the blame & consequences to the failed parents. I'm not saying punish them. They've been punished enough. Why punish anyone else then?

We strike a balance as best we can. So we require that electrical wires be insulated, and hydro tower ladders not come to the ground, and cars be driven according to rules, and guns not be shot off in the city, and houses have smoke detectors, dangerous dogs be leashed and muzzled, cars not be left running in the street, manholes be covered, excavations be promptly backfilled and ponds be surrounded by fences.

Again I disagree. There is nothing balanced about the current status quo. If there are to be any punishments meted out by the state then a balanced approach would be to punish the negligent caretakers More severely than the pond guy. We've already established that the parents have suffered enough but really, a kid died in the man's pond.... He has suffered enough too. The government has to either get its pound of flesh from everyone in fair proportions or stay the hell out of it.


The basic principle is: What would a reasonable person do? The answer is: She'd say, "A kid could drown in this, they wouldn't be able to stand up. Good thing I have no kids, and I can manage the ones I invite. Wait! What stops a kid from chasing his ball into the yard? Or my daughter's kid with the ADD from running to Gran when I'm in the house, and his Mom's getting the things outta the car. Or the little kid next door whose idiot parents can't keep track of him". Reasonable people don't ignore danger, trusting that some other person—like a bad parent, unreasonable by definition—will look out for it.

A reasonable person should not have to consider these things as its their property. Also a reasonable parent should watch their kid. So if the parents don't have to live up to the standard, why should anyone else be held to it?

It's why they invented fences in the first place, to keep unwanted intruders out. It's why the advice on all the pond websites and brochures, written by reasonable people for reasonable people is: Have a fence. It's why the law says: Have a fence.

If "Parents watch your kids" worked, we wouldn't need fences at all. In fact you wouldn't have needed to do all that typing, and we'd all have halos. But some parents are unreasonable, just like some pond owners. And for both, we have laws.

"Parents watch your kids" would work better if it were as zealously enforced as the attacks on the intruded upon homeowners are when disaster strikes. The fact is that too many parents have been let into a false sense of security & apathy because such idiotic laws have all but absolved them from responsibility for their kids....& to a huge extent blame & punishment if things go wrong. It's ass backwards.

It's basic logic.
The kid was the parent's responsibility.
The parents failed in their responsibility.
As a direct result of their failure the kid died.
The kid had could have just as easily tripped off the sidewalk & cracked his head... No one would be looking to blame anyone but the parents.
The kid had could have just as easily eaten a stone & choked... No one would be looking to blame anyone but the parents.
No one would be looking to blame anyone but the parents because in those instances there is no convenient way to defer blame. They are forced to face the truth & that truth is that their failure alone was the cause of death. Every other factor is entirely secondary & only considered so that there is someone else to blame.
The pond guy is in fact no more responsible than a curb or a swallowed rock. Because he's a human with assets to sieze, the government is only too happy to use him as a scapegoat & a distraction from the cold hard truth that sometimes shit just happens


PS: fair enough, but that is not what you said, even if it is what you meant. I quoted what you shouted all in caps more than once. It is unreasonable to imagine that others will magically figure out what you really meant, if you can't put it into words yourself. Thanks for doing so, but that still leaves the issue of the innocent kids of bad parents. And the momentary lapses of good ones and …. And the stupid negligence of the guy next door with bad parents of a two year old next door leaving his unattended pond already fenced, but with a busted gate.

Shit happens. Just because a few unattended kids die does not make fucking up everyone else's life with intrusive regulation & draconian punishments right. As we can see no matter what "the Law" says or does some kids are just gonna die. I say err on the side of fairness...put the responsibilities where they belong & leave most people the hell alone.
 
Last edited:
Respectfully I disagree. It's Not a bad answer for keeping kids safe... it's simply not perfect. Nothing is perfect. That's just life, & in the case of a Very few unlucky kids, death.

It's insane to give up on reinforcing the best though imperfect solution to the problem holding parents responsible for watching their kids. It is downright stupid to compound the abandonment of that solution by offering the even less fair & feasible solution of the whole world watching out for every possible hazard to be encountered by negligent parents stray kids.




If parents watched their kids they wouldn't be facing such dangers alone. The fact that a many parents fail & a tiny subset of kids die as a result does not negate the reality that parents who watch their kids have a much lower probability of tragedy happening......& that when it does their failure is solely to blame. Accidents happen. All I suggest is that we confine the blame & consequences to the failed parents. I'm not saying punish them. They've been punished enough. Why punish anyone else then?



Again I disagree. There is nothing balanced about the current status quo. If there are to be any punishments meted out by the state then a balanced approach would be to punish the negligent caretakers More severely than the pond guy. We've already established that the parents have suffered enough but really, a kid died in the man's pond.... He has suffered enough too. The government has to either get its pound of flesh from everyone in fair proportions or stay the hell out of it.




A reasonable person should not have to consider these things as its their property. Also a reasonable parent should watch their kid. So if the parents don't have to live up to the standard, why should anyone else be held to it?



"Parents watch your kids" would work better if it were as zealously enforced as the attacks on the intruded upon homeowners are when disaster strikes. The fact is that too many parents have been let into a false sense of security & apathy because such idiotic laws have all but absolved them from responsibility for their kids....& to a huge extent blame & punishment if things go wrong. It's ass backwards.

It's basic logic.
The kid was the parent's responsibility.
The parents failed in their responsibility.
As a direct result of their failure the kid died.
The kid had could have just as easily tripped off the sidewalk & cracked his head... No one would be looking to blame anyone but the parents.
The kid had could have just as easily eaten a stone & choked... No one would be looking to blame anyone but the parents.
No one would be looking to blame anyone but the parents because in those instances there is no convenient way to defer blame. They are forced to face the truth & that truth is that their failure alone was the cause of death. Every other factor is entirely secondary & only considered so that there is someone else to blame.
The pond guy is in fact no more responsible than a curb or a swallowed rock. Because he's a human with assets to sieze, the government is only too happy to use him as a scapegoat & a distraction from the cold hard truth that sometimes shit just happens




Shit happens. Just because a few unattended kids die does not make fucking up everyone else's life with intrusive regulation & draconian punishments right. As we can see no matter what "the Law" says or does some kids are just gonna die. I say err on the side of fairness...put the responsibilities where they belong & leave most people the hell alone.
Thanks, you clearly put a lot of thought into this. But I must point out that you spent it arguing a view no one has put forward, certainly not me. I haven't read anyone excusing the parents, nor have I encountered anyone stupid enough to imagine making the whole world safe. The only folks even raising such nonsense are those who, like yourself, do so to shoot it down.

But it's naive to imagine that inattentive parents are the only people who could be at fault if a child has an accident. The drunk who drives through the swing set, for example. Attentive or negligent, how could parents be soley responsible for that? You are factually wrong to say so, as you are to suggest that 'the status quo is unbalanced' and you have made an unsupported assertion about punishment outcomes with no facts.

Negligent parents most definitely have liability in law. Although some cops may feel, like you, that their child's death is punishment enough for the parents, there's likely enough police and prosecutors who believe in parental responsibility to ensure a legal follow-up after emotions calm. Completely speculative to say there won't be charges. I must say though, your 'hold them responsible but don't charge them' position is hard to understand.

Does your 'suffered enough' doctrine apply to all crimes? Do we make people prove genuine suffering? Does the law have no power to educate or deter? I think most law and order folks and most bleeding hearts would disagree. That is why we make laws; it does no good to punish people after the damage is done. The point is to avoid the bad act in the first place, be it bad parenting, drunk driving, murder or whatever. So we publish laws and make the stiff penalties known in the fond hope most folks will get it. Those who don't get charged.

You come up with a better way than punitive laws to encourage people to prevent such things and I'll be the first on your bandwagon, But either everyone lives alone and far apart, or we all act like responsible reasonable people and make sure no one dies because we didn't live up to our responsibilities to each other. Sorry, but you don't get to put a trip wire across your walk and a mantrap under the steps just because it's your property. Not even if you post a 'Enter at your own risk' sign.

The myth is that accidents happen, and therefore what happens is an accident. Just as you imagine that attentive parents would have saved the kid, I know a fence built to the prescribed standard would have. I also know that not minding him, and not having the fence means that this child's death was no accident. It was entirely and easily preventable. Those who could have, should have, and did not live up to their responsibility to prevent it must face the consequences.

Nothing more needs to be said.
 
In other news, Chris Brown is suing the club for allowing Drake to enter and allowing Drake to beat him (Chris Brown). If the club had put a fence around Drake, then Drake could not have beaten the crap out of Chris Brown. It is all the clubowner's fault that Chris Brown got beat up.
 
It's unfortunate that a child died. The yard was fenced off, but not the pond. Why was this child allowed to walk into a neighbors yards? The kid was being watched by the grandmother ???

I've see many houses with ponds,the yards are fenced off. Does this bylaw require an additional fence just around the pond ?

Should we put a fence around everything ?? I have a kids playset in my yard, I should fence if off just in case one of the neighorhood kids decided to jump off the highest point and break his neck.

Adults need to be responsible for their offspring !
 
I believe a child can drown in less water than 24'' .
I have been told my whole life a child can drown in a few inches in a bath tub . again a slippery surface .
But I have looked around on the net and can not find if a pond that is less than 24 inches needs a fence .
I am in no way trying to belittle the fact that a parent lost a child .
But my question is ... IF the pond had been a foot deep would he still be liable .
I believe the child would have died if the pond had been shallower
the real question comes to dept in the first place ,,
In the summer the pond may be 24 inches as that is all it is ; but in the spring it may be even deeper because of the winter run off and the pond is actually deeper because of water on the shore.
So does a landowner have to fence a 12 inch pond in the spring because the pond is flooded .
There is a ditch in front of my house that has a couple of feet of water in the spring and nothing come summer .
Should I fence this ditch .
because of all the news I believe stores have sold a lot of fences lately .