Iran Talks fail again

1. it's hearsay, one person's recollections of another person's recollections of a conversation.

2. no direct or public threat against Iraq was made, and in any case we're talking about a threat against Iran aren't we?

3. this supposed point that you're dwelling on has very little to do with this thread.

4. gryf is a total idiot, that argument does not need to be proven again. (Truth is a good defence against libel. Deal with it.)
 
1. it's hearsay, one person's recollections of another person's recollections of a conversation.

2. no direct or public threat against Iraq was made, and in any case we're talking about a threat against Iran aren't we?

3. this supposed point that you're dwelling on has very little to do with this thread.

4. gryf is a total idiot, that argument does not need to be proven again. (Truth is a good defence against libel. Deal with it.)

Somebody gets it.
 
Really? I see Sharon responding in this series of sentences.

"Sharon had said that if Iraq hit Israel, their response would 'escalate' which he took to mean go nuclear. Bush said he said to him 'You will not, you will not do that, it would be crazy.' He said he would keep them under control, adding 'A nuke on Baghdad, that could be pretty tricky.'"

Which matches exactly what I said. I blame the educational system for your ability to follow along.
 
1. it's hearsay, one person's recollections of another person's recollections of a conversation.

2. no direct or public threat against Iraq was made, and in any case we're talking about a threat against Iran aren't we?

3. this supposed point that you're dwelling on has very little to do with this thread.

4. gryf is a total idiot, that argument does not need to be proven again. (Truth is a good defence against libel. Deal with it.)

Israel is the country that stole nuclear knowledge from the US, bombed one of their ships to try to get them into a war, tried to sell the bomb to apartheid South Africa and is now threatening war against Iran. Israel's history of nuclear threats is very much relevant to this thread.
 
Israel is the country that stole nuclear knowledge from the US, bombed one of their ships to try to get them into a war, tried to sell the bomb to apartheid South Africa and is now threatening war against Iran. Israel's history of nuclear threats is very much relevant to this thread.

Wow! did anyone else just experience whiplash?
 
Israel is the country that stole nuclear knowledge from the US, bombed one of their ships to try to get them into a war, tried to sell the bomb to apartheid South Africa and is now threatening war against Iran. Israel's history of nuclear threats is very much relevant to this thread.

If Iran had said something like "If Israel disarms we will destroy our nuclear program and never start it again, and agree to legit inspections" than it might be.

Your logic is no more than "because some guy in Saudi beats his wife and we can't prosecute him we shouldn't prosecute Canadian wife beaters."

Your usual poor performance.
 
I'm glad that the usual clowns have used a thread about Iran still refusing the international expectations on the nuclear program has become just another chance for their moronic and nonsensical attacks on Israel.


And just for fun, Iran's take on things.

http://www.tehrantimes.com/politics...al-understanding-with-six-powers-ahmadinejad-
Commenting on the latest round of talks between Iran and the major powers, the president said that Iran’s nuclear activities have been within the framework of international regulations and under the supervision of the International Atomic Energy Agency, adding that the Islamic Republic has always adhered to its international commitments.

He also said that Iran has never been in pursuit of nuclear weapons and has always been seeking to promote friendship between the nations and governments.

“Arrogant and hegemonistic (powers) should stop showing hostility toward the Iranian nation and other justice-seeking and freedom-seeking nations because given the current situation in the world, cooperation between nations is much better that creating hostility and division,” he said.

In addition, he said that negotiations with Iran will be a suitable opportunity for the West to “return to the framework of law.”

The UN chief also said that Iran has always been an influential country in the region and played key roles on the world stage.
 
If Iran had said something like "If Israel disarms we will destroy our nuclear program and never start it again, and agree to legit inspections" than it might be.

Iran keeps saying it will end 20% enrichment if sanctions are toned down, and will allow more inspections with the end of sanctions as well.
They don't have a nuclear weapons program to destroy, it was stopped in 2003.
They have also shown support for a nuclear free middle east, which is more then Israel has ever said.
 
Which matches exactly what I said. I blame the educational system for your ability to follow along.

I guess I've got to connect the dots for you. You said:

In fact, Sharon did not even use the term nuke etc in the conversation.

The article you are referencing says:

"Sharon had said that if Iraq hit Israel, their response would 'escalate' which he took to mean go nuclear. Bush said he said to him 'You will not, you will not do that, it would be crazy.' He said he would keep them under control, adding 'A nuke on Baghdad, that could be pretty tricky.'"

See? That wasn't hard, was it?
 
Iran keeps saying it will end 20% enrichment if sanctions are toned down, and will allow more inspections with the end of sanctions as well.
They don't have a nuclear weapons program to destroy, it was stopped in 2003.
They have also shown support for a nuclear free middle east, which is more then Israel has ever said.

Their public statements are meaningless. They have not reached a deal, and have for years breached an agreement they signed, almost immediately after they signed it.

And when you combine that with their calls for genocide...they are working their way into a conflict that they cannot win. Most unwise.
 
I guess I've got to connect the dots for you. You said:



The article you are referencing says:

"Sharon had said that if Iraq hit Israel, their response would 'escalate' which he took to mean go nuclear. Bush said he said to him 'You will not, you will not do that, it would be crazy.' He said he would keep them under control, adding 'A nuke on Baghdad, that could be pretty tricky.'"

See? That wasn't hard, was it?

Is English your first language? The article is clear that Bush thought he used the word "nuke." And in your specific quote Bush used the word "nuke", not Sharon.

Learn to read my tyranny supporting friend.
 
Their public statements are meaningless. They have not reached a deal, and have for years breached an agreement they signed, almost immediately after they signed it.

And when you combine that with their calls for genocide...they are working their way into a conflict that they cannot win. Most unwise.

Calls for genocide?
You, sir, are off your rocker.

Please supply evidence or retract this ridiculous statement.


(oh, and just to save time, try to find some evidence other then the one mistranslated quote of 'wipe Israel off the map', that 6 year old quote has been debunked and the man who said it is no longer holding power)
 
Calls for genocide?
You, sir, are off your rocker.

Please supply evidence or retract this ridiculous statement.


(oh, and just to save time, try to find some evidence other then the one mistranslated quote of 'wipe Israel off the map', that 6 year old quote has been debunked and the man who said it is no longer holding power)

Your faux outrage is just childish. And the claim of mistranslation also a cop out.

But let's stay modern and up to date shall we:

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...ays-legal-religious-justification-attack.html

And this does not even cover Khomeni' saying Israel is a cancer that must be cut out, confirming he will support any nation that confronts Israel, and admitting he has supported groups fighting Israel in the past.

Keep embracing your foolish fanaticism. It makes you look silly. Yup, calls for genocide.
 
Is English your first language? The article is clear that Bush thought he used the word "nuke." And in your specific quote Bush used the word "nuke", not Sharon.

Learn to read my tyranny supporting friend.

The sentence construction does not support that. If he did, then whose "nukes" is Bush saying he can control?
 
Your faux outrage is just childish. And the claim of mistranslation also a cop out.

But let's stay modern and up to date shall we:

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...ays-legal-religious-justification-attack.html



And this does not even cover Khomeni' saying Israel is a cancer that must be cut out, confirming he will support any nation that confronts Israel, and admitting he has supported groups fighting Israel in the past.

Keep embracing your foolish fanaticism. It makes you look silly. Yup, calls for genocide.

You are relying on an article from WND.com? You are joking, right? This is the same outfit that's been leading the Obama citizenship canard and published articles deploring America's depravity as being responsible for 9/11.

Now, relying upon WMD.com looks very, very silly. Amateurish.

Learn about sources. When you have, come back.
 
Your faux outrage is just childish. And the claim of mistranslation also a cop out.

But let's stay modern and up to date shall we:

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...ays-legal-religious-justification-attack.html

And this does not even cover Khomeni' saying Israel is a cancer that must be cut out, confirming he will support any nation that confronts Israel, and admitting he has supported groups fighting Israel in the past.

Keep embracing your foolish fanaticism. It makes you look silly. Yup, calls for genocide.

Got any reputable sources, or have you been reading the dailies in the grocery store lineup again?

You said 'calls'.
Lets see some, plural, and from credible sources.
Or you could retract the statement......
 
Maybe grog should read fars or irna. Lots of great examples from the official Iranian mouthpieces.
 
Got any reputable sources, or have you been reading the dailies in the grocery store lineup again?

You said 'calls'.
Lets see some, plural, and from credible sources.
Or you could retract the statement......

Oh look, the children who argue Hitler is a symbol of peace and that we can trust Iran talk about the quality of sources.

Are you saying those statements were not made?

But if you want another how about:


“The Zionist regime is a true cancer tumor on this region that should be cut off,” the supreme leader said. “And it definitely will be cut off.”

http://www.washingtonpost.com/world...ed-satellite/2012/02/03/gIQARNuDmQ_story.html

The two of you have reached the point of delusional in missing the positions Iran have taken against Israel and the Jewish people.

But I guess the whole west has been fooled and only the two of you have figured it out.

Retract...sure thing Sherlock.