Pond Death

Ok, ok, I called my local contractor. We are going to turn my house into a fortress. Nobody gets in or gets out without 16,000 alarm going off. Too bad there is a city bylaw that says fences can't be more than 8 feet high. That means Fuji can still stand on his soapbox and watch my wife sunbathe nude in our backyard.
 
Too bad there is a city bylaw that says fences can't be more than 8 feet high. That means Fuji can still stand on his soapbox and watch my wife sunbathe nude in our backyard.

Agree with you that bylaw should permit taller than 8 feet fences. And
you don't need to stand on a soapbox to look over your neighbor's fence.

 
not really, it depends on when they asked and what other matters were being attended to..
Nevermind, you are probably talking about the context of this story
Needless to say if the tenants reported the problem the day before that is one thing. However, if they reported it a month ago, and then again ten days ago and the Landlord did nothing. . . .
 
Rubmeister is pretty much correct about the law. Within reason, people have a legal responsibility to guard against potential hazards in specific ways. Some of these hazards are set out in statutes or regulations (like fencing around decorarive ponds) and some are found in case law. Some are not set out anywhere at all and are determined after the fact by lawyers and judges. You can be found to have negligently created a situation that led to someone's death or injury and be criminally and civilly responsible as a result, even if no existing law prohibited whatever it was you did.

Incidentally, if you did not create the hazard, you are not required to save someone from dying as a result. As far as I recall, there are no good samaritan laws in Ontario. So long as you are not the homeowner, or were otherwise legally responsible for the lack of fencing or for lack of supervision (of the child), you could watch the child drown while sipping a vodka tonic without criminal liability.
 
As far as I recall, there are no good samaritan laws in Ontario. So long as you are not the homeowner, or were otherwise legaly responsible for the lack of fencing or for lack of supervision (of the child), you could watch the child drown while sipping a vodka tonic without criminal liability.
Few Good Samaritan laws involve a duty to rescue (although some jurisdictions do have the same) most rather insulate the rescuer from liablity if they make a good faith effort to rescue (however, you still can't start and then say Hell my feet are getting wet I'm going to get an Ice Cream).
 
(however, you still can't start and then say Hell my feet are getting wet I'm going to get an Ice Cream).

So the take away lesson here is if you see someone drowning walk away. Better than risking having second thoughts and getting analed in court.
 
So the take away lesson here is if you see someone drowning walk away. Better than risking having second thoughts and getting analed in court.

Yep.

You could also try to rescue someone, fail, and then get charged and/or sued with the allegation that your efforts actually caused the other person to drown. (See what happens when a doctor tries and fails to save someone who collapses on the street in front of them).

Most people who rescue strangers simply don't know the law.
 
So the take away lesson here is if you see someone drowning walk away. Better than risking having second thoughts and getting analed in court.
No that is not the lesson at all! You merely have to make a good faith effort.

For instance you can't start CPR and then quit after 30 seconds because you decide that an ice cream would taste great. But if you start CPR and after 15 minutes are exhausted and the ambulance still hasn't turned up - that is a different matter.

Or shout don't worry I'll go in after the child - when you don't know how to swim and due to that a trainer from the Saint John Ambulance just went around the corner because they believed you.
 
Yep.

You could also try to rescue someone, fail, and then get charged and/or sued with the allegation that your efforts actually caused the other person to drown. (See what happens when a doctor tries and fails to save someone who collapses on the street in front of them).

Most people who rescue strangers simply don't know the law.
I don't know what the heck type of Good Samaritan Law you have heard about, but that just plain flat out isn't true in any jurisdiction of which I am aware!

Now it is true that you have to perform to your knowledge level, so a quack physician is going to be judged by the competence of a normal physician not some truck driver who knows absolutely nothing about breach births.
 
I don't know what the heck type of Good Samaritan Law you have heard about, but that just plain flat out isn't true in any jurisdiction of which I am aware!

from Ontario's Good Samaritan Act, 2001, section 2:
Protection from liability 2. (1) Despite the rules of common law, a person described in subsection (2) who voluntarily and without reasonable expectation of compensation or reward provides the services described in that subsection is not liable for damages that result from the person's negligence in acting or failing to act while providing the services, unless it is established that the damages were caused by the gross negligence of the person. 2001, c. 2, s. 2 (1).[28]

Other provinces have different laws of course , and Quebec you can get in trouble for not helping someone.
 
Yep.

You could also try to rescue someone, fail, and then get charged and/or sued with the allegation that your efforts actually caused the other person to drown. (See what happens when a doctor tries and fails to save someone who collapses on the street in front of them).

Most people who rescue strangers simply don't know the law.

How many cases are there where resucers involved in a rescue are charged criminally?

How many cases are there where rescuers are sued civilly?
 
You have a point, spineless Canadians like nanny laws. Railings are fine but put a cooler next to balcony rail and ..woops.. its so much easier to win the darwin award. The underlying point Rub, is human stupidity, carelessness, and neglect is what kills people. No amount of petty laws will protect humans from their own stupidity.

Actually you are just simply wrong.

Certain laws have produced measurable reductions in injuries and deaths. No law will eliminate injuries and deaths, but some sure have reduced them.

Take seat belts for example.
 
With backyard pools, if a kid falls in, he is not coming out, he is dead. These ponds could be the same with the plastic liners covered in slime. If a kid steps on the liner, he falls and slides down into the pond, and is not coming out. These ponds could be death traps for children that get too close.

If a home owner dug a pit and put spikes at the bottom, then covered the pit over and put some shiny stuff in the middle of the cover that would attract toddlers, we would not be questioning as much the home owners responsibility to fence the area.

Like the swimming pool or bear trap, if you build something that is a death trap, you better fence it off.
 
Other provinces have different laws of course , and Quebec you can get in trouble for not helping someone.
Due to Quebec's Civil Law background (although the trouble is civil [different use of civil] not criminal).

Of course I haven't mentioned any of the exceptions such as spouses have a duty to rescue each other, parents have a duty to rescue their children.
 
And fences around ponds have reduced what? Want a fence around your bathtub too? Its a pond - sometimes.

Here's a slight adjustment to your thinking and a very key distinction: The overwhelming majority of people wear a seatbelt because it protects THEM, not because it protects others. The overwhelming majority of people put a fence around their pool because it protects THEM and their kids, not because it protects others. The people that are generally unaware, and non thinking are also not aware of these well intentioned, but moronic "laws".

Anyway, as shown above, safety is a matter of awareness and choice. A law is not going to protect you, and neither is the threat or actuality of a jail term or fine to someone else.

Carelessness aka negligence and mistakes are simply that.

So laws that have been successful in preventing injuries and deaths are "moronic". What an odd worldview.

Perhaps according to you we should have no laws or regulations at all.

And if the problem is that people are not aware of the laws in question, the solution is to make people aware, as opposed to not passing them in the first place.
 
Yes, many of these laws are enacted not to protect, but as hindsight to an problem that has occured, and to provid a blame pathway.…edit…You have a point, spineless Canadians like nanny laws. Railings are fine but put a cooler next to balcony rail and ..woops.. its so much easier to win the darwin award. The underlying point Rub, is human stupidity, carelessness, and neglect is what kills people. No amount of petty laws will protect humans from their own stupidity.
You left murder out of your list of what kills. If laws are as ineffective as you say let's never again hear about their deterrent effect after a killing OK? As you say, laws can't fix stupid any more than they can fix evil, but let's hope most people are both good and ignorant rather than evil and stupid. The existence of the law gives all sorts of folks the opportunity to educate those good folks. Like your realestate agent, the building inspector, your contractor, the guy who wrote the brochure taped to the plastic pond…. Even your slacker tenant in the basement. Sometimes that education can be painful, like when your kid dies, or you realize the death you did nothing to prevent will cost you more than sorrow. The major point of punitive laws is not to apply that pain, but to encourage people to avoid it by obeying the law. The deterrent effect, which we now hope has resulted in numerous fence purchases.

An sidelight on the 'criminal negligence causing death' charge in today's Star regarding the Christmas Eve scaffolding collapse that killed four workers. There, as in this story legal responsibility is foggy, and shared. But the goal is clear: To see that people do not die through neglect of obvious safety measures like fences, or lifelines. At the basis of the legal definition of 'negligence' is the concept that no reasonable person would ignore this danger, and that's who we want to fix. Reasonable people who are merely ignorant

If laws don't do the trick, what else have we got? Or do we just let those easily preventable deaths just happen?
NorthPole said:
The overwhelming majority of people put a fence around their pool because it protects THEM and their kids, not because it protects others.
Couldn't let that line from another post pass. Unless you meant "…it protects THEM" from the penalty for not having a fence, you have it backwards. The commonest argument most folks offer for not fencing ponds and pools is THEY and their kids don't need a fence, and they're inside it anyway. The whole point of the fence law is to protect others by keeping them out; not to prevent grown adults who could easily climb it, but infants and animals when you're not there to shoo them away. It would take more than any law imaginable to protect an owner from drowning in his own pool.
 
Lots of tragic things can happen to an unsupervised 2 year old. He could just as easily climb up a few stairs on his neighbour's house and then fallen off the porch and break his neck. Should we also put a gate in front of our front stairs?
 
With backyard pools, if a kid falls in, he is not coming out, he is dead. These ponds could be the same with the plastic liners covered in slime. If a kid steps on the liner, he falls and slides down into the pond, and is not coming out. These ponds could be death traps for children that get too close.

If a home owner dug a pit and put spikes at the bottom, then covered the pit over and put some shiny stuff in the middle of the cover that would attract toddlers, we would not be questioning as much the home owners responsibility to fence the area.

Like the swimming pool or bear trap, if you build something that is a death trap, you better fence it off.

why is the homeowner so seriously regulated when the city' roads and access to the rivers and lakes is not fenced and never subject to this kind of liability after drownings and accidents? BULLSHIT!

The bluffs kills adults and children every year and I don't see the city preventing access or being sued for it. The lowly homeowner gets the shaft every time.
 
why is the homeowner so seriously regulated when the city' roads and access to the rivers and lakes is not fenced and never subject to this kind of liability after drownings and accidents? BULLSHIT!

The bluffs kills adults and children every year and I don't see the city preventing access or being sued for it. The lowly homeowner gets the shaft every time.

Do you have a clue how many times a year the City of Toronto gets sued for negligence under the Occupiers Liability Act?
 
Lots of tragic things can happen to an unsupervised 2 year old. He could just as easily climb up a few stairs on his neighbour's house and then fallen off the porch and break his neck. Should we also put a gate in front of our front stairs?

How many drownings do children suffer compared to broken necks from short falls?

And their actually are building code guidelines for stairs, railing etc, so they are indeed regulated.