Pond Death

Without having access to nearly enough facts to come to useful conclusions, I can say I was surprised by both the speed and severity of the charge.

Having said that LE does have a tendency to overcharge because it is way easier to plead down than to amend up.
 
the clue is "rented". If you have ever been a small landlord, you'll know that renters destroy houses. How many times has your backyard gate "broken"? Ever? most home-owners would ask how it could even break. but renters do stuff. sorry the landlord has to take the fall. he should have filled in that pond tho. he made a mistake. a tragic one.
 
I don't know the entire details, but I'm assuming that the kid decided to sneak into the neighbours backyard without permission. Sorry the kid got killed but charging the owner for negligence? its a fucking 25inch pond, in private property for god sakes xDD There is a huge pond, storm water retention pool steps away from my house, one that is dangerous for even an adult. Its not fenced. Who does one blame if one of the dozens of kids outside playing decide to venture in there and gets killed?

Watch your fucking kids parents! It wasn't like the pond was built into the public footpath. One should be allowed to have their entire backyard wired with live electrical wire or like without having to worry about getting charged if some random kid or person decides to trespass and gets killed. Isn't that the same as having a vicious pitbull to protect one's property?

Your warning to parents is well put. The excuse you make for the negligent owner of the hazardous and illegal pond isn't. The matter of the stormwater retention tank is irrelevant to this sad story, but your account of the effort you'd made to correct this dangerous situation would be instructive.

And no, having a pit-bull like the one that escaped its yard and savaged and almost killed a leashed collie on my front lawn isn't the same at all. And the toddler would still be dead.

Owners need to be actively responsible, not just imagine they are.
 
Actually, the current law require any doors that open from the house into the backyard be self-closing and latching for just this reason.

And because owners don't look up and read all the bylaws—and all too often their contractors don't either—we have permits and inspectors who do.

Unfortunately, pretty much everyone would think having a full time inspection team following up every Home Depot pond and liner sale would be a waste of taxes, and we don't even closely track swimming pool sales.

If you don't want to pay for a nanny-state doing it for you then you must be the DiY Pond and Pool and Fence and Safety Inspector. And you don't get to say, "It was my day off, so it was on Fred's list." You are never off the job.

The point about access doors was well taken, but it shouldn't have suggested in any way that ordinarily responsible owners would ever allow such a situation. It's not like this was the first time a kid wandered into water adults thought was safe. I'm sure oil&gas intended his mention of it to be an instructive alert and in no way an excuse.
 
Having said that LE does have a tendency to overcharge because it is way easier to plead down than to amend up.
LE charged a shopkeeper for apprehending a shoplifter. LE charged a carowner for for throwing spice in a car thief's face. This charge of criminal negligence causing death will be tossed out of court.
 
LE charged a shopkeeper for apprehending a shoplifter. LE charged a carowner for for throwing spice in a car thief's face. This charge of criminal negligence causing death will be tossed out of court.

I hope not. And no one was charged for apprehending a shoplifter. It doesn't help the discussion to be fast and loose with describing precise and important stuff like liability laws. Next thing you know people will be ignoring them.

I'd bet, if the owner is found guilty, that the court will recognize his fault was common and inadvertant, although stupid, serious and deadly, and that his sentence will reflect that to teach him and to teach us.

All three instances do have one aspect in common: You need to act responsibly or there will be consequences for you, and acting responsibly isn't as easy or simple as your first thought.
 
All three instances do have one aspect in common: You need to act responsibly or there will be consequences for you, and acting responsibly isn't as easy or simple as your first thought.
Last Fall, I was doing some roofwork at the back of my house and left the ladder in place for several days. My neighbour was concerned. She said a Peeping Tom could sneak into my backyard, climb the ladder and fall and break his neck. Then I would be arrested for criminal negligence causing broken neck and also be subject to a $10 million civil lawsuit.
 
I suspect that unless the home owner was repeatedly notified by bylaw officers that the gate needed to repaired (secured) then he will plead to a lesser charge. Sad story but I agree, if you're an adult looking after kids it's your responsibility for their safety first and foremost.

You have to think of it this way. This world is full of things just waiting to take your kids, protect them!
 
Last Fall, I was doing some roofwork at the back of my house and left the ladder in place for several days. My neighbour was concerned. She said a Peeping Tom could sneak into my backyard, climb the ladder and fall and break his neck. Then I would be arrested for criminal negligence causing broken neck and also be subject to a $10 million civil lawsuit.

I assume your point in a negligence thread depends upon your neighbour being a high-priced liability lawyer and not a nosy busybody. Or just someone with a better sense of danger than you. Cops would have made the same point about your ladder but might have thought burglary more impressive. One of the first things I learned in the workplace is your ladder leaves when you do. Unattended, they get misused.

The danger she drew your attention to is why contractors strap plywood over the lower rungs of ladders and scaffolds they do leave in place. As they are behind fences, it's more a belt and suspenders thing, but when you're out to keep places safe that's a good attitude. You didn't say whether yours was fenced off, but the pond in this story was not.

If all you're concerned about is your own liability, a decent fence and a closed gate have long been held to protect you, although even then you have to inspect and maintain it and take note of changed threats and dangers. None of which is apparent in this tale. Or yours.

The point goes back to Aardvark's 'attractive nuisance'. Any ordinary person is supposed to know that ponds, especially cute ones, construction sites, holes, scaffolds and such unusual things are attractive and that they present dangers that aren't always obvious to the naive and unwary. That is why, if you create such an attractive nuisance, it is your responsibility to fence it off from the curious and the child-like.

We humans didn't get to this point in our evolution by ignoring obvious dangers, especially dangers to our offspring. And since we can't drown the few adults who don't get that, we lecture and take them to court instead. The rest of us actually do know better, especially when reminded by a sad tale like this.
 
Cops handcuffed mom after they arrived, but later removed them.

What a tragedy.
 
You said that the bylaw officers needed to give notice? Nope. The owner has a responsibility not to be negligent. And in this case it seems the tenants had complained of the broken gate and it was not fixed.

Actually what I said/meant was that if the owner had been given notice to fix the fence it would strengthen the Crown's case and therefore make it less like that they would offer a plea or reduce the charge from Criminal Negligence to a lesser charge. But yes, he wouldn't have had to been given notice in order to lay a charge.
 
Without having access to nearly enough facts to come to useful conclusions, I can say I was surprised by both the speed and severity of the charge.

Having said that LE does have a tendency to overcharge because it is way easier to plead down than to amend up.
"Const. Kwong said the charge of criminal negligence causing death, which can be laid even when no intent or malice is shown, carries a maximum penalty of life in prison."

Wow, I guess so. That is an equivalent sentence to Depraved Indifference Murder, rather than Criminally Negligent Manslaughter which typically has a maximum sentence of 25 years and rarely is that long. To my mind unless there was a long history of ignoring repeated notices of safety violations this is clearly manslaughter not murder.
 
I believe deterrence is sometimes cited when considering severity of penalties. Given that the penalty for whatever charge he's eventually tried on will likely be far, far less than that max, might this be someone's idea of putting out a wake-up to all the other pond and water-feature owners who have never considered theirs from the point of view of safety or liability? If they're aware at all, I doubt anyone will put off their fence project because, "they never convict at the max". But the words "life in prison" might get their attention.
 
I believe deterrence is sometimes cited when considering severity of penalties. Given that the penalty for whatever charge he's eventually tried on will likely be far, far less than that max, might this be someone's idea of putting out a wake-up to all the other pond and water-feature owners who have never considered theirs from the point of view of safety or liability? If they're aware at all, I doubt anyone will put off their fence project because, "they never convict at the max". But the words "life in prison" might get their attention.
For most people I would think the possiblity of even five years, and additionally a civil suit for significant damages would be enough to prompt them to check as to whether their pond needs a fence.
 
Kids are left "unattended" a lot. It is normal and not against the law. But it IS against the law to have and unfenced pool or pond deeper than 24". In this case, the gate was rotted of the hinges and was leaned up against the fence. There is a big lawsuit here.

( BTW, as you obviously haven't even read the news, he was with the grandmother.)

Charge Granny with negligent homocide!It's lucky they don't live near the beaches, cause there ain't no fence around Lake Ontario! Sue the city!
 
.......................
A child dies in a pond because no one was attending to them, the child may as well have just run off into the road, pulled a pot of hot water on their head, eaten the cow manure in the yard.

In this case it is a lot easier for the kid to slip off her grandma's hand and
run off into the road. The pond doesn't look anything like a death trap to
kids in the neighborhood. From the video report it it is nothing within
the sight of people on the street. It is not in the open and it wasn't
completely unfenced. It was reported that the kid entered the backyard
at the entry near the rear side of he house where the gate was broken.
It is unthinkable that any toddler passing by the house could just get
rid of the supervising adult, run around the house all the way to the
pond behind to get drowned. According to one neighbor the kid was
often seen running in front of his house. It looks more like the tragedy
could be the result of adults who habitually let an unusually vibrant
toddler running loose.

Normally I am not one who come to the defense of someone guilty
of willful negligence. I am all for fencing and other safety measures in
both private and public spaces where appropriate to safeguard the public.
But the charge of the owner of the pond in this case is clearly misplaced.
 
there is no fence around the road or the lake.....only parents and guardians can protect 2 year olds .
 
Whoever left the 2 year old kid in the backyard by themselves is/are the person/s who should be charged with negligence first, especially since they would/should have known the gate was broken for some time.