The Queen: three steps for Canada to replace the monarchy

Certainly you're free to form any opinion you choose about anything you wish, but having made yours public, perhaps you could cite an instance of non-boring history from anywhere, so we can see how Canada's past doesn't measure up. I ask just for amusement, like you I am very happy at the small success we've made in the peace, order and good government line that has contributed to Canadian unexcitement, then and now.

And you should still see the Encampment.
 
Get down to Fort York and see the Encampment art installation. Two hundred old fashioned army tents, each one with an art piece about an individual whose life was affected and changed by the War of 1812. All sorts: People we've never heard of, people we might have, like David Secord or Catherine Brant, and famous folk like Zeb Pike—after whom Pike's Peak is named—who commanded the invaders during the battle and died here, or Joseph Wilcocks whose idealism earned him a street name here, but led him to switch sides, or the guy they named Molly Wood's Bush after, who no one could call dull or boring (and he got two streets) or David Thomson who drew the boundary maps and has a certain renown in the west (l;ewis and Clark would be American equivalents of a sort).

Some of the pieces are failures, but you cannot say those were dull people or boring times. And some will bring tears. If you time it right, you'll see the tents lit and glowing in the twilight.

Canadian history's only dull because we ignore it.

Monarchists are predictable. If they are not glorifying the monarchs, they are glorifying war. Try social history for a change. You might learn something about Canada.
 



They won't confiscate your teaspoons, but this monarchy-supporting government has no problem confiscating land that was bestowed by the king of England.

http://www2.macleans.ca/2012/06/18/at-war-with-the-feds/

If you think only Constitutional Monarchy's are the only government that can confiscate land then you need an education. the list is long, but i'll stay close to home so as not to confuse you. The elected provincial government of this province can and have done exactly the same. Nice try.
 
Monarchists are predictable. If they are not glorifying the monarchs, they are glorifying war. Try social history for a change. You might learn something about Canada.

They are not glorifying war. Fort York is a living museum that educates the population on a period of Canada's history that happens in large part to be punctuated by a war lasting two years and some think was the beginning of Canada becoming a country.
 
They won't confiscate your teaspoons, but this monarchy-supporting government has no problem confiscating land that was bestowed by the King
While I have tremendous sympathy for Frank Meyers, U.E. and his family, this has what to do with Canada being a Monarchy?

This also happens in Republics, in the U.S. Expropriation is termed Eminent Domain. At least in both Canada and the U.S. the land owner is entitled to the fair market value of the property as set by neutral appraisers.

A sad story but nothing to do with the Monarchy other than that the land in question was a rare example of a Loyalist Land Grant still occupied by the original grantees family (and in the male line).
 
Certainly you're free to form any opinion you choose about anything you wish, but having made yours public, perhaps you could cite an instance of non-boring history from anywhere, so we can see how Canada's past doesn't measure up. I ask just for amusement, like you I am very happy at the small success we've made in the peace, order and good government line that has contributed to Canadian unexcitement, then and now.

And you should still see the Encampment.

I probably should see the encampment, I would probably learn a shit load.

I would suggest off the top of my head that the history of the United States, France, Italy, Germany, Austria, England and many other nations is way less boring than ours. And there is more of it. But I like the fact we are boring.

To give you an example, and I concede this is an oversimplification. Looking at the history of western settlement, the US let settlers and guns go west before law and order got there, making it for a crazy wild history there. Canada, through better planning had far better law enforcement in the west and thus the history of our west (with some small exceptions like Riele (sp?)) pretty tame. Good governance makes in many cases for boring history and that works for me.

Our exciting history of participation in the Boer War, WWI, WWII and Korea, was really us getting involved in other people's history. We didn't play any role in percipitating those crisises.

And there is nothing in Canada history that could compare to say...the defeat of the Turks at the seige of Vienna.
 
Monarchists are predictable. If they are not glorifying the monarchs, they are glorifying war. Try social history for a change. You might learn something about Canada.

Saying that war happened and trying to understand it is not glorifying war. War is one of the great tests of a nation, a people, a community or individuals. It is completely normal for people to be interested in times of conflict and strife.

The bubonic plague sucked too, it might have killed half of europe's population. But by studying it and understanding it, we are not glorifying it.

I guess you want us to run screaming from the past into a socialist history re-write.
 
Nothing particularly tame about the incident with Pie-a-Pot nor the Cypress Hills Massacre in our history. When we're not looking for the deaths and battles, our history was made by the same sort of folks doing the same sort of stuff to survive and bring up kids as they did in any country. That's the real history. Not the Battle of Hastings, but how long it took for English to emerge from Anglo-Saxon screwing around with Norman—formerly Norse French.

Whether they're military or outlaw, the shootings are tabloid shit. Perhaps ours seems boring because we didn't have the dime novelists of the American west writing about outlaws—and embroidering their nastiness into fantasy. But have a read of Roughing it in the Bush, or the writings of her sister, for encounters with starvation, killer winters, Indians and the odd shooting rebellion. All just outside Peterborough.

That's the real history; the settlers who brought what we self-importantly call 'civilization' and who made it stick. The gunfighters and freebooters are unimportant comic book-style precursers. But one of the Encampment figures did get Pike's Peak out in that American west named after him, which perhaps makes him more than just another forgettable general shot at the bottom of Bathurst Street.

And there's always Pierre Berton who was nothing, if he was absolutely not boring about our history. It's not the past that's uninteresting, it's that we're not interested. Which says volumes about us and nothing at all about history.