The Queen: three steps for Canada to replace the monarchy

lurkerjoe said:
Sir John A MacDonald was a foreign bastard, too. He was born in Scotland. Laurier, he's almost a foreign bastard being born in Quebec.
That sycophant and suckup to the monarchy wanted to call the new British colony The Kingdom of Canada.
Ugh. Glad that didn't happen. Went with Dominion instead, until we had established a bit of a rep in WW2 and eventually felt enough national pride to drop the "Dominion" part completely in 1982.
It's past time to take the next step.
Why get rid of the monarchy?
Canada gains nothing.

No, Canada gets nothing from being beholden to the British monarch. That's why the ties should be cut.

Without Britain Canada would either be the 51st state or a third world country.
Or we'd all be speaking French and part of the Francophonie empire. Maybe in that case we'd be drinking Labatt wine instead of beer LOL.
http://www.francophonie.org/

Besides that is no longer true, which is the point.

People often complain about Canadian history being boring. Doing nothing, such as remaining attached to the monarchy, is boring.
 
That sycophant and suckup to the monarchy wanted to call the new British colony The Kingdom of Canada.
Ugh. Glad that didn't happen. Went with Dominion instead, until we had established a bit of a rep in WW2 and eventually felt enough national pride to drop the "Dominion" part completely in 1982.
It's past time to take the next step.


No, Canada gets nothing from being beholden to the British monarch. That's why the ties should be cut.


Or we'd all be speaking French and part of the Francophonie empire. Maybe in that case we'd be drinking Labatt wine instead of beer LOL.
http://www.francophonie.org/

Besides that is no longer true, which is the point.

People often complain about Canadian history being boring. Doing nothing, such as remaining attached to the monarchy, is boring.

They do? You do, but I can ever remember anyone saying or writing that anywhere. Perhaps you could offer up an example.
 
That sycophant and suckup to the monarchy wanted to call the new British colony The Kingdom of Canada.
Ugh. Glad that didn't happen. Went with Dominion instead, until we had established a bit of a rep in WW2 and eventually felt enough national pride to drop the "Dominion" part completely in 1982.
Where on earth do you get the idea that the term Dominion of Canada was abolished in 1982? The Constitution Act 1982 does not explicitly state that it does, and of course incorporated preceding Constitution Acts. Further in fact Dominion of Canada has been officially used post 1982.


Or we'd all be speaking French and part of the Francophonie empire. Maybe in that case we'd be drinking Labatt wine instead of beer LOL.
Unless you are throwing back to there being no Canada at all - Nouvelle France having continued. What a Harry Turtledove alternative universe you are ocupying to believe that posible.
 
Last edited:
They do? You do, but I can ever remember anyone saying or writing that anywhere. Perhaps you could offer up an example.

This is not the first time you has shown an utter disconnect from reality.
Sadly I am such a loser that I will show how you are wrong, even though based on past experience it is an utter waste of my time.

All these quotes from people who are sex crazed and retard strong about Canadian history and yet they all acknowledge that people do in fact complain about Canadian history being boring. They disagree with the complaint, but the complaint must exist for them to react to it.

Unless you are 12, a shut in or lived in Denmark with retarded people your whole life, I have a hard time believing that you have never heard anyone say that or seen it written anywhere.


http://books.google.ca/books/about/A_Short_History_of_Canada.html?id=beFgpa6lj-EC
“Canadians believe that their history is short, boring and irrelevant. They are wrong on all counts.” – Desmond Morton, from the Introduction

http://theagenda.tvo.org/blog/agenda-blog/canadian-history-rocks

It's always been a truism that for many many Canadians, our history is boring. Certainly, it pales in comparison to our neighbors from the south, whose glorious political and military campaigns are fodder for books and movies too numerous to mention.


http://www.canada.com/ottawa/ottawa....html?id=74b01157-f40c-4812-9cae-af93a17c136f

"As someone who has spent 30 years researching, writing and teaching the history of Canada, I hear two main messages from my fellow Canadians about my favourite subject: 1. It's boring; 2. We need more of it. "


http://www.canadiancontent.ca/issues/1098canhistory.html
"What is it about Canadian History that helps us all find cures for our insomnia? ... You see up until about a year ago, I was one of you. I thought, Canadian History was full of boring tales about white haired old men in uncomfortable looking shirts."

http://davidmcconkey.com/Canadian-history-boring-not.php

http://www.teachers.ab.ca/Publicati...ion/Pages/Historians make history boring.aspx

"Canadian history is not all boring, it’s Canadian historians who are boring," says John Lutz, a professor at the University of Victoria and co-director of the website Great Unsolved Mysteries in Canadian History (www.canadianmysteries.ca leaving the ATA website). Lutz blames historians for Canadians’ lack of enthusiasm for their own history.


http://www.sunnewsnetwork.ca/video/1223352049001
Think Canadian history's boring? Think again! John Robson talks up some of our colourful characters and events

http://www.senioryears.com/canadahistory.html
It has been said that Canada has no history or if it has, its history is boring. I beg to differ;
 
It's always been a truism that for many many Canadians, our history is boring. Certainly, it pales in comparison to our neighbors from the south, whose glorious political and military campaigns are fodder for books and movies too numerous to mention.
At the same time and we have seen it posted right here on TERB Canadians take pride in: Not having a history of Indian Wars like the U.S. (Sitting Bull met not by the Cavalry but by four members of the North West Mounted Police (Major James M. Walsh, a sergeant and three troopers ), and not having had a Civil War etc. . .
 
This is not the first time you has shown an utter disconnect from reality.
Sadly I am such a loser that I will show how you are wrong, even though based on past experience it is an utter waste of my time.

All these quotes from people who are sex crazed and retard strong about Canadian history and yet they all acknowledge that people do in fact complain about Canadian history being boring. They disagree with the complaint, but the complaint must exist for them to react to it.

Unless you are 12, a shut in or lived in Denmark with retarded people your whole life, I have a hard time believing that you have never heard anyone say that or seen it written anywhere.


http://books.google.ca/books/about/A_Short_History_of_Canada.html?id=beFgpa6lj-EC
“Canadians believe that their history is short, boring and irrelevant. They are wrong on all counts.” – Desmond Morton, from the Introduction

http://theagenda.tvo.org/blog/agenda-blog/canadian-history-rocks

It's always been a truism that for many many Canadians, our history is boring. Certainly, it pales in comparison to our neighbors from the south, whose glorious political and military campaigns are fodder for books and movies too numerous to mention.


http://www.canada.com/ottawa/ottawa....html?id=74b01157-f40c-4812-9cae-af93a17c136f

"As someone who has spent 30 years researching, writing and teaching the history of Canada, I hear two main messages from my fellow Canadians about my favourite subject: 1. It's boring; 2. We need more of it. "


http://www.canadiancontent.ca/issues/1098canhistory.html
"What is it about Canadian History that helps us all find cures for our insomnia? ... You see up until about a year ago, I was one of you. I thought, Canadian History was full of boring tales about white haired old men in uncomfortable looking shirts."

http://davidmcconkey.com/Canadian-history-boring-not.php

http://www.teachers.ab.ca/Publicati...ion/Pages/Historians make history boring.aspx

"Canadian history is not all boring, it’s Canadian historians who are boring," says John Lutz, a professor at the University of Victoria and co-director of the website Great Unsolved Mysteries in Canadian History (www.canadianmysteries.ca leaving the ATA website). Lutz blames historians for Canadians’ lack of enthusiasm for their own history.


http://www.sunnewsnetwork.ca/video/1223352049001
Think Canadian history's boring? Think again! John Robson talks up some of our colourful characters and events

http://www.senioryears.com/canadahistory.html
It has been said that Canada has no history or if it has, its history is boring. I beg to differ;


Many also say said that climate change is a hoax, but that doesn't make it the nor does the fact that you can google something doesn't change the fact that I never heard anyone say it nor read it.

Uneducated people will say all sorts of things, but none of these reference say that Canadian history is boring. As matter of fact they say much the opposite and 'that' was my point. Just check the thread on the origins of life on earth for proof.
 
Many also say said that climate change is a hoax, but that doesn't make it the nor does the fact that you can google something doesn't change the fact that I never heard anyone say it nor read it.

Uneducated people will say all sorts of things, but none of these reference say that Canadian history is boring. As matter of fact they say much the opposite and 'that' was my point. Just check the thread on the origins of life on earth for proof.

The claim you disputed is this
"People often complain about Canadian history being boring. "
Actually you never disputed the claim, you only claimed never to have heard of it being an issue.

I have shown that many people do find that Canadian history is boring. That is it an issue of concern to those who do love Canadian history.

It does not matter if the people who find Canadian history are right or wrong because THAT ISN"T THE INITIAL CLAIM!

Thus I am right and you are wrong. It really isn't that hard.

Your comments are much like someone claiming that 44% of Americans don't believe in creationism because creationism is wrong. That is just silly.

This is where you put your fuji like response.
 
The claim you disputed is this
"People often complain about Canadian history being boring. "
Actually you never disputed the claim, you only claimed never to have heard of it being an issue.

I have shown that many people do find that Canadian history is boring. That is it an issue of concern to those who do love Canadian history.

It does not matter if the people who find Canadian history are right or wrong because THAT ISN"T THE INITIAL CLAIM!

Thus I am right and you are wrong. It really isn't that hard.

Your comments are much like someone claiming that 44% of Americans don't believe in creationism because creationism is wrong. That is just silly.

This is where you put your fuji like response.


Correct, I actually said I'd never heard that, not that one had ever said it. I hear that HS english credit courses are available in many places. You might want to refresh you comprehension skills.
 
I do indeed. As I posted, even a canadian monarch would be an improvement of the current state. Of course, the monarchy is an outdated concept, that sooner or later will be discontinued by canadians. Canadians of british heritage are fast becoming a minority in Canada, and there is no reason to expect that descendents of immigrants will have any desire to extendt the memory of Canada's colonial past.

The desparate postings of the monarchists here show that they know in which direction the wind is blowing.

A Canadian monarch would be less useful then a British one. I think you underestimate the appeal of the Royals even among non brits.
 
My point wasn't so much that Canadian history is boring, it's that finally becoming independent of the British monarchical system would be a fascinating, relevant and maturing chapter of modern Canadian history.
Doing nothing, going along with our current status of having a foreigner as head of state simply due to inertia, is boring.

danmand said:
I do indeed. As I posted, even a canadian monarch would be an improvement of the current state. Of course, the monarchy is an outdated concept, that sooner or later will be discontinued by canadians. Canadians of british heritage are fast becoming a minority in Canada, and there is no reason to expect that descendents of immigrants will have any desire to extendt the memory of Canada's colonial past.

The desparate postings of the monarchists here show that they know in which direction the wind is blowing.
Exactly. Even the appointed Senate is an outdated concept, and results in undeserving bootlicking drunken boors such as Mike Duffy winning that money-for-life lottery.

The British system of monarchy and upper class patronage has also delivered to us Baron Black of Crossharbour, PC, OC, KCSG and that alone should have Canadian monarchists change their minds about this entire unwarranted arrangement of royal titles and paid-for honours.

I'm continually astounded in this thread that there are members of a pluralistic democratic country who are in favour of being the subjects of an entirely undeserving British royal family simply due to their bloodline and 'because that's how it's always been'.
 
My point wasn't so much that Canadian history is boring, it's that finally becoming independent of the British monarchical system would be a fascinating, relevant and maturing chapter of modern Canadian history.
Doing nothing, going along with our current status of having a foreigner as head of state simply due to inertia, is boring.

Exactly. Even the appointed Senate is an outdated concept, and results in undeserving bootlicking drunken boors such as Mike Duffy winning that money-for-life lottery.

The British system of monarchy and upper class patronage has also delivered to us Baron Black of Crossharbour, PC, OC, KCSG and that alone should have Canadian monarchists change their minds about this entire unwarranted arrangement of royal titles and paid-for honours.

I'm continually astounded in this thread that there are members of a pluralistic democratic country who are in favour of being the subjects of an entirely undeserving British royal family simply due to their bloodline and 'because that's how it's always been'.

You might just find that the next interesting chapter will take place when William and Kate take control. Charles will be a almost a footnote.

We don't have Lord Black. He's just Conrad black ex-media baron and ex-con. For every Mike Duffy, we get our share of Senators Dellaire and LeBreton. I'm sure we could come up with a few drunken elected louts in the Congress. Do you not think we have an upper class and a patronage system in Canada? Try walking down the halls of UCC and see the Who's Who of the power elite in this Country.

I'm not quite sure what qualifies you to say the Monarchy of Britain are undeserving. Something tells nme you haven't enough knowledge of the history of the British Crown. How is it they are undeserving?
 
Gentlemen! Don't get your teapots in a tither! No one is going confiscate your "There'll always be an England" teaspoon sets when Canada finally grows up and cuts the apron strings. And when you do crawl out from under the Queen's dress you may find a sunny day and a bright independent Canadian future!
 
Gentlemen! Don't get your teapots in a tither! No one is going confiscate your "There'll always be an England" teaspoon sets when Canada finally grows up and cuts the apron strings. And when you do crawl out from under the Queen's dress you may find a sunny day and a bright independent Canadian future!

My teapot is just fine, although i drink more coffee, and I certainly don't consider myself tied to anyones apron strings. I'm more concerned about the clusterfuck that's being perpetrated by the Harper hillbillies in Ottawa, my apologies to hillbillies, that by some imagined restriction imposed on us by the Monarchy.
 
Correct, I actually said I'd never heard that, not that one had ever said it. I hear that HS english credit courses are available in many places. You might want to refresh you comprehension skills.

It is also clear that I am gobsmacked that there could be someone who had not heard of that, unless

"This is not the first time you has shown an utter disconnect from reality...
Unless you are 12, a shut in or lived in Denmark with retarded people your whole life, I have a hard time believing that you have never heard anyone say that or seen it written anywhere
."

From what I wrote above it is clear that I understood that you claim not to ever had heard it.
Also although I never suggested that you claimed that no one ever said it [as everyone has said just about anything at some point], however your initial response clearly puts forward that you didn't think it was anything other than a fringe thing.


I find it very funny that someone like yourself suggests that others need a refresh of comprehension skills when the problem is that you are the one who lacks them. You are constantly misreading things.
 
It is also clear that I am gobsmacked that there could be someone who had not heard of that, unless

"This is not the first time you has shown an utter disconnect from reality...
Unless you are 12, a shut in or lived in Denmark with retarded people your whole life, I have a hard time believing that you have never heard anyone say that or seen it written anywhere
."

From what I wrote above it is clear that I understood that you claim not to ever had heard it.
Also although I never suggested that you claimed that no one ever said it [as everyone has said just about anything at some point], however your initial response clearly puts forward that you didn't think it was anything other than a fringe thing.


I find it very funny that someone like yourself suggests that others need a refresh of comprehension skills when the problem is that you are the one who lacks them. You are constantly misreading things.

Nice dance, but nothing changes. Stop spitting into the wind and the gobsmacking will stop.
 


Gentlemen! Don't get your teapots in a tither! No one is going confiscate your "There'll always be an England" teaspoon sets when Canada finally grows up and cuts the apron strings. And when you do crawl out from under the Queen's dress you may find a sunny day and a bright independent Canadian future!
They won't confiscate your teaspoons, but this monarchy-supporting government has no problem confiscating land that was bestowed by the king of England.

http://www2.macleans.ca/2012/06/18/at-war-with-the-feds/

The verdict was never really in doubt; if the government wants to buy your land, selling is the only real option. But for Frank Meyers and his family, the official confirmation was no less devastating: their beloved farm, more than two centuries old, will indeed be transformed into a top-secret training ground for JTF 2, the Canadian military’s elite special forces squad.

“I am of the opinion that the properties proposed for expropriation are absolutely essential for the safety and security of Canada,” reads the final decision from Ottawa, signed by Public Works Minister Rona Ambrose. “For that reason and in absence of valid justification to do otherwise, I have confirmed my intention to expropriate.”

The paperwork, obtained by Maclean’s, marks the end of a long, public battle that pitted a piece of Canadian history against modern-day national security. The direct descendant of Capt. John Walden Meyers—a Loyalist war hero and the founder of Belleville, Ont.—Frank Meyers has spent seven decades farming the very same plot of land that King George III bestowed on his famous forefather as gratitude for his service during the American Revolution.
 
I'm not quite sure what qualifies you to say the Monarchy of Britain are undeserving. Something tells nme you haven't enough knowledge of the history of the British Crown. How is it they are undeserving?
They have not been elected to any position in the Canadian government and are therefore undeserving of any loyalty or recognition in our democracy. The queen of England has certainly done nothing to warrant having her face on Canada's currency. The nepotism of "being born into England's royal family" is by definition undeserving.
 
People often complain about Canadian history being boring. Doing nothing, such as remaining attached to the monarchy, is boring.

Personally, I find Canadian history boring, but that is not a complaint. I like it that way and would be happy to have plenty more of it.
 
Get down to Fort York and see the Encampment art installation. Two hundred old fashioned army tents, each one with an art piece about an individual whose life was affected and changed by the War of 1812. All sorts: People we've never heard of, people we might have, like David Secord or Catherine Brant, and famous folk like Zeb Pike—after whom Pike's Peak is named—who commanded the invaders during the battle and died here, or Joseph Wilcocks whose idealism earned him a street name here, but led him to switch sides, or the guy they named Molly Wood's Bush after, who no one could call dull or boring (and he got two streets) or David Thomson who drew the boundary maps and has a certain renown in the west (l;ewis and Clark would be American equivalents of a sort).

Some of the pieces are failures, but you cannot say those were dull people or boring times. And some will bring tears. If you time it right, you'll see the tents lit and glowing in the twilight.

Canadian history's only dull because we ignore it.
 
Get down to Fort York and see the Encampment art installation. Two hundred old fashioned army tents, each one with an art piece about an individual whose life was affected and changed by the War of 1812. All sorts: People we've never heard of, people we might have, like David Secord or Catherine Brant, and famous folk like Zeb Pike—after whom Pike's Peak is named—who commanded the invaders during the battle and died here, or Joseph Wilcocks whose idealism earned him a street name here, but led him to switch sides, or the guy they named Molly Wood's Bush after, who no one could call dull or boring (and he got two streets) or David Thomson who drew the boundary maps and has a certain renown in the west (l;ewis and Clark would be American equivalents of a sort).

Some of the pieces are failures, but you cannot say those were dull people or boring times. And some will bring tears. If you time it right, you'll see the tents lit and glowing in the twilight.

Canadian history's only dull because we ignore it.

I freely admit that whether or not any particular history is interesting is a matter of opinion. I am well informed on Canadian history and still find it boring.