The Queen: three steps for Canada to replace the monarchy

by symbolically submitting to a foreign monarch

Symbolically whipped? I guess I'm made of sterner stuff, as I don't feel whipped, subservient, subordinate, downtrodden or whatever adjective have been used to in previous posts.

She's not a foreign monarch. She is the Queen of Canada until we say not.
 
Soon, only Canada will remain as whipping boy for the British Empire...what an embarrassment.
If this is the way you feel, what Constitutionally needs to happen has already been spelled out. Either start your campaign or not.
 
blackrock13 said:
She's not a foreign monarch. She is the Queen of Canada until we say not.
Wasn't born here, doesn't hold a Canadian passport, never passed a citizenship test.
Phil C. McNasty said:
Meh, she doesnt have any real power in Canada anyways
No power, not a citizen, non-resident, pays no taxes.
We'd be so much better off cutting the apron strings and having nil involvement from the British monarchy. We can do it! I really think we can be a real country, on our own.

If this is the way you feel, what Constitutionally needs to happen has already been spelled out. Either start your campaign or not.
Unfortunately this is not the time. The Harper Government favours linking patriotism with fealty and obedience to the British monarchy.

http://www.ctv.ca/CTVNews/TopStories/20120101/harper-government-monarchy-policy-120101/
That priority has clearly shifted now, she said, adding the Tories have done more than any other modern Canadian government to foster royal connections by promoting the monarchy's presence in the country, both on state and charitable visits.

"It's difficult to tell what approach the Conservative government may have going forward, but they certainly seem to be encouraging royal visits and royal involvement in Canadian institutions," she said.
 
It appears that Australia is thinking of bailing, as are many African countries. Soon, only Canada will remain as whipping boy for the British Empire...what an embarrassment.

Sooner or later, I expect as you do quite late, Canada also will abolish the monarchy. The descendants of british immigrants, who in their minds ( and only in their minds) are the real canadians, will be a smaller and smaller minority in Candada, and the descendants of immigrants from other parts of the world will have no reason to glamourize Canada's colonial past, quite the opposite, as a matter of fact.

As many have posted, this silly idea of having a foreign Queen as head of state of a soverign country is an embarassment.
 
Sooner or later, I expect as you do quite late, Canada also will abolish the monarchy. The descendants of british immigrants, who in their minds ( and only in their minds) are the real canadians, will be a smaller and smaller minority in Candada, and the descendants of immigrants from other parts of the world will have no reason to glamourize Canada's colonial past, quite the opposite, as a matter of fact.
Perhaps but when those immigrants are concentrated in Toronto, Vancouver and Montreal it will remain hard to meet the Constitutional burden.
 
Born here has nothing to do with Jus Sanguinis, further, it is hard to hold a passport when those passports are issued in your name.

You only had thirteen years of Jean Chrétien and Paul Martin in which to have waged your campaign.
Yes it was disappointing that Chretien did not accomplish more. And the Cons fake outrage over Adscam hurt Paul Martin, who could have actually helped the country move forward with another term in office. It might take a Quebec born PM to finally cut the apron strings with Britain.

But it's a sadly negative attitude you display in this thread Aarvark154. Like an abuse victim who think it's easier to go along with the abuse rather than work to make a change. Or are you saying we need to vote for the NDP if we expect to have progressive policies?
Political inertia is not a good reason to sit back and take it. It's why pot remains illegal, and why we're going through the current court case with prostitution.

It seems that it is much easier for legislators to pass laws, than to get rid of them. And it's much easier to ignore the opportunity to grow up and cut the ties with the monarchy, than to work to change them.
 
As a non-interested (ie- I have no dog in the fight, not that I am not paying attention to the situation) foreign party:

I think you're all crazy.

This is getting worked up over something that really doesn't matter. Ok, in a perfect world I can see why you would want to get rid of the Queen. Fine. But I can also see why some wouldn't want to and I can recognize that this would just be an expensive, contentious, unhappy debate THAT WOULDN'T BE ABOUT ANYTHING.

You'd end up spending a lot of money, a lot of effort, all to dot some "i"s and cross some "t"s that doesn't really change anything worth talking about.

Oooooooooooh, the British monarch is on your money! I have to admit, I couldn't give a rat's ass about the pictures of the epople on your money that I spend in Canada.

The author of the artucle is an idiot. Even *I* can see that there won't be some "quiet, easy" change on this matter. That so many have voiced their opinions on this thread is proof enough of that.

There are fights worth fighting. This would be picking a painful fight for a bullshit "win". This is the sort of fight of which Phyrric victories are made.
 
that is why I'm not fighting a fight, I'm just offering my opinion...and I am of British ( and Irish) blood myself, but identify only as a Canadian
 
Damn it YOU'RE RIGHT! Lets take the Maple leaf off the flag and replace it with Mohammed.

we got rid of the red ensign in the 60's, but not without lots of whining from conservatives and veterans and others....very controversial, but Pearson was determined ...and right! Now it is time to say goodbye to the British throne.
 
The cost per capita to maintain the Monarchy system in Canada is more per capita than the Brits pay. We have to maintain two Heads of State and a Lieutenant General for each Province. The argument for continuity the British Royal family brings is rubbish. Continuity is only important to the British as the institution of the monarchy has come to define British Democratic history. In Canada no such happens for a sizable percentage of the population, the French certainly don't have this view and neither do new Canadians. While I respect the traditions of the Monarchy I would like to suggest that we get rid of the British Monarchy and the Governor General and start our own Monarchy. My suggestion is that Mod100 be the first or my favorite just because it would upset Danmand and Fugi ... ROB FORD. However I'm open to suggestions. lol
 
Shades of Katie Engelhart, the last figures I saw the difference was all of 21 cents per capita. Roughly $1.53 versus $1.32, remember too that most of that cost in Canada would be there if the Monarchy were to have been abolished yesterday.

Finding hard numbers for the Office of the President of the U.S. is far more difficult however I can tell you that it is a good bit more than $1.53 per capita.
 
Shades of Katie Engelhart, the last figures I saw the difference was all of 21 cents per capita. Roughly $1.53 versus $1.32, remember too that most of that cost in Canada would be there if the Monarchy were to have been abolished yesterday.

Finding hard numbers for the Office of the President of the U.S. is far more difficult however I can tell you that it is a good bit more than $1.53 per capita.

But I would gladly be Clown Prince for only 1 dollar per capita, and I am Canadian.
 
I hate the queen of England, can't stand seeing her undeserving nonnative mug on our money

Sir John A MacDonald was a foreign bastard, too. He was born in Scotland. Laurier, he's almost a foreign bastard being born in Quebec.
 
Sir John A MacDonald was a foreign bastard, too. He was born in Scotland. . .
Add to the list Sir Alexander Mackenzie also born in Scotland and Sir Mackenzie Bowell born in England although neither of them has their face on a Bank of Canada Note.
 
The cost per capita to maintain the Monarchy system in Canada is more per capita than the Brits pay. We have to maintain two Heads of State and a Lieutenant General for each Province. The argument for continuity the British Royal family brings is rubbish. Continuity is only important to the British as the institution of the monarchy has come to define British Democratic history. In Canada no such happens for a sizable percentage of the population, the French certainly don't have this view and neither do new Canadians. While I respect the traditions of the Monarchy I would like to suggest that we get rid of the British Monarchy and the Governor General and start our own Monarchy. My suggestion is that Mod100 be the first or my favorite just because it would upset Danmand and Fugi ... ROB FORD. However I'm open to suggestions. lol

Why do you say new Canadian have no affinity towards the Crown as many of them have one as as their previous home were members of the British Commonwealth? Canadian continuity comes from the fact that Queen Elizabeth has been our monarch for 60 years. You can't have more continuity than that. You say there French don't, yet how many show up to agree the royals when they go to Quebec. certainly more were there than the lazy ass Republican. The support for the monarchy is lowest in Quebec, but still sizable.
 
chris123 said:
Why get rid of the monarchy?
Canada gains nothing.
Without Britain Canada would either be the 51st state or a third world country.

Seriously.

How many of the "new Canadians" are from Hong Kong (pre-'97, or at least got British passports as a golden parachute), India, Pakistan, South Africa, etc., even leaving out the British Isles?

The (massive) Hong Kong investment in Canada alone wouldn't have been possible if Canada had severed ties to the British Empire. The very immigration that some are using to say why the British monarchy should be cut out of Canada is the RESULT of that connection to Britain.