The Queen: three steps for Canada to replace the monarchy

So Dan, do you endorse the position of the article you posted that we should select some other Canadian "head of state" ...

I do indeed. As I posted, even a canadian monarch would be an improvement of the current state. Of course, the monarchy is an outdated concept, that sooner or later will be discontinued by canadians. Canadians of british heritage are fast becoming a minority in Canada, and there is no reason to expect that descendents of immigrants will have any desire to extendt the memory of Canada's colonial past.

The desparate postings of the monarchists here show that they know in which direction the wind is blowing.
 
? :confused:

You have a peculiar version of bearing (borne) true allegiance.



A bit like swearing an oath to protect, preserve and defend the Constitituion of the United States, and then promptly turning around and arguing that it should be scraped and replaced with the Constitution of Belarus.

You are on a roll. Now you are also claiming that americans are not allowed to argue for an amendment to the american constitution.
 
What benefit is there to getting rid of the Queen? I prefer to think of her as my head of state then Douchbag Harpo. Having the Queen as our head of state has many many significant benefits with very little cost. God save the Queen!!! This moron suggest picking a "Canadian Head of State" WTF? Another expensive patronage position which costs more then the Queen and has ZERO international prestige? What a DUMB, DUMB idea.
That`s a bizarre political question, it should be What benefit is there to continue being yoked to the British monarchy?

Why should there be a figurehead position in our system at all? There`s no reason for an unelected, unappointed foreigner to be our powerless head of state. Almost any selection process including a lottery would be better than clinging to the medieval system of appointment by birth; leave that to the other oil-rich nations, the ones in the middle east who still cling to the archaic and undemocratic system of leadership through bloodlines.

And what benefit does this old woman bring? Job creation program? Technical expertise? Technological innovation?! The tradition of afternoon tea?! She doesn`t even pay taxes here, and we all know how terbites feel about women who are freeloading moochers.

Aardvark154 said:
Oh you mean when you swore on oath:

I swear (or affirm) that I will be faithful and bear true allegiance to Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth the Second, Queen of Canada, Her Heirs and Successors. . . .
I hate that oath. There is no reason any Canadian should need to take an oath to a foreign and non-resident monarch. Turns my stomach. And, her heirs and successors? All of them?

rs8v1x.jpg
 
? :confused:

You have a peculiar version of bearing (borne) true allegiance.



A bit like swearing an oath to protect, preserve and defend the Constitituion of the United States, and then promptly turning around and arguing that it should be scraped and replaced with the Constitution of Belarus.
I see no problem with giving the US Constitution a good close scrape now and then. Somehow the same document that today protects the freedom of Americans of all hues nonetheless permitted the enslavement of hundreds of thousands of them years ago. In fact the South claimed they went to war to preserve and defend the rights of states under that Constitution. Without a word of it needing to be repealed or changed, Lincoln and his Cabinet proclaimed those who were slaves under it moments before were now free under it. Which suggests that at some point in time, someone must not have been defending and preserving it, either Lincoln the Emancipator or all the Presidents before him. Either that or we have to be a tad more liberal in our interpretations of what those high phrases mean in real life.

Compared to starting a shooting war, a suggestion that our monarch be required to reside in Canada, or be replaced by a person who will seems far less traitorous. A bit more sucky than the current arrangement perhaps, but stiil within the bounds of 'allegiance' to the Crown.
 
That`s a bizarre political question, it should be What benefit is there to continue being yoked to the British monarchy?

Why should there be a figurehead position in our system at all? There`s no reason for an unelected, unappointed foreigner to be our powerless head of state. Almost any selection process including a lottery would be better than clinging to the medieval system of appointment by birth; leave that to the other oil-rich nations, the ones in the middle east who still cling to the archaic and undemocratic system of leadership through bloodlines.

And what benefit does this old woman bring? Job creation program? Technical expertise? Technological innovation?! The tradition of afternoon tea?! She doesn`t even pay taxes here, and we all know how terbites feel about women who are freeloading moochers.

I hate that oath. There is no reason any Canadian should need to take an oath to a foreign and non-resident monarch. Turns my stomach. And, her heirs and successors? All of them?

rs8v1x.jpg




You must have a very weak constitution if you feel `yolked` by the monarchy, much like those who claim we bow down to the Monarch. The benefits that the monarchy gives to the country were well outlined in the last batch of threads posted during the royal wedding last year. Have a good read.

Do you believe Harry has Nazi sympathies based on this Halloween costume? It was a brain fart that many teen suffer and somehow I think he`s been schooled on it from many quarters.
 
Do you believe Harry has Nazi sympathies based on this Halloween costume? It was a brain fart that many teen suffer and somehow I think he's been schooled on it from many quarters
I agree, it was just something stupid he did as a kid. I highly doubt he's a Nazi sympathiser
 
I agree, it was just something stupid he did as a kid. I highly doubt he's a Nazi sympathiser

Although I have to point out that it is a family tradition.
 
You are on a roll. Now you are also claiming that americans are not allowed to argue for an amendment to the american constitution.
I'm certain you can not be so blind to nuance in real life.

To argue for a constitutional amendment to require congressional pay increases to not take effect until the next Congress, is quite different from attempting to alter the U.S. Constitution to entirely change the system of government. It is the later which is analogous to what you would like to do.
 
Let's all tell it like it is...canucks continue with this farce so that Canadians of British ancestry a.k.a. The fabled "real canadians" continue to feel at home in this increasingly diverse country. That's also the reason we have train wrecks like robbie donuts reigning as first citizen of the largest city of a G8 country. But he's the right kind of people, of course.

That bitch and her half bred son and heirs can jump off the royal balcony, for all I care. Just to rub it in, I would love to elect the blackest black dude in dreadlocks as a replacement for the current welfare recipient at Rideau hall (the very white and person of English extraction Mr. Johnston).
 
Let's all tell it like it is...canucks continue with this farce so that Canadians of British ancestry a.k.a. The fabled "real canadians" continue to feel at home in this increasingly diverse country. That's also the reason we have train wrecks like robbie donuts reigning as first citizen of the largest city of a G8 country. But he's the right kind of people, of course.

That bitch and her half bred son and heirs can jump off the royal balcony, for all I care. Just to rub it in, I would love to elect the blackest black dude in dreadlocks as a replacement for the current welfare recipient at Rideau hall (the very white and person of English extraction Mr. Johnston).


Wow, did you miss your anger management session this week? Half bred son? Are you now blaming the monarchy for TO electing Rob Ford? Many of the diverse population also called her their Queen before they came here. You might want to check that out.
 
Wow, did you miss your anger management session this week? Half bred son? Are you know blaming the the monarchy for TO electing Rob Ford? Many of the diverse population also called her their Queen before they came here. You might want to check that out.
It does sound that way doesn't it.
 
Wow, did you miss your anger management session this week? Half bred son? Are you know blaming the the monarchy for TO electing Rob Ford? Many of the diverse population also called her their Queen before they came here. You might want to check that out.

No anger here. I reserve the right to not confer my allegiance or respect upon that British parasite, hence my use of the direspectful term to describe her. And do you actually propose that anyone with the least discrimination should regard that goofball first son of hers with any degree of the respect due a sovereign? Whatever floats your boat, Blackrock, but for me and a ton of people the monarchy is an embarrassment. I am loyal to the future of this great country, not a useless vestige of its past. Maybe I'd feel differently about it if my surname began with 'Mc..'.

Another thing, if I had written that post in anger why would that fact alone have disqualified my views? Honestly, what's wrong with expressing anger sometimes. Things change in a society when a sufficient number of people get riled up enough to demand change. Many observers of this country have noted the weird absence of indignation among canucks, the complacency and apathy that seems to characterize public life here. Maybe we could use a little more anger...
 
No anger here. I reserve the right to not confer my allegiance or respect upon that British parasite, hence my use of the diminutive term to describe her. And do you actually propose that anyone with the least discrimination should regard that goofball first son of hers with any degree of the respect due a sovereign? Whatever floats your boat, Blackrock, but for me and a ton of people the monarchy is an embarrassment. I am loyal to the future of this great country, not a useless vestige of its past. Maybe I'd feel differently about it if my surname began with 'mc..'.

You showed your lack of knowledge calling Prince Charles a half bred. It's not disrespect that you show, it's ignorance. Now, you fall back on that old favorite canard of DM that the Royals being parasites, despite the clear facts they aren't; again showing your ignorance. I'm not quite sure how many people consider the Monarchy an embarrassment. Perhaps you can provide something to back it up. Not wanting the monarchy any longer is a lot different then considering them an embarrassment. Exactly how many people make up a ton? If you were a 'mc', you probably be of Irish decent so I'm not so sure of your claim. Yet a large number of the citizen of Eire showed up to welcome her, so I suspect their ill will was put away for a while that day.
 
No anger here. I reserve the right to not confer my allegiance or respect upon that British parasite, hence my use of the direspectful term to describe her. And do you actually propose that anyone with the least discrimination should regard that goofball first son of hers with any degree of the respect due a sovereign? Whatever floats your boat, Blackrock, but for me and a ton of people the monarchy is an embarrassment. I am loyal to the future of this great country, not a useless vestige of its past. Maybe I'd feel differently about it if my surname began with 'Mc..'.

Well said.
 
No anger here. I reserve the right to not confer my allegiance or respect upon that British parasite, hence my use of the direspectful term to describe her. And do you actually propose that anyone with the least discrimination should regard that goofball first son of hers with any degree of the respect due a sovereign? Whatever floats your boat, Blackrock, but for me and a ton of people the monarchy is an embarrassment. I am loyal to the future of this great country, not a useless vestige of its past. Maybe I'd feel differently about it if my surname began with 'Mc..'.

Another thing, if I had written that post in anger why would that fact alone have disqualified my views? Honestly, what's wrong with expressing anger sometimes. Things change in a society when a sufficient number of people get riled up enough to demand change. Many observers of this country have noted the weird absence of indignation among canucks, the complacency and apathy that seems to characterize public life here. Maybe we could use a little more anger...

Lack of respect and an inability to discuss things civilly often leads to one being marginalized and left out of the adult conversations. In fact I would say that manners and respect, and civil discourse are strong parts of Canadian culture, something you claim some allegiance or loyalty to.

If you want our political system to look like the American one, feel free to get angry and shout pejorative slogans that are not based on the truth.

Then go kick some cans with the other angry youth and let the grown ups go about their work.
 
Lack of respect and an inability to discuss things civilly often leads to one being marginalized and left out of the adult conversations. In fact I would say that manners and respect, and civil discourse are strong parts of Canadian culture, something you claim some allegiance or loyalty to.

If you want our political system to look like the American one, feel free to get angry and shout pejorative slogans that are not based on the truth.

Then go kick some cans with the other angry youth and let the grown ups go about their work.

this from one of terb's angriest masters of the 'personal insult as argument' genre....priceless!

It appears that Australia is thinking of bailing, as are many African countries. Soon, only Canada will remain as whipping boy for the British Empire...what an embarrassment.