Catholic Priest Pedophiles

A long post. With the good bad and ugly on display.
Pehaps we should remember that throughout history the authority group that has been guilty of the most child abuse is fathers. Even worse than men of God...Fathers in fact are gods to their children. And swept under the rug? Sadly families have been guilty of this as well. Perhaps it show a horrible weakness, in the males of the world.

The long and short of it is men...must do better. Whatever used to be overlooked, must now be seen through a micro-scope. What was in the dark...must be exposed to bright light. It's tough, and pehaps slightly unfair to judge what happened in the past with 2012 sensibilties.

My take on it, is the church had many good, and a few bad. (Wrong was still wrong even if it was overlooked). It is now the job of the good to rebuild trust with the world. The only way this will happen is if every interaction with young people going forward is far above board. I believe most priests know this....now.

Well said.
 
Of course my profession has nothing to do with it, although I do represent sexual assualt victims quite often.

But I note, as usual, that your post is completely bereft of facts, argument or analysis. Well done. Creating a post with 0% value, as you often do, is a great skill.

thanks...I model myself after Johnny Cochrane.
 
A long post. With the good bad and ugly on display.
Pehaps we should remember that throughout history the authority group that has been guilty of the most child abuse is fathers. Even worse than men of God...Fathers in fact are gods to their children. And swept under the rug? Sadly families have been guilty of this as well. Perhaps it show a horrible weakness, in the males of the world.

The long and short of it is men...must do better. Whatever used to be overlooked, must now be seen through a micro-scope. What was in the dark...must be exposed to bright light. It's tough, and pehaps slightly unfair to judge what happened in the past with 2012 sensibilties.

My take on it, is the church had many good, and a few bad. (Wrong was still wrong even if it was overlooked). It is now the job of the good to rebuild trust with the world. The only way this will happen is if every interaction with young people going forward is far above board. I believe most priests know this....now.


A young priest I know of was quoted as saying that the bad apples of the RCC are a minute minority, and that the good done by the Church far exceeds its failings.

If it is held to account and is paying damages, isn't it on the road to redress it's wrongs? (If it doesn't, it will pay the price of declining attendance and support).

Should it be dismantled?
 
Should it be dismantled?

I thought this thread had really jumped the shark, but this is an important question.

It goes to the heart of my objection to many people's angry cries to "bring down the church" etc. or ban the RCC.

Firstly, it is probably not practical. The RCC has over a billion members, in almost every country, and has its own country. While communist countries from time to time have banned the RCC, most people view that as a violation of the basic democratic freedom of religion, and it seems to be able to come back afterwards (although no really strongly Catholic Country has ever banned the RCC).

The second question is that of collective or organizational guilt. Our justice system is effectively built on the principle that individuals do wrong and that individuals who do wrong should bear their own punishment. The idea that an institution or an organization can really be responsible for wrongs is simply foreign to our way of thinking about crime, punishment and guilt. While there are some rare examples in western legal history of the imposition of collective guilt, or worse, guilt by membership, they are rare and viewed with suspicion and concern by most jurists.

Thirdly, there is also the practical question. The RCC is probably the world's largest charitable organization. It does a boatload of good work in places all over the world, and have developed very effective infrastructure to do so. If it was "dismantled" it could well cause more harm that good. Considering the very low number of sex assualt cases going on currently in the RCC, this idea seems less rational day by day.
 
The second question is that of collective or organizational guilt. Our justice system is effectively built on the principle that individuals do wrong and that individuals who do wrong should bear their own punishment. The idea that an institution or an organization can really be responsible for wrongs is simply foreign to our way of thinking about crime, punishment and guilt. While there are some rare examples in western legal history of the imposition of collective guilt, or worse, guilt by membership, they are rare and viewed with suspicion and concern by most jurists.
Besides the above legal points, it also strikes me ironic that some of the same people who like to make these organizational guilt arguments would be horrified to be compared to Nazis, yet one of the charges at the Nuremburg Tribunals was the imposition of collective punishment.
 
The reason the catholic charities were set up is to help people procreate and provide assistance to needy families so their offspring can also contribute their money to the church when they grow up. There wouldn't be over one billion catholics worldwide if they were taught that birth control is acceptable and should be used in cases where families are too poor to have kids. But no, the church keeps telling them to procreate whether they can afford to have the children or not!! They are even publicly against the use of condoms! How stupid is that? They're in denial that people are going to have sex regardless of what they preach and teach and then denies them the right to protect themselves from STD's at the same time!!! Can anyone say infuriating?
 
The reason the catholic charities were set up is to help people procreate
Does that apply to Quaker and Mennonite charities as well? What about Anglican and Orthodox charities?

There does does seem to be quite a bit more to it than that!
 
The reason the catholic charities were set up is to help people procreate and provide assistance to needy families so their offspring can also contribute their money to the church when they grow up. There wouldn't be over one billion catholics worldwide if they were taught that birth control is acceptable and should be used in cases where families are too poor to have kids. But no, the church keeps telling them to procreate whether they can afford to have the children or not!! They are even publicly against the use of condoms! How stupid is that? They're in denial that people are going to have sex regardless of what they preach and teach and then denies them the right to protect themselves from STD's at the same time!!! Can anyone say infuriating?

Oh come on. The poor of all races/creeds have more children than the rich. That's nothing new, or not typical of human behaviour. (Actually the idea of have very few or no children, and using effective BC is pretty new)

People are going to have sex...you're right. But is it really so bad to preach that the best place for sex is in a husband/wife commited relationship? Is that not an ideal? Perhaps unattainable for some...but not all.
 
Same old denial

The reason the catholic charities were set up is to help people procreate and provide assistance to needy families so their offspring can also contribute their money to the church when they grow up. There wouldn't be over one billion catholics worldwide if they were taught that birth control is acceptable and should be used in cases where families are too poor to have kids. But no, the church keeps telling them to procreate whether they can afford to have the children or not!! They are even publicly against the use of condoms! How stupid is that? They're in denial that people are going to have sex regardless of what they preach and teach and then denies them the right to protect themselves from STD's at the same time!!! Can anyone say infuriating?

THAT is, and always has been the Catholic church's mantra, being preached to this day.
Is NOT even close to Anglican and Protestant churches views on making babies .
I know, do I have facts, yes, my extended family is mixed Catholic and Protestan and Anglican.

Tends to keep the poor close.

FAST
 
THAT is, and always has been the Catholic church's mantra, being preached to this day.
Is NOT even close to Anglican and Protestant churches views on making babies .
Needless to say true, however, that is not at all the same as saying that the sole reason for Roman Catholic charitable giving is to encourage procreation!
 
Does that apply to Quaker and Mennonite charities as well? What about Anglican and Orthodox charities?

There does does seem to be quite a bit more to it than that!

I didn't mean to say that this is the sole and only reason for the charities, but in my mind it is one of them.
 
'The'reason the catholic charities were set up 'is' to help people procreate and provide assistance to needy families so their offspring can also contribute their money to the church when they grow up. There wouldn't be over one billion catholics worldwide if they were taught that birth control is acceptable and should be used in cases where families are too poor to have kids. But no, the church keeps telling them to procreate whether they can afford to have the children or not!! They are even publicly against the use of condoms! How stupid is that? They're in denial that people are going to have sex regardless of what they preach and teach and then denies them the right to protect themselves from STD's at the same time!!! Can anyone say infuriating?

I didn't mean to say that this is the sole and only reason for the charities, but in my mind it is one of them.

Yes you did as your post clearly shows.

Now after the backpedal we are left with the question how much of the the reason; most, a lot, some? If not the only reason, what are some if the other reasons.?

Having seen the churches work in Africa, the last thing they're expecting is for those they help to pay them back. The recipients barely have money to survive let alone give some back to the church. They may pay them back with their muscle and sweat, but that's not what you're claiming either. There is little chance that the recipients in Uganda, Sudan, Ethiopia, and where ever the Zimbabwe refugese land will be paying anyone back for a number of generations. If you were to say that to the people of Haiti, they'd laugh in your face.
 
Yes you did as your post clearly shows.

Now after the backpedal we are left with the question how much of the the reason; most, a lot, some? If not the only reason, what are some if the other reasons.?

Having seen the churches work in Africa, the last thing they're expecting is for those they help to pay them back. The recipients barely have money to survive let alone give some back to the church. They may pay them back with their muscle and sweat, but that's not what you're claiming either. There is little chance that the recipients in Uganda, Sudan, Ethiopia, and where ever the Zimbabwe refugese land will be paying anyone back for a number of generations. If you were to say that to the people of Haiti, they'd laugh in your face.

You could also add the Canadian Martyrs....They converted (or attempted to ) the Canadian Natives for the salvation of souls (both the natives and their own)....You can choose to believe that it was or was not a worthwile endevour, but the natives were not paying them any money.
 
I thought this thread had really jumped the shark, but this is an important question.

It goes to the heart of my objection to many people's angry cries to "bring down the church" etc. or ban the RCC.

Firstly, it is probably not practical. The RCC has over a billion members, in almost every country, and has its own country. While communist countries from time to time have banned the RCC, most people view that as a violation of the basic democratic freedom of religion, and it seems to be able to come back afterwards (although no really strongly Catholic Country has ever banned the RCC).

The second question is that of collective or organizational guilt. Our justice system is effectively built on the principle that individuals do wrong and that individuals who do wrong should bear their own punishment. The idea that an institution or an organization can really be responsible for wrongs is simply foreign to our way of thinking about crime, punishment and guilt. While there are some rare examples in western legal history of the imposition of collective guilt, or worse, guilt by membership, they are rare and viewed with suspicion and concern by most jurists.

Thirdly, there is also the practical question. The RCC is probably the world's largest charitable organization. It does a boatload of good work in places all over the world, and have developed very effective infrastructure to do so. If it was "dismantled" it could well cause more harm that good. Considering the very low number of sex assualt cases going on currently in the RCC, this idea seems less rational day by day.

Point #1) Though they may not have banned the RCC, Quebec was once enslaved by it but has now evolved to a point where the church's influence is minimal. That is how people voice their concerns - less bums in the pews.

Point #2) Have you heard of the Residential Schools or the Chinese Head Tax? These were crimes against humanity committed by institutions and the guilt has clearly fallen on the government and is an example of collective guilt. Slavery is another example: no one is singling out particular slave owners, but rather a condemning of government policy that allowed it.

Point #3) Many criminals were previously considered pillars of the communty, but it does not lessen the crimes they have committed , let alone the systematic attempts to cover up and avoid justice. Apparently Hitler was very good at lifting the German economy.
 
Last edited:
as Father O'Cochrane used to say, "If the penis does not fit, you must jam it!"
 
Point #2) Have you heard of the Residential Schools or the Chinese Head Tax? These were crimes against humanity committed by institutions and the guilt has clearly fallen on the government and is an example of collective guilt.
Actually the issue is vicarious liability in that the individuals who committed the abuse did so within the scope of their employment and the institution knew or should have known of the wrongdoing and did nothing about it, you might wish to see this as collective guilt, however, legally it is far from it.
 
Actually the issue is vicarious liability in that the individuals who committed the abuse did so within the scope of their employment and the institution knew or should have known of the wrongdoing and did nothing about it, you might wish to see this as collective guilt, however, legally it is far from it.

Damn laws again.