Catholic Priest Pedophiles

The answer is because you think the church is more important than the kids.
Actually, I believe what is "more important" is the presumption of innocence in Criminal Trials.

I know they must be guilty, hence therefore they are is little better than a Bill of Attainder and there is good reason why Bills of Attainder haven't been used for well over 150 year in the U.K. and are unconstitutional in the U.S.A.
 
False equivalency. I'm not sure the world is suffering from a surplus of wrongly accused priests (as abhorrent as any one case might be) but we do know that thousands of young boys have been completely and fully destroyed and then stonewalled by a nasty and truly evil monolith headed by the Il Capo Ratzinger.

And by the way, how do you know these two priests were falsely accused? What was the evidence? Just one accusation? Or something more tangible? How did you determine they were falsey accused, and why isn't this in the newspaper?

Playing the witch hunt card is tiresome, but it does show you two morons for what you are. Anyone who reads these threads can see that your false equivalency gives you away. "But the priests" you yell. "But the church does such good work". Divert and deny, divert and deny.

I asked RLD if it was one of his children that was abused, what would he feel like? He called me a drama queen. Interesting, and also revealing. I guess being emotional is a weakness for him.

So by day he fights for the victims of sexual abuse, and in between spends literally tens of hundreds of hours on TERB defending the church and condemning anyone who condemns pedophiles. Interesting. If you don't become emotional about priestly abuse, what exactly would move you? And if you can't afford to be emotional for whatever reason, why would you chase down people that are, and diminish them, as if having sympathy for the victim could be anything other than human.

The answer is because you think the church is more important than the kids. It's rather simple. The church will survive (unfortunately). The kids will suffer forever, and because of clowns like you two who diminish the people that try to reveal the facade.

Yes, we mustn't be too hasty about condemning pedophiles, because they're society's weak and disenfranchised, especially when cosseted by a massively evil organization dressed up in white and funny hats.

10's of thousands hours? No one I've read on TERB has claimed we should look at pedophiles as weak and disenfranchised. You are a drama queen.

So RLD, actually has worked sexual assault cases, so know how it works include the bogus claim by some on anonymity of the accusers and the accused, unlike most of the wannabe legal experts on TERB, and you accuse him of being phony. No one claims we shouldn't condemn pedophiles, another claim from you a self evident drama queen, just not assume guilt until their day in court. That really the basis of their point and basis of most great legal systems in the industrialized world. There must be something worthwhile to it. My position is some accusers are liars. In my little world, I've counted three personal friends whose lives were ruined or nearly ruined by false accusation and attempts at quick justice. I wonder if you're of the mind to hang all those found guilty or simply accused of murder. If we hang a couple of innocent people, that's life, at least the guilty didn't get away with it.
 
All of us would I believe agree with your larger point.

HOWEVER, what I believe you want to say is: If a Priest or a Nun is accused of sexual abuse they should be Inhibited (not allowed to exercise any aspect of their public ministry until the conclusion of trial). If they are convicted they should be Deposed (defrocked), religious authorities should take immediate action including notifying police when accusations are brought to their attention rather than attempting to cover them up.

Well put. I suspect that as well and agree fully.
 
Oh please! Are you really that naive? And just because they don't have shareholders doesn't mean it's not a profitable operation. Are you aware the Vatican is one of the richest institutions in the world? Consider all the lands they own and priceless pieces of art they own.

I am not naive in the slightest. But my experience with sex abuse victims has not come through sitting and watching TV.

You really don't know much about the Vatican. Until a recent clean up, it was losing money. It runs nothing like a business. Not even close. Its expenditures are not designed to make a profit. They are undoubtedly one of the richest NGOs in the world, they also happen to be the oldest and the largest. They have over a billion members.

There is no doubt the Vatican has a great deal of assets. That does not make it a business. I saw a number recently that Catholic charities help fund food, clothes or education for 8,000,000 children in Italy alone. I just don't see how you make a profit at that.
 
I asked RLD if it was one of his children that was abused, what would he feel like? He called me a drama queen. Interesting, and also revealing. I guess being emotional is a weakness for him.

So by day he fights for the victims of sexual abuse, and in between spends literally tens of hundreds of hours on TERB defending the church and condemning anyone who condemns pedophiles. Interesting. If you don't become emotional about priestly abuse, what exactly would move you? And if you can't afford to be emotional for whatever reason, why would you chase down people that are, and diminish them, as if having sympathy for the victim could be anything other than human.

The answer is because you think the church is more important than the kids. It's rather simple. The church will survive (unfortunately). The kids will suffer forever, and because of clowns like you two who diminish the people that try to reveal the facade.

You are a drama queen. One does not set policy or have a rational discussion about an issue by personalizing it as much as possible. I might even call you hysterical and a poor attempt at being a manipulator.

Child abuse is a terrible crime. One of the worst imaginable. Those who do it, should be punished severely.

People who don't do, or have nothing to do it should not be smeared by fools like you because it makes you feel good. If one Jew poisons someone does that make all jews poisoners.

I think you for proving again you are a drama queen. I actually know what 10's of thousands of hours are. Most lawyers don't bill 2500 hours a year, to suggest I literally spend ten's of thousands of hours on TERB is just you being a delusional drama queen. Again. Well done.

The victims of child abuse deserve a more honest, realistic advocate than you. And you are no advocate for them, you are just a hater of the RCC. And dishonest, or careless with the facts.

These children who are abused will likely suffer for the rest of their lives. But it has nothing to do with me. And hopefully nothing to do with you either. They will likely suffer for the rest of their lives because the wounds they have suffered are impossible to fully heal for most of them. For you to use their pain to fuel you own sick, childish, fantasy-like prejudices is really kind of sad.
 
There is no doubt the Vatican has a great deal of assets. That does not make it a business. I saw a number recently that Catholic charities help fund food, clothes or education for 8,000,000 children in Italy alone. I just don't see how you make a profit at that.

Look if you want to be a "Hall of Fame" shameless Catholic Church Apologist at least get some facts right, otherwise people will begin to believe that you just make stuff up to suit.

The facts are that, in total, there are only 4.1 million children under the age of 14 in the whole country which has a population of 61 million. Therefore helping 8 million is probably wrong by a factor of 10 or 20 or more. Of course if helping with food includes the candy that they give the priests for the choir boys........


http://www.indexmundi.com/italy/demographics_profile.html

As far as the Church losing money - tough to tell but certainly it doesn't help to pay out close to $2 billion in settlements to victims in the United States alone amid falling attendence.
http://ncronline.org/blogs/essays-theology/financial-scandal-catholic-church
 
Look if you want to be a "Hall of Fame" shameless Catholic Church Apologist at least get some facts right, otherwise people will begin to believe that you just make stuff up to suit.

The facts are that, in total, there are only 4.1 million children under the age of 14 in the whole country which has a population of 61 million. Therefore helping 8 million is probably wrong by a factor of 10 or 20 or more.

http://www.indexmundi.com/italy/demographics_profile.html

You are quite correct, 8,000,000 was the number of people helped in the US a few years ago. I will poke around and see if I can find the number for Italy again. But my point remains. You don't make a profit helping the poor.
 
You are quite correct, 8,000,000 was the number of people helped in the US a few years ago. I will poke around and see if I can find the number for Italy again. But my point remains. You don't make a profit helping the poor.

You also don't make a profit paying out $2 billion in victim compensation in the US.
 
You are a drama queen. One does not set policy or have a rational discussion about an issue by personalizing it as much as possible. I might even call you hysterical and a poor attempt at being a manipulator.

Child abuse is a terrible crime. One of the worst imaginable. Those who do it, should be punished severely.

People who don't do, or have nothing to do it should not be smeared by fools like you because it makes you feel good. If one Jew poisons someone does that make all jews poisoners.

I think you for proving again you are a drama queen. I actually know what 10's of thousands of hours are. Most lawyers don't bill 2500 hours a year, to suggest I literally spend ten's of thousands of hours on TERB is just you being a delusional drama queen. Again. Well done.

The victims of child abuse deserve a more honest, realistic advocate than you. And you are no advocate for them, you are just a hater of the RCC. And dishonest, or careless with the facts.

These children who are abused will likely suffer for the rest of their lives. But it has nothing to do with me. And hopefully nothing to do with you either. They will likely suffer for the rest of their lives because the wounds they have suffered are impossible to fully heal for most of them. For you to use their pain to fuel you own sick, childish, fantasy-like prejudices is really kind of sad.

Careful counsel, sounds like you're getting emotional.

The victims of child abuse can use every advocate that consciousness can muster, you pretentious fool. You don't even realize how ridiculous you're being in telling who should and shouldn't be an advocate for sexually abused children. Everyone has a role to play in our world jackass. If it wasn't for all the angry voices, the church would still be gliding along as if all was well.

Even today, Ratzinger that scumbag is still pretending it's all a "mystery" why priests abused children. I'm sure biology + powerful institution + the fog of religion can explain it very well!

http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/2012/06/17/catholic-church-sex-abuse_n_1604363.html?utm_hp_ref=canada

Stupidity starts here>>>>>"The weeklong Eucharistic Congress, held by the Vatican every four years in a different part of the world, took place against a backdrop of deep anger over child-abuse coverups and surveys showing declining weekly Mass attendance in Ireland, where church and state were once tightly entwined.

"How are we to explain the fact that people who regularly received the Lord's body and confessed their sins in the sacrament of Penance have offended in this way?" the Pope said, referring to church staff who abused children.

"It remains a mystery," he said. "Yet evidently their Christianity was no longer nourished by joyful encounter with Jesus Christ. It had become merely a matter of habit."<<<<<< Deny and divert. "It's a mystery". Not really Pope.
 
Careful counsel, sounds like you're getting emotional.

The victims of child abuse can use every advocate that consciousness can muster, you pretentious fool. You don't even realize how ridiculous you're being in telling who should and shouldn't be an advocate for sexually abused children. Everyone has a role to play in our world jackass. If it wasn't for all the angry voices, the church would still be gliding along as if all was well.

Even today, Ratzinger that scumbag is still pretending it's all a "mystery" why priests abused children. I'm sure biology + powerful institution + the fog of religion can explain it very well!

http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/2012/06/17/catholic-church-sex-abuse_n_1604363.html?utm_hp_ref=canada

The weeklong Eucharistic Congress, held by the Vatican every four years in a different part of the world, took place against a backdrop of deep anger over child-abuse coverups and surveys showing declining weekly Mass attendance in Ireland, where church and state were once tightly entwined.

"How are we to explain the fact that people who regularly received the Lord's body and confessed their sins in the sacrament of Penance have offended in this way?" the Pope said, referring to church staff who abused children.

"It remains a mystery," he said. "Yet evidently their Christianity was no longer nourished by joyful encounter with Jesus Christ. It had become merely a matter of habit."

Too afraid to respond to the substantive stuff. Still standing behind 10's of thousands of hours? Are are you willing to admit you were just exagerating like the DQ you are?

Does this mean that you can fully explain the phenomena of pedophilia? I guess you don't have any humility like the Pope does. I am not surprised, for the trendy iconoclast like yourself, both facts and humility are anathema.

I don't claim to get to decide who advocates for sex abuse victims, but I have never seen you do so. And if you try to do so, I expect you will again prove yourself a dishonest, hysterical embarassment.
 
You also don't make a profit paying out $2 billion in victim compensation in the US.

That is true but for many years, I believe 25 years in a row, before all these compensation payments were common place, the church lost money. When ~80% of your operating cost goes to charity works, it's no surprise. With that kind of money donated, even if the church was made to pay taxes, they'd be able to write most of them off, so pay little or none at all.

Even in progressive countries like Iceland, a government church tax of <10% is levied for church charities. If you are of no religious belief you pay the University of Iceland charity to the same end.I believe similar government taxes are levied by various European governments as well.
 
Does this mean that you can fully explain the phenomena of pedophilia? I guess you don't have any humility like the Pope does.

Choke. Ratzinger, humility? I'm not sure he'll be remembered by clear thinking people for his "humility".

This is not for you, but for all the people who read your threads to see that the man you admire is as close to a definition of evil as you can get while still wearing a funny hat. It makes everything you type melt into nonsense. I truly wish we were in a real world setting so I could savage all your pretentious bullshit and show you for the pedophile protector you are. Sadly, we aren't. But people can figure it out easy enough so I will be on my way again.

Hitchens:

http://www.slate.com/articles/news_...words/2010/03/the_great_catholic_coverup.html

This is one of my favs:

http://www.nytimes.com/2010/03/25/world/europe/25vatican.html?pagewanted=all

"Top Vatican officials — including the future Pope Benedict XVI — did not defrock a priest who molested as many as 200 deaf boys, even though several American bishops repeatedly warned them that failure to act on the matter could embarrass the church, according to church files newly unearthed as part of a lawsuit."

And on and on it goes. But to you Ratzinger has "humility." Priceless.

I take heart that Ratzinger's wikipedia page is littered with a little reality in there with all the accolades. It's comforting to a simple guy like me who believes in truth, damn the consequences.
 
"How are we to explain the fact that people who regularly received the Lord's body and confessed their sins in the sacrament of Penance have offended in this way? It remains a mystery, yet evidently their Christianity was no longer nourished by joyful encounter with Jesus Christ. It had become merely a matter of habit
You have never said or known anyone else to say - 'I just don't understand why they did what they did, they certainly knew better'?

Neither statement is one of criminology or psychology.
 
Choke. Ratzinger, humility? I'm not sure he'll be remembered by clear thinking people for his "humility".

This is not for you, but for all the people who read your threads to see that the man you admire is as close to a definition of evil as you can get while still wearing a funny hat. It makes everything you type melt into nonsense. I truly wish we were in a real world setting so I could savage all your pretentious bullshit and show you for the pedophile protector you are. Sadly, we aren't. But people can figure it out easy enough so I will be on my way again.

Hitchens:

http://www.slate.com/articles/news_...words/2010/03/the_great_catholic_coverup.html

This is one of my favs:

http://www.nytimes.com/2010/03/25/world/europe/25vatican.html?pagewanted=all

"Top Vatican officials — including the future Pope Benedict XVI — did not defrock a priest who molested as many as 200 deaf boys, even though several American bishops repeatedly warned them that failure to act on the matter could embarrass the church, according to church files newly unearthed as part of a lawsuit."

And on and on it goes. But to you Ratzinger has "humility." Priceless.

I take heart that Ratzinger's wikipedia page is littered with a little reality in there with all the accolades. It's comforting to a simple guy like me who believes in truth, damn the consequences.

Oh no...you would savage me...I am so scared. With your lies and exaggerations?

You lie, exaggerate, and name call, and then run away from your own words like the fearful little man you are.

And if you had read the thread, you would know that we already dealt with the second issue at length, but why bother dealing with the facts. The Pope didn't get around to defrocking a priest who had already been criminally convicted and resigned...that is the best you can do? Pathetic.

Show some balls, if you can explain pedophilia and its origins...do it...or admit the Pope was right in saying it was a mystery.

But you are a coward in all levels. I have never protected a pedo or even acted for one. But you resort to mindless, childish name calling because it is all you have.

Thankfully you are anonymous, because real victims and real advocates would be hurt by having a coward like you claiming to be on their team.


And this Pope, who you clearly irrationally hate, cried when he met with abuse victims...and unlike you...they respect the man and how he dealt with them. But I guess you will want to tell them how to feel next.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/apr/18/pope-child-abuse-sex-abuse


The group's spokesman, Lawrence Grech said the pope had cried during the 20-minute meeting. "I saw the pope cry with emotion and I felt freed of a great weight," he said, adding that Benedict had blessed each of them. " I hadn't been to mass for a long time and I'd lost my faith, but now I feel a confirmed Catholic".

An unnamed victim was quoted in local newspaper the Times of Malta: "We now have peace in our hearts ... because the pope found time to meet us. We now look forward to the end of the court case, and the closure of this chapter."

Go ahead, tell Mr. Grech how evil the church is and how evil the Pope is.
 
rld is obviously pro Vatican or pro Catholicism and refuses to admit the truth about the issues and problems. I give up with him and can't be bothered with him anymore.
 
rld is obviously pro Vatican or pro Catholicism and refuses to admit the truth about the the issues and problems. I give up with him and can't be bothered with him anymore.

I stick to the facts. It is a pretty simple formula that serves me well.

A lovely vague allegation. What truth do you suggest I refuse to admit?

Do you mean like your false allegation that it was Ratzinger's idea to sweep things under the carpet and transfer priests from parish to parish? That was a flat out lie...why should I embrace your dishonesty?

Or your allegation that the RCC has big marketing and advertising budgets...when they don't? Is is your false allegations you want me to embrace?
 
The legal firm of Rid, Aardvaark and the Apologists are merely using their verbal skills to support their previously held biases towards supporting the RCC no matter what shit they pull. The constant reminders of their "profession" don't really add any weight to their argument, but maybe it allows them to bill clients for all the time they spend on terb.
 
The legal firm of Rid, Aardvaark and the Apologists are merely using their verbal skills to support their previously held biases towards supporting the RCC no matter what shit they pull. The constant reminders of their "profession" don't really add any weight to their argument, but maybe it allows them to bill clients for all the time they spend on terb.

Of course my profession has nothing to do with it, although I do represent sexual assualt victims quite often.

But I note, as usual, that your post is completely bereft of facts, argument or analysis. Well done. Creating a post with 0% value, as you often do, is a great skill.
 
The legal firm of Rid, Aardvaark and the Apologists are merely using their verbal skills to support their previously held biases towards supporting the RCC no matter what shit they pull. The constant reminders of their "profession" don't really add any weight to their argument, but maybe it allows them to bill clients for all the time they spend on terb.

Aside from the point that their profession has given first hand knowledge and experience of the inner workings of the legal system and insight on what actual victim think and do, over you and most other members on the BB, not much value at all.

Have you known, counseled, met, or defended any victims or families of victims? Somehow from your comments I doubt you have been a victim, but I could be wrong.
 
A long post. With the good bad and ugly on display.
Pehaps we should remember that throughout history the authority group that has been guilty of the most child abuse is fathers. Even worse than men of God...Fathers in fact are gods to their children. And swept under the rug? Sadly families have been guilty of this as well. Perhaps it show a horrible weakness, in the males of the world.

The long and short of it is men...must do better. Whatever used to be overlooked, must now be seen through a micro-scope. What was in the dark...must be exposed to bright light. It's tough, and pehaps slightly unfair to judge what happened in the past with 2012 sensibilties.

My take on it, is the church had many good, and a few bad. (Wrong was still wrong even if it was overlooked). It is now the job of the good to rebuild trust with the world. The only way this will happen is if every interaction with young people going forward is far above board. I believe most priests know this....now.