By the way, where is blackrock13?
Probably still playing in the :"adult scrabble" thread he created
By the way, where is blackrock13?
Hate to break this to you, but most of the threads on TERB are like that.an escort review board where dignified discussions are entertained by a group of rather intelligent participants
We all know that messing with children is WRONG. If many charges of pedofile points to Catholic or Roman Catholic Church, then they must be doing something WRONG. By the way, where is blackrock13?
why am i not surprised by the fantasy world you and YOUR friend have created for yourselves here: an escort review board where dignified discussions are entertained by a group of rather intelligent participants lol..keep 'em coming. your killing me!
And now the rates are in fact very low.
is the right approach to simply to continue to attack an organization that had such a problem and has almost eliminated it, while ignoring groups that are doing it much more frequently?
How do you know the rates are now low?
The organization you claim has almost eliminated the problem has show they are evasive and obstructive when dealing with accusations. A system of moving molesting priests from parish to parish. Full knowledge that they are molesters, yet passing them on to other parishes. Taking them into the Vatican to be kept under the protective wing of the Church administrators. Yet all is well now.Right.
exactly...the church creates the problem with the oath of celibacy, then they deny that that is the root cause of the problem ( not the only one however - there is also the fact that a priest is a trusted authority figure who must be submitted to and never morally questioned). They further compound their guilt by trying to cover up and avoid dealing firmly with the failed celibates. It is this last point that seriously calls into question their validity as an accepted pillar of our society - unless you are a member of the indy cult band, Aardvaark, Rid and the Deluded Apologists.
Did you all know that the current Pope was the one who drafted the Vatican doctrine for the previous Pope on how to deal with pedophile priests? It was Ratzenburg's idea to sweep these cases under the carpet and just transfer these priests from parish to parish. Makes me sick and disgusted.
Did you all know that the current Pope was the one who drafted the Vatican doctrine for the previous Pope on how to deal with pedophile priests? It was Ratzenburg's idea to sweep these cases under the carpet and just transfer these priests from parish to parish. Makes me sick and disgusted.
Ratz did not take on this role until about 2001.
Incorrect, he was appointed in 1981, here's a quote from the following link:
"The diocese recommended removing Kiesle (KEEZ'-lee) from the priesthood in 1981, the year Ratzinger was appointed to head the Vatican office that shared responsibility for disciplining abusive priests."
More on Ratzinger in this link:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/04/09/pope-benedict-stalled-chi_n_532073.html
Prior to 2001, the primary responsibility for investigating allegations of sexual abuse and disciplining perpetrators rested with the individual dioceses. In 2001, Ratzinger convinced John Paul II to put the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith in charge of all investigations and policies surrounding sexual abuse in order to combat such abuse more efficiently.[131][132] According to John L. Allen, Jr., Ratzinger in the following years "acquired a familiarity with the contours of the problem that virtually no other figure in the Catholic church can claim" and "driven by that encounter with what he would later refer to as 'filth' in the church, Ratzinger seems to have undergone something of a 'conversion experience' throughout 2003–04. From that point forward, he and his staff seemed driven by a convert's zeal to clean up the mess".[133] In his role as Head of the CFD, he "led important changes made in church law: the inclusion in canon law of internet offences against children, the extension of child abuse offences to include the sexual abuse of all under 18, the case by case waiving of the statute of limitation and the establishment of a fast-track dismissal from the clerical state for offenders."[134] As the Head of the CDF, Ratzinger developed a reputation for handling these cases. According to Charles J. Scicluna, a former prosecutor handling sexual abuse cases, "Cardinal Ratzinger displayed great wisdom and firmness in handling those cases, also demonstrating great courage in facing some of the most difficult and thorny cases, sine acceptione personarum (without exceptions)"
You're not reading either, of course he had governance. Ratzinger was appointed in 1981 to head the Vatican office that shared responsibility to discipline abusive priests. The diocese recommended to Ratzinger in 1981 to remove the priest but he let it languish for almost 6 yrs before he defrocked him. Ratzinger had the power to defrock but was stalling as he was more concerned about the impact it would have on the church, meanwhile the accused priest worked with children during that time and God knows what he did.
Whether it was initially a joint governance and later centralized is irrelevant, the bottom line is Ratzinger was in the position to take action on abusive priests and he didn't.
Afterward, Kiesle was sent to therapy and then "offered hospitality" by the pastor at St. Columba in Oakland, Crespin said. Kiesle was removed from the priesthood at his own request in 1981.
The first priority of the Vatican or the Roman Catholic Church is protection and maintenance of its public image........not the protection of those abused by priests! They're a profitable business and like any other business public relations, marketing and advertising are big expenses and of major importance.
Bear in mind that there were many abuse cases which never came to public attention because the Church made settlements with these people and their families to keep the offences out of the lime light.
It is amazing how you can read their minds. They are not like a business because there are no shareholders or CEO's to make a profit. But you might want to spend a few minutes seeing how much money Catholic charities distribute, how many people they feed and educate in third and first world countries, and how many people are treated free of charge in Catholic hospitals in places like the united states. For the Catholic Church, marketing and advertising budgets are almost non-existent. I bet you have seen hundreds of times more ads for UNICEF, or Cancer Groups than for any Catholic charities. They simply run on a different model. I have no idea why you feel the need to make these things up. Care to show some evidence that advertising and marketing are big budgets for the RCC? I would love to see it.
And the question of private settlements is twofold. I have represented a number of sex abuse victims and in almost every case it is the victim who is interested in having their privacy protected. The cases often use pseudonyms for the plaintiffs and the full name for the defendants. Oh say for instance J.J. v. The United Church Priory of X. So the court rules favour protecting pltffs identities. In addition when a diocese settles it has to account for the payout as what it is. So if they pay out $500k for a sex abuse case, that is what it is on the books for.
There are lots of times that there are confidentiality terms in the settlement agreements, usually just to protect the identity of the victim and the amount involved. But even these cases have been accounted for in the numbers of academic studies on the number of victims, the victim patterns and the dates involved.
You seem to be assuming that there were also sorts of anonymous complaints that have had silence bought. Do you have some evidence of this or it is just speculation?
One thing is for sure, that after this became a big public issue, some number of complaints and suits likely were brought without merit. But personally I have no way of quantifying how many such suits were brought or how much money they got, so I don't even try to inject that into the discussion. However it seems the church/religion haters have no compunctions about unfounded accusations built on speculation.
It is amazing how you can read their minds. They are not like a business because there are no shareholders or CEO's to make a profit. But you might want to spend a few minutes seeing how much money Catholic charities distribute, how many people they feed and educate in third and first world countries, and how many people are treated free of charge in Catholic hospitals in places like the united states. For the Catholic Church, marketing and advertising budgets are almost non-existent. I bet you have seen hundreds of times more ads for UNICEF, or Cancer Groups than for any Catholic charities. They simply run on a different model. I have no idea why you feel the need to make these things up. Care to show some evidence that advertising and marketing are big budgets for the RCC? I would love to see it.
And the question of private settlements is twofold. I have represented a number of sex abuse victims and in almost every case it is the victim who is interested in having their privacy protected. The cases often use pseudonyms for the plaintiffs and the full name for the defendants. Oh say for instance J.J. v. The United Church Priory of X. So the court rules favour protecting pltffs identities. In addition when a diocese settles it has to account for the payout as what it is. So if they pay out $500k for a sex abuse case, that is what it is on the books for.
There are lots of times that there are confidentiality terms in the settlement agreements, usually just to protect the identity of the victim and the amount involved. But even these cases have been accounted for in the numbers of academic studies on the number of victims, the victim patterns and the dates involved.
You seem to be assuming that there were also sorts of anonymous complaints that have had silence bought. Do you have some evidence of this or it is just speculation?
One thing is for sure, that after this became a big public issue, some number of complaints and suits likely were brought without merit. But personally I have no way of quantifying how many such suits were brought or how much money they got, so I don't even try to inject that into the discussion. However it seems the church/religion haters have no compunctions about unfounded accusations built on speculation.