I would sue....

Scarey

Well-known member
The parents in a heartbeat.I have a male friend who spent exactly 2 years as a teacher before he quit out of fear of shit happening just like this.His Dad was a teacher and saw the good he could do.I'll never forget a quote he had."My dad used to say kids can be cruel....now some of them are pure evil."

http://news.ca.msn.com/top-stories/falsely-accused-teacher-calls-for-accountability-1

It's a very tricky situation that takes a fair bit of balancing.

Let's say the young child is a liar, and his parents believed him. You can't sue the parents or punish the parents for believing the child. You have to investigate every allegation of abuse, because abuse is real and can ruin children.

If the parents made the shit up and you can prove it than you can punish them, but you have to be careful not to discourage others from coming forward with legit complaints.

I have represented a number of victims of teacher sexual abuse and in many of the cases the parents and principals did not at first believe the complaints which compounded the problem.

Will kids lie from time to time? Sure. does that make them "pure evil." I think not.
 
Something is certainly way out of balance here. I agree that there should be some sort of accountability for students and parents when blatantly false allegations are made. The consequences for the teachers involved are very serious.
 
Teachers (all adults for that matter) should give up trying to teach/install even the simplest and most benign values in other peoples' kids. She should have let the kid throw the banana away without making any comment at all. In today's world, there are just too many ways for things to go wrong.
 
Teachers (all adults for that matter) should give up trying to teach/install even the simplest and most benign values in other peoples' kids. She should have let the kid throw the banana away without making any comment at all. In today's world, there are just too many ways for things to go wrong.


Accept now you have the Boomerang lunch program where children have to put their garbage back in their lunch bags to bring home so that the school is not responsible for throwing away excess garbage or can not be held account for the lack of recycling and composting.

So again, damned if you do and damned if you don't.

As for the false accusations, I think if they are found to be false, the parents should pay the fees involved in the investigation. At the very least. Not to mention any loss of income to the party being falsely accused. It is a start. It is done after the fact, so the outcome of the investigation determines if the parents have to pay and ensure the safety of the children being met. It does not matter if the child lied to their parents or not. As parents we are still responsible for our children, right or wrong.
 
I have a male friend who spent exactly 2 years as a teacher before he quit out of fear of shit happening just like this.
Tell him he can't run from the fear, another child will take him down. :eyebrows:
He can still be arrested after someone makes a false accusation in the community, doesn't have to be in a classroom.
 
Ridiculous that it came to this. That spoiled little kid will be running back to his parents when he is 30 years old and someone hurts his feelings.
 
Accept now you have the Boomerang lunch program where children have to put their garbage back in their lunch bags to bring home so that the school is not responsible for throwing away excess garbage or can not be held account for the lack of recycling and composting.

So again, damned if you do and damned if you don't.

As for the false accusations, I think if they are found to be false, the parents should pay the fees involved in the investigation. At the very least. Not to mention any loss of income to the party being falsely accused. It is a start. It is done after the fact, so the outcome of the investigation determines if the parents have to pay and ensure the safety of the children being met. It does not matter if the child lied to their parents or not. As parents we are still responsible for our children, right or wrong.

As long as you don't mind parents not reporting serious problems in the future...
 
I've had a teacher friend threatened that he would be accused of abuse via an anonymous phone call which he knew sounded like some student that didn't like him for some reason (it was a voice mail message). Luckily, another teacher saw said student at a nearby phone booth at around the time of the phone call, and the student taken to task.

I've heard other examples of unruly and cruel if not evil high school students doing things against teachers.

Parents will believe their kids no matter what (I remember the day when the teacher was always right). One parent said there should be video cameras in the classrooms. At 1st, my friend thought this was a stupid if not illegal thing to do, but perhaps it might empower teachers and keep the unruly kids in check.
 
Teachers (all adults for that matter) should give up trying to teach/install even the simplest and most benign values in other peoples' kids. She should have let the kid throw the banana away without making any comment at all. In today's world, there are just too many ways for things to go wrong.

Years ago, good teachers also instilled values. Mind you, it's probably not a teacher's job to scold students not to waste food. Damned if they do, damned if they don't.
 
I tend to agree. Don't sweat the small stuff.

(and as if anyone would eat half a banana after its been in a lunch box all afternoon, it would be all icky ... it was garbage)

If she wasn't a new supply teacher and had a good rapport with the kids, she probably could suggest that he have the banana cut in half so he could have the option of eating only half. But you're right, she can't worry about correcting every small detail.
 
I've had a teacher friend threatened that he would be accused of abuse via an anonymous phone call which he knew sounded like some student that didn't like him for some reason (it was a voice mail message). Luckily, another teacher saw said student at a nearby phone booth at around the time of the phone call, and the student taken to task.

I've heard other examples of unruly and cruel if not evil high school students doing things against teachers.

Parents will believe their kids no matter what (I remember the day when the teacher was always right).One parent said there should be video cameras in the classrooms. At 1st, my friend thought this was a stupid if not illegal thing to do, but perhaps it might empower teachers and keep the unruly kids in check.

Ahhh... The good ol' days. Remember when you got into trouble at school and dare not tell your parents? Well the balance has reversed to the point where the teacher (who used to be an extension of the parent), can do no more than turn a blind eye.

And we wonder why kids don't learn a thing at school....
 
Ridiculous that it came to this. That spoiled little kid will be running back to his parents when he is 30 years old and someone hurts his feelings.

Sadly yes, he will. It ALL starts at home and parents these days are in many cases too lazy, too busy or just don't care enough to be the best parents they can be.
 
Sadly yes, he will. It ALL starts at home and parents these days are in many cases too lazy, too busy or just don't care enough to be the best parents they can be.
Add too afraid to this list as well. Many parents are "afraid" that there kids won't like them if they act like parents and not like a "best friend".
 
Parents will believe their kids no matter what (I remember the day when the teacher was always right). One parent said there should be video cameras in the classrooms. At 1st, my friend thought this was a stupid if not illegal thing to do, but perhaps it might empower teachers and keep the unruly kids in check.

Sadly, this is not the case. On many occasions I have represented victims of teacher sexual abuse whose parents did no believe them, even when later it was proven with 100% certainty the abuse had taken place.

I think the idea of the cameras is not a bad one at all.