How to regulate indoor sex work

Point taken.

I'll say this. If the prostitution case goes to the Supreme Court of Canada, my money is on Alan Young and the people who started the challenge. I'll forget trying to get any stats and go with my gut.

Alan Young has been kicking ass and taking names for years. His list of names he's beat include Trudeau, Mulroney, Cretien, Martin and now Harper. Just about every Prime Minister over the last 20ish years has lost to him.

I hardly bet they're going to make a legal challenge in the Supreme Courts, more than likely they'll reword the laws and pass a new anti-prostitution law.
 
I hardly bet they're going to make a legal challenge in the Supreme Courts, more than likely they'll reword the laws and pass a new anti-prostitution law.

I hope you're right but I'm skeptical.

I think the government is going to feel heat from some of its base to challenge the ruling. It may sound cynical, but sometimes governments launch challenges even when the legal merits are dubious.

For example, Ontario Attorney General John Gerretsen was already talking on Monday about appealing this decision to the Supreme Court. I would say his comments to the press made it pretty clear his statement was based on concerns about public opinion, rather than a careful consideration of the ruling.

http://www.torontosun.com/2012/03/26/ontario-eyes-appeal-of-brothel-ruling
 
Ok, here is a rough timeline.

1) Trudeau "legalized" homos in 1974.
2) Touch dancing was 'legalized" in 1995. The usual suspects were crying "the sky is falling, the sky is falling".
3) Same sex marriages legalized in 2008.
4) Consensual adult sex made illegal by Stephen Harper in 2014. If Harper is smart, he would leave this thing alone like he did with same sex marriage and blame it on the courts. No man, not even Stephen Harper, is more powerful:p than the Constitution.
 
Correct me if I am wrong. But I've read somewhere Layton actually was found naked in a massage parlour. He's hobbying this kinda entertainment but would like to put a ban in it? :confused:

Perhaps he was worried his favourite rub and tug would go under if lap dancing got to be too popular.
 
Why change anything? What is wrong with the status quo? You go to the condo:cool: 10 minutes early. You call the agency for th passcode. They say call back in 15 minutes. You call back in 15 minutes and nobody answers. Hee, hee, hee.
 
no prob :) (usually it's me that is guilty of this but...) give me some room in your inbox :P
Done :thumb:

Ok, here is a rough timeline.

1) Trudeau "legalized" homos in 1974.
2) Touch dancing was 'legalized" in 1995. The usual suspects were crying "the sky is falling, the sky is falling".
3) Same sex marriages legalized in 2008.
4) Consensual adult sex made illegal by Stephen Harper in 2014. If Harper is smart, he would leave this thing alone like he did with same sex marriage and blame it on the courts. No man, not even Stephen Harper, is more powerful:p than the Constitution.

4) sooner than 2014. Conservatives typically try to criminalize any activities they don't approve of. And apparently sex between unmarried consenting adults is "bad for society" :confused:
"As the prime minister has said, prostitution is bad for society and harmful to communities, women and vulnerable persons," Justice Minister Rob Nicholson in a statement emailed to Postmedia News.
The Conservatives are going to have to try to overturn this ruling and impose stricter, probably mandatory sentencing for escorts and clients.

The idea of adding 'brothels' to already-existing strip clubs makes sense for management, but I don't know if the dancers would be happy about having that sort of competition in the same building.
 
It will be not be the 15 -20 girl brothels that will spring up like mushrooms because of the change in law. What you will see is a lot of one or two girl operations opening up without fear of being interfered with by the police. I know a guy that works for a company that owns over 300 very large properties in Toronto. He tells me that in the 40 high rise apartment buildings that his company manages, every one of them has at least one apartment where a woman is offering sex services that they know about. Many of these buildings have more than one apartment where sex is offered. He tells me that it is not just the young women that offer these services, there have been a few cases where women in their mid 40s and over 50 have lost their jobs due to downsizing at their companies have stopped paying their rent. A quick fix for these women is that they will put an ad in the Craigslist and offer massage ( +? ) or offer companionship at their apartments. There will be less regulation for people that are already offering services. I think there will be a lot more temps getting in the biz because of the change in law.

8VIvZ.jpg
 
The idea of adding 'brothels' to already-existing strip clubs makes sense for management, but I don't know if the dancers would be happy about having that sort of competition in the same building.

I'm guessing it's been a while since you've been to a strip club.
 
The idea of adding 'brothels' to already-existing strip clubs makes sense for management, but I don't know if the dancers would be happy about having that sort of competition in the same building.
Many dancers would be more than happy. One advantage of an SC is that the girl you see is the girl you see and not some retouched photos on a website.
 
It will be not be the 15 -20 girl brothels that will spring up like mushrooms because of the change in law. What you will see is a lot of one or two girl operations opening up without fear of being interfered with by the police. I know a guy that works for a company that owns over 300 very large properties in Toronto. He tells me that in the 40 high rise apartment buildings that his company manages, every one of them has at least one apartment where a woman is offering sex services that they know about. Many of these buildings have more than one apartment where sex is offered. He tells me that it is not just the young women that offer these services, there have been a few cases where women in their mid 40s and over 50 have lost their jobs due to downsizing at their companies have stopped paying their rent. A quick fix for these women is that they will put an ad in the Craigslist and offer massage ( +? ) or offer companionship at their apartments. There will be less regulation for people that are already offering services. I think there will be a lot more temps getting in the biz because of the change in law.
8VIvZ.jpg
that does not sound too promising
the point of a brothel for me is to have an actual choice
a 1-2 women operation is a fucked up concept, because without the boss overseeing an operation the stupid bitches gonna charge prices that are not commensurable with their age, appearance etc.
 
Jennifer, when you can safely operate out of your own place, no neon sign is needed. I'll just slip thru the back door. ;)
 
Done :thumb:



4) sooner than 2014. Conservatives typically try to criminalize any activities they don't approve of. And apparently sex between unmarried consenting adults is "bad for society" :confused:

The Conservatives are going to have to try to overturn this ruling and impose stricter, probably mandatory sentencing for escorts and clients.

The idea of adding 'brothels' to already-existing strip clubs makes sense for management, but I don't know if the dancers would be happy about having that sort of competition in the same building.

Relax the Conservative fear-mongering Matt. I already told Rockslinger that no P.M. is above the law (i.e., the Constitution).
 
Relax the Conservative fear-mongering Matt. I already told Rockslinger that no P.M. is above the law (i.e., the Constitution).
I don't fear Conservatives, GPIDEAL. I hate them.

And your guarantee is not convincing me that the Harper gov't is not going to try to outlaw prostitution. Election laws mean nothing to them, and their attempts at internet snoopig demonstrated they don't care about our right to privacy. So I doubt the Constitution will stop them from coming up with some attempt.
"As the prime minister has said, prostitution is bad for society and harmful to communities, women and vulnerable persons," Justice Minister Rob Nicholson said in an emailed statement. "We are reviewing the decision and our legal options. The Ontario Court of Appeal has affirmed the validity of the ban on solicitation for the purposes of selling sex. We continue to see a social need for laws to control prostitution and its effects on society."

That does not seem like the words of a gov't that is going to accept the current lawless status.
 
I'm guessing it's been a while since you've been to a strip club.
True, and on refelction I could be wrong. Last time I was at the Brass Rail was around 5 years ago.


Although, in fairness, the Liberal government in Ontario has said pretty much the same thing.
Yeah I know. Too bad the Liberals these days are trying so hard to be 'centrist' that they've moved many policies to the right.
http://www.torontosun.com/2012/03/26/ontario-eyes-appeal-of-brothel-ruling
“Our main concern is that people feel safe in their communities,” he said, adding he believes the law has served Canadians well over the years.

The Ontario government has 60 days to launch an appeal.

Gerretsen said he wants to talk to his counterparts in Ottawa because if the law needs to be rewritten, it will fall to the federal government to do so.

“It’s their criminal law that’s basically called into question here,” he said. “They’re the people who will have to deal with this issue if any legislative action is to be taken.”
Safe from what? As far as crimes go, men and women hooking up for sex indoors is about the least noticeable by 'communities'.
Seems like the Ontario gov't (Garretsen) wants to let the feds deal with this problem.

PC Leader Tim Hudak said he hopes that the Dalton McGuinty government will make it very clear that it will appeal this court decision to legalize brothels in the province.

“This is not in keeping with the values of the vast majority of Ontarians,” Hudak said Monday.
I wish reporters would call BULLSH!T whenever politicians make up statistics on the spot. Especially when they're wrong.
Globe and Mail poll (of course it's statistically flawed but still)
78% in favour of decrim
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news...inalize-brothels/article2381449/?from=2381372

Toronto Sun poll of Canadians
47% approve, 36% disapprove
http://www.torontosun.com/2012/03/28/canadians-coming-around-to-brothels-poll
 
I don't fear Conservatives, GPIDEAL. I hate them.

Hate comes from fear, ignorance or misunderstanding. If I can't quell your concerns, then you should find a Conservative SP (not MP lol) who might get you to like one.

And your guarantee is not convincing me that the Harper gov't is not going to try to outlaw prostitution. Election laws mean nothing to them, and their attempts at internet snooping demonstrated they don't care about our right to privacy. So I doubt the Constitution will stop them from coming up with some attempt.

They haven't outlawed it and can't outlaw it (That would mean a waste of taxpayer's money because it would be challenged and not prevail as a new law, particularly in light of the recent SCOC decision). The Constitution or Charter of Rights & Freedoms is the supreme law of the land. It is non-partisan. Judges are not politicians. They can overrule bad laws. The internet snooping thing was not aimed at eavesdropping on the average citizen but criminals who hide behind privacy laws. Unfortunately, the law drafted is imperfect, but also a threat to a very tiny group of people concerned about their hobbying secret on a review board which the majority of society might not sympathize with us. Legislation proposed by Liberal governments have also been subject to Constitutional challenges.

As the prime minister has said, prostitution is bad for society and harmful to communities, women and vulnerable persons," Justice Minister Rob Nicholson said in an emailed statement. "We are reviewing the decision and our legal options. The Ontario Court of Appeal has affirmed the validity of the ban on solicitation for the purposes of selling sex. We continue to see a social need for laws to control prostitution and its effects on society."

That does not seem like the words of a gov't that is going to accept the current lawless status.

He mentions the ban on public solicitation, or the SW face of the industry, which nobody likes. Also, the comment about continuing to see a social need for laws to CONTROL prostitution is not meant to abolish or outlaw it, just regulate it, not ban it.

They are politicians. They have to make a comment that makes them look good. Like it or not, WE here on Terb are a tiny minority in the electorate or mainstream society, who probably don't share our views, and perhaps who find the court decision a little disturbing. Ironically, their fear is borne out of ignorance too.