Where do atheists get their morals? (The Atheist Experience)

I respectfully disagree. Teaching a child morals because it's a better way to develop/maintain a positive community doesn't need any level of faith.

I think each family has a right to raise their children the way they want. But teaching a young person about abstract ideas like community and positivity etc sounds pretty complicated.
 
There is also opinion that the humans have not found an answer to this question and likely never will.

.... and I'll except that, but until then, to over simplify it, let someone who finds solace in religion as a group or one on one practice it in peace or we are no better than Stalinist Russia.
 
Yeah, I'm somewhat familiar with the subject, from both fiction and non-fiction sources. But usually the information is only a subtext to a larger point, such as Tom Harpur's book about the Pagan Christ. I'd love to find a nicely written book or article that is primarily focused on the Bible's creation and is easy to read, if such a thing exists.

Here is a very good one on the NT:

http://www.amazon.ca/The-New-Testam...=sr_1_3?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1332954050&sr=1-3
 
I think each family has a right to raise their children the way they want. But teaching a young person about abstract ideas like community and positivity etc sounds pretty complicated.
I am not sure that a family has a right to raise their children the way the want. Let alone the moral right.

And abstract ideas like community and positivity sound just as difficult to accept as a story about the old man in the sky.
 
I am not sure that a family has a right to raise their children the way the want. Let alone the moral right.

And abstract ideas like community and positivity sound just as difficult to accept as a story about the old man in the sky.

Well either a family as a right to raise their child the way they want, or the state or someone else will dictate it to them. Do you think what a family should teach its children should be dictated by an outside authority?

And my understanding (admittedly limited) of moral development in children is that punishment and discipline can be taught very early, while more abstract comments have to wait, and some people never develop those abstract reasoning skills at all.
 
Well either a family as a right to raise their child the way they want, or the state or someone else will dictate it to them. Do you think what a family should teach its children should be dictated by an outside authority?

And my understanding (admittedly limited) of moral development in children is that punishment and discipline can be taught very early, while more abstract comments have to wait, and some people never develop those abstract reasoning skills at all.
I think that the society should at the very least regulate things like corporal punishment.
 
I think that the society should at the very least regulate things like corporal punishment.

I agree. But that is a long way away from setting the agenda on what morals parents can teach their kids, which is what we were talking about.
 
Open mind

Yup what you learned in life . You argue that atheism is bs in a threads about atheism

atheism is BS.


but organized religion is also bs. You`re all over the place. You learned stuff really well.

If atheism is bs and organized religion is bs what is left? Oh, FASTs opinion.

I`ll try to help to you out here again, the reason I said the label, “atheism” was bs, ( I could have used a better adjective) is because, from the time the term was coined, it has been used as a pejorative.

Therefore, the label is widely misused, especially by the religious.

I never denied that there are “groups” of atheists, and funny enough, are starting to sound like they have “found religion” in their zeal to prove their point.

I, and a LOT of people are NOT one of them, get that through your little narrow minded head.

When somebody asks me if I believe in a god, I say no, the reply is invariably “so you are an atheist”, my reply is …… NO.

To put in simple terms for you, ….. the absence of a belief in myths, does NOT require a label, except of coarse, you are religious.

I know its hard for some people to “think out side the box”, but just try, its good for you, helps develop your brain.


FAST
 
It is amazing the double standard that is applied to religion. Simply amazing.

I have yet to meet anyone who lives perfectly, by a perfect code and never does anything hypocritical or self interested. Yet the non-religious expect to hold the religious up to a standard that they themselves cannot meet. Talk about disingenuous.

Have you ever joined a secular or political organization that does everything the way you want for the reasons you want? Do all of your friends or members of your community think exactly the way you think they should? Do you ever try to convince someone that they are wrong but your point of view is right?

What gives a person the right to choose which religious laws to follow? The same thing that gives you the right to choose to follow none of them if you don't want to. Freedom and reason.

By the by, there is nothing in the Bible saying abortion is wrong. In fact, the only inference that can really be drawn from the Bible about this issue is that a fetus is not a person until birth.

And Bill Maher is the only show I never miss. If you get the chance to see him live you should...he is amazing.

The non-believers have a right to be pissed, because we have the beliefs of the pious rammed down our throats . Why is prostitution hampered by the state? Not for any rational reason...it just offends the church ladies!
 
Why is prostitution hampered by the state? Not for any rational reason...it just offends the church ladies!
I guess one can make an argument that it decreases the value of civilian vagina on the market and is therefore an unfair trade practice.
 
I thought Baptists hated missionary position sex because it could lead to dancing?

The way you young people dance, that could be true.

In my day, the joke was Baptists don't like to have sex standing up because it could lead to dancing.
 
I'll try to help to you out here again, the reason I said the label, “atheism” was bs, ( I could have used a better adjective) is because, from the time the term was coined, it has been used as a pejorative.

Therefore, the label is widely misused, especially by the religious.

I never denied that there are “groups” of atheists, and funny enough, are starting to sound like they have “found religion” in their zeal to prove their point.

I, and a LOT of people are NOT one of them, get that through your little narrow minded head.

When somebody asks me if I believe in a god, I say no, the reply is invariably “so you are an atheist”, my reply is …… NO.

To put in simple terms for you, ….. the absence of a belief in myths, does NOT require a label, except of coarse, you are religious.

I know its hard for some people to “think out side the box”, but just try, its good for you, helps develop your brain.


FAST

The pejorative use is predominately by idiots, I've not seen that much on this BB. If someone assumes you're an atheist because you don't simply believe in God, then he's ignorant, as he doesn't realize there's middle ground. As for the use of labels, they're used all the time. Right or wrong that's how many things operate. as for my not thinking outside the box, I often get a paycheck for doing just that, but hey. anyone who claims they don't labels people, bullshit. Everyone does it. That's how we think.

As for your claiming there aren't groups of atheist, you must be confusing me with somebody else. I didn't make that charge against you.

Keep swinging.
 
The pejorative use is predominately by idiots, I've not seen that much on this BB. If someone assumes you're an atheist because you don't simply believe in God, then he's ignorant, as he doesn't realize there's middle ground. As for the use of labels, they're used all the time. Right or wrong that's how many things operate. as for my not thinking outside the box, I often get a paycheck for doing just that, but hey. anyone who claims they don't labels people, bullshit. Everyone does it. That's how we think.

As for your claiming there aren't groups of atheist, you must be confusing me with somebody else. I didn't make that charge against you.

Keep swinging.


Please tell me HOW one is to know in what manner the label is being applied to a person.
The person using the label could genuinely believe it is not a pejorative, or the person is using it in a negative fashion, usually the religious.
No way of knowing, but just confirms the use of the label is defective.

And I’m not talking about terb, but in public, shit, I've been called worst than that here.

Anyway, I’m glad you agree with me, that the general use of the atheist label IS NOT correct.

HOME RUN

FAST
 
Please tell me HOW one is to know in what manner the label is being applied to a person.
The person using the label could genuinely believe it is not a pejorative, or the person is using it in a negative fashion, usually the religious.
No way of knowing, but just confirms the use of the label is defective.

And I’m not talking about terb, but in public, shit, I've been called worst than that here.

Anyway, I’m glad you agree with me, that the general use of the atheist label IS NOT correct.

HOME RUN

FAST

Fuck you really are dumb or trolling, I can't tell.

Every time you see a person you label them, whether that label stick depends on what happens.A label as simple as 'hot' or 'not hot'. Then you talk to them and decide right or wrong, smart or dumb and you go from there. Even if you can't decide right away, you then file it under 'later'. Humans think binaurally and the result governs the next label. The human brain can only work on one thought at a time and the result of that thought is labelled so you can find it later The fact that the brain works really fast saves a lot of time.

I don't agree with you that atheist isn't correct, just one of a few possibilities.

I have not doubt that you've been called worse.

Most of the live humans I talk to don't think of the term atheist as a pejorative term (can't speak for all of course), even the staunchest French RC in my family on my SO's side.
 
There is no god in buddhism so they're all buddhists who believe if you fuck with karma, it will fuck you back even harder.
 
For anyone who ponders the question and tries to come up with a general rule for his own good conduct, ignoring all other influences and authorities, do as you would be done by is the only sensible answer.
 
Last edited:
BLACKROCK'S binaural brain does NOT multitask

Fuck you really are dumb or trolling, I can't tell.

Every time you see a person you label them, whether that label stick depends on what happens.A label as simple as 'hot' or 'not hot'. Then you talk to them and decide right or wrong, smart or dumb and you go from there. Even if you can't decide right away, you then file it under 'later'. Humans think binaurally and the result governs the next label. The human brain can only work on one thought at a time and the result of that thought is labelled so you can find it later The fact that the brain works really fast saves a lot of time.

I don't agree with you that atheist isn't correct, just one of a few possibilities.

I have not doubt that you've been called worse.

Most of the live humans I talk to don't think of the term atheist as a pejorative term (can't speak for all of course), even the staunchest French RC in my family on my SO's side.

First, binaural, means 2, two.
And after reading your last post, I'm preparied to help you out in another area.

So I am including a link ...... http://www.mentalhealthcanada.com/

You really do need help dude, or are you just "off your meds".

If you are a cop, I sure would't want to be approached by you in an attempt to charge me with "J-walking".

Sorry, I won't be replying to any of your posts, well maybe when your medicated again.

HAT TRICK

FAST