Where do atheists get their morals? (The Atheist Experience)

They forgot to mention that the New Testament was written hundreds of years later under the influence of the Church.... They forgot to point out all the inconsistencies between the books of the Bible. (But who cares cuz Matthew, Mark, Luke, John, etc. were telling things as they happened - no need to question it....)

The gospels of Matthew, Mark, Luke and John were written around 70--90. The writings of the apostle Paul
were written at an earlier time probably about 1--2 decades after Christ.

This is not meant to be a defense of the truthfulness of the scriptures. But even as an unbeliever
I always tried to be fair and factual in my arguments against the Christian faith.
 
The gospels of Matthew, Mark, Luke and John were written around 70--90. The writings of the apostle Paul
were written at an earlier time probably about 1--2 decades after Christ.

This is not meant to be a defense of the truthfulness of the scriptures. But even as an unbeliever
I always tried to be fair and factual in my arguments against the Christian faith.

I've often wondered -- is there any easy-to-follow book or guide that describes the story of how the Bible came about?

I tried one time to find something online, but naturally I ended up with a whole bunch of sources that explained why "God" gave the Bible to mankind. Not exactly what I was seeking.

I'm interested in the history of the Bible, but only in the simplified version. Nothing too taxing for my short attention span.
 
I was listening to CBC radio on Sunday of all things. I finally found out what was my beef with religion. I don't "hate" or "dislike" religion I just don't approve of "organized religion". As Jen so masterfully stated the inconsistencies of organized religion I think this is the very reason why so many people, at least in N.A., say they are "spiritual" but not "religious". Organized religion in my opinion is not divine inspired as many want us to believe but is flawed like any other human institution. Who is to say what goes or doesn't? Who decides what text make up the 'bible' we use today? It was a human institution with their own agenda not divine origin. I have always heard the argument that they are divine driven working by the 'hand of god'. Hmmmm, if that were true then why all the inconsistencies and contradictions of interpretation, does god like controversy and discontent and furthering people's careers in these organization ??? :frusty:
 
... If you are going to remove religion, you need to replace it with something,....
I respectfully disagree. Teaching a child morals because it's a better way to develop/maintain a positive community doesn't need any level of faith.
 
How dare you

I was listening to CBC radio on Sunday of all things. I finally found out what was my beef with religion. I don't "hate" or "dislike" religion I just don't approve of "organized religion". As Jen so masterfully stated the inconsistencies of organized religion I think this is the very reason why so many people, at least in N.A., say they are "spiritual" but not "religious". Organized religion in my opinion is not divine inspired as many want us to believe but is flawed like any other human institution. Who is to say what goes or doesn't? Who decides what text make up the 'bible' we use today? It was a human institution with their own agenda not divine origin. I have always heard the argument that they are divine driven working by the 'hand of god'. Hmmmm, if that were true then why all the inconsistencies and contradictions of interpretation, does god like controversy and discontent and furthering people's careers in these organization ??? :frusty:

Wait for it, your about to be told by the all knowing, all seeing people here !!!!

Who are you to have that opionion about religion, thats just NOT allowed, your going to hell, what ever that is.

FAST
 
re golden rule - there is absolutely no fucking golden rule outside of religion or upbringing by parents whose parents were religious.

If anything, the real golden rule is Homo homini lupus est*

*it is a Latin phrase meaning "man is a wolf to [his fellow] man." First attested in Plautus' Asinaria (495, "lupus est homo homini"), the phrase is sometimes translated as "man is man's wolf", which can be interpreted to mean that man preys upon man. It is widely referenced when discussing the horrors of which humans are capable. - wiki

Your view is clearly the view of religious types to justify the need for religion, sort of like Colonial Brits discussing the White Man's Burden to civilize the savages. We could discuss how cultures using god's will as a reason to oppress and conquer is an example how God's Laws are no better than Man's.
 
They rent their morals from Anglicans who cheat on their wives :)
 
...
What gives a person the right to choose which religious laws to follow? The same thing that gives you the right to choose to follow none of them if you don't want to. Freedom and reason. ....

And that shows we need religion because of..............? Sounds like you are arguing against the need for religiously mandated morals.
 
I respectfully disagree. Teaching a child morals because it's a better way to develop/maintain a positive community doesn't need any level of faith.
why would a child believe that the community interests should come before his/her personal interests?
 
I've often wondered -- is there any easy-to-follow book or guide that describes the story of how the Bible came about?

I tried one time to find something online, but naturally I ended up with a whole bunch of sources that explained why "God" gave the Bible to mankind. Not exactly what I was seeking.

I'm interested in the history of the Bible, but only in the simplified version. Nothing too taxing for my short attention span.

Old Testament - oral tradition eventually recorded (in the way that God's will said it should?)
New Testament - a selection of religious writings selected from a larger group and edited by the Church starting with the Council of Nicea (again, divinely inspired to remove any heresy?). The Dead Sea Scrolls are believed to be an example of non-accepted gospels.
 
They rent their morals from Anglicans who cheat on their wives :)

Or maybe from those Baptists who think dancing leads to sex.

Those Baptists are wrong, by the way. After I first heard that theory, I went dancing every night for the next two weeks, and I didn't get anything.
 
afterhours said:
why would a child believe that the community interests should come before his/her personal interests?

They don't have to. It's their parents who are teaching them who see the need. It's not like young kids see religion as a reason for their actions either.

You could quite simply look at kids raised by criminal parents and see how the kids morals are likely to be similar to their examples.
 
Old Testament - oral tradition eventually recorded (in the way that God's will said it should?)
New Testament - a selection of religious writings selected from a larger group and edited by the Church starting with the Council of Nicea (again, divinely inspired to remove any heresy?). The Dead Sea Scrolls are believed to be an example of non-accepted gospels.

Yeah, I'm somewhat familiar with the subject, from both fiction and non-fiction sources. But usually the information is only a subtext to a larger point, such as Tom Harpur's book about the Pagan Christ. I'd love to find a nicely written book or article that is primarily focused on the Bible's creation and is easy to read, if such a thing exists.
 
Wait for it, your about to be told by the all knowing, all seeing people here !!!!

Who are you to have that opionion about religion, thats just NOT allowed, your going to hell, what ever that is.

FAST

Na!, they'll that special observation just for you. Having just an opinion is not wrong, but having an opinion based on little else, but your opinion, is really weak.
 
Real

Na!, they'll that special observation just for you. Having just an opinion is not wrong, but having an opinion based on little else, but your opinion, is really weak.

MY opinion is based on what I have learned in life, NOT what is in some book of myths, or a bunch of self appointed guru,s.

What do you base your opinion on, oh wait, you never have one, except what has been pounded into your head.

But I understand your upset, losing all of the arguments.

FAST
 
MY opinion is based on what I have learned in life, NOT what is in some book of myths, or a bunch of self appointed guru,s.

What do you base your opinion on, oh wait, you never have one, except what has been pounded into your head.

But I understand your upset, losing all of the arguments.

FAST

Yup what you learned in life . You argue that atheism is bs in a threads about atheism

atheism is BS.


but organized religion is also bs. You`re all over the place. You learned stuff really well.

If atheism is bs and organized religion is bs what is left? Oh, FASTs opinion.
 
Yup what you learned in life . You argue that atheism is bs in a threads about atheism
atheism is BS.

but organized religion is also bs. You`re all over the place. You learned stuff really well.
If atheism is bs and organized religion is bs what is left? Oh, FASTs opinion.
There is also opinion that the humans have not found an answer to this question and likely never will.
 
Yeah, I'm somewhat familiar with the subject, from both fiction and non-fiction sources. But usually the information is only a subtext to a larger point, such as Tom Harpur's book about the Pagan Christ. I'd love to find a nicely written book or article that is primarily focused on the Bible's creation and is easy to read, if such a thing exists.

Harper's book is really bad. His Egyptology is about 100 years out of date and his main source for translations and his theory was some weird school teacher with a bunch of strange theories. No one in the field of Egyptology or classical or biblical studies gives it any shrift at all.

I might have some references for academic texts on the origins of the OT and NT at home, I will see if I can find them for you.
 
And that shows we need religion because of..............? Sounds like you are arguing against the need for religiously mandated morals.

We live with religiously mandated morals every day...and it has built this society we cherish.

But I don't think religious people should be held to a higher standard than anyone else.