Where do atheists get their morals? (The Atheist Experience)

re golden rule - there is absolutely no fucking golden rule outside of religion or upbringing by parents whose parents were religious.

If anything, the real golden rule is Homo homini lupus est*

*it is a Latin phrase meaning "man is a wolf to [his fellow] man." First attested in Plautus' Asinaria (495, "lupus est homo homini"), the phrase is sometimes translated as "man is man's wolf", which can be interpreted to mean that man preys upon man. It is widely referenced when discussing the horrors of which humans are capable. - wiki

I think you are quite right about that.
 
You can come to conclusions about what systems of governance and what shared moral ideas make a community thrive and which don't work well at all.

Studying people, or individuals is fascinating, but it doesn't really take you too far with governance or political science.
I will worry about governance when I will have a country to govern. Since I don't have one, my primary concern is to not let those in power to cheat me into obedience using, among other things, religion.
 
Secular Humanism suggests a morality based on reason, because if we all act well towards each other, we'll all get along and be happy.
 
Secular Humanism suggests a morality based on reason, because if we all act well towards each other, we'll all get along and be happy.

Funny you should mention, one SP has recently preached this to me. I had to point out to her that my little issue with this notion is that I like to fuck women who are significantly younger than me. That seems to require dominating over other males rather than merely getting along with them and being happy.
 
I will worry about governance when I will have a country to govern. Since I don't have one, my primary concern is to not let those in power to cheat me into obedience using, among other things, religion.

Then I trust you are pleased to live in a country that works hard to protect your freedom to not be religious.
 
Secular Humanism suggests a morality based on reason, because if we all act well towards each other, we'll all get along and be happy.

So much for capitalism...I guess if we were all secular humanists we wouldn't even need a police force...
 
Then I trust you are pleased to live in a country that works hard to protect your freedom to not be religious.
That is one way of looking at it, I guess.
On the other hand, North America is notorious for its hypocrisy, be it religious or post-religious. Putting vagina on a pedestal is an unfortunate consequence of that hypocrisy.
 
Hmm I thought the golden rule was "kill them all and let god sort it out" ...oh wait a minute.. that was during the Crusades..lol....

lol---
 
That is one way of looking at it, I guess.
On the other hand, North America is notorious for its hypocrisy, be it religious or post-religious. Putting vagina on a pedestal is an unfortunate consequence of that hypocrisy.

The Greek goddess Pussalia?
 
On a semi-related note, I have recently visited Titanic artefacts exhibition and among other things found interesting that women and children were allowed to board lifeboats first.

I wonder where the "gentlemanly" notion of allowing women to go first came from? Is it religious? Moral? Seems to be sexist to me.
 
Last edited:
That is one way of looking at it, I guess.
On the other hand, North America is notorious for its hypocrisy, be it religious or post-religious. Putting vagina on a pedestal is an unfortunate consequence of that hypocrisy.

But you are perfectly free to join the dominant culture in the hypocrisy or not. The state will not limit your choice.
 
Simantics

The way you talk we could never talk about groups at all. We could not talk about Canadians, or sociopaths, or anything else. The way you approach this is simply absurd.

Are you suggesting it is impossible to take a survey of atheists?

Canadians have this little certificate stating "I am a Canadian", says so right here.

No, you would take a survey of people who believe in a god, everbody else, does not, NO LABEL needed.

FAST
 
Funny you should mention, one SP has recently preached this to me. I had to point out to her that my little issue with this notion is that I like to fuck women who are significantly younger than me. That seems to require dominating over other males rather than merely getting along with them and being happy.
that's why we have religion...to control the primitives , but there will always be selfish pricks who only think of themselves . That is the human condition. We are not all enlightened
.
 
I believe in God but think Religion is an outdated man-made way to control society when society was uneducated and unorganized.

Take for-instance Sikhs. Sikhs carry a little dagger with them. They carry that little dagger because back in the day - they were constantly invaded, raped an pillaged by outsiders. So it became part of their religion to carry a dagger in order to their defend themselves. Their "god" didn't tell them to carry a dagger.... their leaders did. Catholics aren't supposed to have pre-marital sex.... well sure it makes sense when you consider that women used to marry once they got their periods... it's right to make it law that men not have sex with 12 year-olds.... People weren't educated and they feared God - the best way to control society was through Religious laws. There will always be people who don't follow what is morally right - whether they are religious or not.... but now we have developed societies to control those who hurt others. (and thankfully we live in a country where our laws are secular)

I grew up Catholic and have a Religious father and sister (who is currently working on her second masters in Theology).

As much as I was a good Catholic girl.... I found hypocricy right from the get-go. When I look at the ultra-religious now - all I see is people twisting their religious texts to suit their self-centered wants, needs, and opinions.

I laugh a little when I see people pick and choose which parts of their Religion they will follow.... What gives a person the right to pick and choose which Religious Laws you will follow? You're Catholic and you've had pre-marital sex - that's ok but God says abortion is bad so the woman who chooses to have a say about her body is bad bad bad? Gay people shouldn't be allowed to marry the person they love. What gives you the right to play God? Are you really following your religion when you don't follow all your religion tells you to?

When I was a little girl - before I started school, before I went to Church, and before my Dad started on his Religious re-awakening... I knew the difference between right and wrong. When I was disciplined by my parents, it was after the fact. When I stole that Rainbow bright out of the lost and found in grade 1 (lol), I knew it was wrong even before my parents caught me and gave me hell for it lol.

(Everything is ok in the end though since I went to Confession and told the priest I stole that Rainbow Bright Doll... I said my 10 Hail Mary's and one Our Father and I'm still going to Heaven - thank Goodness....)

That - I believe (as other have mentioned) is that inherent moral consciousness that we all posses. I like to think that that is God. I believe we all have that and we all have the same moral consciousness and the same God (or whatever you wanna call him or her or it). Some people are bad - some people lack compassion or empathy and we are all influenced by the society in which we are a part of (of course).

But I don't think believing in fairy tales makes a person good. I do believe that believing in those fairy tales can make a person much more narrow-minded. Perhaps if people started finding guidance in their inherent instincts of what is right and wrong (ie., do unto others...) rather than relying on religious texts or their 'fear of God' to guide them - we'd have a helluva lot less hate, a helluva lot less prejudice, a helluva lot less corruption, a helluva lot less war.....

One thing that has always kinda made me chuckle is the Religion Curriculum in the Separate School Board. In grade 9 we studied the Old Testament. We were taught that all those stories were symbol stories, passed on generation to generation. We were told that those things never really happened - but they were fables meant to teach people. So Adam and Eve never existed, Noah never built a big Arc, Moses didn't really spend 40 years in the desert, Samson never had his hair cut off... yadayadayada.

But in grade 10 we studied the New Testament (ie. all that is Christian). Well gosh-darn it - we were told that Jesus walked on water and preformed all these miracles.... No ifs ands or buts about it. Why? well that's the basis of the Catholic faith. We were literally taught that all that is Judaism was based on fables but all that was Catholic was based on fact. They forgot to mention that the New Testament was written hundreds of years later under the influence of the Church.... They forgot to point out all the inconsistencies between the books of the Bible. (But who cares cuz Matthew, Mark, Luke, John, etc. were telling things as they happened - no need to question it....)

That is enough to tell me that Religion is more about competition and brainwashing and superiority complexes than it is about peace and love and the one"God" that is supposed to love us all.

As a side note - Mill Maher is my hero. :thumb:
 
that's why we have religion...to control the primitives.
if by primitives you mean poor young good-looking women then I wholeheartedly agree with your religion.
 
Marry me

I believe in God but think Religion is an outdated man-made way to control society when society was uneducated and unorganized.

Take for-instance Sikhs. Sikhs carry a little dagger with them. They carry that little dagger because back in the day - they were constantly invaded, raped an pillaged by outsiders. So it became part of their religion to carry a dagger in order to their defend themselves. Their "god" didn't tell them to carry a dagger.... their leaders did. Catholics aren't supposed to have pre-marital sex.... well sure it makes sense when you consider that women used to marry once they got their periods... it's right to make it law that men not have sex with 12 year-olds.... People weren't educated and they feared God - the best way to control society was through Religious laws. There will always be people who don't follow what is morally right - whether they are religious or not.... but now we have developed societies to control those who hurt others. (and thankfully we live in a country where our laws are secular)

I grew up Catholic and have a Religious father and sister (who is currently working on her second masters in Theology).

As much as I was a good Catholic girl.... I found hypocricy right from the get-go. When I look at the ultra-religious now - all I see is people twisting their religious texts to suit their self-centered wants, needs, and opinions.

I laugh a little when I see people pick and choose which parts of their Religion they will follow.... What gives a person the right to pick and choose which Religious Laws you will follow? You're Catholic and you've had pre-marital sex - that's ok but God says abortion is bad so the woman who chooses to have a say about her body is bad bad bad? Gay people shouldn't be allowed to marry the person they love. What gives you the right to play God? Are you really following your religion when you don't follow all your religion tells you to?

When I was a little girl - before I started school, before I went to Church, and before my Dad started on his Religious re-awakening... I knew the difference between right and wrong. When I was disciplined by my parents, it was after the fact. When I stole that Rainbow bright out of the lost and found in grade 1 (lol), I knew it was wrong even before my parents caught me and gave me hell for it lol.

That - I believe (as other have mentioned) is that inherent moral consciousness that we all posses. I like to think that that is God. I believe we all have that and we all have the same moral consciousness and the same God (or whatever you wanna call him or her or it). Some people are bad - some people lack compassion or empathy and we are all influenced by the society in which we are a part of (of course).

But I don't think believing in fairy tales makes a person good. I do believe that believing in those fairy tales can make a person much more narrow-minded. Perhaps if people started finding guidance in their inherent instincts of what is right and wrong (ie., do unto others...) rather than relying on religious texts or their 'fear of God' to guide them - we'd have a helluva lot less hate, a helluva lot less prejudice, a helluva lot less corruption, a helluva lot less war.....

One thing that has always kinda made me chuckle is the Religion Curriculum in the Separate School Board. In grade 9 we studied the Old Testament. We were taught that all those stories were symbol stories, passed on generation to generation. We were told that those things never really happened - but they were fables meant to teach people. So Adam and Eve never existed, Noah never built a big Arc, Moses didn't really spend 40 years in the desert, Samson never had his hair cut off... yadayadayada.

But in grade 10 we studied the New Testament (ie. all that is Christian). Well gosh-darn it - we were told that Jesus walked on water and preformed all these miracles.... No ifs ands or buts about it. Why? well that's the basis of the Catholic faith. We were literally taught that all that is Judaism was based on fables but all that was Catholic was based on fact. They forgot to mention that the New Testament was written hundreds of years later under the influence of the Church.... They forgot to point out all the inconsistencies between the books of the Bible. (But who cares cuz Matthew, Mark, Luke, John, etc. were telling things as they happened - no need to question it....)

That is enough to tell me that Religion is more about competition and brainwashing and superiority complexes than it is about peace and love and the one"God" that is supposed to love us all.

As a side note - Mill Maher is my hero. :thumb:

WOW, beauty and brains, you said it better than I ever could.
But be prepared for a LOT of flaming.

FAST
 
I believe in God but think Religion is an outdated man-made way to control society when society was uneducated and unorganized.

Take for-instance Sikhs. Sikhs carry a little dagger with them. They carry that little dagger because back in the day - they were constantly invaded, raped an pillaged by outsiders. So it became part of their religion to carry a dagger in order to their defend themselves. Their "god" didn't tell them to carry a dagger.... their leaders did. Catholics aren't supposed to have pre-marital sex.... well sure it makes sense when you consider that women used to marry once they got their periods... it's right to make it law that men not have sex with 12 year-olds.... People weren't educated and they feared God - the best way to control society was through Religious laws. There will always be people who don't follow what is morally right - whether they are religious or not.... but now we have developed societies to control those who hurt others. (and thankfully we live in a country where our laws are secular)

I grew up Catholic and have a Religious father and sister (who is currently working on her second masters in Theology).

As much as I was a good Catholic girl.... I found hypocricy right from the get-go. When I look at the ultra-religious now - all I see is people twisting their religious texts to suit their self-centered wants, needs, and opinions.

I laugh a little when I see people pick and choose which parts of their Religion they will follow.... What gives a person the right to pick and choose which Religious Laws you will follow? You're Catholic and you've had pre-marital sex - that's ok but God says abortion is bad so the woman who chooses to have a say about her body is bad bad bad? Gay people shouldn't be allowed to marry the person they love. What gives you the right to play God? Are you really following your religion when you don't follow all your religion tells you to?

When I was a little girl - before I started school, before I went to Church, and before my Dad started on his Religious re-awakening... I knew the difference between right and wrong. When I was disciplined by my parents, it was after the fact. When I stole that Rainbow bright out of the lost and found in grade 1 (lol), I knew it was wrong even before my parents caught me and gave me hell for it lol.

That - I believe (as other have mentioned) is that inherent moral consciousness that we all posses. I like to think that that is God. I believe we all have that and we all have the same moral consciousness and the same God (or whatever you wanna call him or her or it). Some people are bad - some people lack compassion or empathy and we are all influenced by the society in which we are a part of (of course).

But I don't think believing in fairy tales makes a person good. I do believe that believing in those fairy tales can make a person much more narrow-minded. Perhaps if people started finding guidance in their inherent instincts of what is right and wrong (ie., do unto others...) rather than relying on religious texts or their 'fear of God' to guide them - we'd have a helluva lot less hate, a helluva lot less prejudice, a helluva lot less corruption, a helluva lot less war.....

One thing that has always kinda made me chuckle is the Religion Curriculum in the Separate School Board. In grade 9 we studied the Old Testament. We were taught that all those stories were symbol stories, passed on generation to generation. We were told that those things never really happened - but they were fables meant to teach people. So Adam and Eve never existed, Noah never built a big Arc, Moses didn't really spend 40 years in the desert, Samson never had his hair cut off... yadayadayada.

But in grade 10 we studied the New Testament (ie. all that is Christian). Well gosh-darn it - we were told that Jesus walked on water and preformed all these miracles.... No ifs ands or buts about it. Why? well that's the basis of the Catholic faith. We were literally taught that all that is Judaism was based on fables but all that was Catholic was based on fact. They forgot to mention that the New Testament was written hundreds of years later under the influence of the Church.... They forgot to point out all the inconsistencies between the books of the Bible. (But who cares cuz Matthew, Mark, Luke, John, etc. were telling things as they happened - no need to question it....)

That is enough to tell me that Religion is more about competition and brainwashing and superiority complexes than it is about peace and love and the one"God" that is supposed to love us all.

As a side note - Mill Maher is my hero. :thumb:

It is amazing the double standard that is applied to religion. Simply amazing.

I have yet to meet anyone who lives perfectly, by a perfect code and never does anything hypocritical or self interested. Yet the non-religious expect to hold the religious up to a standard that they themselves cannot meet. Talk about disingenuous.

Have you ever joined a secular or political organization that does everything the way you want for the reasons you want? Do all of your friends or members of your community think exactly the way you think they should? Do you ever try to convince someone that they are wrong but your point of view is right?

What gives a person the right to choose which religious laws to follow? The same thing that gives you the right to choose to follow none of them if you don't want to. Freedom and reason.

By the by, there is nothing in the Bible saying abortion is wrong. In fact, the only inference that can really be drawn from the Bible about this issue is that a fetus is not a person until birth.

And Bill Maher is the only show I never miss. If you get the chance to see him live you should...he is amazing.