Where do atheists get their morals? (The Atheist Experience)

canada-man

Well-known member
Jun 16, 2007
33,850
3,777
113
Toronto, Ontario
canadianmale.wordpress.com
 
Can't speak for others but my main ones are:

- treat others as you wish to be treated until they demonstrate they don't deserve it
- do what you want as long as you don't hurt anyone
- take responsibility for yourself

You don't need religion in order to live correctly.
 
Can't speak for others but my main ones are:

- treat others as you wish to be treated until they demonstrate they don't deserve it
- do what you want as long as you don't hurt anyone
- take responsibility for yourself

You don't need religion in order to live correctly.

Well said
 
Can't speak for others but my main ones are:

- treat others as you wish to be treated until they demonstrate they don't deserve it
- do what you want as long as you don't hurt anyone
- take responsibility for yourself

You don't need religion in order to live correctly.

Yet some people need reminders and can't be trailblazers or doers, they need to be led. Are they weak? It's not always the case. They may have other strengths, but just don't want to lead or even walk side by side. Do they need religion to get that guidance? Only they can say.

We all believe in the Golden Rules, but how many of it are able to follow it 100%? Hopefully that's what parents, siblings, then SO's do, but later in life who is there to keep reminding you. That's what spiritual leaders do. Are they the only ones capable of doing that, no but that is a large part of their job.
 
As a hardcore atheist my only credo is to maximize my own pleasure up to and including stealing other people's chinese food order if I can get away with it.
 
From the Golden Rule - same as religious people.
Yepper that Golden Rule created by Pagans is all you need!
Hell.... Jesus H Christ even copied it!.....:biggrin1:
 
Can't speak for others but my main ones are:

- treat others as you wish to be treated until they demonstrate they don't deserve it
- do what you want as long as you don't hurt anyone
- take responsibility for yourself

You don't need religion in order to live correctly.

The thing is most of this was hardwired into us over time via biblically derived mores and virtues as civilization progressed.

Anyhow you splice it, it took great effort over time to quell the ego.

The inherent idea of a divine power along with Biblically derived mores, protestant ethics or whatever else you wish to call it, had a great part to play in what we call civilization today.

For this reason, I didn't think atheists had morals to begin with.
 
You really, really don't want me to post all the stuff in those religions that posits the EXACT OPPOSITE.
Not to mention what's already been said - that the golden rule predates ALL OF THESE.

Just one example will do, where in Taoism or Buddhism do the holy writings contridict the Golden Rule. No need to over work yourself, just one contradiction.

No one is claiming they invented the golden rule, but they did put in word, and script and teach it, so that more people would hear the Message. That they also don't contradict it sometimes is also not in question.
 
As a hardcore atheist my only credo is to maximize my own pleasure up to and including stealing other people's chinese food order if I can get away with it.

So you are the one who keeps getting g my orders! At least I didn't pay for them in advance.
 
Cause the Religious types are so well groomed when it comes to morals.

Ill take my chances in a room full of skeptics before a room full of dedicated believers any day.


Go for it. I'll take good advise from wherever or whomever I can find it.
 
The thing is most of this was hardwired into us over time via biblically derived mores and virtues as civilization progressed.

Anyhow you splice it, it took great effort over time to quell the ego.

The inherent idea of a divine power along with Biblically derived mores, protestant ethics or whatever else you wish to call it, had a great part to play in what we call civilization today.

For this reason, I didn't think atheists had morals to begin with.

Golden rule predates Christianity. It derives, I believe, because people realized that working together made for more prosperity or even survival over someone who was selfish.
 
Cause the Religious types are so well groomed when it comes to morals.

Ill take my chances in a room full of skeptics before a room full of dedicated believers any day.
Hmm, I suspect you are stacking the deck - since reading the above I get the impression that you want your "religious types" to be a bunch of self-righteous do-gooders, at that rate many believers might choose your "skeptics" as well.
 
Treating others as you wish to be treated despite their demonstration that they don't deserve it is much classier.

True and I will to a point, but eventually some people use up that margin of error and require different measures. For example I was at the recent home show and wandered by one of the home security booths whereupon I was stopped by one of their salesmen.

Salesman: Does your home have a monitored alarm system?

Me: Yes it does.

S: Have you heard what our system can do?

Me: I'm not in the market, I'm happy with what I currently have, thank-you. <start to move on>

S: <grabbing my arm> But our system can do blah, blah and blah.

Me: <politely disengaging my arm> I'm sure it's wonderful, but I'm not interested. Thank-you!

S: <grabbing my arm again> But you really should take a look at our system.....

Me: <sharply removing his hand from my arm> Perhaps you don't understand English my friend. When you hear the words "I'm not interested" this should be your clue to leave that person alone and look for a customer who might be interested in your product. It does not mean "I'm being coy, I want you to bodily force me to stand here and buy your product". So let's try it again. "I"M NOT INTERESTED! THANK-YOU!".

S: You're missing a good chance sir!

Me: Whatever.
 
Hmm I thought the golden rule was "kill them all and let god sort it out" ...oh wait a minute.. that was during the Crusades..lol....